There is absolutely nothing unreasonable in the policy that you have relayed from your parish. Nothing.
Easter this year is April 16 and today is March 11. That is hardly an onerous delay.
As for calling the offices of Catholic Answers, I cannot imagine how that would be of any utility, since the decision lies with your parish priest and with your diocese.
Since you have listed your religion as “Raised Catholic but not sure what I believe now,” you would benefit from the class.
Since you qualify yourself simply as “raised Catholic,” are you actually practicing the Faith? Or is your spouse? That is, actually, a more relevant question to be asking in light of canon 868.