No runaway trolley this time

  • Thread starter Thread starter Scowler
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
In the trolley case … throwing [the switch] kills only one, but in that example you oppose throwing the switch. How is the surgeon allowed to act so that the direct result of his action is someone’s death while the bystander is not?
Because the surgeon does not target the child by his action (eg. removal of tubal section). Here the death of the child is indirect - it is not in the moral object. There is an alternative medical procedures (chemical injection) that is immoral because it targets the child (kills the child ‘directly’).

Does throwing the switch for the trolley directly or indirectly target the one? It does seem to be different from the medical scenario above in that chemical injection certainly “intends” (in fact relies upon) the death of the child (intended means). But such intentions are placed in the “Intention” font.

The terms “Directly”, “Indirectly” are references to the ordering of the act.

PS: This discussion more properly belongs in the other thread.
 
Last edited:
Did you intend to mention that the sick patient desired to die? Even in your system, I assume this would be an important consideration?
Let’s see the possibilities:
  1. If the patient were lucid, and expressed her wish to be “terminated”, it would make the act mandatory. The patient’s wish comes first.
  2. If the patient had a living will, stipulating that she does not wish to suffer, and asks that the suffering be treated - in any way possible - and would be in a coma, but still having pain, it would be another factor to follow her last expressed desire.
  3. If the patient were lucid, and expressed that her life be prolonged ONLY with any ordinary care, and would confirm that her wish is still the same, then her wish should take precedence - even if she denies the necessary about of painkiller. If she wishes to suffer… it is her choice.
  4. There is one more scenario. The patient is in coma, had no previous will, cannot be asked now, and we can tell with medical certainty that she cannot recover, then she should be “killed”. In this case the golden rule takes precedence. “Do unto others…etc”.
But for you it does not matter. Does it? It’s all “murder”.
If the dose was chosen to kill, rather than to ease pain, then the act was wrong.
The dose was chosen to alleviate the pain with the medical certainty that it is a lethal dose. So for you it is “murder”. Or is it? Where is the principle of “foreseen but unintended”? The physician who administers the drug only intends to manage the pain and does not intend to kill. But he knows full well that the dose is lethal. Does the intent matter, all of a sudden?
Torturing to death entails plainly the greater moral evil. So the details matter as to gravity - not necessarily to whether the act is moral or immoral.
Don’t quibble. Both are murders in your view. There is a small difference, but when push comes to shove, they are murders. Sure, there is a difference in degree between a shot in the brain and slowly roasting someone on fire, but these are unimportant details in the final scheme of things… both are murders.
This principle is similar to that explained above.
In other words, there is no significant difference. No “mercy” killing, no “compassion”, no “respect”, just “murder”. I can only hope that you (or any of your loved ones) will never face this problem - on the “receiving” end.
 
Last edited:
It is my knowing choice of an act with that moral object that defines murder.
Which is the very definition of the intent font re the killing defined by murder!
Murder is a definition of an immoral act because the very definition requires that we specify the intent also.

Killing on the other hand does not specify either the innocent detail of the object nor the intent to do so. That is why identifying an act as a killing is not enough to identify immorality at either objective or subjective (culpability) levels.
 
Last edited:
In other words, there is no significant difference. No “mercy” killing, no “compassion”, no “respect”, just “murder”.
Immorality is not primarily in the degree of disorder of the outward act.
It is in the adherence of the heart to that outward act and what that outward act, by its own inherent meaning, indicates re the interior malice a d lack of charity of the actor.

Aquinas would likely say the guy above is more torturer than murderer though he is both. But his heart is clearly in the torture and murder is but an inevitable consequence of his desire for torture and not getting caught.

Most of us can see that there is some respect involved in someone choosing to deliver a clean murder over a tortured one.
Both are obviously grave evils of course.
 
Last edited:
If the patient were lucid, and expressed her wish to be “terminated”, it would make the act mandatory. The patient’s wish comes first.
This is from the Book of Scowler of course. I would suggest differently, viz: One’s man’s death wish does not become another man’s obligation.
But for you it does not matter. Does it? It’s all “murder”.
That depends on your definition of Murder and the moral system under which you evaluate acts. It is already established that your system and Catholic Moral Theology will reach different conclusions.
The physician who administers the drug only intends to manage the pain and does not intend to kill. But he knows full well that the dose is lethal.
He does not know that. Chronically ill patients (eg. cancer sufferers) are on pain killers over extended periods of time and the medical reality is that the body builds up tolerance to life-threatening side-effects (eg. cessation of breathing) far more quickly than it does to the drug’s analgesic effects. Increasing levels of morphine (say) will kill the pain before it kills the patient.

