NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

tundra1

Guest
Is it not the Catholic Church’s teaching that,

1.NFP is only to be used in the most serious of situations.

If true, why is this not preached more?
For example, I have watched many good programs on EWTN and read many articles and discussions on the internet about NFP, but this fact is almost always left out of the discussion. Yet it is so vital to the spiritual well being of the couple practicing NFP.

Am I mistaken, is this not a teachings of the Church.
Thank you all.
 
Not true. Practicing Nfp is not inherently sinful since you are naturally participating in the marital act.

If however your attitude is primarily to contracept using Nfp, then your motivation may be sinful. But if you’re obedient to the church, in that you are open to children at any time in marriage, then Nfp, especially for new couples may be a welcome tool.

We used it to actually p(name removed by moderator)oint those times when conceiving would be easier. It works.
 
I have been a NFP instructor and I would say that the use of NFP can be sinful, venial or mortal, if done with a contraceptive mentality. It depends on the will of the couple and their culprability. For instance, I have instructed people who were not married and who were not intending marriage- ever- and who only wanted to use NFP for health reasons. They broke the guidelines straight away, fell pregnant and planned for a termination. Sadly she miscarried but the intention was still bent on an anti-life mentally. I stopped teaching NFP- but 15 years later I hope to shortly start teaching it again as I simply will not teach those sort of people and know how to say no(finally at 44) however I was under the guidance at the time that NFP would lead them open to the natural law- this was not possible with a stubborn "bad"will. So although NFP in itself is morally neutral its usuage by the couple could be sinful. Hence, all NFP centres should be prepared with brochures/formation to help secular people with anti-life but health-only values. I have come across young couples who are well off that never knew that you had to have grave reasons to avoid pregnancies(financial, health-physical/mental/genetic, government policy) and had postponed pregnancy flippantly for 5 years- good Catholics too- just uninformed and lazy. But as soon as I gently corrected their view they were horrified and determined to do what was right. However, I have met Christians who have huge families very young, with no spacing between pregnancies, who are angry/resentful at each other, impoverished and negligent of their offspings emotional needs- and their kids lose their faith very quickly. I have also noticed that people who miscarry alot with large families, really need to give their bodies a rest after the miscarriage to avoid any more, and do not use NFP- it saddens me as the Church has not absolutely accepted or rejected the concept of limbo- so I would encourage the use of NFP to space the pregnancies alittle in order to restore maternal health optimally and lessen the chance of serial miscarriage. Sorry for my prattle, just a few thoughts
God bless Edel
 
Is it not the Catholic Church’s teaching that,

1.NFP is only to be used in the most serious of situations.

If true, why is this not preached more?
For example, I have watched many good programs on EWTN and read many articles and discussions on the internet about NFP, but this fact is almost always left out of the discussion. Yet it is so vital to the spiritual well being of the couple practicing NFP.

Am I mistaken, is this not a teachings of the Church.
Thank you all.
It is the Church’s stance that a couple must have a JUST reason for using NFP–not a ‘most serious situation’. NFP would be very difficult to use in a sinful manner, because it calls for sacrifice and abstinence.
 
Yes, the misuse of NFP can be sinful (but using NFP when it is not life or death does not mean it is being misused), and I agree that it is important to explain that a couple must prayerfully discern whether they have sufficient reasons to avoid. I don’t agree with the thought that it is nearly impossible to use it sinfully, which is why I do think it is important we, as married people, prayerfully look deep into our reasons to avoid when using it, and do this regularly, as we cannot base this decision solely on Earthly matters without keeping God in the equation
From the Catechism:
[2371](javascript:openWindow(‘cr/2371.htm’)😉 "Let all be convinced that human life and the duty of transmitting it are not limited by the horizons of this life only: their true evaluation and full significance can be understood only in reference to man’s eternal destiny."161
Also from the Catechism: (the Catechism uses the term just, other documents use serious and grave)
For just reasons, spouses may wish to space the births of their children. It is their duty to make certain that their desire is not motivated by selfishness but is in conformity with the generosity appropriate to responsible parenthood. Moreover, they should conform their behavior to the objective criteria of morality:
When it is a question of harmonizing married love with the responsible transmission of life, the morality of the behavior does not depend on sincere intention and evaluation of motives alone; but it must be determined by objective criteria, criteria drawn from the nature of the person and his acts criteria that respect the total meaning of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love; this is possible only if the virtue of married chastity is practiced with sincerity of heart.156
 
