Need advice re MIL

  • Thread starter Thread starter 90Domer
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
9

90Domer

Guest
Happy Feast Day of the Immaculate Conception!

I had a question regarding my mother-in-law and her behavior. It is widely acknowledged by her family (sons included) that she has a sharp tongue and says obnoxious things on a regular basis. Prior to being widowed, my FIL would help “smooth things over” whenever she said some inappropriate. However, she’s been widowed 6 years, and her mouth is getting her into trouble more and more. She lies, twists the truth to suit her, and plays the victim. On top of that, she has not taken widowhood well and is often quite negative/cynical and is in a faith crisis of sorts.

Often, she’ll talk to me in an attempt to obtain more information about what’s going on in our household. My husband has learned to be very tight-lipped with her and also knows how to ignore her sharp tongue. I have not mastered such skills, so she tends to offend me about 6 times per conversation. The first few I can let go, then it gets to the point where I can’t continue speaking with her.

Here’s my question. On several occasions, I have asked my husband to back me in telling
her that a certain comment/behavior was inappropriate. He won’t do it because he feels it will not solve anything. DH claims that she won’t change. I tell him that I don’t care about her changing, but I want to know he’s in my corner. More importantly, I want MIL to know that her son is in my corner and such treatment is really inappropriate. Is that asking too much?

I have spoken to a priest/Catholic therapist. Both have told me to avoid talking to her and
to limit visits. She has a strained relationship with her middle son. She and the youngest get along fine, but I supposed it’s because she has fully embraced his SSA.

Love to hear any similar stories or your thought. Thank you and God bless.
 
Coming at it from the husband perspective, I can tell you that it is very reasonable for you to expect your husband to openly support you, and this can be done without dishonoring his relationship with his mother, and should be done despite his presumption that it will change nothing. I think he underestimates the influence he can have on her behavior.

My mother moved in with my wife and I temporarily (a few months) while she was in the process of moving to our area. And although my mother’s behavior was not rude or spiteful as in your experience, I can tell you that her mannerisms and proclivity to meddle in household affairs drove my wife bonkers. And I did very little to openly back my wife at first. I quickly realized that in-law problems can rapidly evolve into marital conflicts. I mean, I knew they could, but I never thought that some of the smaller issues could evolve into that so quickly.

Long story short…I have since embraced more strongly the very real need to stand by my spouse in all these types of problems, to side with her if she tells me she is having problems (unless it is very clear that she is fabricating the issue or otherwise has a negative agenda), and to do so openly.

I will say that this is not easy to do in many cases. Your DH has to carefully balance his support for you and his respect for his mother. But right is right, and he should speak up in your defense and make efforts to either resolve the problem, or atleast publicly proclaim his agreement with your position. Right is right, and the marriage trumps his closeness with his mom. Even if she is offended by his defense of you, right is right.

-Steve
 
Thank you, Steve, for a husband’s perspective. Our marriage was also on the rocks for this very issue. It took a therapist to flat out tell my husband that he was wrong in keeping quiet. My husband could not figure out why I couldn’t let things slide off my back like he’s able to do. And he felt saying something would do little to change her, as I mentioned in my first post. We do not agree on that point.

If I can ask 1 additional question: were you willing to defend your wife if you didn’t hear something first hand but rather a few hours after the fact?
 
Thanks for the very sincere posts! I will take all advice to heart! And I don’t answer the phone anymore, despite her sometimes seeking me out.
 
Thank you, Steve, for a husband’s perspective. Our marriage was also on the rocks for this very issue. It took a therapist to flat out tell my husband that he was wrong in keeping quiet. My husband could not figure out why I couldn’t let things slide off my back like he’s able to do. And he felt saying something would do little to change her, as I mentioned in my first post. We do not agree on that point.

If I can ask 1 additional question: were you willing to defend your wife if you didn’t hear something first hand but rather a few hours after the fact?
It was quite common for me to not witness firsthand the things my mother would do that drove my wife up the wall. My wife would tell me that this was perhaps purposeful, because my mother knew that I would object to her comments and have opportunity to intervene. Not sure I agree with that even to this day, but suffice it to say that normally I rarely witnessed these things. And although I did not do well with it in the past, I know now that I should always give my wife the benefit of the doubt, and do as much as possible to openly support her and make others aware of that support.

