Need help with embarrassment at school when not receiving Holy Communion

  • Thread starter Thread starter Eric67
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I am not sure why people had to make a deal about it. More people need to have your attitude towards proper reception of Holy Communion. Priests really need to bring this up more in homilies and also encourage more frequent visits to the confessional/reconciliation room. Speak to your parish priest about it,and hopefully he will preach on the subject.
 
in response to this thread, many have said something along the lines of, “It’s nobody’s business,” or, “No one should ask why you aren’t receiving,” I realize that this is true and has been given in good faith, but it doesn’t change the fact that this is what is happening to the OP.

No offense intended for those who have responded as such, but it’s sort of like telling an abused wife, “Your husband shouldn’t be hitting you anyway. That’s his problem. Now, just go on home and deal with it.” In other words, the ideal situation is not the reality, and that’s a problem.

Teenagers will talk. Period. And, even if they don’t, it feels like all of the world has eyes on you when you are the one person not going forward to receive Holy Communion.

As an aside, our Hispanic brothers and sisters still honor this teaching of the Church. Some catechesis needs to be done on what, exactly, the Church teaches and why, as well as what constitutes grave matter, but in general, those from a Hispanic background see nothing abnormal about abstaining from Holy Communion. But, I digress.

Back to the topic at hand. As I see it, the OP has two equally unattractive realities.

First, he could receive the Eucharist, conscious of grave sin, which the Church forbids.
Second, he could abstain, and face the scorn and ridicule of his peers.

I would propose, however, a third option. Speak with your priest. As a priest who is a chaplain in a Catholic high school, I would be floored (in a good way, in a way that I would be thrilled beyond words) if a student took his or her faith so seriously as to approach me with this issue. Your priest might be able to offer a solution. He might be willing to hear confessions before the school Mass. He might be able to offer you counsel that what you are struggling with is NOT grave matter, or a developed addiction limits your ability to give full consent. In either case, the action in question would NOT be a mortal sin, and thus not a reason to not receive Holy Communion. But, I stress ONLY YOUR PRIEST can tell you this for sure.

Speak with him. You might be pleasantly surprised by what he has to say.
 
in response to this thread, many have said something along the lines of, “It’s nobody’s business,” or, “No one should ask why you aren’t receiving,” I realize that this is true and has been given in good faith, but it doesn’t change the fact that this is what is happening to the OP.

No offense intended for those who have responded as such, but it’s sort of like telling an abused wife, “Your husband shouldn’t be hitting you anyway. That’s his problem. Now, just go on home and deal with it.” In other words, the ideal situation is not the reality, and that’s a problem.

Teenagers will talk. Period. And, even if they don’t, it feels like all of the world has eyes on you when you are the one person not going forward to receive Holy Communion.

As an aside, our Hispanic brothers and sisters still honor this teaching of the Church. Some catechesis needs to be done on what, exactly, the Church teaches and why, as well as what constitutes grave matter, but in general, those from a Hispanic background see nothing abnormal about abstaining from Holy Communion. But, I digress.

Back to the topic at hand. As I see it, the OP has two equally unattractive realities.

First, he could receive the Eucharist, conscious of grave sin, which the Church forbids.
Second, he could abstain, and face the scorn and ridicule of his peers.

I would propose, however, a third option. Speak with your priest. As a priest who is a chaplain in a Catholic high school, I would be floored (in a good way, in a way that I would be thrilled beyond words) if a student took his or her faith so seriously as to approach me with this issue. Your priest might be able to offer a solution. He might be willing to hear confessions before the school Mass. He might be able to offer you counsel that what you are struggling with is NOT grave matter, or a developed addiction limits your ability to give full consent. In either case, the action in question would NOT be a mortal sin, and thus not a reason to not receive Holy Communion. But, I stress ONLY YOUR PRIEST can tell you this for sure.

