Non catholic attending Mass.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Nicole09
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

Nicole09

Guest
I have been to Mass with my Catholic boyfriend a couple of times. And I was wondering if it is required for me to kneel when he does and whenever we walk in to use what I assume to be holy water to make a cross on my forehead?
 
I have been to Mass with my Catholic boyfriend a couple of times. And I was wondering if it is required for me to kneel when he does and whenever we walk in to use what I assume to be holy water to make a cross on my forehead?
The actions you describe are only required of Catholics. As a guest you are only accompanying him. You may sit throughout the Mass, or kneel or stand, as you choose.
 
I have been to Mass with my Catholic boyfriend a couple of times. And I was wondering if it is required for me to kneel when he does and whenever we walk in to use what I assume to be holy water to make a cross on my forehead?
The sign of the cross is a form of prayer. If you are uncomfortable with it, don’t sweat it. I am glad that you want to spend time with your boyfriend doing something that is important to him, even if it is a little uncomfortable for you.

We, as a community in worship, try to do things together like sit, stand, kneel. There are specific reasons for each. For example, we pray kneeling or standing and we listen to the readings (except the Gospel) sitting. If you are comfortable doing that, it would be seen as a sign of respect for our practices to follow along, but, you won’t be the first or the last to sit through the mass if that is what you feel is appropriate for you. There is a great conversion story by a former protestant minister named Scott Hahn. His initial contact with the Catholic Mass was sitting in the back as a disinterested observer. He sat there and just took notes. (He also eventually became a Catholic. Its a fascinating and funny story if you ever get a chance to listen to it.)

Anyway, I’m sure your boyfriend appreciates the effort your making.
 
I have been to Mass with my Catholic boyfriend a couple of times. And I was wondering if it is required for me to kneel when he does and whenever we walk in to use what I assume to be holy water to make a cross on my forehead?
There’s absolutely no harm in doing these things, and what a lovely act of solidarity with your boyfriend! When in Rome (quite literally) do as the Romans! 🙂 👍
 
Thank you all for helping me to understand. I will feel much more comfortable when I attend Mass again this Sunday. And jbarbaretta, I actually just finished reading a book about people’s conversion to the faith and I will definitely look up Scott Hahn. I need to learn all I can because I plan to go through the rcia classes very soon.
 
my wife has been sitting while I kneel for over 32 years…maybe one day she will kneel beside me when she is lead by the Holy Spirit, but until then…
 
I am a non-Catholic (non-believer, actually) who, in an effort to foster some family unity, attends weekly mass with my Catholic wife. Although I am in the same pew every Sunday, as a non-Catholic, I suppose I am still sort of a guest. As a guest, I feel an obligation not to be a distraction to those who are there to worship. So, I try to just blend in and not break any big rules. (Such as presenting myself for communion or shouting “Amen! Preach it Brother!” during the homily.)

My suggestions: Stand when everyone else stands; sit when everyone else sits; kneel when everyone else kneels. If you’re not comfortable with it, don’t genuflect or cross yourself. (I don’t, and no one has ever seemed to notice.) Don’t go up for communion and don’t drink the holy water. Don’t ask where to hang your coat, because there are no coat racks. Otherwise, just go with the flow and enjoy what will probably be an interesting experience. And one last thing…be sure to stick around for the post-mass donuts.
 
I am a non-Catholic (non-believer, actually) who, in an effort to foster some family unity, attends weekly mass with my Catholic wife. Although I am in the same pew every Sunday, as a non-Catholic, I suppose I am still sort of a guest. As a guest, I feel an obligation not to be a distraction to those who are there to worship. So, I try to just blend in and not break any big rules. (Such as presenting myself for communion or shouting “Amen! Preach it Brother!” during the homily.)

My suggestions: Stand when everyone else stands; sit when everyone else sits; kneel when everyone else kneels. If you’re not comfortable with it, don’t genuflect or cross yourself. (I don’t, and no one has ever seemed to notice.) Don’t go up for communion and don’t drink the holy water. Don’t ask where to hang your coat, because there are no coat racks. Otherwise, just go with the flow and enjoy what will probably be an interesting experience. And one last thing…be sure to stick around for the post-mass donuts.
It’s nice that you go with your wife to Mass. I know it’s comforting for her to have you there, but aren’t you wondering if there’s some reason she goes to Mass other than the Sunday obligation? Maybe you’re missing something by just being there in body and not in spirit. Aren’t you just curious enough to go to RCIA classes there, at least long enough to find out what your wife’s beliefs are all about? If you really want to make her happy, and I get the impression that that’s why you go to Mass with her, why not do a little studying? You could drop out, of course, but you would be a little wiser about what she believes. Can’t hurt.
 
Aren’t you just curious enough to go to RCIA classes there, at least long enough to find out what your wife’s beliefs are all about?
Been there…done that. I attended RCIA for about three months. Interesting, but I didn’t really learn anything that I didn’t already know.

A lot of people on here (not necessarily you, Waiting) suggest that all I have to do is “learn what the Church really teaches” and I’ll suddenly become a believer. Since I am married to a Catholic and want to have an understanding of her religion, I’ve done a bit of studying. I think I have a fairly decent understanding of what the Church teaches. I just don’t believe it.