My situation, again, seems much milder than yours. Thus, I would say two things. 1) if the way you portray the behavior of your MIL and DH is accurate, your DH should definitely be stepping up to the plate in open support of you. And 2) Your MIL needs prayers and lots of them. I will try to make a point to do so myself for her, and for you and your DH. Seems she has a tremendous amount of stress (and perhaps anger) in her life due to the circumstances you’re describing. This is obviously a wonderful opportunity for you to exercise self-sacrifice and penance to help you, and others around you, grow in Christ.
 
I have known many people like this. I could give you a booklet on how the type operates and what your FIL and youngest BIL may prize about her, but let’s skip that. Let’s cut to the chase: You are tilting at windmills.

Your husband is not taking her side, but rather has decided that, as the saying goes, you can’t teach a pig to sing. You just frustrate yourself and annoy the pig. You want him in your corner? He has simply learned that it makes more sense to get out of the pig pen. Except in cases where the pig has gotten out of her own pen and onto your side of the fence, he’s being a lot more practical. If her opinions aren’t making decisions in your house, let her be. He’ll be more forceful in standing up to her on behalf of his household if he saves his battles for when it really counts.

You’re a grown woman. She is, too. If this was an honest misunderstanding, your husband might be able to help, but you know that your MIL understands very well that her mouth offends others on a regular basis. She has asked no one to help her and has begged pardon of no one. Neither is she singling you out for abuse. Rather, she expects all others, including you, to take her as she is, even as she bludgeons everyone else with her own blunt decrees about what is and is not acceptable in everyone else. Do you think your husband can make you into an exception? So it is: Take her or leave her as she is, because she has no inclination to change to suit you or anyone else.

Put yourself in your husband’s shoes for a minute, too. Do you have parents with decent manners? Have you any idea what it has been like to go through life with a parent who is regularly an embarrassment? He can more than commiserate with you, but if it were in his power to change her, don’t you think it would have already been done years ago? He learned from his father how to “handle” her, and that starts and ends with accepting her as she is.

Let him love what good points his mother has–she is not one of those mothers who leaves you wondering what she thinks of you, that is one thing ;)–and choose to overlook or avoid the rest with him. He didn’t choose his mother, but he did choose you. Be the spouse you would want him to be, the spouse you would thank God for having sent, were you in his situation. Handle his mother on your own, without complaint, and don’t ask him to do what can’t be done. You’ll both be a lot happier, and you’ll come away with a lot less mud on you.
 
I got a MIL from the same batch and all I can say is that once the priest who was our director told DH that he needs to stand up for his family and be a man, she got so nasty towards him as well that after years and years of abuse and lies and meanness, we ended up having to sever all ties.

There are some miserable people out there who are the opposite of “peace makers” and sometimes it’s just best to stay away. We, personally, let it go on until it started affecting the kids and cause serious strain between us, and in my opinion, that was way too long!
 
I got a MIL from the same batch and all I can say is that once the priest who was our director told DH that he needs to stand up for his family and be a man, she got so nasty towards him as well that after years and years of abuse and lies and meanness, we ended up having to sever all ties.

There are some miserable people out there who are the opposite of “peace makers” and sometimes it’s just best to stay away. We, personally, let it go on until it started affecting the kids and cause serious strain between us, and in my opinion, that was way too long!
This is how it goes. You can’t change them. You can only decide how much of them you are willing to take. If they want to see more of you, then changing becomes their choice. That is not the way to bet, though. Even if they learn to bite their tongue for short periods of time–no small improvement!–they often have to let someone know that this is what they’re doing! Their tongue may wag less, but they find ways to let you know they have kept their old mindset.

It sometimes works that someone with a longtime habit of abusing others does truly clean up their act. That is a beautiful thing, because of course they are far happier, too, not just their victims. I’ve never seen that happen because of a confrontation, though, not in an older person. When I’ve seen a big change like that, it’s been something else that’s done it: sometimes giving up an addiction, sometimes having a near-death experience or going through a death of a loved one and having that wake them up. That true change, that true healing of the wound that was in the end always the thing spewing all the venom, is well worth praying for. It is a release from a slavery when it comes, and I mean in the person who changes.
 
