New Study Shows Abstinence Education Effective

Status
Not open for further replies.
Before the sexual revolution, there was sex outside of marriage, but not nearly as much as afterwards, when it literally exploded. I went to a Catholic high school before the sexual revolution. My friends went to a public high school. There were virtually no teen pregnancies at either place. Why? Fear of pregnancy. There was no pill to guarantee sex without consequences. Abortion was largely unavailable. Condoms were kept behind the pharmacy counter. No one was willing to risk it, because pregnancy meant either immediate marriage, or giving the child up for adoption, and in either case, a ruined reputation. Read the book.
Maybe sex among young people was less but your statement didn’t restrict itself to them. As far as I’m aware, there were pregnancy homes and distant aunts when girls got pregnant, not to mention the phenomenon of the shotgun wedding. Abortion was not legal, but there were ways - always have been.

My impression of the pre-60s is that people hid lots of stuff, not that they were necessarily less sinful. I have heard much from people who were young in those times, and even if it is just word of mouth, the amount of pedophilia, incest and plain old garden variety immorality that existed is quite revealing; not to mention transactional sex among the desperately poor. My first knowledge of abortion were whispers about an elderly woman in our neighborhood who had never married but was rumored to have aborted several pregnancies. So unless you have some reliable numbers that indicate sexual purity before the 60s, I’ll go with my gut and personal experiences on this one.
 
That seekerz would even pose such a preposterous question is proof of what they teach these days about the way it was, vs the reality that, we here, who are older, actually remember as being the reality, which the immoral have effectively erased from existence.
My question was preposterous? Really? Just recently, one fellow poster offered an interesting insight into research interview she held with octogenarians and their reports of sexual activity and abortion in their day, seem to differ substantially from yours…wish I could find it now.
 
My question was preposterous? Really? Just recently, one fellow poster offered an interesting insight into research interview she held with octogenarians and their reports of sexual activity and abortion in their day, seem to differ substantially from yours…wish I could find it now.
Yes, shamefully preposterous. I was ashamed to even read it. But that goes to show the completely opposite direction of our agendas.

Maybe this is it?

youtube.com/watch?v=heRvRYGX6Rk

They also have a video called, “boys beware”.
 
Well, having lived through the relative calm of the pre-sexual revolution era and the social chaos that followed the sexual revolution, I simply speak from my own experience that things have changed drastically, and for the worse.

Human nature has not changed. We were no less sinners then than now. But consider how the social milieu has changed. Then, the most popular TV show was “I Love Lucy.” There was no internet and no porn available to be piped into homes. Children were not given “sexuality education” beginning in first grade, nor were free condoms available. Sex without consequences was not possible.

The biggest change was the introduction of the oral contraceptive pill. Suddenly, sex without personal consequences became possible. Sex without commitment was possible. Women could no longer cite fear of pregnancy as a reason to not have pre-marital sex. The power shifted to men. Now, if women wanted a boyfriend, sex was expected.

That was why, in reading Mary Eberstadt’s book, it was like going through a detailed account of the changes in society that I have experienced in the course of my own lifetime. Not only that, but she cites numerous studies as to the effects of this change. Yes, things have gotten worse. But for many, sex without consequences still maintains a powerful hold—powerful enough to make us blind to the disastrous societal consequences of the change.
 
I want to mention a few cautions about this study. One is that it doesn’t say how long the effectiveness of the abstinence program will last. The time period studied was short: less than a year.

Another caution is that although the program seemed effective among 9th graders who were still virgins, it wasn’t effective in reducing sexual activity among those who were already active.

And, the program only studied ninth graders. Whether it would be effective with older students is unknown.

Still, the study is one more thing to consider when designing a sex education curriculum.
 
Well, having lived through the relative calm of the pre-sexual revolution era and the social chaos that followed the sexual revolution, I simply speak from my own experience that things have changed drastically, and for the worse.

Human nature has not changed. We were no less sinners then than now. But consider how the social milieu has changed. Then, the most popular TV show was “I Love Lucy.” There was no internet and no porn available to be piped into homes. Children were not given “sexuality education” beginning in first grade, nor were free condoms available. Sex without consequences was not possible.

The biggest change was the introduction of the oral contraceptive pill. Suddenly, sex without personal consequences became possible. Sex without commitment was possible. Women could no longer cite fear of pregnancy as a reason to not have pre-marital sex. The power shifted to men. Now, if women wanted a boyfriend, sex was expected.

