Non-religious/secular pro life arguments?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DeusExMachina
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
There is no “natural law”. All human laws are social constructs. (By the way referring to “revelation” is not a secular argument.)
There is no natural law…
oooooo K.
You do like fringe positions don’t you.
There are no rights either. A “right” which is not enforced and cannot be enforced is not a “right”. It is just a pie in the sky.
So might makes right.
Wow.
This is a rather timely discussion given the happenings in Ferguson Mo and a thousand other places where the value of human life is in the balance.
 
I don’t disagree Micosil. It cannot be argued that from the moment of conception the ‘clump of cells’ is not a developing organism and in the natural course of things cells’ will become a fully fledged human and nothing else. To my knowledge those who are pro-choice do not disagree with this as it is scientific fact.

What I was trying to say (perhaps badly) is the fact that from the moment of conception an organism is developing that will by the natural course of things be a ‘fully fledged’ human in nine months time will fail to persuade those who are pro-choice that when a woman becomes pregnant she must continue with that pregnancy irrespective of how she feels about it and how she became pregnant in the first place.

As I said, the most persuasive arguments are those that are presented from the opponents perspective. Thus, I am attempting to formulate an argument those who do not agree with my position could accept. By accept I don’t mean can’t refute, I mean endorse.
That’s exactly the thing – what I’m saying saying is that once the zygote comes into existence, we already do have a full-fledged human being. And of course, the Church agrees with this – and not because we want to be difficult, or just because ensoulment happens at conception (it does), but also because it’s what science says. 🤷

There is indeed a problem about convincing those mothers, and that’s because whatever issues the pregnancy may cause, they see those issues as more pressing or troublesome than the reality of what exactly is in the womb: a full-fledged human being. One needs to ask then, what’s more important, going through with the pregnancy, however distressing it may be for the mother; or ending a human life so that the mother doesn’t have to go through whatever issue the pregnancy causes? 🤷 Their balance of things is in the wrong direction.
It ends the growth of the zygote / blastocyst / fetus, which will cease to exist as a living material. Yes. The same happens when the zygote does not get implanted into the uterus wall, and gets flushed out from the woman’s body - which happens approximately 95% of the cases.
A miscarriage is very unfortunate, but that is the result of either some sort of trauma the mother experienced (blunt force or whatever), or the result of natural processes. Directly killing the fetus, which is what an abortion does, is something drastically different.
Hold it right there. If someone needs a blood transfusion and you are the only available donor, and refuse it, that is still not viewed as direct killing, and you don’t even need to explain the refusal. One might consider such refusal as inappropriate, but that does not change the fact that the woman (today) has the right to refuse to donate part of her body to save the life of someone else. The same applies to pregnancy.
That a single person happens to be the only donor available at a specific time and place is a cause of circumstances, but in general, multiple people, thousands even could potentially satisfy the blood requirements. However, a fetus is solely dependent on the mother.
 
Entity is a nice neutral word, and I like it. The zygote/fetus has a DNA, which we can call - very imprecisely - a “human” DNA. It is imprecise because there can be variations, and if the deviation is large enough, then the new being would not be able to procreate with “accepted” humans - and as such it would not be part of the human species. The definition of the “species” is just as imprecise as any biological definition.
This flies in the face of pretty much every science textbook and quote from a reputed scientist on this issue. Here’s the thing – if ability to reproduce is the challenge here, then every menopausal woman doesn’t qualify as part of the human species either. Or an infertile man, who was born and otherwise functions in society just like the rest of us. 🤷
Sorry, but that is not relevant. We draw a line legally in both cases. A freshly delivered baby is “officially” a human being, and is allowed to “inherit”. The same “entity”, one minute before was not an “officially recognized human being”, and as such, it cannot inherit.

Of course we all know that these kinds of distinctions are pretty much arbitrary, but that is the case. Almost all the “neat little boxes” we employ for the purposes of categorization or classification are arbitrary.

