"No Church will Save You"

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ceil-1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Ceil-1

Guest
Our hospice chaplain is a lovely man, a Baptist, and very caring.

However, he firmly believes that all one has to do to be saved is mention faith in Christ, somewhere along the line in one’s life.

Bingo, that’s it.

At a recent funeral he put on for a patient, in true Baptist fashion, he made a pitch for the Lord, right in the middle of the service.

I accept all this. My Baptist friend had the same thing done at her wedding. But, one thing he said bothered me.

He said that no church would save us. Only a personal relationship with the person of Christ, and no one, nothing else matters. I know him well enough to know this was a slam against the Church.

Now, I know he is just chomping at the bit to get to me and give me what for, being Catholic and all. So far, I’ve been able to dodge him. He will certainly argue that it is Jesus alone, and assume that I don’t know Jesus, and couldn’t by virtue of the fact that I am Catholic.

I am not looking forward to the conversation, as I take great offense to this assumption, and don’t want it to negatively impact our relationship.

What can I tell this man when the subject comes up?
 
I think you just have to agree, after all, the Jesus bit is right on. The Church is Jesus mystical body, founded by Him and containing the full deposit of faith He left us with. So the function it performs is to get us to know Him better. Even so, I bet you know loads of rubbish Catholics who turn up every Sunday and that’s it…What do people refer to them as? Cultural Catholics or Cafeteria Catholics? Anyway, despite the benefit of the Church, are they developing their relationship with God? It kind of makes you wonder if the Church is doing them any good at all! That said, I think the Church is, I think the Sacraments do take up the slack to some degree. Just some stuff to think about, hope it helps! 👍
 
Yup, Paul refers to the Church as both the Spotless Bride of Christ, and as the Body of Christ. Whether he knows it or not, he’s trying to have Jesus without His Body, or the Perfect Bride He’s One with. He’ll probably claim that the Church is just the collection of the saved, but Jesus makes it clear that’s not true. He refers to the Church on Earth as the Kingdom of God, but says that it contains wheat and tares, and at harvest time (the end of the world), the tares will be thrown into the fire. That is, that some in the Church will go to Hell.

This establishes, for one thing, that the Church isn’t Spotless because Her constituents are (it’s because She’s got the Sacred Deposit of Faith, and because She’s cleansed by Christ). And remember before Paul told even told Timothy to look to Scripture (in 2 Tim 3:16-17), he’d already made sure he was relying on the Church for salvation (1 Tim 3:15).
 
Meh, that’s a tough one. I would just avoid conversation with the man, unless you want to venture a debate. I think it would be wisest to lead the example in this one. You stay in your beliefs and let him to his…but he can watch your example of being a good Christian.

Pray for him. I’ll pray for you. :gopray:
 
I might point out that Martin Luther actually added the word “alone” to the verse that Protestants use for their Sola Gratia (the belief that Christians are saved by grace through faith alone).

Romans 3:28, “For we account a man to be justified by faith.” is the original scripture, but Luther thought he knew better and added

“For we account a man to be justified by faith alone.”

This may not be received very well, but the fact can not be changed.

A friend of mine said this:
Does faith necessarily only mean belief? Isn’t faith something we also have and live out in the course of our lives? Even demons believe in Jesus, yet this doesn’t mean they are Christians! There are just tons of Scripture passages that say we are saved by the free gift of grace, but we must cooperate with God’s grace and live out our faith through faith and works. See Matthew 7:21-27 (Jesus says only those who do the will of His Father will be saved), James 2:24 (“a person is justified by works and not by faith alone”) and Phillipians 2:12 (work out your salvation with fear and trembling.)
That said, the works we are able to do come from God’s gift of grace, which flows from the Sacraments and actually remakes our hearts anew and able to do these works. Protestant theology claims that God merely declares us to be righteous and fit for heaven when we accept Christ in our lives, but God is a God of Truth. To declare us righteous when our hearts are filled with sin and ugliness would be like putting a clean couch cover on top of an old, dirty, stinking couch. Instead, God gives us the help (grace) we need to change our hearts and our lives so we can truly reflect his love in our lives. For this, we especially need the Church and its Sacraments of the Eucharist, Baptism, Confirmation, and all the other ones. We are saved in community, not in isolation with the Protestant “Sinner’s Prayer”. Jesus taught us to say “Our Father, who art in heaven…”
I will think and pray more on this.
 