I have been a NFP instructor and I would say that the use of NFP can be sinful, venial or mortal, if done with a contraceptive mentality. It depends on the will of the couple and their culprability. For instance, I have instructed people who were not married and who were not intending marriage- ever- and who only wanted to use NFP for health reasons. They broke the guidelines straight away, fell pregnant and planned for a termination. Sadly she miscarried but the intention was still bent on an anti-life mentally. I stopped teaching NFP- but 15 years later I hope to shortly start teaching it again as I simply will not teach those sort of people and know how to say no(finally at 44) however I was under the guidance at the time that NFP would lead them open to the natural law- this was not possible with a stubborn "bad"will. So although NFP in itself is morally neutral its usuage by the couple could be sinful. Hence, all NFP centres should be prepared with brochures/formation to help secular people with anti-life but health-only values. I have come across young couples who are well off that never knew that you had to have grave reasons to avoid pregnancies(financial, health-physical/mental/genetic, government policy) and had postponed pregnancy flippantly for 5 years- good Catholics too- just uninformed and lazy. But as soon as I gently corrected their view they were horrified and determined to do what was right. However, I have met Christians who have huge families very young, with no spacing between pregnancies, who are angry/resentful at each other, impoverished and negligent of their offspings emotional needs- and their kids lose their faith very quickly. I have also noticed that people who miscarry alot with large families, really need to give their bodies a rest after the miscarriage to avoid any more, and do not use NFP- it saddens me as the Church has not absolutely accepted or rejected the concept of limbo- so I would encourage the use of NFP to space the pregnancies alittle in order to restore maternal health optimally and lessen the chance of serial miscarriage. Sorry for my prattle, just a few thoughts
God bless Edel
This is the craziness of the teachings of NFP. Yes, it works; we have four kids via NFP - sex when we knew we were going to have a kid. But to say that using NFP is sinful because a couple is using it NOT to conceive is absolutely crazy. Every couple uses it NOT to conceive, or we wouldn’t be using it all all. That is why you have sex during infertile times - to lessen the chance of pregnancy. If what you claim is true, then every couple using NFP is sinning. You can’t split hairs. The contraceptive metality thing is in itself contradictory to using NFP.
 
This is the craziness of the teachings of NFP. Yes, it works; we have four kids via NFP - sex when we knew we were going to have a kid. But to say that using NFP is sinful because a couple is using it NOT to conceive is absolutely crazy. Every couple uses it NOT to conceive, or we wouldn’t be using it all all. That is why you have sex during infertile times - to lessen the chance of pregnancy. If what you claim is true, then every couple using NFP is sinning. You can’t split hairs. The contraceptive metality thing is in itself contradictory to using NFP.
That’s not what she was saying at all… :confused:

She said that NFP CAN be sinful, if done with “contraceptive mentality”… and this is entirely what the church teaches…
I have been a NFP instructor and I would say that the use of NFP can be sinful, venial or mortal, if done with a contraceptive mentality. It depends on the will of the couple and their culprability.
 
This is the craziness of the teachings of NFP. Yes, it works; we have four kids via NFP - sex when we knew we were going to have a kid. But to say that using NFP is sinful because a couple is using it NOT to conceive is absolutely crazy. Every couple uses it NOT to conceive, or we wouldn’t be using it all all. That is why you have sex during infertile times - to lessen the chance of pregnancy. If what you claim is true, then every couple using NFP is sinning. You can’t split hairs. The contraceptive metality thing is in itself contradictory to using NFP.
But NFP CAN be used to help conceive.

Using NFP without a just reason is not sinful in the same way that contraceptives are. It might be a sin agains generosity or selflessness, but it’s not contraceptive in nature. There are lots of good things that can become sinful if used with a wrong intent, for instance food and eating are good, but can be abused if we are gluttonsous. So, NFP could be used with a wrong intent but it’s still moral.
 
Humane Vitae uses the words “serious reasons” which is rather different than “only the most serious reasons”. Paul VI was surprisingly vague in his description of such reasons. There is (IMO) a reason for that.

