Not having kids a sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Protestant_Me
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I personally do not find it in the teachings of christ, it is a sin of marriage because would he rather see a male and female in passion, marriage, rather than fornication. even apostle Paul mentions it better than married instead of running in passion, such then we must stay in passion, commitment outside marriage. The church is that just a church, vatican, of men whom are not married telling us what to do. šŸ‘
 
The Church requires married people vow to be open to life. That doesn’t mean they have to actively try to conceive, but it means that they can’t artificially contracept.
The restriction is not imited to contracepting artificially, but a married couple cannot actively avoid pregnancy by practicing NFP as a matter of course either—they must have serious reason to do so.
 
Not having kids is a sin, having too many kids is a sin, not having enough kids is a sin, having sex in marriage is a sin, but not having sex in a marriage is a sin as well. in fact, everything regarding sex is a sin. Everything.

There’s a reason people think Catholics are neurotic and anti sex! :D:D:D
What nonsense are you spouting?

Having sex out side of a valid marriage is a sin.
Having sex within a valid marriage and not being open to life is a sin.
The number of children you have is not sinful.

Sex is a holy act. It mirrors God’s act of creation. Catholics are not neurotic and anti sex. They don’t profane holy things. When you separate sex from procreation you make something holy into something vulgar and common.
 
What nonsense are you spouting?

Having sex out side of a valid marriage is a sin.
Having sex within a valid marriage and not being open to life is a sin.
The number of children you have is not sinful.

Sex is a holy act. It mirrors God’s act of creation. Catholics are not neurotic and anti sex. They don’t profane holy things. When you separate sex from procreation you make something holy into something vulgar and common.
The ā€œnonsenseā€ I’m spouting was clearly a joke, hence the grinning faces after what I said.

Read my signature again. In fact, memorize it.
 
The primary purpose of sex is for making babies. God gave us sex as a way to procreate. He also gave us marriage so we can have families. Sex and marriage go hand-in-hand and their primary purpose is procreating…
Here we go again. Sex is unitive as well, it’s not just about being a baby factory! Both aspects are equally important.

This is why we Catholics get so many hang ups about pleasure in sex!

NOTICE that no one responded to this post until now. What’s up with that?
 
Here we go again. Sex is unitive as well, it’s not just about being a baby factory! Both aspects are equally important.
Yes, sex is unitive and procreative. Since this discussion is based on a question about the procreative aspect of the marital union, I did not bother to mention the unitive aspect because it appears that the OP already understands this. Procreation is naturally the ā€œprimaryā€ end of the marital act, though you are correct that the unitive aspect and the procreative aspect must both be respected in each marital embrace :
  1. But no reason, however grave, may be put forward by which anything intrinsically against nature may become conformable to nature and morally good. Since, therefore, the conjugal act is destined primarily by nature for the begetting of children, those who in exercising it deliberately frustrate its natural power and purpose sin against nature and commit a deed which is shameful and intrinsically vicious. (Casti Connubii, paragraph 54)
Yes, a couple may engage in the Marital Act even when procreation is not possible and must still order their act toward procreation and unity. And if a couple wishes to engage in the Marital Act only during times when the wife is not fertile, the couple must have a just reason to do so, because the natural primary purpose of marriage (and the marital act) is to procreate. At the same time, a Marital Act that is naturally not procreative (takes place when fertility is absent) is still unitive and can still be ordered toward procreation as long as the couple does nothing to thwart either of the aspects (contraception, for example, would thwart both the unitive and procreative aspects).
 
But it is a sin to have sex outside of marriage. So, why would it be wrong to marry, to be happy with one another, so you are not living in sin.
Catholicism teaches, as EVERY christian denomination taught until 80 years ago, that God created sex, marriage and babies to actually be different aspects of ONE subject: human sexual intimacy.

This seems weird to you because you’ve grown up in a culture that is trying hard to pretend that these are three separate subjects that people can choose ala carte without there being any harmful side effects. But trying to break the moral laws of God is not all that different from trying to break the law of gravity. You only hurt yourself and others in the foolish process of trying. If God really did make these things tangled up into a single subject, then woe to him who thinks himself wise enough to ā€˜fix’ God’s little mistake.
 
