NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My understanding is that the guidance of a priest is ALWAYS needed, in order for NFP to be ethical and in accordance with Church teaching.

This part is often forgotte, along with having just reasons.

Pax
This is not true.
 
And why is simply saying I don’t want to have children, or any more children, trivial?
By saying that you are unwittingly admitting that you’ve bought into modern culture’s notion that marriage, sex and babies are separate topics. What God is telling us through revelation is that He has tied these things up together and that when they are lived as an unmolested whole, they are a source of Grace in our lives. When man attempts to cut them apart into stand alone subjects, the gift is debased from something truly holy into something that merely feeds the human tendency to narcicissm. When you say “I want this marriage, I want my sexual intimacy when I want it, but I refuse to have more children” you are subtly telling God He made us wrong and that you can fix His little oopsie. God’s a smart guy and we humans are notoriously dumb by comparison. But we consistently think we can meddle with His designs and expect no negative consequences (entitled to none, actually).

We humans know pitiably little about how our souls really work, we’ve been given a revelation about human sexuality and its proper function that has a centuries long track record of building up healthy civilization, yet we have the pride and arrogance to cast it aside and ignore the obvious conequences of doing so in our larger culture over the last 60 years! I used to marvel at the seeming stupidity of the Israelites in Exodus (i.e. making a golden calf to worship so soon after God parted the Red Sea for them, etc.) As I got older, I realized that humans haven’t changed a dang bit since then.

I better quit, I’m starting to rant! 😉
 
The couplel decides through prayer and discernment and the guidance of a holy priest or spiritual director, if needed. It should fall within the categories listed above: economic, social or medical.
And emotional (unless it is included under social).

I had a miscarriage a little bit ago, and the thought of getting pregnant scares me. I need time to emotionally recover. So my husband and I are using NFP. It might be a sin, but a man (or woman) doesn’t have to die to go to Hell. I went through Hell and back with our miscarriage, and I’m not prepared to go through it right away.
 
My understanding is that the guidance of a priest is ALWAYS needed, in order for NFP to be ethical and in accordance with Church teaching.

This part is often forgotten, along with having just reasons.

Pax
Can you cite a source for that understand? Or is it simply something you believe should be done?
 
Can you cite a source for that understand? Or is it simply something you believe should be done?
I’ve never heard anything authoritative that backs up that claim. It’s a good idea to have a spiritual director, for sure. And I’d agree that that’s a topic for discussion in spiritual direction.

It’s good advice, but I doubt it’s an authoritative command. The Church doesn’t command us to look both ways before crossing the street either. 😃
 
I’ve never heard anything authoritative that backs up that claim. It’s a good idea to have a spiritual director, for sure. And I’d agree that that’s a topic for discussion in spiritual direction.

It’s good advice, but I doubt it’s an authoritative command. The Church doesn’t command us to look both ways before crossing the street either. 😃
Of course there isn’t anything authoritative.

And it is good advice if you feel that maybe your “just reasons” aren’t what the church would see as “just reasons.”

But if your life is on the line, there is no need to talk about it with anyone other than your doctor and your spouse.
 
Can you cite a source for that understand? Or is it simply something you believe should be done?
It’s something I’ve been told and read, not a personal opinion I formed. I went looking for sources and found this:

catholicapologetics.info/morality/family/nfamp.htm
How does a Catholic married couple know if any reason they have is serious enough to justify using NFP?
It’s not enough that the couple themselves believe their condition is serious. They must also have the advice of a good Catholic-minded doctor, if it is a medical question; and the permission of a good Catholic priest nefore they can start practicing periodic abstinence.
That is what I remember hearing and reading from other sources before.
I’m not familiar with this particular website and unfortunately it doesn’t provide footnotes. Perhaps someone else with expertise on the topic and help us out with more sources- that come from the Church.

Pax and God Bless.
 
Of course there isn’t anything authoritative.

And it is good advice if you feel that maybe your “just reasons” aren’t what the church would see as “just reasons.”

But if your life is on the line, there is no need to talk about it with anyone other than your doctor and your spouse.
With charity, I’d suggest that your comment points to a very common error- having far greater concern over physical danger than over spiritual danger.

You say “if your life is on the line” you only need to talk to a doctor and your spouse. Misapplication of NFP could possibly be a mortal sin. While our physical lives are important, they are insignificant in comparison with our eternal lives. One can not ignore the eternal spiritual ramifications of their actions even if their physical life is in danger. There are several clear examples of Church teaching that touch on this very topic- no exception permitting direct abortion, even to save the life of a mother as well as the immorality of many kinds of organ transplants (heart transplants for one).

Pax and God Bless.
 
There are several clear examples of Church teaching that touch on this very topic- the immorality of many kinds of organ transplants (heart transplants for one).

Pax and God Bless.
What !!?