The intent has always mattered - a wrong intent always condemns the act. It’s just that a good motivation can’t make an evil act good. [Caution: This is a principle of Catholic Moral Theology, so may not be supported in the Scowler system.]
Don’t quibble.
To elucidate the spectrum of evils is not to quibble. Moral vs. Immoral is a Yes/No distinction, but that is not the full story.
No “mercy” killing, no “compassion”, no “respect”, just “murder”.
These might all be present - that was not the matter in debate. The question to be addressed was “are each of the following forms of murder and does the reason for the acts change the answer?”:
  • torturing a person until death;
  • euthanasia;
    The answer under Catholic Moral Theology has been given. You have provided the answers under the Scowler system. 🤷‍♂️
 
Last edited:
Most of us can see that there is some respect involved in someone choosing to deliver a clean murder over a tortured one.
You are preaching to the choir. 🙂
He does not know that.
Come on… doctors are not that ignorant. True, they “practice” on us, but they already know a lot of things.
Chronically ill patients (eg. cancer sufferers) are on pain killers over extended periods of time and the medical reality is that the body builds up tolerance to life-threatening side-effects (eg. cessation of breathing) far more quickly than it does to the drug’s analgesic effects. Increasing levels of morphine (say) will kill the pain before it kills the patient.
Of course that is not always true. But even if it were true, this is the point when you can invoke the Catholic principle of “foreseen but unintended”. The intent is always “internal”, and no one is privy to the information. (Yeah, yeah, God allegedly knows, but let’s leave it up to him.) You don’t have that information, so you cannot say what it is.

We keep running into the problem of hypocrisy. Stealing is always forbidden - but when it becomes necessary to save lives, then it is not called stealing any more, since the original owner did not have the “right” to that stolen piece of bread. Lying is always forbidden - but when it becomes necessary to save the lives of fugitives from a death squad, then it is not called lying any more, since the members of the death squad did not have the “right” to the truth any more.

You need to invent a new terminology to allow some exceptions to your “absolute” principles - and that is called hypocrisy. How much easier, simpler and more reasonable is the rational approach (which you call Scowler’s system - as if I were the one who invented it 🙂 ) where all the fonts need to be examined together and only then can you affix a label of “moral” or “immoral” to it. After all the actual action is always neutral, only the intent, the result and the circumstances make it acceptable or not.

Not all killings are “murder”, even if the victim is “innocent”. There are justifiable instants of homicide. It is no surprise that there is the concept of “mercy killing”, and pretty much everyone accepts it, except the ultra-conservatives, who want to have “absolute” moral laws.
 
Last edited:
40.png
Gorgias:
You choose not to sin.
No, but the moral absolute still stands: do no evil.
How can you avoid “sinning” and/or doing “evil” when all the choices are “evil”, some more, some less. Inaction can be just as evil as active choices.
Inaction is evil when there is a possible course of action which is not evil. If there is no possible course of action that is not evil, inaction is not evil.
Ahh… but Pontius Pilate did commit an evil act – he put to death an innocent man! However, he simply tried to pass the blame off on the Jews! Essentially, he said, “I’m not the cause of me putting an innocent man to death; you’re the cause of me putting an innocent man to death!”
Well, let’s see. He just stood aside and allowed the sentence brought by the Sanhedrin to be carried out. A typical instance of non-action.
No… the Sanhedrin had no authority to crucify. Pontius took a positive action: he approved their request.
 
I have no idea why you think this is a rebuttal.

