Need Help...

  • Thread starter Thread starter grace68
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

grace68

Guest
My husband and I are practicing NFP and at this time have a good reason to postpone pregnancy.

Last night we did some things that led to me being aroused.

Is this a mortal sin? This is something that we do struggle with at times. I always confess it when it happens.

Grace:confused:
 
This is something to discuss with your priest. No one here can tell you whether it was a mortal sin or not.
 
True, no one here can answer that question–but you always see the response “ask your priest.” I have a hard time with that; usually there is no time in confession to turn it into a counseling session.

I did some hip exercises the other day to loosen my hip and that made me aroused. (I kid you not!!) I decided to confess it, but didn’t go into any detail. I certainly didn’t intend to get aroused, but I didn’t stop immediately after I realized what was happening. Now I thought if I got graphic with it, it might embarass the priest in confession, so I was very vague & just said I committed a sin of self-gratificaiton. I don’t want to turn my confessions into something that sounds like a 1-900 number.
 
It’s so HARD to differentiate where self-gratification begins sometimes.

It could just feel good to sit a certain way, and I don’t really realize WHY at first!
😊

Kathrin
 
Not to get off topic from the OP, but it is very hard sometimes. I’m sure when a man goes to confession and talks about “self-gratification” it can be pretty obvious. I’m trying not to be too explicit, but with women it can be completely different and sometimes it can be accidental. But it’s too embarassing to bring that up to a priest, (even reluctant to bring it up on anonymous forum) so I just use the standard “self-gratification” line. I figure the priest can guess whatever he wants but as least Jesus knows what I am sorry for.

For OP, I am single so I am not certain where the line is drawn in marriage.
 
Ran in to these site recently. May ans. some Confession questions.

confessions101.com/english/site.php?use=Question%201

“Q: How does one confess to very embarrassing personal sins of a sexual nature without telling the priest what he or she has done. Won’t Jesus forgive those kinds of sins anyway if one confesses to him personally?”

“A: It is embarrassing to confess personal sins of a sexual nature. You will not be telling the priest anything he has not heard already. In moral theology, he has covered all possible sins of a sexual nature and has heard it all long before he even sits in a confessional.”

“The embarrassment can be minimized by simply stating the category of sin and the approximate number of times it was committed. **There is no need to go into details; in fact, we are dissuaded from going into specific details. **The Church bends over backwards to make confession as easy as possible by allowing the penitent to go anywhere and to any priest he or she wants to, and also to go anonymously by entering the confessional where the priest cannot see the penitent.”

oursaviournyc.org/how-to-make-a-good-confession#5
 
I am a priest.

For Grace 68, yes, have a priest that you can talk to about it - I understand your concern, and even your worry, it can have a big impact on your marriage if you don’t get good answers. I have never hesitated to help people with exactly this question, some times in confession, some times in spiritual direction, some times in just conversation. It is an important question and so it is fair to ask; here is not the time or place for that though.
You will be surprised at how comfortable a priest will be with such discussions.

For Turtle18
“Self gratification” is going to mean something to the priest in the confessional that you don’t mean to say. From the way you describe it here, no priest could be certain if there is mortal sin or not. Saying “self-gratification” is certainly intimating mortal sin (if you came to me, I would ask a question or two to help you figure out how to confess this and maybe deal with those occasions when this sort of thing happens to you).

The advice about stating category and number is ok I guess, since the priest would then be inclined to ask questions to know what he is forgiving or retaining (Jn 20:23). For example, catgory: impurity, is not enough, there are a million variations and the priest needs to know what sin he is dealing with here. So in the end, while that advice might get you where you need to go, it is not really the best way to make a confession.

My advice to turtle18 is to tell the priest “I was doing some exercises and found myself aroused.” If you want to tell him what came of that (you stopped, you said a Hail Mary and the arousing stopped, so you finished your exercises without a problem, whatever), that would be helpful. But he has heard it all before, and he will take it from there - asking about intention or consent, or if it went beyond just being aroused, etc.

“Self gratification” is not really accurate - it sounds like mortal sin, when, as I say, what you described here does not.

“But it’s too embarassing to bring that up to a priest,” you said. Don’t let the devil and pride stop you from saying what needs to be said. “Too embarassing” is a poor reason for not making a confession as well as you can - priests have heard things you never even dreamed of, and God gives us the grace to hear it and talk about it if necessary because it is what we are there for - to heal and help heal souls.

Fear is from the devil, be not afraid.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top