Not everything that is permissible is expedient

  • Thread starter Thread starter Joe_5859
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Joe_5859

Guest
I came across this phrase recently and I’ve been reflecting on it a bit. I did a search and – surprise, surprise – it’s actually from Scripture. :o 1 Corinthians 6:12 and 10:23 to be exact.

Maybe it’s from spending too much time here (:o), but I think it can be tempting to look at every moral question in terms of whether or not it is permissible without ever pausing to consider if it helps us in our growth in holiness. Perhaps that is just the nature of this medium. After all, answering whether or not something is permissible or not in terms of Catholic teaching is something we can more or less do – even for total strangers. Answering whether or not such will help them grow in holiness is not really something we can answer anonymously over the internet.

I’m going to try to keep this in mind for myself at least. It’s easy to look back on the day and think that – since I didn’t really do anything impermissible – I’m in fine shape. But if I am always making the easy decision and never offering the sacrifice, I’m probably not going to progress down the path to holiness very quickly.

Anyway, I thought I’d share the Scripture passage and see what others have to say about it.
 
I think it can be tempting to look at every moral question in terms of whether or not it is permissible without ever pausing to consider if it helps us in our growth in holiness.
Somebody give this guy a medal! That is spot on - and I’d go further to say that what will hinder one person’s holiness will not hinder another, and an act of sacrifice or mortification for one person may be going way too far for another. This is why I find such comfort and help in my regular confessor - he knows me well enough to be able to answer these mural questions with no black and white answer and customize the answer to my current state of holiness.

Thanks for your great post, I needed that reminder today.
 
Somebody give this guy a medal! That is spot on - and I’d go further to say that what will hinder one person’s holiness will not hinder another, and an act of sacrifice or mortification for one person may be going way too far for another. This is why I find such comfort and help in my regular confessor - he knows me well enough to be able to answer these mural questions with no black and white answer and customize the answer to my current state of holiness.

Thanks for your great post, I needed that reminder today.
That’s a good follow up point. That reminds me of a talk I was at a few months back on Ignatian spirituality. One of the interesting things mentioned was how spiritual advice can be completely opposite for two different people depending on where they are at in their walk with God. The more I think about that, the more I recognize how true that is.

If we are not actively striving towards holiness, that little voice of unrest in our soul is usually coming from God in an attempt to shake us out of our spiritual lethargy and get us to turn towards him.

But if we are actively striving towards holiness, that little voice of unrest is often coming from the devil who is trying to distract us and knock us off of the right track.

I notice this here on CAF. Sometimes, you get a poster coming and asking if such-and-such is really a sin when it clearly contradicts Catholic teaching. And some posters will come along and say, “If you have to ask, it’s probably a sin.” That answer can be true some of the time. But there are plenty of other threads where posters are suffering from scrupulosity and experience unrest at the most benign things. For them, that is the worst answer to give them.

This all gets complicated when it’s kind of in between – like with a question such as “Is it wrong to spend time watching TV?” There’s a lot of bad stuff on TV. But there’s also some good stuff. Watching TV is not inherently sinful. But spending too much time watching it can be a distraction from holy pursuits. But then how much time is “too much”? And might that vary from person to person?

All this highlights for me the importance of a regular Confessor and/or spiritual director.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top