NFP CAN be misued in a manner that supports the unhealthy worldview that sex is unrelated to babies, which in turn leads to objectification of spouses in the sexual union. But, unlike contraception, NFP is not inherently inclined to that outcome. NFP, by requiring the couple during the time of the month that that biology most inclines them to passion (fertile time), to abstain from sexual intimacy due to the serious reason in question. This does two things:
  1. It retains the deep spiritual link in the psyche that sex and makin’ babies are tied up together.
  2. It shines a white hot spotlight on the alleged “serious reason” and tends to reveal spurious reasons for what they really are.
Contraception also avoids pregnancy, but does very differently in these two areas:
  1. Contraception tends to reinforce the unhealthy idea that sexual intimacy is only coincidentally related to baby making. Serious perversions tend to result from the loss of the link.
  2. Contraception requires no discernment and does nothing to push the couple back towards reconsideration of just how “serious” their reason is.
In summary, there isn’t an urgent need to browbeat NFP users about how serious their reason is. The method itself pushes their noses into it hard monthly. God’s clever like that… 😉

If you doubt me, take this challenge: Ask around among non-catholics and dissenter catholics who use contraceptives. Of the kids they have, how many are:
  1. “Planned Babies”
  2. “Oops Babies”
  3. “Oh What the Heck Babies”
My prediction is that the majority of NFP couples will have at least one kid in #3 above. Most of the contraceptors won’t even know what you are talking about. It will NEVER occur to them to spontaneously stop taking pills, toss the diaphragm or ditch the condom. OK, maybe the condom ones if they ran out of just don’t feel like using it. But the NFP folk quite often find that the crucible of abstinance burns away their phony ‘serious’ reason and along comes baby!
 
Humane Vitae uses the words “serious reasons” which is rather different than “only the most serious reasons”. Paul VI was surprisingly vague in his description of such reasons. There is (IMO) a reason for that.

NFP CAN be misued in a manner that supports the unhealthy worldview that sex is unrelated to babies, which in turn leads to objectification of spouses in the sexual union. But, unlike contraception, NFP is not inherently inclined to that outcome. NFP, by requiring the couple during the time of the month that that biology most inclines them to passion (fertile time), to abstain from sexual intimacy due to the serious reason in question. This does two things:
  1. It retains the deep spiritual link in the psyche that sex and makin’ babies are tied up together.
  2. It shines a white hot spotlight on the alleged “serious reason” and tends to reveal spurious reasons for what they really are.
Contraception also avoids pregnancy, but does very differently in these two areas:
  1. Contraception tends to reinforce the unhealthy idea that sexual intimacy is only coincidentally related to baby making. Serious perversions tend to result from the loss of the link.
  2. Contraception requires no discernment and does nothing to push the couple back towards reconsideration of just how “serious” their reason is.
In summary, there isn’t an urgent need to browbeat NFP users about how serious their reason is. The method itself pushes their noses into it hard monthly. God’s clever like that… 😉
👍 👍 👍
 
That’s not what she was saying at all… :confused:

She said that NFP CAN be sinful, if done with “contraceptive mentality”… and this is entirely what the church teaches…
Saying someone is using it with a contraceptive mentality and thus are sinning is the same as saying someone using it to NOT conceive is sinning. What is the difference, other than trying to phrase it differently?

Please explain church teaching then:
  1. We must use NFP if we wish to have sex and lessen the chance of having kids.
  2. But using it with a contraceptive mentality is a sin.
  3. So if a couple is engaging in sex during an infertile time because they do not wish to have a child at that time, but are open to it, are thus sinning.
There is no difference.
 
There is no difference.
Then why get so worked up about it? If the church asked you to refrain from wearing red and you didn’t like red clothes anyways, would you make such a fuss?

The bottom line is that all these urgent protestations against church teachings themselves prove how very different NFP is from ABC. If there were no difference, there would be no controversy, no?
 
Quote copied from post #5:

For just reasons, spouses may wish to space the births of their children. It is their duty to make certain that their desire is *not motivated by selfishness *but is in conformity with the generosity appropriate to responsible parenthood. Moreover, they should conform their behavior to the objective criteria of morality.

