Nobody at Confession...Everyone for Eucharist?

  • Thread starter Thread starter punisherthunder
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A while ago I went to Confession on Saturday and nobody was there. The next day at Mass…EVERYONE was in line for the Eucharist.

I don’t want to judge, but if I had the slightest feeling of lust or immoral thought, I NEVER take the Eucharist. I refuse to disrespect Jesus like that. Anyone else feel the same?
Welcome to the American Catholic Church! Yes, our confession lines are desolate but the line for Holy Communnion is full! Hypocrisy? Yes! Condemnnation? Yes!

Take pity and offer sacrifice for your parish.

And might I add, a feeling of lust is not a mortal since since lust must be from the will. Don’t be scrupulous. The devil wants to keep you away from Eucharist.
 
A while ago I went to Confession on Saturday and nobody was there. The next day at Mass…EVERYONE was in line for the Eucharist.
I don’t want to judge, but if I had the slightest feeling of lust or immoral thought, I NEVER take the Eucharist. I refuse to disrespect Jesus like that. Anyone else feel the same?
It was asked why there no respect for Jesus.

I gave plenty of reasons in my posts.

Everyone just wants to knick pick at the reasons.

Mortal Sin has been watered down.

Technology and the personal greed of need for leisure time has watered down Mortal Sin.

Therefore no one believes they commit mortal sins anymore.

Therefore the need for confession has dwindled to almost non-existent.

The “Been there Done that” attitude has watered down Mortal Sin.

The need to be entertained has watered down Mortal Sin.

Make a choice.

Pick one.

A. Mortal Sin has been watered down.

B. Confession is a dead sacrament.

Knick pick if you want if it eases your conscience.
 
Does your leisure time prevent you from giving glory and praise to God.
No. Rather, I’d say my leisure time helps me to praise God.
Is your leisure time more important then giving praise and glory to God?
No, but perhaps I don’t understand the question. I think I need to rest and re-create to allow me to be “recollected”. When I am recollected, I am much better able to pray and to give proper recognition to God’s presence in my every activity. If I am recollected, I am aware of the presence of God as I type. If I’m scattered, then I am less aware or even blind to the presence of God.
Does your leisure time exceed that time which is given to God?
From my perspective, no. I have practically no leisure time because I am always in pain. To me, that is not leisure time. I spend as much time as I need in simple activities to get my mind up to speed. Then, once it is up to speed I use that time up on work, prayer, service, things like that. I’ve only got a set amount of that to go around each day. Sometimes I resent that I don’t get to spend my up time on myself, though. I’m not saying that is right, but I do do it.
Do you believe we are only required give glory and praise to God just on the seventh day?
Absolutely not. I referenced it because we are to do leisurely things on the seventh day, so we are designed for leisure, IMO.
2193 “On Sundays and other holy days of obligation the faithful are bound . . . to abstain from those labors and business concerns which impede the worship to be rendered to God, the joy which is proper to the Lord’s Day, or the proper relaxation of mind and body
2184 Just as God "rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had done,"121 human life has a rhythm of work and rest. The institution of the Lord’s Day helps everyone enjoy adequate rest and leisure to cultivate their familial, cultural, social, and religious lives
I added bold
 
But you could use that time to pray, so obviously you love comming in here more than you love God. Hence, according to your logic, you’re committing mortal sin.😛
Nope. While I am sitting here typing this, I am either listening and praising God via Christian Music on the radio or I am praying in my mind while listening to a CD that has the Hail Mary and the Divine Mercy. Furthermore I give praise and glory to God for 1 hour in a combination of Prayer of the Hours and Reading of the Bible prior to going to bed. That is why you will find very few posts from me during prime time. And when I do watch TV, My nose is buried in the Bible during Commercials.

Anything else Jim?
 
When you are at work, do you sometimes stop and pray?
If you do, you are stealing company’s time.

When you are at work, do you receive any personal phone calls?
If you do, you are stealing company‘s time.

If every one in the company prayed during work for 10 minutes everyday, and times 1000 people, times 12.50/hour…….

For many professionals, we work lots of extra hours without pay, even on Saturdays…
 
Any one thing on any given day that you that is pleasurable to you that you do more than you give to God in Prayer is a Mortal Sin in my honest opinion.😦
This seems confusing. Pleasure is not good or evil. It is the antecedent action that makes it good or bad.

