New Catholic. How do I select a parish?

  • Thread starter Thread starter cons154
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

cons154

Guest
Newbie here, so please forgive if this isn’t posted in the right section.

My wife and I have felt directed to the Catholic Church for some time now. We have both been in evangelical churches our entire lives (currently Church of the Nazarene), and have been very active in our churches. At our current church, I am church pianist, assistant music director, former member of the church board; my wife is a nursery worker, VBS volunteer, etc. Needless to say, this change to the Catholic Church will be a major upheaval in our lives. To clarify: we are thrilled to be making this change, but nervous about what it entails.

Since we are finally (really) ready to make this change, we would like to do it this September when RCIA classes begin. Here’s our conundrum: When seeking out a new evangelical church, the most common process is to simply visit churches over the course of a few weeks to find the right fit. We are unable to visit Catholic parishes at the present time because my duties as assistant music director at our current church mean we must be at this church every Sunday morning. My concern is that if we start RCIA classes at a randomly selected parish, and then discover that the parish isn’t a good fit for our family, we are either stuck at that parish until after Easter or we would have to join another parish’s RCIA classes in the middle of the year. I don’t think either would be fair to the parish or the parish’s people.

We will be able to leave our current church at the end of August. From your experience, would it be acceptable to visit several Catholic parishes and then start RCIA classes late?

Also, it is fairly easy from visiting an evangelical church to determine if the church is a good fit. (By “good fit,” I mean filled with people who are not only seeking God with you, but who share your interests, aren’t all 40 years older or 40 years younger than you, have good preaching and music, have good children’s programming, seem to care about your needs, etc.) It’s easy because evangelical churches tend to be very informal – lots of chit-chat between church members and leadership before, after, and (!) during services. From our visits to Catholic parishes (weekday masses, etc.), it seems like it would be more difficult to “take the temperature” of a parish, its priest, and its people without spending several weeks and/or months becoming part of the parish.

This went on longer than I anticipated. 🙂 I’d appreciate any and all advice and would be happy to answer questions if it will help you understand where I’m coming from.
 
Just briefly, I will say that right now you live in a particular parish. Find out which church that is (often, but not always, the one closest to you - parishes cover a certain area, like cities), and start there - your home parish. If after you spend some time there you find that things are truly intolerable, then look for another parish. A good fit is important, but it could be that your home parish has a need for your particular talents, to make it a better place. Hope that helps.
 
Welcome to CAF and to the Catholic Church! 👋

Actually, one of the major differences between Evangelicals and Catholics is that Catholics belong to the parish where they live. It’s called a territorial parish. The exceptions are parishes that are ethnic or an ordinardiate parish, such as the Anglican Ordinariate. So your parish is whichever one in whose territory you live. You should start there.

Having said that, some Catholic parishes are more traditionally oriented and others are more modern in their approach. This can make it difficult for people if their home parish is one in which they feel they do not fit. So, although you are considered members in your terrritorial parish, you may attend any parish you like.

Again, having said that, Catholics are quite diverse. They may have a large ethnic representation or be mixed race. Some parishes are quite posh while others are poor. Suburban ones tend to be a mixture of middle class, well off and poor.

Catholics are to accept everyone no matter how good a Catholic or bad a Catholic they may be. We are all Catholics, so you’ll find people who hardly participate to those who are deeply involved.

So, it’s best to start with you territorial parish and go from there remembering that everyone is a member of the Church no matter if the parish is active and involved or just fulfilling their obligation. You should talk to the parish pastor and share your journey with him and then start RCIA. It may help you find your feet a bit quicker and he may be able to recommend a good sponsor/(s) for you and your family. God bless you and your faith journey. 🙂
 
Welcome! Welcome!

Even if I am a cradle Catholic, finding a home parish is a big job. I always take into consideration the liturgy of the church, the congregation’s participation, the way the pastor interacts with the people, the way he gives homilies and ways to be able to serve the parish.

When we were still back in Minnesota and fairly new, my family had the habit of going from church to church every Sunday just to get a feel on what the parish life is there. We had one that was ok in liturgy but the pastor was only welcoming to people he knows, then there was one that has an ok liturgy but when you look around the church is barely empty and mostly seniors (that means the parish is not growing, I have nothing against seniors) until we found our home, this parish was teeming with young families, teenagers, adults and seniors and the pastor is amazing, he joins the outings, socializes with as much people as he can after mass.