Sorry OP…didn’t mean to de-rail your thread.
 
I’ve had non Catholics at church with me many times, of course they aren’t expected to get up for Communion!
 
I am a non-Catholic (non-believer, actually) who, in an effort to foster some family unity, attends weekly mass with my Catholic wife. Although I am in the same pew every Sunday, as a non-Catholic, I suppose I am still sort of a guest. As a guest, I feel an obligation not to be a distraction to those who are there to worship. So, I try to just blend in and not break any big rules. (Such as presenting myself for communion or shouting “Amen! Preach it Brother!” during the homily.)

My suggestions: Stand when everyone else stands; sit when everyone else sits; kneel when everyone else kneels. If you’re not comfortable with it, don’t genuflect or cross yourself. (I don’t, and no one has ever seemed to notice.) Don’t go up for communion and don’t drink the holy water. Don’t ask where to hang your coat, because there are no coat racks. Otherwise, just go with the flow and enjoy what will probably be an interesting experience. And one last thing…be sure to stick around for the post-mass donuts.
This is good advice. If I am visiting another house of worship, out of respect for others I will do whatever is requested of those in attendance (short of making any kind of proclamation of faith that I do not agree with).

And to rick43235, you are a fine person for showing that kind of love to your wife. I can appreciate that you are not a believer, but there apparently is some discernment going on within you. I would just keep on doing what you’re doing.
 
Been there…done that. I attended RCIA for about three months. Interesting, but I didn’t really learn anything that I didn’t already know.

A lot of people on here (not necessarily you, Waiting) suggest that all I have to do is “learn what the Church really teaches” and I’ll suddenly become a believer. Since I am married to a Catholic and want to have an understanding of her religion, I’ve done a bit of studying. I think I have a fairly decent understanding of what the Church teaches. I just don’t believe it.

Sorry OP…didn’t mean to de-rail your thread.
Could all those people be wrong? Well, keep going to Mass. It does help keep your spouse happy, and, who knows, maybe the Lord will just decide to give you a personal invitation.
 
I have been to Mass with my Catholic boyfriend a couple of times. And I was wondering if it is required for me to kneel when he does and whenever we walk in to use what I assume to be holy water to make a cross on my forehead?
Thanks for coming to mass. I’d say, do what you feel comfortable doing. However I might ask that you do not receive communion because only Catholics are supposed to. No hard feelings about that. But its a great thing you’re doing for your boyfriend. I dunno if you believe in God but he appreciates what you’re doing 🙂 You’re a great person.
 
I have been to Mass with my Catholic boyfriend a couple of times. And I was wondering if it is required for me to kneel when he does and whenever we walk in to use what I assume to be holy water to make a cross on my forehead?
you are always welcome at Mass, all Masses are open to the public. Do what feels comfortable to you, but nothing that violates your conscience. If using holy water or kneeling does not seem right, don’t do it yet. Catholics do not have open communion so of course you will not receive but can join in prayers for unity of all believers at that time, if your beliefs tend that way.
 
I am a non-Catholic (non-believer, actually) who, in an effort to foster some family unity, attends weekly mass with my Catholic wife. Although I am in the same pew every Sunday, as a non-Catholic, I suppose I am still sort of a guest. As a guest, I feel an obligation not to be a distraction to those who are there to worship. So, I try to just blend in and not break any big rules. (Such as presenting myself for communion or shouting “Amen! Preach it Brother!” during the homily.)

My suggestions: Stand when everyone else stands; sit when everyone else sits; kneel when everyone else kneels. If you’re not comfortable with it, don’t genuflect or cross yourself. (I don’t, and no one has ever seemed to notice.) Don’t go up for communion and don’t drink the holy water. Don’t ask where to hang your coat, because there are no coat racks. Otherwise, just go with the flow and enjoy what will probably be an interesting experience. And one last thing…be sure to stick around for the post-mass donuts.
Great advice!!!
 
I am glad to read your question and all the friendly invitations and replies because I had the same question recently and didn’t think to ask here. My concern as a non-Catholic was to try to fit in when attending Mass as a visitor, and to show respect. Maybe next time I’ll ask here, first!

Thanks to you all.
 
I have been to Mass with my Catholic boyfriend a couple of times. And I was wondering if it is required for me to kneel when he does and whenever we walk in to use what I assume to be holy water to make a cross on my forehead?
I go to mass with catholic friends often enough. I kneel when they kneel, and do all of those things when they do. I have never perceived that they would stop the mass and toss me out if I didn’t. I just do it out of deference for my friends. I show respect for the things that matter to them, and they in turn show respect for what matters to me.

Your friend
Sufjon
 
[QUOT]E=Nicole09;7696474]I have been to Mass with my Catholic boyfriend a couple of times. And I was wondering if it is required for me to kneel when he does and whenever we walk in to use what I assume to be holy water to make a cross on my forehead?

NO!.. Kneeling is a sign of worship; not required from those who are not yet in communion with the Church. The normal posture for you is to sit when we kneel.

Friend, if you have any questions you’d care to ask; I’d be happy tom address them for you.

Just send me a PM…

PJM

God Bless,

Love and prayers,
Pat
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top