To be clear, I don’t think that argumentative confrontation is an advisable method for your husband to utilize in an effort to openly support you. Indeed, this can lead to further irreparable problems, as others have alluded to.

But I also don’t think that a husband should dismiss his wife’s pleas for help and support under the presumption that making MIL aware of the inappropriateness of her behavior would do no good. Obviously it would do good for his wife, and that’s worth atleast some effort.

The OP implied that when FIL was alive, his intervention in MIL’s behavior was helpful. Surely, their son was aware of this, and it seems to me that it may be somewhat of a cop out for him now to so easily dismiss the potential benefit that his open support could do for the situation.

In short, people do need to be called out for their uncharitable behavior, in a charitable way. Prayer is indeed a useful weapon in this dilemma, but IMO, so is some degree of open communication to make MIL aware with certainty that her behavior is inappropriate.

Yes, perhaps she’ll never change. But I think the husband should do something a bit more than what appears to be going on here. Often our silence in the face of inappropriateness communicates to the offender that their behavior is justified.
 
Trust me, I’m trying. Having two people on the autism spectrum, though, tries my patience.

I am trying to look for affirmation in other ways from dh. As I wrote above, that is not always easy when your beloved has AS. But I do believe dh has to learn to correct his mother’s wrongdoings in order to teach my son that such actions will not be tolerated (yes, he has often remained silent when she attacked me in front of him). The last thing I want is for her to ruin my son’s First Holy Communion by ticking someone off.
 
Steve, if your wife thinks your mother manages NEVER to say anything rude infront of you, and only when you’re not around… I suspect she’s right.

Mine does this. However, she and FIL have forgotten to hold their tongue infront of OTHERS. It was my OWN mother and best friend that suddenly witnessed what I’d been saying. Both were shocked as they both admitted to thinking I was exagerating. 'Cause HOW could it be THAT BAD???

Monica is the smart one here. WOW. How I wished I’d embraced the no speaking rule. It’s been nearly 30 years and I’ve been dealing with these people. Attacks on me, comments directed at my family, more recently the Catholic Church (I’m pretty sure they are annoyed at my children going to CCD, and the prospect of catholic school).

The last visit was his whole family. I really agonized about the prospective snotty comments. Then it dawned on me. Just don’t talk. They don’t really want to listen anyway. AND WOW! It worked miracles. I just… “hmmmd,” and “really?” “wow…”

It was a little depressing. I feel I’ve been slowly mourning the loss of an “ideal”.

But the visit went so smoothly! We all hugged on arrival and departure. And absolutely NOTHING of significance was said.

Other issues hang in the balance. Will deal as necessary. But for now… LOVIN’ the keep your mouth shut and don’t answer the phone idea.
 
Trust me, I’m trying. Having two people on the autism spectrum, though, tries my patience.

I am trying to look for affirmation in other ways from dh. As I wrote above, that is not always easy when your beloved has AS. But I do believe dh has to learn to correct his mother’s wrongdoings in order to teach my son that such actions will not be tolerated… The last thing I want is for her to ruin my son’s First Holy Communion by ticking someone off.
Patience is almost an overused word to start to describe it, isn’t it? I hope you are able to put yourself on an “oasis” on a regular basis, with peace and humor. When the battles are fierce, you need to give yourself a real preparation and a real recovery. Take care of your own oxygen needs first, as the airlines tell you. Only then can you be counted on to help anyone else, and you are definitely living in a low-oxygen situation.

I’m going to disagree about your expectations, though. Your husband doesn’t have to learn to correct his mother, and even if he “had” to, the nature of his emotional makeup tells you that it is very unlikely that he ever will. What would have been is what was: those are the cards you have to play.

