Shelby sun,
Please stop taking things out of context, or leaving things out to change the meaning of what is said, and then presenting it as though it is Church teaching. If you cannot
understand the teaching, then perhaps you need to do some more studying (perhaps offline), speak with your priest, and/or see a spiritual director for help in understanding. But to keep implying that “the Church says” these false (or “half-true”) things, especially after the correct teaching has been pointed out to you, is deceitful and manipulative on your part. Please stop it.
In this day an age it seems that it would be more likely a personality issue, a responsibility issue, or a financial reason. There are many people open to having more kids while the ones they have a starving everyday.
These issues could be reasons to avoid pregnancy, which the Church
allows in marriage. These reasons would not necessarily mean it’s an invalid marriage.
Nor does the Church say that we should have as many children as physically possible even if we cannot provide for their needs.
can you truly tell me that you believe every person ever born should marry and have children, that would mean murders, rapist, child abusers, sociopaths, etc. Of the parents that abuse their children or murder their families, you would say they still should have had children.
What if deep down a man knows he is like that, but he is Catholic and is taught that he is suppose to get married and have children and then goes on to beat his children.
This is what I’m talking about. You’ve taken what was said
out of context and you’ve even changed the meaning of it. The Church does NOT say that “every person ever born should marry and have children.” The Church does NOT say that everyone is supposed to get married and have children. In fact, not even the person to whom you were responding said either of those things.
And in case it comes up (or in case it already has and I missed it), couples who are willing but
unable to have children, or who have serious reason to avoid pregnancy for an indefinite amount of time, do NOT necessarily have invalid marriages according to the Church.
As for the couple you know whom you say are not planning to have children… it’s frankly none of your business (or ours) whether they were/are actually
open to having children or not–for all you know, it may be a temporary thing or they may have serious reason to avoid pregnancy or they might even be abstaining. Even if they aren’t open to life, how involved they are with their Church and community has
nothing to do with the validity of their marriage or whether or not they are sinning. You don’t know enough details (much as you probably think you do) to judge the validity of their marriage, and besides, it doesn’t even MATTER for this discussion. One instance of hearsay does not a valid argument make.
