Need help with my wife

  • Thread starter Thread starter curiousone
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

curiousone

Guest
Hi, I am Catholic and my wife was raised Lutheran. Long story short, she has been going to church with me on occasion and has been working through any biases and things that she does not understand. Right now she feels lost, since she does not feel comfortable in her own church, but is still researching Catholicism. She said today that she is uncomfortable at mass and sometimes “does not feel anything”. The logical side of her knows you cant rely on feelings, however she reads conversion stories of people who have joined the church and knew right away they were home. Can anyone here dialogue with me who has gone through similar experiences.
 
In my opinion, the toughest of transitions to make come as a result of being “comfortable” with what has always been familiar. I know that since I have come into the Church, I felt somewhat invalidated as a Christian because of my Anglican upbringing. As I have come to understand and grow in my faith (in the Catholic Church), I have come to better understand why the differences existed. I honestly don’t know that I would have come to this realization so quickly, if I didn’t immerse myself in the Rite of Christian Initiation for Adults. I am so glad I made the choice to do RCIA, and am “richer” because of it. Continually pray for your wife, as she may very likely come to the realization that I did about the Church and its wondrous history and tradition. Give her the encouragement to grow in her faith, and allow her the freedom and flexibility to question without passing judgment.
 
Hi, I am Catholic and my wife was raised Lutheran. Long story short, she has been going to church with me on occasion and has been working through any biases and things that she does not understand. Right now she feels lost, since she does not feel comfortable in her own church, but is still researching Catholicism. She said today that she is uncomfortable at mass and sometimes “does not feel anything”. The logical side of her knows you cant rely on feelings, however she reads conversion stories of people who have joined the church and knew right away they were home. Can anyone here dialogue with me who has gone through similar experiences.
Better look out those priest my find a home in your wifes ***

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)

Leave the grand boys at home JTS
 
To her credit she is trying. It might be worthwhile introducing her to some of the more spiritual woman in your age group from your church and socializing with them and becoming friends. We should never forget that we are spiritual creatures as well as social creatures - we are made for relating to God and each other. It may be that she just needs a “woman’s touch” so to speak to get her comfortable with The Church socially as well as
spiritually. It wouldn’t hurt.

James
 
Hi curious. My story is similar. My wife is Romanian Orthodox but she had been attending Catholic Mass with me. She was also looking for that ‘feeling’ or intangible that would indicate she should join. Finally, one day she decided that it was important to her to have a faith she could practice, particularly with her husband. She’s been in RCIA this year and will join the Church (praise God) at the Easter Vigil. Sometimes where our head leads, our heart follows. She’s now completely comfortable at Church.
 
curiousone, sometimes it takes a long time for a lifelong Protestant to make the decision to enter the Catholic Church. In my case, it took fully five years of attending Mass with my Catholic husband before I approached our pastor about converting. I was a cradle Episcopalian, and I had many issues, some of which I told my husband and some of which I kept to myself. Example, some degree of pride (in a good sense) in my Anglican upbringing. Fear of dealing with my family who knew I was attending a Catholic Church. Fear of the confessional. Fear that I would be put through a lengthy conversion process and be treated as if I knew nothing about the Christian life when in fact I did.

It took five years to get over my fears and finally take the plunge. During all of it, my husband was relatively silent, he just kept on taking to me to Mass and let the Holy Spirit do His work. He let me make this decision for myself with no pressure and he was very patient.

Hope this helps.

Blessings,
Mrs. Mac
 
I can relate. My wife was a Catholic when we met. We bolth went to the Lutheran Church. I have wrestled with this for about two years. My wife has returned to the Catholic Church and I my self and now on my way to coming home. The best advice I can give is listen to her discrepencies and be very patient. Talking with the priest definatly helps, but let her move at her own pace. God will bring all home in good time at his will. Best wishes on supporting your wife through her journy and may God bless you bolth.
 
Hi, I am Catholic and my wife was raised Lutheran. Long story short, she has been going to church with me on occasion and has been working through any biases and things that she does not understand. Right now she feels lost, since she does not feel comfortable in her own church, but is still researching Catholicism. She said today that she is uncomfortable at mass and sometimes “does not feel anything”. The logical side of her knows you cant rely on feelings, however she reads conversion stories of people who have joined the church and knew right away they were home. Can anyone here dialogue with me who has gone through similar experiences.
I was a Methodist when I married my Catholic wife. I had nothing against the Catholic Church but at the time I had no particular interest in finding out anything about it. However, I did attend Mass each Sunday with my wife and I agreed any children would be brought up Catholic. She prayed daily for 10 years for my conversion. After 10 years I woke up suddenly one Saturday morning and somehow knew (without understanding how I knew) that the Catholic Church was the true Church. Immediately after breakfast I jumped in the car and headed to the Church we attended and asked a priest what to do. That’s when I joined an RCIA program and the following year I became a Catholic. I have never regretted that.
I thank my wife for her prayers and God for the grace to see the light.
 
Curiosone,

I am a recent convert to Catholicism from a Baptist background. It took me 8 years attending mass with my family to make the decision to join RCIA. Best decision I have ever made! The Easter Vigil Mass and my first communion were quite an experience.

I would recommend your wife read about other conversions. A good book is “Rome Sweet Home” by Dr Scott Hahn or “Crossing the Tiber” by Steven Ray. These two books meant a lot to me.

