New Study on the Decline in Vocations

  • Thread starter Thread starter misstherese
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That said, I’m pretty sure you’ve never seen a nun not wearing a habit. Nuns are by definition cloistered sisters
This is not true. There are active orders and cloistered orders. Many active orders don’t sport a habit anymore. Yes, there are sisters (not nuns), but they are still considered women religious and still are brides of Christ. I actually think it is more important for them to wear habits because it shows to others that there is something more to life.

This issue reminds me of the stories of St. Padre Pio:
One day a gentleman who wore a jacket, tie and pants was in the sacristy with the others waiting for Padre Pio’s arrival. This man was in the first row. When Padre Pio saw him, he said, “Father, you came “disguised,” but you don’t have to be ashamed. Next time, you can come dressed as priest.”
Padre Pio told another young man who was wearing only pants and a sweater that he should go away and come back wearing the cowl of St. Dominic. Confused and embarrassed, the young man confessed in front of everyone to being a Dominican priest.
 
This is not true. There are active orders and cloistered orders. Many active orders don’t sport a habit anymore. Yes, there are sisters (not nuns), but they are still considered women religious and still are brides of Christ. I actually think it is more important for them to wear habits because it shows to others that there is something more to life.
I am not wrong. I said « nuns »which by definition are cloistered women.
 
They are nuns. Just because they are in an active order doesn’t mean they aren’t nuns.
 
http://www.religious-vocation.com/differences_religious_orders.html#.WlZlOHdMHYU

There are all sorts of definitions. Many active orders live in communities and don a habit, many live in a community and don’t don a habit. I’m not sure when the sister-but-not-a-nun-so-no-need-to-wear-a-habit business came to be, but it must be recent because I know for certain it didn’t exist in the Middle Ages. Beguines existed, which would be sort of like what a sister is, but they also wore something that distinguished them as such.
 
Active Orders
“Active” orders (Franciscans, Dominicans, Jesuits, Missionaries of Charity, etc.) are those who tend to have more direct interaction with the world than contemplative orders. In addition to prayer, active orders may devote some of their “work” time to external apostolates (teaching, preaching, soup kitchens, missions, youth retreats, media apostolates, etc.) rather than to self-supportive ends (gardening, bee farming, candle making, etc.). In this sense, they tend to follow Scripture in a more literal way; to “feed the hungry”, “give drink to the thirsty”; to be in the world, but not of the world. Active orders tend to be less bound by the walls of a monastery, and may reassign its members to different locations abroad. Some of the most active orders, such as the Jesuits, may not even be required to live in community, and are thus the most “free” in terms of possible assignments within the Church. Just as a sparrow requires only a few moments of rest on a small branch before taking to flight again, so too are such members called to obediently go where they are told, be it a professor in a school, a spiritual director in a seminary, a manager of a retreat house, or a missionary in a far off land. Typically, active orders are also Mendicant orders, meaning; they live off of the charity of others, rather than trying to be self-supportive (note; Carmelites and Poor Clares are technically mendicants as well.”
 
Active Orders

“Active” orders (Franciscans, Dominicans, Jesuits, Missionaries of Charity, etc.) are those who tend to have more direct interaction with the world than contemplative orders.
They are not, however, “nuns”, just as a Dominican or Franciscan man is not a monk. They are sisters (woman) and friars (men). Nuns are strictly contemplative and do not leave the cloister except in very rare circumstances, such as medical reasons.

Dominicans and franciscans are not contemplative orders and hence their women are non nuns.
 
Okay, we will go with that number. Assuming 550 priests in chapels across the world (the rest either in administration or seminary as teachers), that works out to an average of 1090. We still have the same issue.

With 300,000 we have about 550 per chapel. I have no clue as to how large chapels are elsewhere in the world.
 
They are nuns. Just because they are in an active order doesn’t mean they aren’t nuns.
Do you understand the distinction between a consecrated woman who is a Nun and a consecrated woman who is a Sister? It is a most fundamental and basic distinction in consecrated life.
 
Yes. The “pantsuit” orders are dying out, and there is currently a resurgence of the prevalence of traditional habits thanks to the interest of the younger generation.

Can you picture Saint Theresa of Avila in a pantsuit? Lol!
Hilary Clinton probably has a full wardrobe of them. Nah, just kidding you. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top