If your point is there is often a lack of balance between secular pursuits and things like praying then I think you have a point.
 
No. Rather, I’d say my leisure time helps me to praise God.
**You and I are of a Minority in the aspect. **
No, but perhaps I don’t understand the question. I think I need to rest and re-create to allow me to be “recollected”. When I am recollected, I am much better able to pray and to give proper recognition to God’s presence in my every activity. If I am recollected, I am aware of the presence of God as I type. If I’m scattered, then I am less aware or even blind to the presence of God.
Unfortunately you don’t speak for the majority of Catholics, confession attendance attests to this.
From my perspective, no. I have practically no leisure time because I am always in pain.
You are added to my prayer list.
To me, that is not leisure time. I spend as much time as I need in simple activities to get my mind up to speed. Then, once it is up to speed I use that time up on work, prayer, service, things like that. I’ve only got a set amount of that to go around each day. Sometimes I resent that I don’t get to spend my up time on myself, though. I’m not saying that is right, but I do do it.
Again, unforturnately, you don’t speak for the majority of catholics, confession attendence attests to this.
Absolutely not. I referenced it because we are to do leisurely things on the seventh day, so we are designed for leisure, IMO.
I added bold
You and Catechism does not speak for what many Catholics do. If that same leisure takes one away from God on the seventh, then the leisure itself is a sin.

The Third commandment does not negate the First commandment.

The first commandment of having no other Gods and of loving God with all your soul, heart.

One is to love God everyday not just on the seventh.
 
A while ago I went to Confession on Saturday and nobody was there. The next day at Mass…EVERYONE was in line for the Eucharist.

I don’t want to judge, but if I had the slightest feeling of lust or immoral thought, I NEVER take the Eucharist. I refuse to disrespect Jesus like that. Anyone else feel the same?
My husband goes to confession once a year, the requirement, and takes the Eucharist every week. For those sins he goes straight to God on a daily basis and asks for forgiveness. Maybe, that is what the people at your church do.
 
There is used to be public confession in some cases and very harsh penances as well. But, that things were once one way does not mean it is the only way or the correct way for today. The Church is guided by the Holy Spirit. We are not simply holy archeologists.
I don’t think you understood what I meant. I agree totally that the Church is in fact guided by the Holy Spirit and things change over time. That’s exactly why we shouldn’t bemoan change (as long as it is still in keeping with Church teaching) as being catastrophic.
 
The problem that I could point out is that, there are people who don’t know the existence of mortal/venial sin. All they know is just sin. So there’s no knowledge, it won’t be mortal sin, right? 😉

I was chatting with my friends before mass last Sunday, and I was explaining about not going to mass on Sunday is a mortal sin. Suddenly, my youth ministry leader heard it and asked me “isn’t all sin mortal?” I was surprised to know that even the youth ministry leader didn’t know about it.

Oh well, we must pray for these people. Usually, I will mention lightly about the catholic teachings when we are chatting. Most of the time, they’ll want to know more. After all, ignorance is a bliss!

I also just knew about the existence of mortal sins few months ago. 🙂
 
The Ten Commandments are inscribed in the hearts of men. That is the natural law and any of those commandments that are broken are without exception a mortal sin. People know that not keeping holy the Sabbath is a mortal sin. They are lieing to themselves.
 
Nope. While I am sitting here typing this, I am either listening and praising God via Christian Music on the radio or I am praying in my mind while listening to a CD that has the Hail Mary and the Divine Mercy. Furthermore I give praise and glory to God for 1 hour in a combination of Prayer of the Hours and Reading of the Bible prior to going to bed. That is why you will find very few posts from me during prime time. And when I do watch TV, My nose is buried in the Bible during Commercials.

Anything else Jim?
WOW, you certainly are holy. 😃

You’re begining to back pedal on your original post where you said that if you kissed your wife but didn’t pray, you commited a mortal sin.

Being a good husband to my wife, is an act of prayer, because our relationship is Christ centered.

As you’ve only just recently confirmed is, that there are many aspects of prayer.

Working at my job and offering it up to God, is prayer.