Speak with him. You might be pleasantly surprised by what he has to say.
When I was a kid in 7th grade, they had confession before first Friday Mass but the priest wouldn’t give me absolution because I couldn’t give him # of times for a sin…so I sat while everyone received. The nun asked why I didn’t receive & I told her. In the future, I avoided confessing to that priest.
 
I guess there are people who do notice such things. But really, if someone is keeping track of those who go forward for communion and those who don’t, my reaction is they need to go to confession and confess that they are busy-bodies. Remember the story of the sinner and the Pharisee. Your prayers as a sinner will be heard. The Pharisee who is judging the sinner is the one that has the real problem.

Those who received our Lord with reverence are not paying attention to anyone except Christ. Those who are sitting back are counting and judging need to be looking into their own hearts.

Don’t be embarrassed. This is between you and God. It is no one else’s business.

It is a hard lesson to learn but once you can see that only God matters, you will learn not to be hurt by other people.
 
I guess there are people who do notice such things. But really, if someone is keeping track of those who go forward for communion and those who don’t, my reaction is they need to go to confession and confess that they are busy-bodies. Remember the story of the sinner and the Pharisee. Your prayers as a sinner will be heard. The Pharisee who is judging the sinner is the one that has the real problem.

Those who received our Lord with reverence are not paying attention to anyone except Christ. Those who are sitting back are counting and judging need to be looking into their own hearts.

Don’t be embarrassed. This is between you and God. It is no one else’s business.

It is a hard lesson to learn but once you can see that only God matters, you will learn not to be hurt by other people.
These are kids that are pestering him …they are not judging, just busting on him!
 
I was also directly asked these questions, and sometimes they have to ask them in front of teachers, which makes things really awkward.
And your teachers do nothing about this? This is essentially bullying, and adults who are entrusted with the care of children have a responsibility to stop this when they’re aware of it happening. Maybe if you spoke with your teachers informing them that being interrogated like that by your peers is making you feel really uncomfortable they’ll take it upon themselves to put a stop to it as soon as they hear it happening the next time.
 
These are kids that are pestering him …they are not judging, just busting on him!
Even when I was a child the psychology of bullies always fascinated me. Of course I did not express the fascination in those terms but still:

When my sister and I were in grade school and in junior-high I learned about bullies. My sister is autistic and rather odd. I am a couple of years younger than her and was just as small and physically just a vulnerable. She was often bullied and made fun of but never around me. These fools did not go after me. I have thought about that and have tried to understand why. If she was with me, even though I was smaller, they left her alone. But, I remember how I felt and what was in my mind and probably what was in my eyes. It wasn’t embarrassment, it wasn’t fear, it wasn’t anything that a victim would feel. I can’t even say that it was anger. There was a fearless emotion for the protection for my sister. I would have been capable of anything if they tried to harm her.

Bullies go after those who feel embarrassment and vulnerability. You teach a young person to be above and beyond those emotions and bullies will back off. Focus on God, focus of what is right and just and the strength gained will be felt around those who would try to bring you down. You teach a young person this inner strength and they will be far better prepared to face life.
 
Even when I was a child the psychology of bullies always fascinated me. Of course I did not express the fascination in those terms but still:

When my sister and I were in grade school and in junior-high I learned about bullies. My sister is autistic and rather odd. I am a couple of years younger than her and was just as small and physically just a vulnerable. She was often bullied and made fun of but never around me. These fools did not go after me. I have thought about that and have tried to understand why. If she was with me, even though I was smaller, they left her alone. But, I remember how I felt and what was in my mind and probably what was in my eyes. It wasn’t embarrassment, it wasn’t fear, it wasn’t anything that a victim would feel. I can’t even say that it was anger. There was a fearless emotion for the protection for my sister. I would have been capable of anything if they tried to harm her.

