Non-Catholic reactions to Pope Benedict's resignation.

  • Thread starter Thread starter TexanKnight
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
General Notice:
There are plenty of threads throughout CAF on the issues of abortion and birth control.
Posts not related to the thread have been deleted.
Please return to the topic of the thread.
 
Quite frankly, my respect for Pope Benedict has increased with this decision. It takes wisdom and humility to relinquish power when one believes they are no longer able to serve the post as someone else might.
The decision indeed shock the Catholic world but being the person he is, it must be made through prayer and for the good of the Church. Not that he has to abdicate, but by doing so it is more of the pragmatism in the Holy Father and he knows best his exact reason.
 
Could they begin deliberating before the current Pope resigns to assure a smooth transition? Imagine what a comfort it will be for the new Pope to have the previous one available for counseling and comfort!!! This could really be a good thing!
And what happens if something happens between Popes that requires papal intervention, comment, comfort? For example if God forbid another 911 happened?
The Camerlengo is charge until a new Bishop of Rome is elected.

If something of major importance happens, then he of course would work with the College of Cardinals.
 
Since I’m an intellectual lutheran, and an admirer of Benedict’s intellectual integrity, I esteem it as a loss for all Christians, although I fully understand and respect the reasoning behind his decision: he is not in full mental nor physical vigor to be able to serve the church 100% according to his wishes. He spoke about retiring and write a book before being elected pope, so I hope that he will be able to write exactly that book now, if God wishes.
 
I can’t imagine what the responsibility of the Office of Pope must feel like.

I would imagine it must be one of the most physically, emotionally and spiritually demanding jobs out there.

I admire him for his integrity to do what he feels is best for the Church and the world wide congregation of Catholics he leads.

It must have taken an enormous amount of personal courage - and I have nothing but admiration for people of integrity and courage.

To the extent this has upset some of my Catholic friends, I feel great empathy with them, and my heart goes out to them. I can understand the shock it must have been.

But I hope they can take heart in the fact the Pope is doing what he feels led to do in their best interest and the interest of the Church as a whole, and trust this is the right decision.

And in this, I hope they can take some measure of comfort.

Sarah x 🙂
 
I can’t imagine what the responsibility of the Office of Pope must feel like.

I would imagine it must be one of the most physically, emotionally and spiritually demanding jobs out there.

I admire him for his integrity to do what he feels is best for the Church and the world wide congregation of Catholics he leads.

It must have taken an enormous amount of personal courage - and I have nothing but admiration for people of integrity and courage.

To the extent this has upset some of my Catholic friends, I feel great empathy with them, and my heart goes out to them. I can understand the shock it must have been.

But I hope they can take heart in the fact the Pope is doing what he feels led to do in their best interest and the interest of the Church as a whole, and trust this is the right decision.

And in this, I hope they can take some measure of comfort.

Sarah x 🙂
Great Post!!! 🙂
 
Since I’m an intellectual lutheran, and an admirer of Benedict’s intellectual integrity, I esteem it as a loss for all Christians, although I fully understand and respect the reasoning behind his decision: he is not in full mental nor physical vigor to be able to serve the church 100% according to his wishes. He spoke about retiring and write a book before being elected pope, so I hope that he will be able to write exactly that book now, if God wishes.
He is a scholarly and prayerful man. His books are incredible, I read a number of them before and after his being named Pope in 2005. I know his recent book on the Infancy Narrative was shorter and some were wondering if it would be his last. I hope in his retirement he is able to finally focus on prayer and writing.

I think part of the reason was to avoid the chaos and pressure of naming a new Pope following a death. He was thinking of the Church and not himself

Lisa
 
I can’t imagine what the responsibility of the Office of Pope must feel like.

I would imagine it must be one of the most physically, emotionally and spiritually demanding jobs out there.

I admire him for his integrity to do what he feels is best for the Church and the world wide congregation of Catholics he leads.

It must have taken an enormous amount of personal courage - and I have nothing but admiration for people of integrity and courage.

To the extent this has upset some of my Catholic friends, I feel great empathy with them, and my heart goes out to them. I can understand the shock it must have been.

But I hope they can take heart in the fact the Pope is doing what he feels led to do in their best interest and the interest of the Church as a whole, and trust this is the right decision.

And in this, I hope they can take some measure of comfort.

Sarah x 🙂
I love this post.

Thank-you for writing this!
🙂
 
There are a lot of nasty comments online but glad to be reminded that courteous people still exist - Catholic or non Catholic- regarding the Pope and his office.
 
I can’t imagine what the responsibility of the Office of Pope must feel like.

I would imagine it must be one of the most physically, emotionally and spiritually demanding jobs out there.

I admire him for his integrity to do what he feels is best for the Church and the world wide congregation of Catholics he leads.

It must have taken an enormous amount of personal courage - and I have nothing but admiration for people of integrity and courage.

To the extent this has upset some of my Catholic friends, I feel great empathy with them, and my heart goes out to them. I can understand the shock it must have been.

But I hope they can take heart in the fact the Pope is doing what he feels led to do in their best interest and the interest of the Church as a whole, and trust this is the right decision.

And in this, I hope they can take some measure of comfort.

Sarah x 🙂
There are some very magnimanous and hearts-warming posts about this subject and this is one of them. Thank you.🙂
 
I thought the Pope resigning due to health concerns was a good thing and I think good for the church. The Mormon prophet gets the same deal, appointed for life, but often in their last years they are incapacitated or at least less effective before the eventual occurs. Any one who has had a loved one pass to the other side have seen the final days are often bad ones.

I’d like to see more of it and I applaud this Pope’s courage for breaking with recent tradition.
 
My mother told me that she found herself greatly respecting his decision and his humility.
It’s a rare thing to see these days for people in places of power.
 
I was surprised whe I heard this news, since usually, Popes remains till death.
But I didn’t like him, because he covered for pedophilic priests.
 
I was surprised whe I heard this news, since usually, Popes remains till death.
But I didn’t like him, because he covered for pedophilic priests.
You are not telling the truth. Please refrain from untrue and perjorative statements about our Holy Father. I am tempted to contrast the reaction of Muslims when specious claims are made about Mohamed. However we are supposed to be charitable on this board.

Lisa
 
He is a scholarly and prayerful man. His books are incredible, I read a number of them before and after his being named Pope in 2005. I know his recent book on the Infancy Narrative was shorter and some were wondering if it would be his last. I hope in his retirement he is able to finally focus on prayer and writing.

I think part of the reason was to avoid the chaos and pressure of naming a new Pope following a death. He was thinking of the Church and not himself

Lisa
I have all three of the “Jesus of Nazareth” books. I haven’t read the Infancy Narrative yet. The first two are outstanding! I also have Mary; The Church at the Source by then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger and Hans Urs Von Balthasar, and this book is excellent as well. So yes, a very scholarly and prayerful man indeed!
 
The majority of the BBC comments posts were callous and cruel. Still alot of hatred for
catholicism…
What a surprise. The BBC doesn’t “do” God, unless it wants something twee for radio 4, or to shout about the theatrics of a church service for some public event.

They really do seem to prefer comments that militate against God, the family, Israel, natives of Britain, the church and everything else that doesn’t suit their miserable, spiteful agenda.
 
Has any one read Scott Hahn’s (former Presbyterian minister) reaction? Im pointing it out because he talks about when he was non-Catholic looking in (when Benedict XVI was Cardinal Ratzinger) among other very touching sentiments. Powerful and emotive I must reiterate.

MJ
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top