Source?
 
from the CCC, 2296:
2296 Organ transplants are in conformity with the moral law if the physical and psychological dangers and risks incurred by the donor are proportionate to the good sought for the recipient. Donation of organs after death is a noble and meritorious act and is to be encouraged as a manifestation of generous solidarity. It is not morally acceptable if the donor or those who legitimately speak for him have not given their explicit consent.
It is furthermore morally inadmissible directly to bring about the disabling mutilation or death of a human being, even in order to delay the death of other persons.
I don’t see an exception being made for heart transplants. I do agree that it’s possible to put people under pressure to ‘sell’ or donate an organ and that should not be done.
 
It’s something I’ve been told and read, not a personal opinion I formed. I went looking for sources and found this:

catholicapologetics.info/morality/family/nfamp.htm

That is what I remember hearing and reading from other sources before.
I’m not familiar with this particular website and unfortunately it doesn’t provide footnotes. Perhaps someone else with expertise on the topic and help us out with more sources- that come from the Church.

Pax and God Bless.
This is simply a web site run by a group of people. You are right in that the site does not provide footnotes or sources. In fact, it looks to be a web site full of opinion.
With charity, I’d suggest that your comment points to a very common error- having far greater concern over physical danger than over spiritual danger.

You say “if your life is on the line” you only need to talk to a doctor and your spouse. Misapplication of NFP could possibly be a mortal sin. While our physical lives are important, they are insignificant in comparison with our eternal lives. One can not ignore the eternal spiritual ramifications of their actions even if their physical life is in danger. There are several clear examples of Church teaching that touch on this very topic- no exception permitting direct abortion, even to save the life of a mother as well as the immorality of many kinds of organ transplants (heart transplants for one).

Pax and God Bless.
So you are saying, that according to Church teaching, not just what you believe, that a woman must get permission from her priest to practice NFP? That a medical condition that could cause the death of the mother would not be a reason to practice NFP if the priest says so?

We are not talking about anything here but NFP. We are not talking about abortion, war, or killing anyone. We are simply talking about periodic abstinence. So I would like to know in what instance would it be a sin to periodically abstain from relations due to the mothers health.

And where do you get the idea that a heart transplant can be immoral?
 
from the CCC, 2296:

I don’t see an exception being made for heart transplants. I do agree that it’s possible to put people under pressure to ‘sell’ or donate an organ and that should not be done.
I didn’t see anything in there that says anything about any transplant procedure in and of itself being immoral. The only thing it claims to be immoral is to kill one person to harvest their organs to save someone else. And that could mean pressuring someone to pull the plug on someone else in a vegetative state in order to get organs. For instance, someone is in a irreversible coma vs. brain dead. If the person in the irreversible coma, but has marginal brain activity, but couldn’t live without machinery, didn’t sign a living will stating go ahead and pull the plug," I don’t want to be on life support if I’m not going to live", then it would be morally wrong for a doctor or anyone to say “he’s not going to ever wake up, and so and so needs his heart to live.” and pressure the family to take him off life support. If the family decides on their own that their loved one wouldn’t want to live like this, receive advanced life support, and they authorize organ harvesting, without pressure, then that’s different.

It’s probably also morally wrong to offer someone money so you could jump ahead in the organ transplant line, too. 😉
 
For the life of me, I totally don’t understand how a priest who is supposed to be “celibate” and I think that would pre-suppose “chaste” can possibly give advice on sexuality in the marriage relationship or advice concerning NFP. Seems pretty strange. I’m sure he can state “what the church says”, but more than this?

I did attend a lecture on canon law and found out that a paraplegic could not get married by the Church unless he could perform the “marital act” in the proper way. He would have to get some treatments and take some special medicine to insure he could perform the act . Otherwise he cannot marry for companionship or love. What nonsense.

In theory everything is wonderful and makes perfect sense, everyday reality is a whole different thing, like someone said, no wonder people become neurotic just thinking about these things.
 
For the life of me, I totally don’t understand how a priest who is supposed to be “celibate” and I think that would pre-suppose “chaste” can possibly give advice on sexuality in the marriage relationship or advice concerning NFP. Seems pretty strange. I’m sure he can state “what the church says”, but more than this?

I did attend a lecture on canon law and found out that a paraplegic could not get married by the Church unless he could perform the “marital act” in the proper way. He would have to get some treatments and take some special medicine to insure he could perform the act . Otherwise he cannot marry for companionship or love. What nonsense.

In theory everything is wonderful and makes perfect sense, everyday reality is a whole different thing, like someone said, no wonder people become neurotic just thinking about these things.
Beautifully said. As in church teachings on sex, which is where this is tied to, I cannot for the life of me believe that God or the Holy Spirit or Jesus dictated that couples cannot get married because they cannot have kids. That is just not possible from a loving God who puts couples together; if we believe that, then not being allowed to marry because you can’t have kids is not valid. Same as limiting intimate relations with your spouse because children are not or cannot be part of the picture. The situation is totally different, though, for the first case.
 
