non-Catholics: why are you here?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ElisabethM
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

ElisabethM

Guest
To those who don’t mind answering, I’m curious as to why you choose to be part of a Catholic forum. I would have zero interest in participating in the equivalent forum of another faith, so, again, just curious as to what you seek here.

em
 
I’ve had/have Catholic family(converts) who have given me a view of the CC that is not too flattering…so I wanted to know for myself. I also have good friends who are Catholic. With my involvement with the Sisters of Mercy, I wanted to understand them a bit better.

For the most part I do now…by some of the postings on this forum I gather they are a tad bit “liberal” for many Catholics who post here.

I wanted a fuller understanding of their faith and see past our differences. Out in the community where “the rubber meets the road”…as in AIDS houses…food kitchens…and a few “retreats” I have attended hosted by the Sisters…this forum reflects a much different “Catholicism” than what I have encountered…it’s nice to see both sides of “Catholic Street”.🙂
 
To those who don’t mind answering, I’m curious as to why you choose to be part of a Catholic forum. I would have zero interest in participating in the equivalent forum of another faith, so, again, just curious as to what you seek here.

em
:confused: Why would you have zero interest? As a Catholic I desire to learn about my fellow brothers and sisters in Christ and fellowship with them.
 
I’ve had/have Catholic family(converts) who have given me a view of the CC that is not too flattering…so I wanted to know for myself. I also have good friends who are Catholic. With my involvement with the Sisters of Mercy, I wanted to understand them a bit better.

For the most part I do now…by some of the postings on this forum I gather they are a tad bit “liberal” for many Catholics who post here.

I wanted a fuller understanding of their faith and see past our differences. Out in the community where “the rubber meets the road”…as in AIDS houses…food kitchens…and a few “retreats” I have attended hosted by the Sisters…this forum reflects a much different “Catholicism” than what I have encountered…it’s nice to see both sides of “Catholic Street”.🙂
Yeah but they wouldn’t be too liberal for this Catholic. 😃 Anyway Jesus walked those same roads. 👍
 
Whatever the reason, I’m glad non-Catholics are here so I get the experience interacting with other faith groups.
 
When i first saw other denominations on here, I thought they were all here to tell us how wrong and wicked we were for not doing things the same; but I was surprised! Most of the people who are here from other religions see us as brothers and sisters, and just wish to understyand us more

I love learning about ethodists and Episcolapians and Lutherans and such. I often don’t agree with some of their teachings, but that doesn’t mean I can’t learn about them
 
When i first saw other denominations on here, I thought they were all here to tell us how wrong and wicked we were for not doing things the same; but I was surprised! Most of the people who are here from other religions see us as brothers and sisters, and just wish to understyand us more

I love learning about ethodists and Episcolapians and Lutherans and such. I often don’t agree with some of their teachings, but that doesn’t mean I can’t learn about them
Ethodist? Is that a Neo-Pagan group?😃
 
Oh gosh, Sorry! My M, J and X keys like to stick! Methodist, naturally 👍
 
Good question – personally it is to further my education concerning the varied Catholic attitude when it comes to the physical practice of the religion of Rome. You see, I have been to Italy on a tour guided by Catholic priest on a visit to 5 of the 7 Basilicas all topped off with a front row seat to meeting the Pope. Hey, I was invited, how could I refuse. I was not allowed to participate in the religious rituals, being a non-catholic, and did respect this as an observer. I was very educational and I saw first hand how tied the European Catholic is tied to the history of the Church which is connected to the architecture and statuary (some call “idols”) of ancient Roman Church. I was also very impressed with the obsessive worship of Mary. I was not totally prepared for that, Mary seemed to enjoy a higher position in the scheme of things than does our Savior.

The American Catholic is not quite the same as the European Catholic in not being so connected to the “Architecture”, you know, the buildings of the past. The Catholic religion of Italy is explained in the buildings, those ancient stone edifices are everything to the Roman Church. Here in the States this is not so much the case as there is no Catholic History like that in Europe. An interesting thing, concerning this obsession with the grand old buildings filled with dead men’s bones is nearly all of the Churches, the Basilicas, were once temples of the Roman Gods. Once Christianity was declared the government approved religion of the Empire the temples were rededicated, renamed, and reassigned to the Saints. So, the Basilicas are built on top of the bones of pagans from the past along with the bones of the saints to come later. This kind of history is not found among the United States Catholics and, I believe, is not fully understood by those converting to the Catholic religion, or those born into the religion.