If this is what the church teaches, then couples following NFP to *avoid *pregnancy because of appropriate parenthood (no money for another child) are not sinning? Or are they sinning because they don’t *want *a child at that time, but for the sake of intimacy, are willing to accept one?

It all simply reinforces for me that the Catholic church believes and teaches that sex is only for having children. It just needs to say so. Yes, when we enter into marriage, part of that is lovingly accepting kids, and in fact, we are supposed to do so. We happily have four.

Just reasons, serious reasons, determine it monthly, sinning using NFP… just gets to plain be too much and confusing.
 
Then why get so worked up about it? If the church asked you to refrain from wearing red and you didn’t like red clothes anyways, would you make such a fuss?

The bottom line is that all these urgent protestations against church teachings themselves prove how very different NFP is from ABC. If there were no difference, there would be no controversy, no?
???

Not saying there is no difference between NFP and ABC. Saying that the sematics are confusing.
 
Quote copied from post #5:

For just reasons, spouses may wish to space the births of their children. It is their duty to make certain that their desire is *not motivated by selfishness *but is in conformity with the generosity appropriate to responsible parenthood. Moreover, they should conform their behavior to the objective criteria of morality.

If this is what the church teaches, then couples following NFP to *avoid *pregnancy because of appropriate parenthood (no money for another child) are not sinning? Or are they sinning because they don’t *want *a child at that time, but for the sake of intimacy, are willing to accept one?

It all simply reinforces for me that the Catholic church believes and teaches that sex is only for having children. It just needs to say so. Yes, when we enter into marriage, part of that is lovingly accepting kids, and in fact, we are supposed to do so. We happily have four.

Just reasons, serious reasons, determine it monthly, sinning using NFP… just gets to plain be too much and confusing.
No… sex is not “only” for having children. The two aspects are NOT separable… they are completely intertwined… inseparable.
Your second paragraph sorta indicates that you may still not understand this. There is no “for the sake of intimacy”… union and procreation are one. Separating the two is the *definition *of the “contraceptive mentality”.

There’s no confusion… you pray about the decision to use NFP with your spouse, you analyze those reasons on a monthly basis and you make a mutual decision - BASED IN PRAYER - whether to avoid relations or not.
I think a lot of times couples have a difficult time understanding the “based in prayer” part. They’re basing it on OTHER factors, like their savings accounts (not meeting a" particular" number, etc) or perceived health (I’m still carrying those 5lbs from my last pregnancy)… these may be very *practical/responsible *reasons, but are they prayerful? That’s up to the couple to decide. This is what the line “Moreover, they should conform their behavior to the objective criteria of morality.” means… it’s “more” than the “responsible parenthood” portion…
Yes, there are certainly very “practical” reasons to avoid at any given time. But unless you can sincerely and PRAYERFULLY come to the conclusion that they are truly MORAL reasons… then it can be a challenge to stick to the plan. :o… and this could (potentially) cross the line into sinning… “are we being selfish in this decision?”…
 
Saying someone is using it with a contraceptive mentality and thus are sinning is the same as saying someone using it to NOT conceive is sinning. What is the difference, other than trying to phrase it differently?
No, the contraceptive mentality does not refer to the fact that the couple is avoiding children, but the reasons behind avoiding. A couple that has discerned they have serious/just/grave reasons to avoid can user NFP to avoid conceiving, without having a contraceptive mentality. A couple that is using NFP because they don’t want more children for selfish reasons (lack of generosity, love of comfort, etc.) would be using NFP to meet their wants/whims, not looking for what God wants. Now, this is still very different from using contraception itself (and its one reason why the term can be confusing.) In contraception the couple is shutting God out of the act, by purposefully messing up the functions of the act so a child is not conceived, with NFP (abstaining during the fertile time), the couple is never shutting God out of the act, never messing the act up. The fact that they are never shutting Him out of the act does not mean that its ok for them to purposefully (without sufficient reason to do so) always skip the fertile periods while enjoying sex during the infertile periods, as marriage is ordered towards procreation, but it is very different from contracepting. Say a woman cannot have any more children because she could die if she did. The Church would be very supportive of this woman and her spouse abstaining, and if they can identify times in which they can participate in the marital act without getting pregnant, the Church would support that too, even if it means using NFP until she is past menopause and they never intend to have children again. The Church recognizes the value and beauty of sex in marriage, regardless of ability to receive more children, and that is why NFP is moral, but the Church also recognizes that marital love is ordered towards procreation, and this is a duty and gift that cannot be taken lightly.
 