On the first point, it is generally preferable to avoid “triangulation” whenever possible, where one party rushes in to the defense of another against a third. It is almost always preferable for the wronged person to firmly and undramatically stand up for himself or herself. This is not a bad example to set for your son. In fact, if he has troubles at school, it is better if he learns to advocate for himself before involving his teacher and to involve his teacher before he calls you in. It is much better to learn that nice people are not doormats than to learn to expect someone to swoop in and save you if you’re attacked. The truth is, very often the person swooping in only makes the situation more embarrassing for the attacked person.

On the note of your son’s First Holy Communion, sometimes one learns about communion under the metaphor of a love feast, and sometimes under the metaphor of sacrificing in order to bear the sins of others. You have the option of deciding not to invite your MIL to any family events, including that one. That’s something you and your husband would have to discuss. Otherwise, you can decide that her presence can’t be helped and that you are going to pass over her rude remarks in the same way you would if she were in early dementia. Either tack is certainly something that can be explained to your son.

Take your cue from the Lord’s words:* “You have heard that it was said, ‘An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth.’ But I say to you, offer no resistance to one who is evil. When someone strikes you on (your) right cheek, turn the other one to him as well. If anyone wants to go to law with you over your tunic, hand him your cloak as well. Should anyone press you into service for one mile, go with him for two miles.” *Matt. 5:38-41

Notice that the Lord did not say, “if someone strikes you on your right cheek, fall down and stay there” nor did He say “should anyone press you into service for one mile, go with them until you can find a way to escape them safely.” He was not advocating for cowardice. He did not say to look for strength in numbers, either. He was teaching the power of the third way, the way that is neither confrontation nor capitulation, but the way by which love shows itself too generous for the desire to overpower by force to keep up with.

As St. Paul put it, “Do not repay anyone evil for evil; be concerned for what is noble in the sight of all. If possible, on your part, live at peace with all. Beloved, do not look for revenge but leave room for the wrath; for it is written, “Vengeance is mine, I will repay, says the Lord.” Rather, “if your enemy is hungry, feed him; if he is thirsty, give him something to drink; for by so doing you will heap burning coals upon his head.” Do not be conquered by evil but conquer evil with good.” Rom 12:17-21

I will tell you that I have met tries by others to control me via orneriness by a combination of affection for the oneriness and firm refusal to let it work as intended, and it has cracked some pretty tough nuts. It deflates the meanness of the person who is trying to control you by being mean to you, because they don’t even suceed in making you dislike them…and trust me, they aren’t looking for a reputation of being a loveable curmudgeon! It makes their meanness into a rubber sword. I’ve had people like this not even use that tack with me any more! It’s like I’m one person they feel guilty trying to overpower, because they are treated better than they deserve in return. It’s almost as if it would be embarrassing for them. With me, they just ask for what they want, and they know if I can do it, I’ll figure out how to do it, and that is how we operate.

Even when that kind does develop a dislike of me, I found there is a great self-confidence to be gained by taking an attempt to provoke you and not looking as if you were even tempted to be ruffled by it. You look bulletproof, it feels good, and eventually, you know what, if you practice awhile, eventually you become bulletproof. It really can happen that way. If it happens that way between you and your MIL, it will be a great day for you.

How did I learn to do that? When I was in grade school, I was nice to someone who made themselves into a pain for everyone else, as a penance for Lent. It turned out that the person softened by having found someone who wasn’t offended by them. It got to be kind of a habit, and a very valuable one. So if you’re going to try this, by all means do it not for the good outcome, but only because it will please the Lord if you do. It is amazing how often that gives us far more than it gives to God, isn’t it? 😃
 
…How I wished I’d embraced the no speaking rule. It’s been nearly 30 years and I’ve been dealing with these people. Attacks on me, comments directed at my family, more recently the Catholic Church (I’m pretty sure they are annoyed at my children going to CCD, and the prospect of catholic school).

The last visit was his whole family. I really agonized about the prospective snotty comments. Then it dawned on me. Just don’t talk. They don’t really want to listen anyway. AND WOW! It worked miracles. I just… “hmmmd,” and “really?” “wow…”

It was a little depressing. I feel I’ve been slowly mourning the loss of an “ideal”.

But the visit went so smoothly! We all hugged on arrival and departure. And absolutely NOTHING of significance was said.