When we moved here in California, me and my husband went church hopping as well. there were only two churches in our area so it was not that hard of a decision. I admired the architecture of the first one…but…the altered the seats and where the altar is, so instead of your focus is on the Cross and the tabernacle, your focus is on the priest, don’t get me wrong but the congregation was big, I saw active youth participation but we felt empty. We wanted a traditional church that does not cut corners on where the focus should be, that’s when we decided to be a member of another parish.

Each parish has its flaws in different areas, take into consideration that evangelical churches are different from Catholic ones. Some Catholic churches are more social, some are more reserved. It all depends on how the pastor sees the parish.

Start looking at parishes near you (its more helpful to be closer if you are planning to be a part of the ministry), read up on their history, and look at their ministries. Go there on a Sunday/Saturday liturgy because that’s where you will see more parishoners in action, how they interact with new comers and with each other and see the interaction of the pastor to the congregation, take time to talk to the pastor too. Once you have made your decision, talk to the parish office about RCIA. They usually will have a sponsor to help you out with your journey which will culminate on Easter vigil (our favorite time of year apart from Christmas!)

Ask St. Anthony’s intercession to help you find a home parish. 😉

God Bless and welcome again!
 
Thanks all for the helpful answers! We live in a large community (well…large for Oklahoma!) - Tulsa - so there are many parishes in our general area of town. Is there a way to find out what would be considered our territorial parish? If I called the Diocese of Tulsa, would they have boundaries set up? Sorry if I sound stupid…this is just all very new. :confused:
 
Thanks all for the helpful answers! We live in a large community (well…large for Oklahoma!) - Tulsa - so there are many parishes in our general area of town. Is there a way to find out what would be considered our territorial parish? If I called the Diocese of Tulsa, would they have boundaries set up? Sorry if I sound stupid…this is just all very new. :confused:
Try www.parishesonline.com – just put in your zip code and it will give you the addresses of your closest parish church(es). There may be more than one.

It will also give you Mass times – you could consider attending a Vigil Mass (Saturday afternoon/evening) rather than Sunday to get a feel for the parish.
 
Thanks all for the helpful answers! We live in a large community (well…large for Oklahoma!) - Tulsa - so there are many parishes in our general area of town. Is there a way to find out what would be considered our territorial parish? If I called the Diocese of Tulsa, would they have boundaries set up? Sorry if I sound stupid…this is just all very new. :confused:
Yes, the diocese would know.

In terms of scoping out a Catholic parish, this can be difficult because the point if Mass is so very different from the point of an Evangelical service. We go to Mass to participate in the sacrifice of Christ on the cross, to be with Him.

The culture of Catholicism developed in an environment in which one lived in a Catholic community, so there was no need for fellowship at Mass, and in which education too was Catholic. As a result, the Catholic habit is to focus on God at Mass, and not so much with our neighbors. We are trying to change that habit, for various reasons, but just because Catholics don’t seem to be welcoming or forthcoming with their spiritual journey doesn’t mean it’s not a good parish.

One way you might check out the parishes nearby is by checking the organizations they have. This will be listed at their website. If they have pro-life, organizations that sound more traditional (lots of saints’ names 🙂 ), or if they have peace & social justice and other names which don’t sound very Catholic, they will tend to be different from each other.
 
Thanks all for the helpful answers! We live in a large community (well…large for Oklahoma!) - Tulsa - so there are many parishes in our general area of town. Is there a way to find out what would be considered our territorial parish? If I called the Diocese of Tulsa, would they have boundaries set up? Sorry if I sound stupid…this is just all very new. :confused:
Hello Cons154,

I actually went ahead and called the Diocese of Tulsa for you. The receptionist said that they do have a map, but do not have it published. She said the today, the Diocese really doesn’t enforce the boundaries (the priests will take care of all the paperwork on your behalf) unless you or a family member requires homebound services**.

She also said that none of the Parishes have their own cemetery, that wouldn’t be an issue either (that’s sometimes a requirement for geographic parishes).

She said the best thing to do is to simply on the “Parishes” link on the website dioceseoftulsa.org and visit the closest parish to your house. However, if you really want to know which one you technically live in, you can call the Diocese at 918-294-1904 and press 0 for operator.

