Entity is a nice neutral word, and I like it. The zygote/fetus has a DNA, which we can call - very imprecisely - a “human” DNA. It is imprecise because there can be variations, and if the deviation is large enough, then the new being would not be able to procreate with “accepted” humans - and as such it would not be part of the human species. The definition of the “species” is just as imprecise as any biological definition.
This flies in the face of pretty much every science textbook and quote from a reputed scientist on this issue. Here’s the thing – if ability to reproduce is the challenge here, then every menopausal woman doesn’t qualify as part of the human species either. Or an infertile man, who was born and otherwise functions in society just like the rest of us.
Sorry, but that is not relevant. We draw a line legally in both cases. A freshly delivered baby is “officially” a human being, and is allowed to “inherit”. The same “entity”, one minute before was not an “officially recognized human being”, and as such, it cannot inherit.
Of course we all know that these kinds of distinctions are pretty much arbitrary, but that is the case. Almost all the “neat little boxes” we employ for the purposes of categorization or classification are arbitrary.
There is one objective difference between the two cases. One minute before the birth the fetus does NOT have a biologically independent existence. Its necessary nutrients are taken from the body of the mother. At the moment of the birth this biological dependence ceases. It is still dependent on someone’s care, but it can be given by anyone. It is not a “biological dependence” any more. And this difference is not a subjective assessment. It exists objectively.
How is it not relevant when a human being begins its existence? The only reason that birth guarantees these
legal privileges as you pointed out is that birth
shows that the person can now
function in society; but that doesn’t change any
biological facts.
But morality is different question. It is next to impossible to reconcile secular morality with the religious one.
Yeah, but until
you, and not me, mentioned the Church in this discussion, no-one was even talking about religious morality. I’m just trying to stick to science and biology here.
Pssst… Non procreative sex is not limited to condoms. I am not about to go into details, but there are methods which preclude conception. One hundred ten percent… and much more fun than the “bam, bam, thank you ma’am” type of encounters.
Sure, and look at what the prevalence of such sexual encounters do to society. Do you think it is a coincidence that ever since contraception of any kind, condoms or not, or the widespread acceptance of sexual methods that aren’t by their nature procreative, things like divorce have sky-rocketed? I don’t know what you may think of other sexuality-related issues, but I do find that
most people of all backgrounds agree that divorce is a terrible thing.
What the church says is irrelevant in this discussion. Remember, it is about “non-religious/secular” arguments.
I understand that, but I’ll remind you once more that is
you, not me, that brought the Church and its teachings into this. I was trying to keep it on-topic and restricted to secular reasoning, but since you said that about the Church and its teachings, I had to point out the flaw in your reasoning.
I don’t see any decay. The purpose is there… it is called loving and caring for each other. To give and accept pleasure does not need “extraneous” justification. Besides, mutually reached pleasure is still the most effective way to create long lasting bonds between the couple. If and when they wish to procreate, that is fine and dandy. But the lack of desire (or possibility) to procreate does not diminish the bonding… no matter what Humanae Vitae says. There is absolutely no rational argument (to my best knowledge) why should people be “open” to procreation each and every time… even when the procreation is biologically IMPOSSIBLE. Playing “dumb” and pretending makes no sense.
Plenty of love and care involved in divorce, huh? Look, all those things are fine and dandy, puppy love is cute and whatnot, but it quite often doesn’t last.