There is one objective difference between the two cases. One minute before the birth the fetus does NOT have a biologically independent existence. Its necessary nutrients are taken from the body of the mother. At the moment of the birth this biological dependence ceases. It is still dependent on someone’s care, but it can be given by anyone. It is not a “biological dependence” any more. And this difference is not a subjective assessment. It exists objectively.
How is it not relevant when a human being begins its existence? The only reason that birth guarantees these legal privileges as you pointed out is that birth shows that the person can now function in society; but that doesn’t change any biological facts.
But morality is different question. It is next to impossible to reconcile secular morality with the religious one.
Yeah, but until you, and not me, mentioned the Church in this discussion, no-one was even talking about religious morality. I’m just trying to stick to science and biology here. 🤷
Pssst… Non procreative sex is not limited to condoms. I am not about to go into details, but there are methods which preclude conception. One hundred ten percent… and much more fun than the “bam, bam, thank you ma’am” type of encounters.
Sure, and look at what the prevalence of such sexual encounters do to society. Do you think it is a coincidence that ever since contraception of any kind, condoms or not, or the widespread acceptance of sexual methods that aren’t by their nature procreative, things like divorce have sky-rocketed? I don’t know what you may think of other sexuality-related issues, but I do find that most people of all backgrounds agree that divorce is a terrible thing.
What the church says is irrelevant in this discussion. Remember, it is about “non-religious/secular” arguments.
I understand that, but I’ll remind you once more that is you, not me, that brought the Church and its teachings into this. I was trying to keep it on-topic and restricted to secular reasoning, but since you said that about the Church and its teachings, I had to point out the flaw in your reasoning. 🤷
I don’t see any decay. The purpose is there… it is called loving and caring for each other. To give and accept pleasure does not need “extraneous” justification. Besides, mutually reached pleasure is still the most effective way to create long lasting bonds between the couple. If and when they wish to procreate, that is fine and dandy. But the lack of desire (or possibility) to procreate does not diminish the bonding… no matter what Humanae Vitae says. There is absolutely no rational argument (to my best knowledge) why should people be “open” to procreation each and every time… even when the procreation is biologically IMPOSSIBLE. Playing “dumb” and pretending makes no sense.
Plenty of love and care involved in divorce, huh? Look, all those things are fine and dandy, puppy love is cute and whatnot, but it quite often doesn’t last.
 
That’s exactly the thing – what I’m saying saying is that once the zygote comes into existence, we already do have a full-fledged human being. And of course, the Church agrees with this – and not because we want to be difficult, or just because ensoulment happens at conception (it does), but also because it’s what science says. 🤷
We agree, but let me propose that the word “full fledged” is problematic when it is used regarding human existence. Somewhat of an oxymoron.

To be a living human means to have being. Period. There is not partial being. Only an insane person would say a person in the womb does not exist. They might call them an “undermensch” (props to Adolph) in an attempt to degrade the status of that being, but can’t deny the existence of a being.

Although a person cannot be a partial being or being in progress (although slave owners and Adolph would disagree), other attributes of life are different. In almost any other area I can think of, you could have a sensible discussion about a state-in-progress.
You can say"
“I am on my way to being a doctor, I am on my way to being a slender person, I am on my way to being just about anything”.
But to be human is not a matter of fledgling or full fledged. No person lives without the prospect of change. But personhood is, nonetheless.

Science supports this without question. An unborn human is a distinct unique entity among countless billions-trillions of organisms. Existing as a wholly unique and unrepeatable being.

We humans must invent perverse moral (a-moral) principles to deny the reality. Oddly enough, a strange religion proposes the idea that what in fact exists as a being, does not exist.
It’s the definition of insanity.
 
We agree, but let me propose that the word “full fledged” is problematic when it is used regarding human existence. Somewhat of an oxymoron.

To be a living human means to have being. Period. There is not partial being. Only an insane person would say a person in the womb does not exist. They might call them an “undermensch” (props to Adolph) in an attempt to degrade the status of that being, but can’t deny the existence of a being.

Although a person cannot be a partial being or being in progress (although slave owners and Adolph would disagree), other attributes of life are different. In almost any other area I can think of, you could have a sensible discussion about a state-in-progress.
You can say"
“I am on my way to being a doctor, I am on my way to being a slender person, I am on my way to being just about anything”.
But to be human is not a matter of fledgling or full fledged. No person lives without the prospect of change. But personhood is, nonetheless.

Science supports this without question. An unborn human is a distinct unique entity among countless billions-trillions of organisms. Existing as a wholly unique and unrepeatable being.

We humans must invent perverse moral (a-moral) principles to deny the reality. Oddly enough, a strange religion proposes the idea that what in fact exists as a being, does not exist.
It’s the definition of insanity.
I find the word useful to drive the point home, as sometimes the pro-abortion camp uses a “functional” definition of human being and “full-fledged” in that case makes it clear that, yes, all the functions required to be considered a human being are there. I totally agree with your point; the thing is, I often find I need to adjust my vocabulary to be better understood in a debate.
 
There is no “natural law”. All human laws are social constructs. (By the way referring to “revelation” is not a secular argument.)
It occurs to me this might be the heart of the difficulty right here.

I proposed that the topic at hand is informed by what is revealed.
You automatically assume revelation is an irrational religious process.

Question: was it revealed to you that the sun rises in the morning? Or is that “religion”.