Bullies go after those who feel embarrassment and vulnerability. You teach a young person to be above and beyond those emotions and bullies will back off. Focus on God, focus of what is right and just and the strength gained will be felt around those who would try to bring you down. You teach a young person this inner strength and they will be far better prepared to face life.
I agree…That’s why I told Eric67 to leave it at that …“it’s none of their business.” Or he can tell them it’s between him, God & the priest. Those kids are not true friends.
 
  1. Find a short, boring, impersonal answer to their questions, and use it over and over in a monotone voice. They will get bored and stop asking. Do not deviate from the standard reply and do not engage in conversation about it.
  2. This may be a cross you bear right now. God bless you for taking the sacraments so seriously! Maybe God is preparing you now to defend your faith in a bigger way later.
Schools can not possibly monitor every conversation, and these things are going to happen. You have to figure out a way to deal with it.
 
He agrees with another priest about how it may give the wrong idea to younger children, but it doesn’t talk about excommunicates or non-Catholics

Would it be a sin to lie if they ask me questions about why I didn’t receive? I’ll bet they will be persistent and will not settle without an answer.
It’s not a sin under these conditions, as they have no right to an answer in the first place.

From the CCC

2489 Charity and respect for the truth should dictate the response to every request for information or communication. the good and safety of others, respect for privacy, and the common good are sufficient reasons for being silent about what ought not be known or for making use of a discreet language. the duty to avoid scandal often commands strict discretion. No one is bound to reveal the truth to someone who does not have the right to know it.282
 
I know they will ask again and again. I know a person that kept asking me why I was in confession so long and when I said “because” he kept asking and then insulted me when I didn’t tell him why. Most of them barely know what mortal sin even is. I learned by asking my mother.
The point is, Eric, they Don’t have to know…Forget them! If they keep asking, they are not true friends.

Tell them it’s between you & God & the priest who is sworn to keep people’s confessions secret! 👍
I think some of the posters here are assuming that these kids are well catechized and know better. From the OPs comments that doesn’t seem safe to assume. If that’s the case then it’s probably baffling to them why anyone wouldn’t receive. From what the OP has posted it seems there is a lack of understanding about proper disposition to receive the eucharist by much of the student body.
 
I think some of the posters here are assuming that these kids are well catechized and know better. From the OPs comments that doesn’t seem safe to assume. If that’s the case then it’s probably baffling to them why anyone wouldn’t receive. From what the OP has posted it seems there is a lack of understanding about proper disposition to receive the eucharist by much of the student body.
You are right. Also, thinking about the word “bully” it doesn’t apply here. The problem with throwing labels around like that when kids are just being ignorant and rude takes away the serious problem of real bullying. You can’t teach young people manners and kindness by labeling them as “bullies”.

You can’t teach young people self reliance and inner strength by constantly protecting them either. There are real victims and there are real bullies. Let us not trivialize the suffering of a helpless autistic child alone on a school ground by the hovering over each young person who needs to face and deal with problems on their own.
 
[edited]

Before I start, I would like to say that we have prayer partners, which basically we sit with them in church and help them. I think since I am not going up, it is having a negative affect on them.

Anyways, I didn’t go up to receive communion again. Last time, I got lucky and was in the last row where my class sits so nobody saw me except my Hispanic friend and I told him that I ate a mint, and he was didn’t make a big deal about it. This time, I was in the middle, so about everybody would see me. After mass they asked the question why I didn’t go up for communion and I said I ate a mint. Of course they have to say a mint doesn’t count as food (does it?) and they make the biggest deal about it as if they don’t have anything interesting happening in their own lives. So they tease me some more, and then they start to take it WAY to far, and then my Hispanic ‘friend’ has to play along with them and he says “He is just trying to avoid Jesus” and that is when I couldn’t stand it. (I am one of those people that worries about what other people think of them.) I got all teary and ran to the bathroom and I cried. Then one of the boys that didn’t tease me ran in after me asking if I was ok. Then one of the boys that was teasing me came in and tried to get me to calm down (so he wouldn’t get in trouble probably) I said I didn’t feel well to try and get him to go away. One person told the teacher so she came in and took me to the office. I went in a room across the office and I calmed down in there. I even took both of my exams in there that we had. I stayed in there for the whole day (We only had a half day) and I got up to go get my stuff and I left. I am kinda scared what will happen tomorrow. I will probably get yelled at by the boys because ‘I got them in trouble.’ I am going to see my priest soon, but I don’t know when. Any advice to help stop this is very much appreciated and please pray that this will come to an end.
 