I was once chided by the chaplain for calling a priest on my patient who was deliberately stopping his meds in an attempt to shorten his life. He was a Catholic.

I wanted him to get last rites, counsel, and confession. I did not agree with his decision, but, I knew the chaplaincy would give them their personal postition, not the Church’s. Plus, they would not have seen to his spiritual needs. In fact, one chaplain gives communion using the words and form of the Mass. He feels it’s the same thing.

They were all quite put out with me, and called me Pastor Ceil. I was very offended by the whole thing, but, decided not to make a case out of it. I was told in no uncertain terms that he either went up or down, nowhere in b/w. I pretended not to hear over the copy machine.
 
Our hospice chaplain is a lovely man, a Baptist, and very caring.

However, he firmly believes that all one has to do to be saved is mention faith in Christ, somewhere along the line in one’s life.

Bingo, that’s it.

At a recent funeral he put on for a patient, in true Baptist fashion, he made a pitch for the Lord, right in the middle of the service.

I accept all this. My Baptist friend had the same thing done at her wedding. But, one thing he said bothered me.

He said that no church would save us. Only a personal relationship with the person of Christ, and no one, nothing else matters. I know him well enough to know this was a slam against the Church.

Now, I know he is just chomping at the bit to get to me and give me what for, being Catholic and all. So far, I’ve been able to dodge him. He will certainly argue that it is Jesus alone, and assume that I don’t know Jesus, and couldn’t by virtue of the fact that I am Catholic.

I am not looking forward to the conversation, as I take great offense to this assumption, and don’t want it to negatively impact our relationship.

What can I tell this man when the subject comes up?
Ceil- I’m not sure what your circumstance is (what is this man the chaplain of?) but - I think you might play this one as a bluff - since the Church is the Body of Christ (Paul) then it is quite possible to encounter Christ in the Church. And the Church/Body of Christ is (in Baptist theology) the assemblage of those who believe and are saved by faith, and since YOU believe and are saved by grace (through faith) - which is entirely within Catholic teaching - then you can tell him that it’s true - no one is saved by the Church - because the Church is made up of the saved. While he’s nodding, you observe that the Church is the Body of Christ, and since no one is saved except by Christ, then in a way, everyone is saved by the Church - and then while he’s looking confused and trying to come up with an answer that fits his theology and not yours, you can change the subject.😃
 
Our hospice chaplain is a lovely man, a Baptist, and very caring.

However, he firmly believes that all one has to do to be saved is mention faith in Christ, somewhere along the line in one’s life.

Bingo, that’s it.

At a recent funeral he put on for a patient, in true Baptist fashion, he made a pitch for the Lord, right in the middle of the service.

I accept all this. My Baptist friend had the same thing done at her wedding. But, one thing he said bothered me.

He said that no church would save us. Only a personal relationship with the person of Christ, and no one, nothing else matters. I know him well enough to know this was a slam against the Church.

Now, I know he is just chomping at the bit to get to me and give me what for, being Catholic and all. So far, I’ve been able to dodge him. He will certainly argue that it is Jesus alone, and assume that I don’t know Jesus, and couldn’t by virtue of the fact that I am Catholic.

I am not looking forward to the conversation, as I take great offense to this assumption, and don’t want it to negatively impact our relationship.

What can I tell this man when the subject comes up?
A funeral is a private affair and is usually conducted according to the wishes of the patient and the family. If the patient and the family are Baptists or in agreement with the tradition, there is nothing wrong with the preacher giving a pitch for the Lord according to their tradition, just as there is nothing wrong for a Catholic patient to have a funeral Mass according to our tradition. Anyone attending the funeral is a visitor and must respect the religious beliefs of others. What the Baptists do, the Baptists do, and what the Catholics do, the Catholics do, even if it may be offensive to others not of that belief system. You just have to accept the fact that when you voluntarily attend the religious services of non-Catholics there are things you are not going to agree with or like. But you are there, in effect, as a guest, and of your own choosing. You go with the flow.