I visit this site, on occasion, to listen to the various views, some really good and though provoking and other just plain silly. My position is simple, if you don’t like the Catholic religion or the Catholics then get out. If you are confessing the religion as your salvation then who am I to say you are wrong. It should be remembered, the Protestant is a Catholic that does not believe in the supremacy of the Pope. It would not and does not surprise me to read of Protestant believers returning to the Catholic Church, after all, the Protestant Churches are her daughters.

Peace to you and yours, your servant in YaHshua, Dan
 
I’ve had/have Catholic family(converts) who have given me a view of the CC that is not too flattering…so I wanted to know for myself. I also have good friends who are Catholic. With my involvement with the Sisters of Mercy, I wanted to understand them a bit better.

For the most part I do now…by some of the postings on this forum I gather they are a tad bit “liberal” for many Catholics who post here.

I wanted a fuller understanding of their faith and see past our differences. Out in the community where “the rubber meets the road”…as in AIDS houses…food kitchens…and a few “retreats” I have attended hosted by the Sisters…this forum reflects a much different “Catholicism” than what I have encountered…it’s nice to see both sides of “Catholic Street”.🙂
Not really pubs, stick around, the more you get to know us, the more you will grow to love us,😃
 
My extended family is Catholic, and I like to stay informed on current Catholic teaching and views on various issues.
 
Good question – personally it is to further my education concerning the varied Catholic attitude when it comes to the physical practice of the religion of Rome. You see, I have been to Italy on a tour guided by Catholic priest on a visit to 5 of the 7 Basilicas all topped off with a front row seat to meeting the Pope. Hey, I was invited, how could I refuse. I was not allowed to participate in the religious rituals, being a non-catholic, and did respect this as an observer. I was very educational and I saw first hand how tied the European Catholic is tied to the history of the Church which is connected to the architecture and statuary (some call “idols”) of ancient Roman Church. I was also very impressed with the obsessive worship of Mary. I was not totally prepared for that, Mary seemed to enjoy a higher position in the scheme of things than does our Savior.

The American Catholic is not quite the same as the European Catholic in not being so connected to the “Architecture”, you know, the buildings of the past. The Catholic religion of Italy is explained in the buildings, those ancient stone edifices are everything to the Roman Church. Here in the States this is not so much the case as there is no Catholic History like that in Europe. An interesting thing, concerning this obsession with the grand old buildings filled with dead men’s bones is nearly all of the Churches, the Basilicas, were once temples of the Roman Gods. Once Christianity was declared the government approved religion of the Empire the temples were rededicated, renamed, and reassigned to the Saints. So, the Basilicas are built on top of the bones of pagans from the past along with the bones of the saints to come later. This kind of history is not found among the United States Catholics and, I believe, is not fully understood by those converting to the Catholic religion, or those born into the religion.

I visit this site, on occasion, to listen to the various views, some really good and though provoking and other just plain silly. My position is simple, if you don’t like the Catholic religion or the Catholics then get out. If you are confessing the religion as your salvation then who am I to say you are wrong. It should be remembered, the Protestant is a Catholic that does not believe in the supremacy of the Pope. It would not and does not surprise me to read of Protestant believers returning to the Catholic Church, after all, the Protestant Churches are her daughters.

Peace to you and yours, your servant in YaHshua, Dan
This post made my day. Why can’t we all be as loving and resectful as this? 👍
 
This post made my day. Why can’t we all be as loving and resectful as this? 👍
He said, ‘I was also very impressed with the obsessive worship of Mary. I was not totally prepared for that, Mary seemed to enjoy a higher position in the scheme of things than does our Savior.’

This seems to be something he judged because of something he viewed with his eye. Would it do any good for us to explain Mary is honored and venerated, but not worshipped? If his opinion, based on what he saw, overrides explanations from Catholics, I fail to see the ‘respect’ of the entire post.
 
To those who don’t mind answering, I’m curious as to why you choose to be part of a Catholic forum. I would have zero interest in participating in the equivalent forum of another faith, so, again, just curious as to what you seek here.

em
I came here recently because 1) I’d heard it was an awesome forum, 2) I grew up in a mostly Catholic neighborhood and want to keep growing in my understanding of the Church, and 3) I don’t think I can stay Episcopalian/Anglican forever and might just have to swim that Tiber before too much longer. 😃 This seems like a good place to learn from (and be blessed by) you all!
 
I originally came here to find out more about the Catholic faith and how to encourage the cafeteria Catholics around me. I haven’t been very good about accomplishing that original intent though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top