Other issues hang in the balance. Will deal as necessary. But for now… LOVIN’ the keep your mouth shut and don’t answer the phone idea.
You are so right about the “mourning of an ideal.” I have had a falling out with a relative that I had in my head was this very straight-forward person who I learned had a habit of saying different things behind my back. It’s been like going through a death, and it still grieves me. When you don’t get the MIL you always dreamed of, it is like that MIL you thought you’d get was thrown in prison or something. The “unfairness” of it can hang on for a long time. You just get through those feelings as best as you can, and sometimes that can’t be rushed. That’s nothing to be ashamed of, but just our human weakness, and it is good that you pointed that out. It is crummy enough to have go through it without beating yourself up about it!

On the “no speaking rule”, I know of someone who had a creative riff on that. She wasn’t in a situation that she could just cut her MIL out of her life. Her husband was in the family business, it was a small place where everyone was related to everyone, and it just wasn’t possible. She would put up with her MIL with the “hmmmd,” and “really?” “wow…” method when she could. When she just could not take it, though, she would wait until it was her turn to talk, reply in an unruffled “hmmmd,” and “really?” “wow…” sort of way, but then to give herself a reprieve, she’d hang up in the middle of her own sentence, as if the phone had failed! Yeah, it’s totally passive aggressive, yeah, you can’t do it very often, but she said that once in awhile, it felt REALLY GOOD. 😃

Sometimes, a teeny bit of naughtiness on the side is just the thing, if only for the humor in it. I’m sure the Lord understands!
 
Thank your for all the thoughtful posts. I wanted to list what I have felt I learned through this post and from private consultations:
  1. Lower my expectations: MIL, in all likelihood will never change or change very little. I have to go into situations with her knowing this behavior is the norm.
  2. Keep my mouth shut: This means enforcing the boundaries that I have put up…no exceptions.
  3. Keep my husband in the loop: Ask him to kindly correct his mom about said behavior without expecting anything great to change. Also, compliment and support him, as he’s been through the ringer as well (and for a longer period of time).
  4. Trust in God: If I do the right thing in my life, God will take care of me, even if I have to suffer in the process. Also, prayer for MIL, as she’s obviously not in as good a place as I am.
God bless.
 
Keep my husband in the loop: Ask him to kindly correct his mom about said behavior without expecting anything great to change. Also, compliment and support him, as he’s been through the ringer as well (and for a longer period of time).
This is something that is worth a real discussion with your husband. Concentrate not so much on achieving the solution you think you want, and more on identifying the full nature of the problem both from your view and from your husband’s and if possible your MIL’s. The best solutions usually come when you fully understand the problem from everyone’s perspective. If you’re going to keep a bear from eating your food while you’re camping, after all, it helps to think like the bear!

How does he feel when she acts that way? How does he feel when both she and you have conflicting expectations about how he should act? What would be his ideal in terms of dealing with her behavior, something he would walk away from feeling he and his family had done the right thing? What are the reactions he expects from her if your collective behaviors changed? What if his predictions (or yours) are incorrect? What then?

You can talk about the different ways he might show support for you, too, or role-play how she typically talks or acts, how the two of you might handle these situations depending on their setting, and how each scenario feels to you. Plan on debriefing after you try each planned response, to see how each of you felt about how it went.

What if he were simply to say, “You’re going to have to excuse me, Mom. Sharon, would you like to join me?” Would that be something that would work for the two of you? How do you think his mom would react? At least you’ll have some idea what is going through each of your minds during these run-ins with her. It might help if you feel more as if you are facing her as a “problem” together, that you’re both helping each other through the situation to the best of your ability, rather than enduring both her and your spouse’s actions.

For instance, my husband has told me that if he doesn’t introduce me to someone I don’t know, it may mean he thinks I know them, but it may also mean that he cannot remember their name! On this account, I know not to ask him to introduce me to someone who is standing in earshot. Rather than let on the greater faux pas of forgetting their name, we pretend the faux pas towards me that he neglected to introduce me. I introduce myself to them, they introduce themselves to me, and of course my husband apologizes…for forgetting the introduction, not for forgetting the name. We have many little agreements like this by which we cover for each other.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top