However, the chaplain has no right to approach you in an effort to challenge your religious beliefs, especially if it is in the workplace and he is an employee or a volunteer for the Hospice. He should not approach patients or their families like this either. That is considered harrassment and most places of employment have policies addressing this, and the person doing it could be subject to disciplinary action. And especially in a Hospice, where one of the primary goals is to meet the spiritual needs of the patient and their families, this is a very sensitive issue. The agency could find themselves in trouble both legally and with accrediting agencies if they do not address it. So if this is taking place in the workplace with patients and familes, it needs to be reported. You can deal with your own personal issues with it as you choose, but if he tries to prosetylize you in the workplace, you have that option.

However, if you wish to try to maintain a friendship with this man, try to deal with it in a loving manner. Tell him in a loving way that you do not wish to discuss it. You do not have to argue with him. If he persists, end the conversation politely and walk away. Arguing over these things at a workplace is not advisable. You are being paid to do your work, or are volunteering to do a job, not argue over religious matters. If he becomes too persistant, you may have to end the friendship and report him, but if he has any common sense he should know these things and leave you alone.
 
I work for a hospice agency. The chaplain in question is the head chaplain. He is part of the hospice care team, and his staff shares our patients. He is also responsible for our (the nurses and nursing staff) spiritual care, at least as it applies to our ability to do our jobs. He’s not allowed to pry, but can follow up on volunteered information.
 
Our hospice chaplain is a lovely man, a Baptist, and very caring.

However, he firmly believes that all one has to do to be saved is mention faith in Christ, somewhere along the line in one’s life.

Bingo, that’s it.

At a recent funeral he put on for a patient, in true Baptist fashion, he made a pitch for the Lord, right in the middle of the service.

I accept all this. My Baptist friend had the same thing done at her wedding. But, one thing he said bothered me.

He said that no church would save us. Only a personal relationship with the person of Christ, and no one, nothing else matters. I know him well enough to know this was a slam against the Church.

Now, I know he is just chomping at the bit to get to me and give me what for, being Catholic and all. So far, I’ve been able to dodge him. He will certainly argue that it is Jesus alone, and assume that I don’t know Jesus, and couldn’t by virtue of the fact that I am Catholic.

I am not looking forward to the conversation, as I take great offense to this assumption, and don’t want it to negatively impact our relationship.

What can I tell this man when the subject comes up?
maybe you can tell him that you agree that Jesus saves us, and that one of the ways you encounter Jesus is in the Sacraments at your Church 🙂
 
I work for a hospice agency. The chaplain in question is the head chaplain. He is part of the hospice care team, and his staff shares our patients. He is also responsible for our (the nurses and nursing staff) spiritual care, at least as it applies to our ability to do our jobs. He’s not allowed to pry, but can follow up on volunteered information.
Then he should know better than to try to challenge your personal religious beliefs. Following up on volunteered information does not include trying to convert you from your beliefs. That means working within the framework of what your beliefs are to help you deliver the best care you can to your patients, and to support the patients on their spiritual journey. If the patient is Catholic and wishes to see a priest, that means calling one. If they need a Rosary, get them one. If the patient is Jewish, that means calling the Rabbi, etc. It does not mean trying to convert anyone, staff or patient, to one’s own personal beliefs. People working in Spiritual Care are highly trained and are trained to meet the needs of all types of people with all types of belief systems and have access to resources to meet their needs. I cannot imagine a Hospice chaplain chomping at the bit to get ahold of a Catholic staff member and try to prosetylize them. I know our Spiritual Care staff quite well and how they operate. I don’t think they would have a job very long if they tried that.
 
You may want to tell him that, while you agree that only Jesus saves, the only way to truly know him fully and intimately is to do as He Himself said,“He who eats my flesh…”.
Help your friend to understand that it is the Catholic Church who truly leads one to absolute intimate union with Jesus! Anything he has experienced outside of the Church is shallow by comparison! Don’t belittle his experience; but, do let him know how much deeper the relationship can be if he only embraces the Truth of the Catholic Church!
 