Also, if you are looking for a little more traditional you also have a few other options:
  1. you could attend Mass at your Cathedral in Tulsa (most likely in English) holyfamilycathedralparish.com
  2. you could attend the Extraordinary Form of the Mass (in Latin) at the Parish of the Most Precious Blood (a FSSP parish) in Tulsa mostpreciousbloodparish.com/
  3. you could also try the Marnoite Rite Catholic Church in Tulsa - it’s in communion with the Pope, but is an Eastern Catholic Church, not a Roman Rite, Latin Catholic Church (aka Roman Catholic)
    dioceseoftulsa.org/index.cfm?load=org&org=81
God Bless and may The Lord guide you on your Faith Journey.

**Homebound services are for the elderly & sick people who have a hard time making it to mass can have communion brought to their house and a priest come to visit for Confession and/or Anointment of the Sick.
 
The culture of Catholicism developed in an environment in which one lived in a Catholic community, so there was no need for fellowship at Mass, and in which education too was Catholic. As a result, the Catholic habit is to focus on God at Mass, and not so much with our neighbors. We are trying to change that habit, for various reasons, but just because Catholics don’t seem to be welcoming or forthcoming with their spiritual journey doesn’t mean it’s not a good parish.
Definitely a true statement. A Catholic parish is usually very different than an Evangelical church. Catholics view the Parish as a place to go to receive the sacraments more than a social setting. My Mom is an Evangelical so I understand how social an evangelical community is! It may take you a little longer to make friends at a Catholic Parish, but don’t let that discourage you. Generally, in my experience, there is a core group of about 30% of the Parish that is really, really active. It might just take a little longer to break into that group than what you are used to.

Anyway, I was in your same situation last year. My territorial parish had some nice folks but the pastor was on the very liberal side. After some time attending Mass there before RCIA started, I decided to look around. I really fell in love with the Extraordinary Form parish in my diocese but it was pretty far from my house and school. The pastor there (also a convert!) recommended I go through RCIA at a Parish located a few minutes from my law school. (My law school was very far from my house.) So, I did that. It worked out great with my study schedule. That being said, I didn’t usually go there on Sundays because our RCIA group didn’t do the walk out and meet thing. I mostly went to the EF Parish on Sundays or another parish close to my house.

All that to say, if you don’t feel like your territorial parish is a good fit and you want your family to go through RCIA at a different Parish, it shouldn’t be a problem although Parish shopping isn’t really a traditional Catholic practice. If you discover half way through RCIA that the Parish isn’t a good fit, then you can also easily move to a different Parish after you become Catholic, although you will likely make some RCIA friends, making this decision more difficult.

JMR
 
Hello, pray on it first. Chose your closest parish and pray once more. God will gently send you where. you need to be. Now, it is always a first timers mistake to find the parish one likes. The best approach is to ask God where He may want you. It’s not always about feeling good and finding the right people. You may never find them. Better to understand that the Lord is present at all parishes before the tabernacle. When one goes to church it is less for ones comfort and more on spending time before our Lord where ever He may lead us. Stick to one parish and hold out as long as for ever, if not you will be like the ‘Cafeteria Catholic’ who is and never will be pleased with a church (because of ones arrogance and pride). Instead, with a better attitude join a comfortable parish and devote all your services to it as you have with the former group. Get involved and enjoy your ride. Remember, it is about visiting with Christ on Sundays and spending quality time at Mass time. As St. John the Baptist eloquently put it ,it is less about me and more about Him. God Bless and good luck with your wonderful journey.
 
Thank you all so much! This forum is awesome! My wife and I are feeling a bit better about this whole thing now. There are just so many differences between the Catholic and evangelical communities. “Church shopping” is something we’ve lived with our whole lives, but one of the things that attracted us to the Catholic church is the fact that the mass is for one specific purpose. Evangelical services are a hodge-podge of performances, multimedia entertainment, chit-chat, sermons, etc. – much of which distracts from the point of worship. So we are becoming accustomed to the idea that the point of going to mass is not the same as the point of going to an evangelical service. We are much more optimistic now. 👍 Thanks again.
 
Thank you all so much! This forum is awesome! My wife and I are feeling a bit better about this whole thing now. There are just so many differences between the Catholic and evangelical communities. “Church shopping” is something we’ve lived with our whole lives, but one of the things that attracted us to the Catholic church is the fact that the mass is for one specific purpose. Evangelical services are a hodge-podge of performances, multimedia entertainment, chit-chat, sermons, etc. – much of which distracts from the point of worship. So we are becoming accustomed to the idea that the point of going to mass is not the same as the point of going to an evangelical service. We are much more optimistic now. 👍 Thanks again.
I’m glad I can help. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top