When something is revealed you have a two step process. The revealing of reality and the observation of it.
It is true that nature reveals. Always.
Observation of it is another story. The observation might be missing, or might not be true.

If what is revealed is not observed, or if what is observed is denied, the result is irrationality, or “non-sense”.
 
No society ever has dared to declare a “right” to someone else’s bodily resources.
Non-sense.
Are you claiming a mother has the right to let her 1 year old toddler starve?

Bodily resources:
Feeding a child requires the use of a mother’s hands, feet, brain, emotions, the monopolization of her time,
…
maybe we should just say it requires devoting her being to feeding her child. In fact, maybe you’ve noticed that women have breasts, which have a specific function in the existential human realm.

Name a society that excuses a mother not giving her self to feeding her child.
(yes it is somewhat of a trick question)
Go ahead…
 
Non-sense.
Are you claiming a mother has the right to let her 1 year old toddler starve?

Bodily resources:
Feeding a child requires the use of a mother’s hands, feet, brain, emotions, the monopolization of her time,
There is no reason to talk to someone who does not see the difference between giving a glass of milk and having the zygote imbedded in the uterus.
 
Plenty of love and care involved in divorce, huh? Look, all those things are fine and dandy, puppy love is cute and whatnot, but it quite often doesn’t last.
I expected better from you. Just because the love and the caring might end, it does undo the value of it while its lasts. Just because you will eliminate today’s meal through your hind orifice, it does not lessen the nutritional value today.
 
There is no reason to talk to someone who does not see the difference between giving a glass of milk and having the zygote imbedded in the uterus.
“No reason” is probably a good phrase to use.
I’m sorry you don’t respond well to direct refutations and questions. Fair enough. You can ignore my posts if you find them difficult.

Please pardon me while I continue to point out the problems with your reasoning.

“Giving a glass of milk” is a gross oversimplification of the matter at hand. And a slap in the face for parents, who devote their entire being to parenting. Do you have children?
What child do you know that can survive on a “glass of milk”?
Perhaps you thought your gloss of the language could hold up to scrutiny. Perhaps you are mistaken.

If you can, name us a society that excuses a mother allowing her 1 year old child to starve to death.
Simple, direct questions.
Anyone else could answer also if you are not up to it.
 
I’m working on this and thought I would throw my theory out here for feedback.
Since you are interested in developing such an argument, I’m told by several Philosophical types online that the following book is very thorough and addresses the arguments you are looking for.

The Ethics of Abortion: Women’s Rights, Human Life, and the Question of Justice (Routledge Annals of Bioethics) Christopher Kaczor
 
Since you are interested in developing such an argument, I’m told by several Philosophical types online that the following book is very thorough and addresses the arguments you are looking for.

The Ethics of Abortion: Women’s Rights, Human Life, and the Question of Justice (Routledge Annals of Bioethics) Christopher Kaczor
Haven’t read it (yet), but I too have heard that one is darn good. And the second edition just came out, so it should be expanded a little bit. Another really solid on is Francis Beckwith’s Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice. Beckwith’s has the benefit of being half the price of Kaczor’s.
 
Haven’t read it (yet), but I too have heard that one is darn good. And the second edition just came out, so it should be expanded a little bit. Another really solid on is Francis Beckwith’s Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice.
I haven’t read it either sadly, I just heard it was good. The library where I am doesn’t have it… Hopefully I will be able to purchase it in the future.

Thanks for the recommendation! I will add that one to my list of books!
 
There is no reason to talk to someone who does not see the difference between giving a glass of milk and having the zygote imbedded in the uterus.
Of course there is a difference, just not a non-arbitrary one. If an infant has the right to breast milk (let’s assume for the sake of argument that there is no other means available), then the mother’s right to autonomy isn’t exactly absolute. But any further dividing line seems to be, at best, incredibly contentious.
 
Of course there is a difference, just not a non-arbitrary one. If an infant has the right to breast milk (let’s assume for the sake of argument that there is no other means available), then the mother’s right to autonomy isn’t exactly absolute. But any further dividing line seems to be, at best, incredibly contentious.
The difference is only arbitrary if the locus of morality is self-centered.
“It makes all the difference to me if I have to do the work of carrying the child all day long inside of me as opposed to caring all day long for the child outside of me.”
The self absorbed viewpoint focuses on the relative inconvenience to the self, not the value and support of the other’s life.

If the value of each human life is accepted as an intrinsic value, there really is no difference between the commitment required to support a one year old, compared to the child-in-womb. The types of care are simply different. The human “value” cared for is intrinsic and not arbitrary.
So we have a war between types of care and inconvenience, and the value of human life.

In any case, I do not know of a society which excuses the starvation of a 1 year old child on the grounds of inconvenience. “The child requires my bodily resources to live. I reject it”…does not carry any weight for a 1 year old child.
 
