No… sex is not “only” for having children. The two aspects are NOT separable… they are completely intertwined… inseparable.
Your second paragraph sorta indicates that you may still not understand this. There is no “for the sake of intimacy”… union and procreation are one. Separating the two is the *definition *of the “contraceptive mentality”.
Just have to disagree on it. Because based on what you say here, I would bet then that the majority couples using NFP are sinning. If in fact that using NFP and having sex at the infertile times to lessen the chances of having a child is a sin, then yep, sex is for having kids. Makes no sense other wise. Yeah, the church teaches unitive and procreative at all times. But it seems that you are saying that the difference lies in whether the couple is thinking, “Gee, I hope we don’t get pregnant” or “It’s OK if we do.”
There’s no confusion… you pray about the decision to use NFP with your spouse, you analyze those reasons on a monthly basis and you make a mutual decision - BASED IN PRAYER - whether to avoid relations or not.
I think a lot of times couples have a difficult time understanding the “based in prayer” part. They’re basing it on OTHER factors, like their savings accounts
The way this is phrased, and the way this is usually phrased when it is brought up, seems to say that finances are not a matter of concern. Hell, yes, we base it on finances. To do otherwise is utterly irresponsible. Is it the only factor? Probably not. Is it the main factor for many, many couples? You bet. I’d have had (past tense) a housefull if we had the money and the house; we didn’t, we don’t, and we will not any time soon. That has been the case for many years. At this time, at our age, no I don’t particularly wish to have more children. Would we welcome them? Of course. Is it best for the child if our age presents health concerns? No. But our finances, and now age, are the primary factors in not having more children.
(not meeting a" particular" number, etc) or perceived health (I’m still carrying those 5lbs from my last pregnancy)… these may be very *practical/responsible *reasons, but are they
prayerful? That’s up to the couple to decide. This is what the line “Moreover, they should conform their behavior to the objective criteria of morality.” means… it’s “more” than the “responsible parenthood” portion…
Yes, there are certainly very “practical” reasons to avoid at any given time. But unless you can sincerely and PRAYERFULLY come to the conclusion that they are truly
Bringing children into the world a couple cannot afford financially or provide a proper place for them to live is moral? “Objective moral criteria” - what is that? It means the couple has to decide, but seem to be condemned for it at the same time if ever health or finances are even mentioned. It has been said more than once in these forums and threads that couple should just go ahead and have kids; God will provide. Is that the moral way - roll the dice - to bring kids into the word as loving parents? I think not. And I do not think it is sinning or selfish./COLOR]
MORAL reasons… then it can be a challenge to stick to the plan.

… and this could (potentially) cross the line into sinning… “are we being selfish in this decision?”…