need help

  • Thread starter Thread starter anrmenchaca74
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

anrmenchaca74

Guest
Well what do I do if my wife has a “free spirit” and doesn’t agree with nfp and believes in her heart that God wants her to have her tubes tied so she won’t go through hard pregnancies and harsh monthly visits? I just told her how I have been feeling towards her and now she has shut herself off from me. Please help
 
Tube tying has no bering on aunt flo. And Artifical Birth Control has frighteningly strong connections to cancer.
It would be shortsighted to treat the symptoms. And treated correctly it may cause infertility anyway but unlike tube tying it will fix the monthly problem.

Sex is part of marriage but sex makes babies. Things like this should be dicussed before marriage.

You dont say how many kids you have, how old you are, etc. Some women loose fertility in their mid 30’s…some not until 40’s. It can do psycological damage to perminatly sterilize…and it may be a moot point if your wife is in her late 30’s.

Its rough, for sure.
 
Well what do I do if my wife has a “free spirit” and doesn’t agree with nfp and believes in her heart that God wants her to have her tubes tied so she won’t go through hard pregnancies and harsh monthly visits? I just told her how I have been feeling towards her and now she has shut herself off from me. Please help
I was looking through your past posts to get an idea of what is going on with you and your wife. I have a couple of questions for you.

How many children do you have, other than the one she is carrying right now?

You said in another post that you led her back to the Church. Was she lapsed and was she using contraception while she was lapsed? Does she have experience of using contraception and being “spontaneous” and not limited to any particular time for having sexual relations?

Does she believe in the Church’s reasons for being opposed to contraceptives? If she used contraceptives previously, does she regret this or does she believe it’s OK to use artificial birth control?

Has she decided that she wants X number of children and no more?

I think you are going to have a hard time convincing her to continue to be open to the possibility of having more children, or using nfp, if she has a past with contraceptives that she doesn’t regret. Will she talk to a priest about this?
 
I was looking through your past posts to get an idea of what is going on with you and your wife. I have a couple of questions for you.

How many children do you have, other than the one she is carrying right now?

You said in another post that you led her back to the Church. Was she lapsed and was she using contraception while she was lapsed? Does she have experience of using contraception and being “spontaneous” and not limited to any particular time for having sexual relations?

Does she believe in the Church’s reasons for being opposed to contraceptives? If she used contraceptives previously, does she regret this or does she believe it’s OK to use artificial birth control?

Has she decided that she wants X number of children and no more?

I think you are going to have a hard time convincing her to continue to be open to the possibility of having more children, or using nfp, if she has a past with contraceptives that she doesn’t regret. Will she talk to a priest about this?
We are currently pregnant with our fourth child. And when we first got married we were both cradle Catholics. She had been using the shot as a means of contraception until in September 2001, we got pregnant with our first child. After our first child, we got pregnant again and when my 1st was barely 8 months she miscarried at 5 months. We tried again and got pregnant with our second child. Shortly after his birth, my wife had an iud inserted. We were still not very close to the church and both she and I weren’t very informed about NFP and the views on contraception. Well now we are VERY close to the Catholic faith, however she believes in her heart that we have that option to choose in terms of using contraception. She even threw that whole " its not in the bible" bit and that’s where we really disagree. She goes as far as to make it seem that there won’t be any Passion between us if we do NFP and she she’s feels that its not right to limit ourselves passionately if that is a gift from God. And now she is viewing this as an attempt to really kill the person who she is. And that makes me feel guilty. As far as talking to a priest, I feel it would make things worse between us. This will be our last baby and her justification for tying her tubes is that she suffers a lot during her pregnancy and mothly visits. I have basically given up all hope when it comes to talking with her about NFP and the churches teachings. I already know how she is going to react and she is just going end up being upset with me and shut herself off emotionally to me. Right now, things are a little better so. I don’t know, I can’t prove it to her otherwise.
 
OK, thanks for the further information. I sure wish that wives had to get their husband’s signature to get their tubes tied…Her OB doctor should not do that procedure until he/she has spoken to both of you. For one thing, having her tubes tied/clipped is not going to help with her periods at all. That would take a hysterectomy but then she’d have hormone problems and would go into instant menopause.

How does she suffer during pregnancy? Does she get morning sickness? I was sick for 3 mos. with my first one, 4 mos with my 2nd one. I got through that and had a good time until the baby got too big for me to be comfortable. I mean, there is no doubt that having kids changes a woman’s body…permanently. But so what?

I’m really sorry about your miscarriage, that must have been very difficult for both of you.

I know just what you’ve been through - I was using contraception for years before I returned to the Church, and even after that. I wasn’t sure I wanted to know what the Church required of me…and my husband didn’t want any more than 2 kids. So for me, it’s my husband who would have insisted on contraception even if I hadn’t wanted to. I figured he couldn’t handle more than 2 and even that was stretching his capabilities at many points along the way.

Anyway, your wife seems rather immature about this - she says you should have no limits on having sex? Well, there are plenty of things that grown adults have to limit - such as eating, drinking, partying, sleeping, speeding on the freeway, etc. etc. etc. Her argument, that you shouldn’t be restrained by NFP, is not well thought out. But I guess she knows she can have the upper hand here anyway, if she goes ahead with the procedure, what can you do?

And you know that she is going to sin, but she is ignoring the Church and God on this subject and doing it her way.

I will pray for you, maybe having the new baby will change her mind.
 
