Not having kids a sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Protestant_Me
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

Protestant_Me

Guest
Why is it so wrong for a Catholic to choose not to have children? I don’t think a church or otherwise should be able to choose for someone whether or not they have kids. I myself want children, and don’t understand why you wouldn’t. But none-the-less, I think it should be up to the person if or not they want kids. People aren’t having abortions, so why is it a sin? Some people just aren’t good with children. :confused:
Code:
                      God Bless Your Day,
                           Protestant Me.
 
A permanent intention against children is an impediment to a valid marriage.
 
It’s perfectly fine to not want children.

However, the Church says that the primary purpose of marriage is raising children.

So, if one does not want children, then they should not marry.
 
It’s perfectly fine to not want children.

However, the Church says that the primary purpose of marriage is raising children.

So, if one does not want children, then they should not marry.
Yes, that. We are free to not want children…and not marry. For those who are married, begetting children is a natural end of marriage. So, if we don’t want children, we choose another vocation in life other than marriage.
 
But it is a sin to have sex outside of marriage. So, why would it be wrong to marry, to be happy with one another, so you are not living in sin.
 
Why is it so wrong for a Catholic to choose not to have children? I don’t think a church or otherwise should be able to choose for someone whether or not they have kids. I myself want children, and don’t understand why you wouldn’t. But none-the-less, I think it should be up to the person if or not they want kids. People aren’t having abortions, so why is it a sin? Some people just aren’t good with children. :confused:
Code:
                      God Bless Your Day,
                           Protestant Me.
I think your questions have been answered quite well in this discussion thread:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=543136
 
But it is a sin to have sex outside of marriage. So, why would it be wrong to marry, to be happy with one another, so you are not living in sin.
There is such a thing as self control. You don’t get married to have sex; yes, it is part of marriage, but not a valid reason to marry someone. Being open to life, however, is part of a valid marriage.
 
But it is a sin to have sex outside of marriage. So, why would it be wrong to marry, to be happy with one another, so you are not living in sin.
It’s not about having or not having children. It’s about the using sexuality and marriage as God intended.
 
I personally do not find it in the teachings of christ, it is a sin of marriage because would he rather see a male and female in passion, marriage, rather than fornication. even apostle Paul mentions it better than married instead of running in passion, such then we must stay in passion, commitment outside marriage. The church is that just a church, vatican, of men whom are not married telling us what to do. 👍
 
But it is a sin to have sex outside of marriage. So, why would it be wrong to marry, to be happy with one another, so you are not living in sin.
The primary purpose of sex is for making babies. God gave us sex as a way to procreate. He also gave us marriage so we can have families. Sex and marriage go hand-in-hand and their primary purpose is procreating…and there are many other secondary benefits as well. **We do not need to have sex with one another in order to be happy with one another. We also do not need to be married in order to be happy. ** However, if we wish to have sex, we must not only be married, but we must recognize the natural end of the marital act (sex), which is procreation.

If one wants absolutely no children, then marriage is a poor vocation for them because the vocation of marriage is ordered to procreation (making babies) and raising a family. But happiness can be found in other vocations that do not involve marriage and having babies.
 
I personally do not find it in the teachings of christ, it is a sin of marriage because would he rather see a male and female in passion, marriage, rather than fornication. even apostle Paul mentions it better than married instead of running in passion, such then we must stay in passion, commitment outside marriage. The church is that just a church, vatican, of men whom are not married telling us what to do. 👍
No, this is not correct. The Church is the Church on Earth the Christ established. The Church Teachings are the Truths of God. We are not discussing the opinions of a group of men sitting in a building. We are discussing God’s natural law.

Also, before you decide to interpret Scripture, please research the correct explanations. You can find most of the answers you’ll need in the Catechism of the Catholic Church regarding this current topic. With all due respect, your entire post is an offense against Truth (see Catechism paragraphs 2475-2513).
 
But it is a sin to have sex outside of marriage. So, why would it be wrong to marry, to be happy with one another, so you are not living in sin.
that is not the purpose of marriage. Perhaps your lack of belief in the sacramental nature of marriage and that it is a vocation in the Church cloud your ability to recognize this important and central fact about marriage. “Being happy” may be a fruit of marriage, but it is not its purpose.

Note also: Your original question asks if “not haven children” is a sin. It is not. There are many married couples who do not have children for various reasons that turned out that way.

That is NOT the same thing as entering marriage with a permanent intention against children. A person cannot validly enter marriage with a permanent intention against children.
 
Not having kids is a sin, having too many kids is a sin, not having enough kids is a sin, having sex in marriage is a sin, but not having sex in a marriage is a sin as well. in fact, everything regarding sex is a sin. Everything.

There’s a reason people think Catholics are neurotic and anti sex! :D:D:D
 
Not having kids is a sin, having too many kids is a sin, not having enough kids is a sin, having sex in marriage is a sin, but not having sex in a marriage is a sin as well. in fact, everything regarding sex is a sin. Everything.
What religion is that? Is this you personal belief?
 
Why is it so wrong for a Catholic to choose not to have children? I don’t think a church or otherwise should be able to choose for someone whether or not they have kids. I myself want children, and don’t understand why you wouldn’t. But none-the-less, I think it should be up to the person if or not they want kids. People aren’t having abortions, so why is it a sin? Some people just aren’t good with children. :confused:
Code:
                      God Bless Your Day,
                           Protestant Me.
No, it’s not wrong for a Catholic to choose not ot have children, and it is up to them, and it’s not a sin. However the Church won’t allow a person opposed to having children to be married in the Church. The Church requires married people vow to be open to life. That doesn’t mean they have to actively try to conceive, but it means that they can’t artificially contracept, and that if they do get pregnant, they have to accept that pregnancy.
 
No, it’s not wrong for a Catholic to choose not ot have children, and it is up to them, and it’s not a sin. However the Church won’t allow a person opposed to having children to be married in the Church. The Church requires married people vow to be open to life. That doesn’t mean they have to actively try to conceive, but it means that they can’t artificially contracept, and that if they do get pregnant, they have to accept that pregnancy.
Thank you, I was looking for an answer like this with some explination, rather than why it is wrong to not concieve and how it isn’t legal in the church. That I already was aware of.
🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top