God Bless
 
Thanks for the support and help. It is hard to find support at my “home” parish from other supportive females. It is a parish that has lost its purpose in a lot of ways so I cannot direct her towards other females or couples. We have been going to a parish down the road about 25 minutes whose priest is outstanding. In fact last night He gave the perfect homily. I prayed and prayed for her to hear something she can use in her own spiritual journey and part of his homily was about having faith and believing and doing things despite feeling “empty”. I wish I had an audio version but my wife was moved to tears (I was misty eyed as well) by his examples and how he drove his point home. I felt like I should have been standing up and cheering!
 
What does this mean in relation to the comments of any/all of the posters?
The OP - She said today that she is uncomfortable at mass and sometimes “does not feel anything”.

I simply was conveying that worship is not like entertainment, but worship is a verb.
 
The OP - She said today that she is uncomfortable at mass and sometimes “does not feel anything”.

I simply was conveying that worship is not like entertainment, but worship is a verb.
Okay. I get it now.
 
Hi, I am Catholic and my wife was raised Lutheran. Long story short, she has been going to church with me on occasion and has been working through any biases and things that she does not understand. Right now she feels lost, since she does not feel comfortable in her own church, but is still researching Catholicism. She said today that she is uncomfortable at mass and sometimes “does not feel anything”. The logical side of her knows you cant rely on feelings, however she reads conversion stories of people who have joined the church and knew right away they were home. Can anyone here dialogue with me who has gone through similar experiences.
Something that might be worth talking to her about, but gently of course, is that the point of Mass is not to go so you get a fuzzy feeling or re-enact those silly inspirational Protestant conversion films, you go to Mass for God, not for yourself. I wonder sometimes how people say “I don’t go to Mass anymore, I just don’t get anything out of it”. Of course you don’t, you’re going for the wrong reason!

Also, I wouldn’t necessarily say “you can’t rely on feelings”. Don’t discount your feelings, for when we are on God’s path and following His will as best we can, our feelings can often be wonderful messengers of His thoughts and feelings.

Everyone is different, and some people have spectacular conversions and some have subtle ones that take more time. One is not less than the other, because they lead to the same place, and are just God’s particular way of talking to that particular individual: some need spectacular words from Him, some need subtle ones, even if they want spectacular ones.

Also, if you’re not deeply engrained in this parish, perhaps trying another parish would help?
 
Hi, I am Catholic and my wife was raised Lutheran. Long story short, she has been going to church with me on occasion and has been working through any biases and things that she does not understand. Right now she feels lost, since she does not feel comfortable in her own church, but is still researching Catholicism. She said today that she is uncomfortable at mass and sometimes “does not feel anything”. The logical side of her knows you cant rely on feelings, however she reads conversion stories of people who have joined the church and knew right away they were home. Can anyone here dialogue with me who has gone through similar experiences.
“Jesus has a very special love for you. As for me, the silence and the emptiness is so great that I look and do not see, listen and do not hear.”
— Mother Teresa to the Rev. Michael Van Der Peet, September 1979

One of our greatest modern day Catholics,Blessed Mother Theresa,who LIVED her Faith had very little spiritual consolation and “felt” very little but persevered in her Faith and love for our Lord.She in effect was consoling our Lord and not the other way around.St John of the Cross and St Theresa of Avila also experienced this paucity of consolation.It is a reminder to us to be Christians of conviction rather than Christians of emotion.

I agree with Buffalo.Worship is a verb.👍
 
“Jesus has a very special love for you. As for me, the silence and the emptiness is so great that I look and do not see, listen and do not hear.”
— Mother Teresa to the Rev. Michael Van Der Peet, September 1979

One of our greatest modern day Catholics,Blessed Mother Theresa,who LIVED her Faith had very little spiritual consolation and “felt” very little but persevered in her Faith and love for our Lord.She in effect was consoling our Lord and not the other way around.St John of the Cross and St Theresa of Avila also experienced this paucity of consolation.It is a reminder to us to be Christians of conviction rather than Christians of emotion.

I agree with Buffalo.Worship is a verb.👍
Yeah we went to church last night and in his homily, he talked about feelings and used Mother Theresa as an example. It was a brilliant homily that moved my wife to tears.
 
Hi, I am Catholic and my wife was raised Lutheran. Long story short, she has been going to church with me on occasion and has been working through any biases and things that she does not understand. Right now she feels lost, since she does not feel comfortable in her own church, but is still researching Catholicism. She said today that she is uncomfortable at mass and sometimes “does not feel anything”. The logical side of her knows you cant rely on feelings, however she reads conversion stories of people who have joined the church and knew right away they were home. Can anyone here dialogue with me who has gone through similar experiences.
Hi. I don’t know if you’re looking for answers from Cradle Catholics, but in my experience, I didn’t have a conversion (or reversion) until I was well into my adulthood. The fruits of the vine ripen at different stages of time. For some, early on; for others later in life. Your wife shouldn’t feel discouraged because she doesn’t “feel” anything at Mass. Few do, and the few that do, don’t all the time. We all go through periods of dryness, etc. The fact remains that God is calling her to something wonderful. He’s inviting her to learn more about Him. She should not be hesitant to say “yes” to this invitation and God may grace her later with the special feelings she longs for. Asking God to help her love Him more would be a good step for her to take. I believe that’s one prayer God always answers in a timely fashion. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top