We are currently pregnant with our fourth child. And when we first got married we were both cradle Catholics. She had been using the shot as a means of contraception until in September 2001, we got pregnant with our first child. After our first child, we got pregnant again and when my 1st was barely 8 months she miscarried at 5 months. We tried again and got pregnant with our second child. Shortly after his birth, my wife had an iud inserted. We were still not very close to the church and both she and I weren’t very informed about NFP and the views on contraception. Well now we are VERY close to the Catholic faith, however she believes in her heart that we have that option to choose in terms of using contraception. She even threw that whole " its not in the bible" bit and that’s where we really disagree. She goes as far as to make it seem that there won’t be any Passion between us if we do NFP and she she’s feels that its not right to limit ourselves passionately if that is a gift from God. And now she is viewing this as an attempt to really kill the person who she is. And that makes me feel guilty. As far as talking to a priest, I feel it would make things worse between us. This will be our last baby and her justification for tying her tubes is that she suffers a lot during her pregnancy and mothly visits. I have basically given up all hope when it comes to talking with her about NFP and the churches teachings. I already know how she is going to react and she is just going end up being upset with me and shut herself off emotionally to me. Right now, things are a little better so. I don’t know, I can’t prove it to her otherwise.
Getting her tubes tied isn’t going to make her monthly visits better, actually for some women it makes them worse. Is she considering getting an ablation done with the tubal? That would make her cycle much lighter, so maybe that’s what she is planning.

Anyways, getting sterilized is obviously against Church teachings, as is any type of Artificial Birth Control(ABC), but if she is dead set on one or the other, I’d have to say at least ABC would leave you the chance for her to change her mind at some point where as reversing a tubal is definitely hard and if she gets an ablation, impossible.

I will pray that your wife will see the sin that a tubal/ABC is, and have a change of heart.
 
OK, thanks for the further information. I sure wish that wives had to get their husband’s signature to get their tubes tied…Her OB doctor should not do that procedure until he/she has spoken to both of you. For one thing, having her tubes tied/clipped is not going to help with her periods at all.That would take a hysterectomy but then she’d have hormone problems and would go into instant menopause.
SHE even understands that. She was the one that told me about hormones going out of whack if a woman ties her tubes or gets a hysterectomy which is a contradiction because she would have rather used an IUD or depo rather than tie her tubes at one point in our marriage. I DID tell her that the pill and the IUD are abortaficient and she freaked out. So hoping that she would reconsider, she said that she would rather do something surgically.
How does she suffer during pregnancy? Does she get morning sickness? I was sick for 3 mos. with my first one, 4 mos with my 2nd one. I got through that and had a good time until the baby got too big for me to be comfortable.
She was involved in an accident 10 years ago which has pretty much messed up her neck and back. A few years back her lower back gave out on her and she was in an extreme amount of pain to the point where she couldn’t walk or stand for a while. She has to have regular chiropractic visits in which she gets adjusted and does spinal decompression. This was one of the reasons, at first, in which I felt we shouldn’t get pregnant because I know that she can get big, however, if all that weight from the baby starts to mess with her lower back,then she can have a bad episode and render her helpless. Of course I would be there to help but that is the reason why she doesn’t want to have anymore babies. It’s the high possibility of her back giving out on her. Not only that, she feels that strain of that specific area in her lower back and she’s afraid that it will give out on her at work. To make matters worse, I work 45 minutes away from her so I wouldn’t be able to get there fast enough
I mean, there is no doubt that having kids changes a woman’s body…permanently. But so what?
LOL…Yea but I’m the guy remember, so I just can’t exactly tell her “But so what?”
I’m really sorry about your miscarriage, that must have been very difficult for both of you.
Yes it was…
Anyway, your wife seems rather immature about this - she says you should have no limits on having sex? Well, there are plenty of things that grown adults have to limit - such as eating, drinking, partying, sleeping, speeding on the freeway, etc. etc. etc. Her argument, that you shouldn’t be restrained by NFP, is not well thought out. But I guess she knows she can have the upper hand here anyway, if she goes ahead with the procedure, what can you do?
Well, it’s hard to explain it to her. I even told her that it’s about disciplining ourselves and WHOA!!! She just view that as a sucker punch to the gut because she even went as far as to tell me that I said to her “You told me that it says in the bible that there is nothing wrong with being passionate with one another, that it is a gift from God and NOW your telling me we have to limit ourselves? THAT’S a contradiction!!” What she doesn’t understand is that there is a time for it and when we abstain for a while and conjoin, then that union will be much stronger not just physically and emotionally but more important spiritually.
And you know that she is going to sin, but she is ignoring the Church and God on this subject and doing it her way.
So am I just supposed to sit and watch? She is my wife and I love her with all my heart and I am responsible for not only her earthly needs but far more important her spiritual needs as well.
…maybe having the new baby will change her mind.
Well that’s what I was hoping for…but who knows we still have 5 more months to go and this would a good time to start a Novena.
 
OK, thanks for the further information. I sure wish that wives had to get their husband’s signature to get their tubes tied…Her OB doctor should not do that procedure until he/she has spoken to both of you. For one thing, having her tubes tied/clipped is not going to help with her periods at all. That would take a hysterectomy but then she’d have hormone problems and would go into instant menopause.
He won’t. As long as she is able to process her condition and make medical decisions it is not even legal to refuse to do a procedure until you can speak to someone’s spouse. He doesn’t even have a legal right to be informed unless she says he can be or unless she is incapacitated.

Really all he can do is make his opinion known.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top