Need Help ASAP with Tactful Answer Animals Heaven

  • Thread starter Thread starter deanarrca
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

deanarrca

Guest
Ok My sister is not a Christian or Catholic/ kinda agnostic. Her beloved Dog died yesterday I sent her a nice St Francis Condolence Card she emailed me and said thanks for the card but I thought Catholics didn’t believe dogs have a soul and go to heaven-- Ok I want to write her and respond in a loving caring way but want to be correct. Any ideas would greatly be appreciated. She wants to use that as something against the church and Christianity in general. I want to sen a loving response but I don’t want to completely avoid the question.

Thanks in advance Deana
 
As I recall Jimmy Akin stating on Catholic Answers Open Forum he said that animals do not have eternal souls like we do, thus they do not go to heaven. He did philosophize that if God considered it edifying for our eternal happiness to permit our pet to be with us in heaven then He could do that, if He wanted to.

Here’s how one of the apologists here answered.

God bless! 🙂
 
Okay here is what I sent I totally plagiarized (cut and pasted from Jimmy Akins)

But is was a quick email note to my sis. She just sent me an email Smiley Face back so I guess she liked the answer 🙂

**The Church has never settled on the issue, so you are free to believe either way. What do we know? We know that God created animals without an eternal soul as humans have - in other words, if animals are in heaven, it is for God’s purposes as creator and for our purposes as the height of God’s creation - not because they are “saved” and “merit” eternal bliss.

I guess the final answer is - we can hope so. As the Catechism of the Catholic Church says in 1047

The visible universe, then, is itself destined to be transformed, “so that the world itself, restored to its original state, facing no further obstacles, should be at the service of the just,” sharing their glorification in the risen Jesus Christ (CCC 1047).

As animals are part of the “visible universe,” it seems possible that they too might share “their glorification in the risen Jesus Christ.” It might be possible that God might also re-create those animals who have been a pleasure and comfort to man in his earthly journey. We don’t know in this life, but it is something for which we can hope.

Heaven will have all that is needed for our perfect happiness. If you need your pets with you in heaven in order to be perfectly happy, your pets will be there.We realize that God alone suffices for perfect happiness; but we also know that God, in his great love for us, gives us more than our mere necessities and that his love is reflected to us in his creation. It may be that our animal friends’ presence in the next life will be God’s gift to us.**
 
Great response. Since dogs do not have souls, they do not need to be saved, nor can they be damned. Since God created animals for our use and pleasure, why should they not be with us again? Even though they have no individual soul, they always exist in the mind of God, who never forgets even one iota of His creation, even the smallest blade of grass, and that is all that matters. 😉
 
Okay here is what I sent I totally plagiarized (cut and pasted from Jimmy Akins)
A wonderful and thoughtful post you sent your sister. Just to clarify though, that link I had was not from Jimmy Akin but from Michelle Arnold. I only heard Jimmy express similar sentiments on the radio and I was recalling what I said about him from memory. God bless you!! 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top