If there is a Priest saying Mass…then there is a Priest who can hear a confession…so seek him out prior to Mass if one has committed a mortal sin…

Keep following Jesus with the seriousness and joy of authentic commitment…
 
I feel for you. Sorry you are having a difficult time doing what is right. It has been many years since my Catholic school days but I do remember having the whole school go to confession several times during the year. Any chance your school does that? If not have you suggested it to the teachers? You could even send in a suggestion with out giving your name. Sounds like lots of kids there could benefit from some reconcelliaton.
 
I used to be REALLY sensitive, (and still am). When I was young, if someone teased me, for any reason, I would get upset, cry. Often, this was what they wanted. They WANTED me to react, get upset. So, the more upset I became, the more they would do it.

Often, I’d go to my mother, who would advise me, time and again, “They are doing this for attention. IGNORE THEM!” She may never have gotten more than a high school degree, but I can assure you she knows a lot about human behavior, and psychology.

My brother used to tell me to ignore people, and it’s taken me till later in my life till I’ve actually been able to successfully ignore people. I have often spent my life trying to please them (which, inicidentally, is often probably impossible).

I STILL get upset, and I’ve taught. You should see what they put us TEACHERS through. I’ve had all I can do, in the past, not to cry, as well. They would be rebellious and all the rest, and I’d be responsible for trying to reign all that in.

When I first came to Mexico, I taught at a home for children. At one point, as a combination of not being able to speak, and understand Spanish, well enough at that time, adjusting to an entirely new culture, AND having students who were rebellious in the extreme, I cried daily! I would try to do that in private, retreat to my room…or with a trusted friend, and cry.

Anyway, I still teach but no longer bother with large groups. I have small ones, but I have since tried harder NOT to take things personally. Well, I’ve since realized that a lot of those kids come from families who have never properly taught them…manners, etc. They might even come from families where there is abuse, and they often imitate that, right or wrong.

I also worked in mental health, and it’s important to realize what’s you, what’s them. To me, THEY are the problem, NOT you! So, number one, realize that. You are NOT the problem. Do NOT let them get you to think, in your remotest thoughts you are!

Secondly, this is a trick one of my supervisors taught me when dealing with difficult situations in life. She imagines a shield around herself, that what people say do NOT penetrate the shield, rather, that she’s protected, that EVERYTHING simply slides right off it…like water off a duck’s back!

Another friend said it was hard disciplining her kids, and she’s imagine herself as much bigger! lol So, there are a lot of tricks.

I also once had a friend who used humor! So, they were picking on the two of us, and instead of getting upset, like I did, he would, to me…imitate himself loading a gun, shooting one. I laughed. Then, we, together, imagined it was a bigger and bigger gun…until it was a canon! So, he helped me a lot.

Some comedians have actually suffered greatly, use humor, also as a defense (or attack).

If you can, try to leave that place where they are, head to the bathroom if you feel you’ll cry.

If you DO cry, realize one more thing, that it’s not the end of the world. I work at a Blind Association, and one of the teachers goes out of his way to teach people, men especially, that it’s actually OKAY to cry. In fact, I’ve seen that man, the coordinator, cry on several occasions. Now, it’s unfortunate a person sees one crying and attacks, but try to realize that these kids are going through a phase, are VERY immature!

They are childish, and wrong. It’s wrong to do that, clearly. They’re abusive, and that’s why you feel the way you do.