What is it you disagree with and why?
It was not a rebuttal. It was an agreement. 🙂 I agree that there is real difference between a straight and quick kill and slowly baking someone to death in boiling oil. I only have problems with some Catholics, who declare that both of them are “murders”.
Inaction is evil when there is a possible course of action which is not evil. If there is no possible course of action that is not evil, inaction is not evil.
Ah. It is only evil, if there is no “better” option available? I certainly agree with that - if you are unable to interfere, then inaction is not evil. That is trivially true, but that was not the question. What decides which is the “better” option, the action or the inaction? If you only have two options, where both have “evil” (harmful) consequences to it, which one are you supposed to choose? The one with fewer “evil” consequences? That would be proportionalism, wouldn’t it?
No… the Sanhedrin had no authority to crucify. Pontius took a positive action: he approved their request.
Not approved, allowed the verdict to stand. Maybe the Sanhedrin had no authority to perform the crucifixion, but it had the authority bring the verdict.
 
40.png
BlackFriar:
I have no idea why you think this is a rebuttal.

What is it you disagree with and why?
It was not a rebuttal. It was an agreement. 🙂 I agree that there is real difference between a straight and quick kill and slowly baking someone to death in boiling oil. I only have problems with some Catholics, who declare that both of them are “murders”.
Inaction is evil when there is a possible course of action which is not evil. If there is no possible course of action that is not evil, inaction is not evil.
Ah. It is only evil, if there is no “better” option available? I certainly agree with that - if you are unable to interfere, then inaction is not evil. That is trivially true, but that was not the question. What decides which is the “better” option, the action or the inaction? If you only have two options, where both have “evil” (harmful) consequences to it, which one are you supposed to choose? The one with fewer “evil” consequences? That would be proportionalism, wouldn’t it?
No… the Sanhedrin had no authority to crucify. Pontius took a positive action: he approved their request.
Not approved, allowed the verdict to stand. Maybe the Sanhedrin had no authority to perform the crucifixion, but it had the authority bring the verdict.
Inaction is evil when there is a possible course of action which is not evil. If there is no possible course of action that is not evil, inaction is not evil.

Ah. It is only evil, if there is no “better” option available? I certainly agree with that - if you are unable to interfere, then inaction is not evil. That is trivially true, but that was not the question. What decides which is the “better” option, the action or the inaction? If you only have two options, where both have “evil” (harmful) consequences to it, which one are you supposed to choose? The one with fewer “evil” consequences? That would be proportionalism, wouldn’t it?
Correct. Therefore, if you have a set of possible actions, and at least one of them is not evil, and inaction foreseeably allows one of the evil consequences to occur, then inaction is not morally licit.

On the other hand, if you have a set of possible actions, and none of them is not evil, then one chooses inaction. Inaction is not, in and of itself, evil or good, per se. So, it is not as if we’re “choosing the least evil” among a list of evil actions (i.e., evil act 1, …, evil act n, inaction).
 
Therefore, if you have a set of possible actions, and at least one of them is not evil, and inaction foreseeably allows one of the evil consequences to occur, then inaction is not morally licit.
This is again trivially true. If there is one morally licit option, then that is the one which should be chosen. If there are several such options, then the best one should be chosen. Isn’t that obvious?
Inaction is not, in and of itself, evil or good, per se.
Just like “action” is also neutral - per se. Pulling the trigger of a gun is neutral, only the circumstances make it good or evil. Even pointing a gun toward a human is neutral, only the circumstances can tell if the homicide is justified or not. I keep wondering why is it that you try to fight this simple and obvious fact.
So, it is not as if we’re “choosing the least evil” among a list of evil actions (i.e., evil act 1, …, evil act n, inaction).
And this is the fundamental problem with your approach. You correctly included “inaction” among the evil actions, and then you don’t present any reason why “inaction” should have a privileged status? If you say that “evil” is “evil”, then there is no reason to choose “inaction”. If you say that there is a difference between two evil choices, then you subscribe to utilitarianism / proportionalism. You can’t win. 🙂
 
This is again trivially true. If there is one morally licit option, then that is the one which should be chosen. If there are several such options, then the best one should be chosen. Isn’t that obvious?
Yes, but it’s only part of the argument against your point.
Just like “action” is also neutral - per se. Pulling the trigger of a gun is neutral
Wow. Just… wow. I can’t believe you argue for that. “All action is amoral”? Good luck with that one. :roll_eyes:
And this is the fundamental problem with your approach. You correctly included “inaction” among the evil actions, and then you don’t present any reason why “inaction” should have a privileged status? If you say that “evil” is “evil”, then there is no reason to choose “inaction”. If you say that there is a difference between two evil choices, then you subscribe to utilitarianism / proportionalism. You can’t win.
Hardly. My approach simply identifies that inaction isn’t inherently evil.