Beautifully said. As in church teachings on sex, which is where this is tied to, I cannot for the life of me believe that God or the Holy Spirit or Jesus dictated that couples cannot get married because they cannot have kids. That is just not possible from a loving God who puts couples together; if we believe that, then not being allowed to marry because you can’t have kids is not valid. Same as limiting intimate relations with your spouse because children are not or cannot be part of the picture. The situation is totally different, though, for the first case.
You CAN get married if you can’t have kids. You can’t get married if you can’t perform the act BEFORE marriage and it’s known.

Priests are people, too. We act like they couldn’t have a clue about relationships. Guess what, they can. We act like it’s not GOD speaking through them (esp during confession). Guess what, it is. They are given special graces to handle these questions and problems.
 
Is it not the Catholic Church’s teaching that,

1.NFP is only to be used in the most serious of situations.

If true, why is this not preached more?
For example, I have watched many good programs on EWTN and read many articles and discussions on the internet about NFP, but this fact is almost always left out of the discussion. Yet it is so vital to the spiritual well being of the couple practicing NFP.

Am I mistaken, is this not a teachings of the Church.
Thank you all.
Only if it’s abused. I feel using it to avoid children because they are inconvenient for the couple at a given time is abuse and is sinful. If it’s for valid medical reasons then I don’t see a problem with it.
 
My understanding is that it is a teaching of the Church… NFP should only be used for a sufficient reason. Not just because the couple doesn’t want children.
Thats my understanding as well. 👍:bowdown2::whistle:
 
I can’t for the life of me understand why a person outside of the marrige gets to decide one of the single most intimate decisions from within a marriage. I find that far more disturbing than the potential mis-use of NFP.

Small things ARE important. Spouses do need to tend to their own emotinal needs, to the needs of children already born, to live within their means. None of those are considered valid, I’m sure and a stern priest would probably reject them.

I am also not married, but I see many different families. Emotinally, it takes alot to have a big family. It takes alot to raise a couple of kids…or even “just” one with disabilities (either the parent or child). It’s like the air mask thing, unless you put your air mask on first, both you and your kid will die. I don’t see how you could possibly have a big family without people nearby to help out. You need to be emotinally stable and be a ROCK in the best of scenerios. Not everyone is capable of that. I think it is better for a couple to err on the side of caution and raise 2-3 functioning, happy kids than do whatever they feel and raise 5-10 kids many of who turn out to be burnouts, drug addicts and prison bench warmers. It should be up to that couple to decide.

This seems to stem from two (both somewhat dangerous) trains of thought prevelant in American society.
  1. I am religious, I am right and therefore if you don’t listen you’re sinning and you MUST listen to my way
  2. the idea that somehow professionals always know better than laymen. And quite franly the professional (Priest) referred to in this scenerio isn’t even qualified. Unless a priest holds a master’s in councelling (at minimum) he is not qualified to deeply council anyway.
 
I can’t for the life of me understand why a person outside of the marrige gets to decide one of the single most intimate decisions from within a marriage. I find that far more disturbing than the potential mis-use of NFP.

Small things ARE important. Spouses do need to tend to their own emotinal needs, to the needs of children already born, to live within their means. None of those are considered valid, I’m sure and a stern priest would probably reject them.

I am also not married, but I see many different families. Emotinally, it takes alot to have a big family. It takes alot to raise a couple of kids…or even “just” one with disabilities (either the parent or child). It’s like the air mask thing, unless you put your air mask on first, both you and your kid will die. I don’t see how you could possibly have a big family without people nearby to help out. You need to be emotinally stable and be a ROCK in the best of scenerios. Not everyone is capable of that. I think it is better for a couple to err on the side of caution and raise 2-3 functioning, happy kids than do whatever they feel and raise 5-10 kids many of who turn out to be burnouts, drug addicts and prison bench warmers. It should be up to that couple to decide.

This seems to stem from two (both somewhat dangerous) trains of thought prevelant in American society.
  1. I am religious, I am right and therefore if you don’t listen you’re sinning and you MUST listen to my way
  2. the idea that somehow professionals always know better than laymen. And quite franly the professional (Priest) referred to in this scenerio isn’t even qualified. Unless a priest holds a master’s in councelling (at minimum) he is not qualified to deeply council anyway.
I agree that some priests do not have the ability to counsel. They can quote doctrine and Canon Law but they lack the ability to help someone understand, if not discern, what is best in a given situation. I know people who have left the church based on bad advice given by a priest–such as to stay in an abusive situation because they made a committment for better or for worse.
 
I had a miscarriage a little bit ago, and the thought of getting pregnant scares me. I need time to emotionally recover. So my husband and I are using NFP. It might be a sin, but a man (or woman) doesn’t have to die to go to Hell. I went through Hell and back with our miscarriage, and I’m not prepared to go through it right away.

I completely agree! I don’t think anyone should tell you to use NFP or not unless they have personally experienced a crisis pregnancy, miscarriage, etcs. One of priests I talked to said it’s better for mother to take care of herself so she can take care of the baby. Makes sense to me. I think we have to do what we have to do to try and take care of ourselves and our kids with what we have at the time and leave the rest to God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top