Need Help/ Do You Think It Was Mortal or Venial?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Parker_James
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

Parker_James

Guest
So about 4-6 months ago I went to confession. I was having real problems with lust and confessed and was forgiven. A couple of days after that however, I preformed a certain act that I don’t know was venial or mortal. (I would much rather not say what it was)

After I thought deeper into what I was doing I stopped and prayed for forgiveness. I felt forgiven and did not do this act or anything like it again. In the months that followed I have grown so much closer to God. I also got confirmed in that time frame and was so filled with the Holy Spirit during the bishop’s homily. It truly was as close to God as I’ve ever felt in my life! After that I continued to grow in my faith and my prayer life has grown tremendously. Just recently my grandfather was in the hospital, close to death, of course I wasn’t the only one praying for him but I was one of the many that did and now he’s back to his old self pretty much.

It was not until recently that I thought back to that night in which I sinned. I still cannot remember if it was a mortal sin or a venial one. I assume it was a venial sin considering my peace right after praying for forgiveness afterwards. I also have heard that anyone in the state of mortal sin is an enemy of God. Yet, in the months that have followed that sin I experienced one of my closet moments to God ever and even have become way more religious. But I still worry that it was mortal.

I don’t know what it is. If it is mortal I want to confess it right away. Yet, so much good has happened to me thorough God since then. How could it be mortal if God has blessed me with so much and brought me so closer to him?
 
Not enough information. Was it of a grave nature? Did you know at the time it was of a grave nature and do it anyway? When in doubt if you have committed a mortal sin or not, you should get to confession at your first opportunity and discuss it with the priest. Even if you believe you received some kind of forgiveness, you still need absolution and that only comes from a priest in confession. Being in the state of mortal sin does not necessarily make you an enemy of God, it cuts you off from God.
 
Three conditions for a sin to be mortal are;

It must be of grave nature.

Must be committed with full knowledge

Must be committed with consent, i.e. freely.

Only you can discern if you met all three conditions. Just asking us here suggest you didn’t have full knowledge, but on the other hand, perhaps you did and are looking to ease your conscience.

Best thing to do is go to confession and confess the sin.

Often, when we realize our sin and are contrite and receive the sacrament of reconciliation, we become more humble, knowing how weak we are.

Jim
 
After much thought and prayer, I have decided that I will confess my sins tomorrow on Ash Wednesday. I truly cannot wait to have this weight off of my shoulders and to be forgiven by The Lord. Truthfully it gives me great peace just now thinking about it, knowing that God wants me to confess and repent and to be able to respond to him “Yes Lord”.

Thank you for y’all’s help! May God bless you both!
 
You are correct in your decision. The subject of whether an act is a mortal or venial is something for a priest in the Confessional to determine. It is not something that should be subjected to discussion on the internet because the answers one can get have a good chance of being wrong. People on the internet cannot see into your heart as your confessor can.
 
After much thought and prayer, I have decided that I will confess my sins tomorrow on Ash Wednesday.
I think you’ve made a very wise choice, and I praise God that He is working in your life in the way that He is. Would that more young people were opening their hearts to Him!
 
Turns out that my mom wants me to go visit my grandfather who is in the hospital (much better than his near death experience though) tomorrow after school. I could still maybe go later after school for the confession times are 6:00 to 7:30 P.M. If not then I’ll have to go Saturday.

Sorry, I guess you guys don’t need a play-by-play of everything but I guess it more so helps me to express my feelings to others. Maybe I need a blog lol 🙂
 
If a penitent is not certain of having committed a sin he is not bound to confess it; and if he does confess it, he should add that he is not certain of having committed it. - Pope St. Pius X

Don’t be tempted to be scrupulous. Of course, all the better if you do confess it. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top