My boyfriend will do all kinds of crazy stuff. He goes around downtown singing at the top of his lungs, some days, and I feel embarrassed as to what everyone else will think. He…doesn´t care what they think. He will ask me why I care what other people think.

He will say, “Do they feed you? Do they clothe you? So…why do you care what they think?!” He told me to just stop that, to stop trying to please everyone, just be concerned about myself and my loved ones, mainly.

Once, his brother tried to tell him what to do when he was growing up, and my boyfriend basically said he didn´t care what his brother thought of him, that he doesn’t feed or clothe him or anything! Actually, instead of my boyfriend getting upset, the brother got upset that he could no longer control using fear!

First line of defense…IGNORE them. See them for what they truly are. Realize THEY are the problem, and do NOT let them get you to internalize. You don´t have to argue with them. They are childish, immature, and when you have people like that, do NOT take ANYTHING they say personally. Consider the source!

If someone tried to tell my boyfriend…“Hey…you ate a mint!”, I think he’d say, “Yeah, and what’s that to you?” Try to defend yourself. Don´t allow them to use you as their doormat, because if you do, you might have that for the rest of your life!

Oh…one last thing…sometimes, another way to throw bullies and others off the trail is to agree with them. Then, it comes across, at times, like a severe sarcasm.
 
If there is a Priest saying Mass…then there is a Priest who can hear a confession…so seek him out prior to Mass if one has committed a mortal sin…

Keep following Jesus with the seriousness and joy of authentic commitment…
YES. ^^^ Talk to the priest about what you can actively do to AVOID this sin!
Just the fact that this keeps happening is something that needs to be addressed, not just accepted as the way it is. Try very hard to amend your behavior so that you can receive.
I’ll say a prayer for you.
 
I’ll give you the same advice my mother gave me. She told me to develop a “thicker skin”. She would tell me not to let things bother me so much, not to take everything to heart.

Now, at the time, I didn´t really hard know how to ignore them. I internalized things.

Once, I had someone who told me, “Stop staring at me!” He was not right, mentally, and I would avert my eyes from people from that point on. To this day, I have trouble maintaining eye contact, and I believe part of that originated at that time. I started to take the advice of these troubled folks.

Now, if someone would say to stop looking at him, I think because I’ve lived longer ,have more life experience, that I’d realize it’s HIM, NOT me.

If it’s something I’m doing wrong, then I need to take a look at that, but if I’m okay, I need to try not to take that personally…otherwise, it will begin to hurt my own self esteem, make me feel badly about myself, give me a complex.

I need to work on assertiveness, myself, but some of it was probably from my childhood, things people said to me, that I took in, believed about myself.

So, if you internalize what people say, you could be my age, struggling to learn how to stand up for yourself. It’d be easier, hard as it is, to start standing up for yourself early on, and people will see they can´t get away with it, that you will defend yourself, verbally and otherwise.

Due to my religious beliefs, I allowed myself to be a doormat, (mistakenly) thinking it was Christlike. I misunderstood what peace was…what “turn the other cheek” meant. I thought I had to just take abuse, sit in silence, not lift a finger in my defense.

I also thought peace at all costs, and that there was no such thing as a just war, for example. Now, if someone attacks me, I am seeing, be it verbally, or physically, I have a right to defend myself.

I’ve been victimized in my life, crimes, a bunch of times, and I think my overly soft spoken ways, posture, signal to people I’m an easy target. So, speak up, and also stand up straight. Act with purpose and confidence. Even if you don´t presently feel it, fake it till you can. 👍
 
Oh yeah…you are probably correct in that they seem to have nothing better to do than worry if you had a mint or not. If it’s in church or not, what concern is that of theirs? You’re correct. Don´t they have anything better to do?

You could even say that, “Don´t you have anything better to do?” Some people say, “Get a life!”
 
I was going to see the priest soon, but that day got canceled, so my parents are scheduling another appointment with the priest. I have homeroom before mass, so I have to be at school, and then we all leave to go to Mass together.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top