Didn’t God say be fruitful and multiply! God is good and knows what will give us peace and joy!
 
The restriction is not imited to contracepting artificially, but a married couple cannot actively avoid pregnancy by practicing NFP as a matter of course either—they must have serious reason to do so.
If the couple is practicing NFP to not get pregnant, they already have good reason - enough to avoid the marital embrace with their spouse at a time when it requires the most discipline, and for extended periods of time.
 
Why is it so wrong for a Catholic to choose not to have children? I don’t think a church or otherwise should be able to choose for someone whether or not they have kids. I myself want children, and don’t understand why you wouldn’t. But none-the-less, I think it should be up to the person if or not they want kids. People aren’t having abortions, so why is it a sin? Some people just aren’t good with children. :confused:
Code:
                      God Bless Your Day,
                           Protestant Me.
Quick history lesson. Up until 1930, not ONE Christian denomination taught that contraception was okay. EVERY Christian denomination taught that it was sinful. In 1930, one denomination gave in to the culture of the day, and allowed contraception in very rare cases, and with the crack in the dam, the flood came through. Now almost every denomination has given in to their parishioners wishes and have stopped teaching God’s will.

Maybe you should ask why your church changed their teachings?
 
Not having kids is a sin, having too many kids is a sin, not having enough kids is a sin, having sex in marriage is a sin, but not having sex in a marriage is a sin as well. in fact, everything regarding sex is a sin. Everything.

There’s a reason people think Catholics are neurotic and anti sex! :D:D:D
Haha, well said. 😃
 
Yes, that. We are free to not want children…and not marry. For those who are married, begetting children is a natural end of marriage. So, if we don’t want children, we choose another vocation in life other than marriage.
Amen!!
 
I personally do not find it in the teachings of christ, it is a sin of marriage because would he rather see a male and female in passion, marriage, rather than fornication. even apostle Paul mentions it better than married instead of running in passion, such then we must stay in passion, commitment outside marriage. The church is that just a church, vatican, of men whom are not married telling us what to do. šŸ‘
Jesus was a man who was never married, I guess HE had no right to tell married people what to do either šŸ™‚
 
Children are the ā€œcrowning gloryā€ of a Catholic marriage (CCC #1652) but couples with no children are not minimalized by the Church.

The catechism instructs in #1654:

Spouses to whom God has not granted children can nevertheless have a conjugal life full of meaning, in both human and Christian terms. Their marriage can radiate a fruitfulness of charity, of hospitality, and of sacrifice.

Older couples, infertile couples, those who practice allowed birth control measures are embraced by the Church as well.
 
Children are the ā€œcrowning gloryā€ of a Catholic marriage (CCC #1652) but couples with no children are not minimalized by the Church.

The catechism instructs in #1654:

Spouses to whom God has not granted children can nevertheless have a conjugal life full of meaning, in both human and Christian terms. Their marriage can radiate a fruitfulness of charity, of hospitality, and of sacrifice.

Older couples, infertile couples, those who practice allowed birth control measures are embraced by the Church as well.
The Church does not allow any birth control measures. But it does allow natural family planning which is quite different because the couple is uses the natural, God given, infertile times to have marital relations.

I don’t mean to be nit-picky but I don’t want anyone who does not know the teachings on birth control to get the wrong idea.
 
Natural family planning* is* a form of birth control, just not like the sort of birth control the larger community thinks of when they encounter the term.

Reading through the studies of the most effective form of the rhythm method, to be as effective as is the use of a condom to avoid contraception requires a structured approach and constant vigilance. I have not talked to anyone who has actually used this formal structure but it certainly requires a family to make an overt choice and to keep it in the front of their minds if the couple is sexually active.

But, yes, natural family planning is entirely different than contraceptive pills, post-coital pills or condoms. It does share the same ends, just different means.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top