There is no reason to talk to someone who does not see the difference between giving a glass of milk and having the zygote imbedded in the uterus.
Come on … parenting is a a lot more involved than just giving an infant a glass of milk.
I expected better from you. Just because the love and the caring might end, it does undo the value of it while its lasts. Just because you will eliminate today’s meal through your hind orifice, it does not lessen the nutritional value today.
Look, the marriage/divorce issue isn’t even on-topic here, I gave it to you as an example of the decay of society – but reflect on this: when you compare marriage, something that theoretically lasts a lifetime, to a simple meal being digested, and the painful, traumatic experience of divorce where multiple parties suffer, to simply going to the bathroom … come on. I don’t need to spell out the obvious here. :rolleyes:
Since you are interested in developing such an argument, I’m told by several Philosophical types online that the following book is very thorough and addresses the arguments you are looking for.

The Ethics of Abortion: Women’s Rights, Human Life, and the Question of Justice (Routledge Annals of Bioethics) Christopher Kaczor
Haven’t read it (yet), but I too have heard that one is darn good. And the second edition just came out, so it should be expanded a little bit. Another really solid on is Francis Beckwith’s Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice. Beckwith’s has the benefit of being half the price of Kaczor’s.
👍 Good recommendations, I may pick them up.
 
We agree, but let me propose that the word “full fledged” is problematic when it is used regarding human existence. Somewhat of an oxymoron.

To be a living human means to have being. Period. There is not partial being. Only an insane person would say a person in the womb does not exist. They might call them an “undermensch” (props to Adolph) in an attempt to degrade the status of that being, but can’t deny the existence of a being.

Although a person cannot be a partial being or being in progress (although slave owners and Adolph would disagree), other attributes of life are different. In almost any other area I can think of, you could have a sensible discussion about a state-in-progress.
You can say"
“I am on my way to being a doctor, I am on my way to being a slender person, I am on my way to being just about anything”.
But to be human is not a matter of fledgling or full fledged. No person lives without the prospect of change. But personhood is, nonetheless.

Science supports this without question. An unborn human is a distinct unique entity among countless billions-trillions of organisms. Existing as a wholly unique and unrepeatable being.

We humans must invent perverse moral (a-moral) principles to deny the reality. Oddly enough, a strange religion proposes the idea that what in fact exists as a being, does not exist.
It’s the definition of insanity.
Beat me to it Clem. Fanatically pro choice individuals such as Solmyr eventually find themselves peddling an argument disturbingly similar to Nazism; now this is only an extreme fringe viewpoint (props to you), but hey, it’s not like Margaret Sanger would disagree :rolleyes:
 
Haven’t read it (yet), but I too have heard that one is darn good. And the second edition just came out, so it should be expanded a little bit. Another really solid on is Francis Beckwith’s Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice. Beckwith’s has the benefit of being half the price of Kaczor’s.
Thanks for the reply. 🙂
 
That’s exactly the thing – what I’m saying saying is that once the zygote comes into existence, we already do have a full-fledged human being. And of course, the Church agrees with this – and not because we want to be difficult, or just because ensoulment happens at conception (it does), but also because it’s what science says. 🤷

There is indeed a problem about convincing those mothers, and that’s because whatever issues the pregnancy may cause, they see those issues as more pressing or troublesome than the reality of what exactly is in the womb: a full-fledged human being. One needs to ask then, what’s more important, going through with the pregnancy, however distressing it may be for the mother; or ending a human life so that the mother doesn’t have to go through whatever issue the pregnancy causes? 🤷 Their balance of things is in the wrong direction.
Perhaps ‘fully fledged’ was a bad choice of phrase. The zygote is not a fully developed human being in the physical sense. That can’t be disputed.

It’s not a matter of convincing mothers the zygote is human in nature, it is a matter of convincing them terminating a pregnancy should not be a legal right under any circumstances, other than the situation were it is a choice between the life of the mother or the life of the unborn child. There are situations that are much more complicated than this. Certainly the arguments you have presented would persuade me, but in my case your preaching to the converted.

Revoking any legal right is a serious business. Consider the story I have posted a link to below. I’m not saying I agree with the woman’s decision, but at the time my heart went out to her, I would be reluctant to judge her for the decision, and I would have difficulty arguing she should not have the right to make the decision she did.

belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/northern-ireland/abortion-debate-her-baby-had-no-brain-but-northern-irelands-law-forced-her-to-carry-it-29648561.html

There must be a more compassionate way to address circumstances such as these, and saying they don’t happen very often is irrelevant when it comes to law. If it happens once the law cannot ignore it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top