No… sex is not “only” for having children. The two aspects are NOT separable… they are completely intertwined… inseparable.
Your second paragraph sorta indicates that you may still not understand this. There is no “for the sake of intimacy”… union and procreation are one. Separating the two is the *definition *of the “contraceptive mentality”.

Just have to disagree on it. Because based on what you say here, I would bet then that the majority couples using NFP are sinning. If in fact that using NFP and having sex at the infertile times to lessen the chances of having a child is a sin, then yep, sex is for having kids. Makes no sense other wise. Yeah, the church teaches unitive and procreative at all times. But it seems that you are saying that the difference lies in whether the couple is thinking, “Gee, I hope we don’t get pregnant” or “It’s OK if we do.”

There’s no confusion… you pray about the decision to use NFP with your spouse, you analyze those reasons on a monthly basis and you make a mutual decision - BASED IN PRAYER - whether to avoid relations or not.
I think a lot of times couples have a difficult time understanding the “based in prayer” part. They’re basing it on OTHER factors, like their savings accounts

The way this is phrased, and the way this is usually phrased when it is brought up, seems to say that finances are not a matter of concern. Hell, yes, we base it on finances. To do otherwise is utterly irresponsible. Is it the only factor? Probably not. Is it the main factor for many, many couples? You bet. I’d have had (past tense) a housefull if we had the money and the house; we didn’t, we don’t, and we will not any time soon. That has been the case for many years. At this time, at our age, no I don’t particularly wish to have more children. Would we welcome them? Of course. Is it best for the child if our age presents health concerns? No. But our finances, and now age, are the primary factors in not having more children.

(not meeting a" particular" number, etc) or perceived health (I’m still carrying those 5lbs from my last pregnancy)… these may be very *practical/responsible *reasons, but are they prayerful? That’s up to the couple to decide. This is what the line “Moreover, they should conform their behavior to the objective criteria of morality.” means… it’s “more” than the “responsible parenthood” portion…
Yes, there are certainly very “practical” reasons to avoid at any given time. But unless you can sincerely and PRAYERFULLY come to the conclusion that they are truly

Bringing children into the world a couple cannot afford financially or provide a proper place for them to live is moral? “Objective moral criteria” - what is that? It means the couple has to decide, but seem to be condemned for it at the same time if ever health or finances are even mentioned. It has been said more than once in these forums and threads that couple should just go ahead and have kids; God will provide. Is that the moral way - roll the dice - to bring kids into the word as loving parents? I think not. And I do not think it is sinning or selfish./COLOR]

MORAL reasons… then it can be a challenge to stick to the plan. :o… and this could (potentially) cross the line into sinning… “are we being selfish in this decision?”…
 
No, the contraceptive mentality does not refer to the fact that the couple is avoiding children, but the reasons behind avoiding. A couple that has discerned they have serious/just/grave reasons to avoid can user NFP to avoid conceiving, without having a contraceptive mentality. A couple that is using NFP because they don’t want more children for selfish reasons (lack of generosity, love of comfort, etc.) would be using NFP to meet their wants/whims, not looking for what God wants. Now, this is still very different from using contraception itself (and its one reason why the term can be confusing.) In contraception the couple is shutting God out of the act, by purposefully messing up the functions of the act so a child is not conceived, with NFP (abstaining during the fertile time), the couple is never shutting God out of the act, never messing the act up. The fact that they are never shutting Him out of the act does not mean that its ok for them to purposefully always skip the fertile periods while enjoying sex during the infertile periods without sufficient reason to do so, but it is very different from contracepting.
No, it is really not much different, not the way this is being discussed. And there we are again - skipping sex during the fetile times without “sufficient reason”. Whose “sufficient reason”? The logic, or lack thereof, in all of this still goes back to couples should be having more kids, because to only have sex during infertile times to lessen the chances of pregnancy is not correct and is sinful and is selfish. Looking for what God wants? Terribly hard to know that, but having more kids “just because” or getting pregnant and then hoping God will send cash (is that testing God or trusting Him, seriously?) isn’t the answer either.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top