You have to let him know that you do know Jesus very well and you do love Him very much. Also that your church teaches you everything about Jesus and about how to love Jesus.

Maybe ask him some pithy questions:

Do you love Jesus? Then how come you have contempt for His church?
Where does it say in the Bible that “no church can save you?”
So Jesus never intended to establish a church here on earth?
 
You have to let him know that you do know Jesus very well and you do love Him very much. Also that your church teaches you everything about Jesus and about how to love Jesus.

Maybe ask him some pithy questions:

Do you love Jesus? Then how come you have contempt for His church?
Where does it say in the Bible that “no church can save you?”
So Jesus never intended to establish a church here on earth?
This man is right in that no church can save anyone. Some who are not in The catholic Church will be saved. Some who are Catholic will not be. We as Catholics believe this, so I’m not sure why him saying “No church can save you” would be upsetting to you. Of course no church can save you!
 
Because I know him well enough to know this was a bash against the Church. I have heard him preach and teach several times before.

We are saved through the Church in the sense that we achieve salvation as a result of it.
If the Church did not exist, there would be no confection of the sacraments. Only a baptized person can baptize another. The Protestants may not like it, but, they are part of the Church. At least the ones who believe in the Trinity, and baptize the way He instructed them to.

I think of the Church as the big ship with the Protestant churches as little life boats that were lowered into the water on their own. They may carry a few to the destination, but, it is precarious at best, not very safe. And they disdain the big boat. They would rather be big captains of their own little boat than be just a nobody on the main ship.
 
We are saved through the Church in the sense that we achieve salvation as a result of it.
Not true…the Church teaches that people can be saved without it, but that the sacraments are the best way to achieve salvation.
 
“The Church,” whatever it claims to be, is an institutionalized body of modified beliefs surrounding the idea of God, Man, and death, namely the feeling of Unity or abandonment. In the end, you choose to align yourself with your perception of what the “Church” teaches as modified to your own circumstances. In other words, the “Church” does no saving on your, or anyone’s behalf, but only provides ideas for acceptance or refusal pertinent to belief, not necessarily fact. So your Chaplain is right, and by the semantics of his statement he included his own “Church.”

But does this Chaplain avowedly have it in for you in terms of hounding you with the Baptist perspective, which, again, is his own modification of what he believes that “Church” to be? In that case, it is not a theological issue. It is an issue of simple civility, similar to someone hounding you with their political or aesthetic view, or their taste in music. Just tell him to lay of, that your state of relationship with God is your business, and you will ask for his (name removed by moderator)ut if you are so moved.
 
Our hospice chaplain is a lovely man, a Baptist, and very caring.

However, he firmly believes that all one has to do to be saved is mention faith in Christ, somewhere along the line in one’s life.

Bingo, that’s it.

At a recent funeral he put on for a patient, in true Baptist fashion, he made a pitch for the Lord, right in the middle of the service.

I accept all this. My Baptist friend had the same thing done at her wedding. But, one thing he said bothered me.

He said that no church would save us. Only a personal relationship with the person of Christ, and no one, nothing else matters. I know him well enough to know this was a slam against the Church.

Now, I know he is just chomping at the bit to get to me and give me what for, being Catholic and all. So far, I’ve been able to dodge him. He will certainly argue that it is Jesus alone, and assume that I don’t know Jesus, and couldn’t by virtue of the fact that I am Catholic.

I am not looking forward to the conversation, as I take great offense to this assumption, and don’t want it to negatively impact our relationship.

What can I tell this man when the subject comes up?
If this “Baptist Chaplin” is actually a pastor, then he has had some schooling behind him to put him in a position to possibly outwit the unsuspecting. How about an eye for an eye (Preacher for Preacher) so to speak, invite him and your parish priest over to dinner and start the question and answer period, then watch where it goes.
 
Detales, I’m sorry, but I don’t agree with you. God is a God of order. He is always very exacting. He leaves the details to those in authority to do so. He requires obedience from those who are subordinate. He always rewards obedience and humility. That is the better way. The other way is some new age hodge-podge.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top