NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I tried reading most of this thread however it has gotten very large 🙂 This may have been addressed already…

FH & I are going to use NFP for first year of marriage, our wedding night is on the predicted peak fertility of my cycle. We have decided not to abstain the night of the wedding, as we feel it would be against Our Lord’s plan.

Is this correct?
You and your spouse may abstain if you prayerfully decide it is for the best, but you could also be open to a honeymoon baby, which brings many blessings, as I and a few other posters on this forum know.
👍
And remember, as you continue to pray about and discern your serious/just/grave reason whatever it is you may find it is no longer a serious/just/grave reason before the estimated year. That is the beauty of NFP, it is not a final decision you are making, it is a dialog between you as a couple and God, where you are seeking to do His will with the awesome gift of fertility that He has given us. Just do your best to seek Our Lord’s plan for you both!
 
I think the difference of opinion is in what “contraception/contraceptive” means. I have been very sick lately precluding any activity with my husband, does that mean I am avoiding pregnancy? I think what the church is saying is that not having sex is not contraception. Contraceptive instead means that we are preventing pregnancy while we are engaged in the marital act. If you are not engaged in the marital act you cannot be ‘contracepting.’
But I think Dan Daly’s point is that you are not abstinent when you are using NFP, only during the fertile period. The rest of the month, by charting your cycle you are able to have “worry free” sex.
 
But I think Dan Daly’s point is that you are not abstinent when you are using NFP, only during the fertile period. The rest of the month, by charting your cycle you are able to have “worry free” sex.
So how many times during the fertile period must a couple have sex in order for that sex to be deemed non-contraceptive? Is once enough or is every day required? Is it a sin to not have sex on the day of ovulation?
 
So how many times during the fertile period must a couple have sex in order for that sex to be deemed non-contraceptive? Is once enough or is every day required? Is it a sin to not have sex on the day of ovulation?
This is a good post. In my NFP discussions on CAF, the argument that NFP allows intimacy on non fertile days= contracption comes up often.

The non fertile days are non fertile by design.

A woman ovulates one day per month, the fertile widnow is about 6 days per month. The Church does not teach that intimacy is only allowed on fertile days. If it did, than post menopausal relations would be wrong, relations during pregnancy would be wrong etc.

We are prohibited from using contraceptives. We are allowed to be intimate as frquently as we like. If we need to avoid pregnancy, we avoid sex when pregnancy can occur.

None of these actions are contraceptive.

People might use NFP for selfish reasons. But the sin would be a selfish attitude not contraception.

Rememeber Gone with The Wind? Scarlet wanted no more children because she was worried she would beecome fat. (extreme example) She was selfish because she was not being open to more children…but also her selfishness was towards her husband as well, rejecting him completely.
 
This is a good post. In my NFP discussions on CAF, the argument that NFP allows intimacy on non fertile days= contracption comes up often.

The non fertile days are non fertile by design.

A woman ovulates one day per month, the fertile widnow is about 6 days per month. The Church does not teach that intimacy is only allowed on fertile days. If it did, than post menopausal relations would be wrong, relations during pregnancy would be wrong etc.

**We are prohibited from using contraceptives. We are allowed to be intimate as frquently as we like. If we need to avoid pregnancy, we avoid sex when pregnancy can occur.

None of these actions are contraceptive.**

People might use NFP for selfish reasons. But the sin would be a selfish attitude not contraception.
Exactly! Also, the Church CLEARLY distinguishes NFP from any act that is contraceptive…they are in no way similar.

From our Pope:
497. When is it moral to regulate births?
2368-2369
2399
The regulation of births, which is an aspect of responsible fatherhood and motherhood, is objectively morally acceptable when it is pursued by the spouses without external pressure; when it is practiced not out of selfishness but for serious reasons; and with methods that conform to the objective criteria of morality, that is, periodic continence and use of the infertile periods.
  1. What are immoral means of birth control?
    2370-2372
    Every action - for example, direct sterilization or contraception - is intrinsically immoral which (either in anticipation of the conjugal act, in its accomplishment or in the development of its natural consequences) proposes, as an end or as a means, to hinder procreation. (Compendium of the Catechism, Pope Benedict XVI) (emphasis mine)
You are free to disagree if you wish…but the Church is not wrong in Her teaching.
 
So, my husband and I must have sex every night, or else we are contracepting. Is that what you believe?
That would be one way for a spouse to have more sex. If you don’t have sex, you are contracepting, which is a sin. You will go to Hell if you don’t have sex now! 😛

I could see that taking off.
So how many times during the fertile period must a couple have sex in order for that sex to be deemed non-contraceptive? Is once enough or is every day required? Is it a sin to not have sex on the day of ovulation?
I can just see it now…we will all have to wear IDs on our shirts/coats, similar to the insignia worn by Jews in Nazi Germany, only these will have microchips containing the wife’s fertility charts and medical information. Then, the NFP Gestapo will use a barcode scanner at will (especially in the Communion line) to determine if the wife is in a fertile period and what other conditions she has so that they can take it upon themselves to judge “grave reasons”, and if they do not find any, they will ship the married couple in a railroad car to “conception camps” which will have the sign at the entrance “Pregnancy macht frei”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top