Remember: according to Catholic Moral Theology, an act is evil if the object of the act is evil or if the intention is evil. Therefore, if inaction is chosen in rejection of (at least one) good option, then we would say that the inaction is evil if either the object of the inaction or the intention of the inaction is evil.
 
Wow. Just… wow. I can’t believe you argue for that. “All action is amoral”?
Of course. All action is amoral - per se. The action is a physical activity (raising a gun and pulling the trigger, for example). It does not include the target of the action, it does not include the reason for the action, it does not include the outcome of the action. All these are extraneous to the action. It is nonsensical to make a judgment about the action without considering ALL the circumstances.
Hardly. My approach simply identifies that inaction isn’t inherently evil.
Just like the action cannot be inherently evil. Nothing is “inherently” evil. What you do, why you do it, how you do it… none of them can be disregarded.
 
It is nonsensical to make a judgment about the action
Agreed. No system of morality does that! In Catholic theology we speak of human acts, not actions. They are not the same.
What you do, why you do it, how you do it… none of them can be disregarded.
As descriptive information, all this may be useful in understanding the human act involved. But in catholic theology, there are inviolable laws, that no “why you did it” make your choice good. It is different in the Scowler system.
 
Agreed. No system of morality does that! In Catholic theology we speak of human acts, not actions. They are not the same.
Of course they are. You try to expand the act/action to incorporate the extraneous factors. This is irrational, even if you affix the label of “Catholic theology” on it.
But in catholic theology, there are inviolable laws.
I am aware of that, but do not accept it, especially because of the illogical attempt to include outside factors into the concept of “act/action”. No reason for repeating it. You try to create “special” definitions for well-understood phenomena, and expect others to go along with them. Just like with theft and lying. Sometimes these acts are justified, other times they are not. It is that simple.
 
Wow. Just… wow. I can’t believe you argue for that. “All action is amoral”? Good luck with that one. :roll_eyes:
There is nothing extraordinary in this statement.
It simply asserts that intent, the basis of moral judgements, cannot be identified simply on the basis of poorly defined behaviours. We need more behaviour/event detail before an inherent meaning can be discovered in the behaviour to likely point to a human intent.

The whole problem with this trolley scenario is that it is too complex for us to use it to say that this disordered behaviour must objectively indicate an evil intent.

Especially when all possible behaviors are disordered (ie leading to death) including choosing to do nothing.
 
Just like the action cannot be inherently evil. Nothing is “inherently” evil. What you do, why you do it, how you do it… none of them can be disregarded.
How do you determine whether an act is evil? What are your criteria? For example: our small town’s only hospital is about to be closed for lack of funds; it will take $1M to save it. Am I justified in breaking into a drug dealer’s house, murdering him, and stealing the million from him to save the hospital? If murder is not inherently evil surely this case would justify it, and if it doesn’t surely you can suggest a situation that would.
 
How do you determine whether an act is evil? What are your criteria?
It requires all the circumstances to be taken into consideration. At this point the analysis must be like this:
  1. it must be shown that the positive result far surpasses the “cost”. It would require ALL the details.
  2. it must be shown that the positive result cannot be achieved if the “cost” is lessened.
To make such a value judgment ALL the circumstances MUST be enumerated and evaluated.
For example: our small town’s only hospital is about to be closed for lack of funds; it will take $1M to save it. Am I justified in breaking into a drug dealer’s house, murdering him, and stealing the million from him to save the hospital? If murder is not inherently evil surely this case would justify it, and if it doesn’t surely you can suggest a situation that would.
In your hypothetical scenario you did not show that there is no other way to salvage the hospital - for example by issuing some bonds, which would allow the people of the small town to “vote with their wallets”. Anyhow, if the people do not care enough to gather that 1 million dollars to save their hospital, then there is no reason to accept that killing the drug dealer is an acceptable solution. Why should any outsider care, if the affected people do not care?
 
Last edited:
Anyhow, if the people do not care enough to gather that 1 million dollars to save their hospital, then there is no reason to accept that killing the drug dealer is an acceptable solution.
What is the $value of a drug dealer in your system scowler? A lot of good can be done with a lot of money. Many starving people saved etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top