That was why, in reading Mary Eberstadt’s book, it was like going through a detailed account of the changes in society that I have experienced in the course of my own lifetime. Not only that, but she cites numerous studies as to the effects of this change. Yes, things have gotten worse. But for many, sex without consequences still maintains a powerful hold—powerful enough to make us blind to the disastrous societal consequences of the change.
Sex without consequences has always been possible - ever heard of a douche? It has simply become easier and not something most people stress over now. There has always been contraception; you might want to read the history of coitus interruptus. There has always been abortion, unfortunately, it just wasn’t legal before the last few decades. There has always been sexual immorality of various types, the difference now is that many such behaviors are now accepted as completely normal, so there is, arguably more of it happening.
 
Sex without consequences has always been possible - ever heard of a douche? It has simply become easier and not something most people stress over now. There has always been contraception; you might want to read the history of coitus interruptus. There has always been abortion, unfortunately, it just wasn’t legal before the last few decades. There has always been sexual immorality of various types, the difference now is that many such behaviors are now accepted as completely normal, so there is, arguably more of it happening.
Yes, there is certainly more of it happening, with increasing degrees of acceptance, since the sexual revolution, which would not have been possible without widespread contraception. The adverse social consequences have been and continue to be a disaster. So while individuals may think that the revolution increased their ability to have sex without consequences, for the culture there are always consequences.
 
Sex without consequences has always been possible - ever heard of a douche? It has simply become easier and not something most people stress over now. There has always been contraception; you might want to read the history of coitus interruptus. There has always been abortion, unfortunately, it just wasn’t legal before the last few decades. There has always been sexual immorality of various types, the difference now is that many such behaviors are now accepted as completely normal, so there is, arguably more of it happening.
Of course these methods exist but as you know douching, showering, withdrawal and so on are not nearly as effective as a hormonal contraceptive or condom, and definitely not as effective as when both are used consistently. The society has also changed and acceptance of contraception is now pretty much ubiquitous, even among many who claim to be religious. They just don’t see a problem with it.
 
My impression of the pre-60s is that people hid lots of stuff, not that they were necessarily less sinful. I have heard much from people who were young in those times, and even if it is just word of mouth, the amount of pedophilia, incest and plain old garden variety immorality that existed is quite revealing;
Interesting. When my mother was in high school pregnancies were extremely rare. People did not have sex on dates. She and her sisters went on many dates in HS and university but in HS pre-marital sex was never mentioned, a boy never hinted he wanted that. It was very rare. In university some pre-marital sex occurred but it was still less common than non-sex. This is info from relatives, who still think the world is pretty much so right now. Hitchhiking was common too. Murder was rare despite most students hitchhiking during the holidays, sometimes across Europe. And both men and women shared the same rooms or sometimes slept in groups in barns and so on when traveling as young students. Sometimes a strange boy and girl shared the same sleeping bag but no touching ever occurred. There just was a different worldview. Sex was something very personal and occurred after marriage. This was long before HIV/AIDS.

Of course there were a handful of people everywhere who were loose. But they were the exception and they were shunned by the more educated students.
not to mention transactional sex among the desperately poor. My first knowledge of abortion were whispers about an elderly woman in our neighborhood who had never married but was rumored to have aborted several pregnancies. So unless you have some reliable numbers that indicate sexual purity before the 60s, I’ll go with my gut and personal experiences on this one.
My info is from Eastern Europe. I can’t comment on what happen in the USA but young people often traveled outside of the Eastern Bloc too and did not suddenly get pregnant in Italy or France.
 
I think the problem is that success for the two methods of education is measured differently. Say you have two groups of students that number 100 each. Group 1 is given abstinence only education and Group 2 is given secular sex education. Now, when all is said and done, in Group 1, only 10 people had sex, 7 of those 10 had protected sex and 3 actually had babies. In Group 2, 90 of the people had sex. All used protection and therefore, no one got pregnant. With those (very hypothetical) scenarios, which method is the most successful?
 
I honestly think that Abstinence Education is really the way to go. I’d even go one step further and propose that abstinence be practiced by everyone, except those who are married for procreation purposes only. It would virtually eliminate abortion, birth control devices and cure many social issues facing our country.
 
As far as sexuality is concerned, erase the past 50 years and set the clock back to about 1955 and don’t let it advance any farther. That’s my hope.

God, I hope I can find a pure, chaste, and spiritually elated Catholic girl. 😦
Eh. Whatever.
 
As far as sexuality is concerned, erase the past 50 years and set the clock back to about 1955 and don’t let it advance any farther. That’s my hope.

God, I hope I can find a pure, chaste, and spiritually elated Catholic girl. 😦
Eh. Whatever.
What’s wrong with 1956? Elvis Presley appears on The Ed Sullivan Show. All down hill from there…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top