So, as I said early, it would would be immpossible to have faith and not prayer.

Jim
 
WOW, you certainly are holy. 😃
Jim
Not even close. That is why I do what I do. My lifelong sins are many, but forgiven, but not fully penanced for.
You’re begining to back pedal on your original post where you said that if you kissed your wife but didn’t pray, you commited a mortal sin.
No, I still hold to that.

You can kiss your wife yesterday and not offer at least one phrase of glory and praise to God on the same day…what the two acts combine are saying:

Wife I love you (by kissing her).
God I don’t love you (by not offering any phrase of Glory and Praise to God).
Being a good husband to my wife, is an act of prayer, because our relationship is Christ centered.
I will have to contemplate that one.
 
The Ten Commandments are inscribed in the hearts of men. That is the natural law and any of those commandments that are broken are without exception a mortal sin. People know that not keeping holy the Sabbath is a mortal sin. They are lieing to themselves.
They may not realize they are lieing to themselves if they have convinced themselves that they are not sinning.😦 One can brainwash one’s own brain into believing something.😦
 
You can kiss your wife yesterday and not offer at least one phrase of glory and praise to God on the same day…
I asked earlier and never got an answer. What is the infatuation with the time period of one day. Could not the same argument be made for any given hour of the day, or for a month, five minutes, etc.?

While I think we all see the necessity that nothing be more important than God, I do not see where the twenty-four hour period is needed to make teh sin of idolatry.
 
Not even close. That is why I do what I do. My lifelong sins are many, but forgiven, but not fully penanced for.

No, I still hold to that.

You can kiss your wife yesterday and not offer at least one phrase of glory and praise to God on the same day…what the two acts combine are saying:

Wife I love you (by kissing her).
God I don’t love you (by not offering any phrase of Glory and Praise to God).
Not mortal sin. Kissing your wife is a sign of affection, which is part of your immediate attention, which is mandated by the sacrament of marraige.
There mere thought about God is also a sign of love and affection.

Anyone who has faith in God is not going to live a day without thinking of him, but even if he were to forget, there would be no mortal sin, because mortal sin requires full knowledge and consent and the act must be grave. If I forget to praise God, it is not done with full knowledge and consent, because I forgot.

Jim
 
I asked earlier and never got an answer. What is the infatuation with the time period of one day. Could not the same argument be made for any given hour of the day, or for a month, five minutes, etc.?

While I think we all see the necessity that nothing be more important than God, I do not see where the twenty-four hour period is needed to make teh sin of idolatry.
I really don’t have an answer for that other than it’s the first Unit of Time that God gave us in his Holy Writ (Genesis).

When first used :

Second : Never
Minute : Never
Hour : Dan 3:6
Day Gen 1:5
Week Gen 29:27
Year : Gen 1:14
 
Anyone who has faith in God is not going to live a day without thinking of him, but even if he were to forget, there would be no mortal sin, because mortal sin requires full knowledge and consent and the act must be grave. If I forget to praise God, it is not done with full knowledge and consent, because I forgot.
In a typical day no one has the excuse of forgetting.

Lets run a typical day for me before my awareness of what Mortal sin is.

5:00 AM get up
5:01 wee wee
5:02 brush teeth and other hygiene stuff
5:10 Make coffe.
5:15 Sit at computer and diddle daddle
6:00 leave of work
7:00 to 4:00 work
4:00 leave for home.
5:00 Eat Dinner (or fix dinner if I got home before me wife did)
5:30 ish snatch a kiss from wife
5:30 Watch News
6:00 Shower
6:10 to 7:00 diddle daddle on the computer
7:00 to 10:00 watch TV
10:00 Bed

and then it starts all over again.

I had full knowledge and consent and grave matter for all the above things.

As you noticed that God was not part of the Day in any sense unless of course you want to use the kissing the wife as a example.

What does our Penitentient Rite say:

I All: I confess to almighty God,
and to you, my brothers and sisters,
that I have sinned through my own fault,
in my thoughts and in my words,
in what I have done,
and in what I have failed to do;

not

and in what I have forgotten to do.

Do you really think God is going to buy the “I FORGOT” excuse?

Nobody can tell me that everything they did in a course of a day was more important than loving God so they forgot to offer a 10 second prayer?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top