Not open to having children

  • Thread starter Thread starter shelby_sun
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I never said no one should ever have children again, which is what you post inferred. Of course they are necessary, and most of the time very wanted, but can you truly tell me that you believe every person ever born should marry and have children, that would mean murders, rapist, child abusers, sociopaths, etc. Of the parents that abuse their children or murder their families, you would say they still should have had children.

What if deep down a man knows he is like that, but he is Catholic and is taught that he is suppose to get married and have children and then goes on to beat his children. Everyone is chemically different and children are wonderful but a big responsibility and at time very stressful. I just don’t not believe everyone is meant to have children. Some are not even capable of raising a pet and God knows everyone’s limitations.

Civilization would be a lot better off if some people didn’t have their own children or as many and adopted those children who have no families.
Of course, not everyone is intended to have children. Not everyone is intended to marry. But all are intended to be children of God and transformed by grace.
 
I never said no one should ever have children again, which is what you post inferred. Of course they are necessary, and most of the time very wanted, but can you truly tell me that you believe every person ever born should marry and have children, that would mean murders, rapist, child abusers, sociopaths, etc. Of the parents that abuse their children or murder their families, you would say they still should have had children.

What if deep down a man knows he is like that, but he is Catholic and is taught that he is suppose to get married and have children and then goes on to beat his children. Everyone is chemically different and children are wonderful but a big responsibility and at time very stressful. I just don’t not believe everyone is meant to have children. Some are not even capable of raising a pet and God knows everyone’s limitations.

Civilization would be a lot better off if some people didn’t have their own children or as many and adopted those children who have no families.
Again, the Church never taught that everyone should get married and have kids.
 
Of course, not everyone is intended to have children. Not everyone is intended to marry. But all are intended to be children of God and transformed by grace.
So you really think that those who never come around to liking or want children simply don’t have grace? In this day an age it seems that it would be more likely a personality issue, a responsibility issue, or a financial reason. There are many people open to having more kids while the ones they have a starving everyday.

The world is simply not as black and white as you would like to make it.

Those who are not open to kids for whatever reason are not suppose to marry and share life with an another adult they love very much according to the Church, even if those two people spend their lives serving God in every other way possible their entire lives. That is still seen as going against the Church. That just doesn’t make sense to me. I have a married couple at the Catholic school I work at that do not plan to have children, yet they spend at least 65 hours a week teaching, guiding, counseling, etc. the students at our school. They are there at extracurricular sports events, dances, award ceremonies. The kids come back for year to see them after they graduate, but they are going against the Catholic Church and I am suppose to say what they are doing is wrong. I am just not going to do that when I have personally seen how many young men over many years they have helped form into wonderful Catholic men.
 
So you really think that those who never come around to liking or want children simply don’t have grace? In this day an age it seems that it would be more likely a personality issue, a responsibility issue, or a financial reason. There are many people open to having more kids while the ones they have a starving everyday.

The world is simply not as black and white as you would like to make it.

Those who are not open to kids for whatever reason are not suppose to marry and share life with an another adult they love very much according to the Church, even if those two people spend their lives serving God in every other way possible their entire lives. That is still seen as going against the Church. That just doesn’t make sense to me. I have a married couple at the Catholic school I work at that do not plan to have children, yet they spend at least 65 hours a week teaching, guiding, counseling, etc. the students at our school. They are there at extracurricular sports events, dances, award ceremonies. The kids come back for year to see them after they graduate, but they are going against the Catholic Church and I am suppose to say what they are doing is wrong. I am just not going to do that when I have personally seen how many young men over many years they have helped form into wonderful Catholic men.
Shelby that is not at all what he said. He made three distinct points.
  1. Not all people are meant to have children
  2. Not all people are meant to be married.
  3. All people are called to be transformed by Christ’s Grace to become children of God and to work on being better imitating Christ in their lives.
Nowhere did he claim that all people would want or be able to have kids if they just asked for more grace. You are reading too much into other people’s posts.
 
Shelby that is not at all what he said. He made three distinct points.
  1. Not all people are meant to have children
  2. Not all people are meant to be married.
  3. All people are called to be transformed by Christ’s Grace to become children of God and to work on being better imitating Christ in their lives.
Nowhere did he claim that all people would want or be able to have kids if they just asked for more grace. You are reading too much into other people’s posts.
It has been said many time on this site that a marriage that is not open to children is seen as invalid by the Church. Is the correct or not? If it is then all married couples are suppose to be open to children or they are not to marry. Is that correct or not. There are some people that are not born with the grace to want or raise children, just like most people are not born with the grace to become a priest. Grace comes in many different ways and actions, but I don’t see way if one does not have a calling to have children, they should then not be able to marry, love, care for a spouse.
 
It is simply not true, that a person that just doesn’t like being around children would not make a good spouse. Children and adult are completely different. Yes making sacrifices are the same, but if one cannot communicate or tolerate children that doesn’t mean they cannot work with adults. It means they have a limitation, we all do, they should not be punished for that.

You simply cannot expect every single person in the world to like or tolerate children. For the Church to teach that only leads to depression, guilt, etc. I see it as very uncaring and outdated along with millions of other Catholic around the world.
hellooo Protestant here.

I would like to interject…If the pope and the cc made up the marriage rules, decided what should or not be included etc. then I agree with shelbysun, just chuck it ALL and run!

However, if God himself made up marriage and all it would entail include allow and not,…then it doesn’t matter how you ‘feel’ on any given day about it,…
it is not coming from the pope, it is all God’s design and the rules are very important.
He made woman for man, joined them, without a pope or a cc at all.
Leaving the cc and the pope and the rules, doesn’t answer this issue, BECAUSE GOD IS STILL AROUND, NO MATTER WHERE YOU GO AND THEY ARE HIS RULES, NOT THE POPES’. …ahem…👍
 
Can you find the quotes where I have ever said the Church should changes or will change it’s teachings on anything. We have interact on this site enough for you to know I have simply have not done either of those things!

I have stated what I believe, that it is not in line with the Church’s teachings, that I do not believe they should change or would, especially under social pressure, and that even though there are millions of Catholics around the world that feel as I do about certain issues, I have never claimed to be right about anything!🤷

I would fully expect the Pope to say everything he has said because that is what the Church teaches. I am not sure why you want to portray me the way you continue to do, but that is your issue not mine.

Of course, the Pope especially this Pope could never imagine someone not liking children or not being able to tolerate being around them, so again it doesn’t surprise me. I am just stating my opinion, yes against the teachings of the Church, and again to say otherwise would be a lie. I have NEVER said anyone should think as I do, but more than you are willing to admit actually do. When one of my priests tell me I don’t belong in the Catholic church I will leave.
ok, ladies, you both have valid points and may have misunderstood each other
further up than the CC and the pope, look wayyyy up,…up there, Its our Heavenly Father, and He is the one that MADE marriage and Made all the rules about it. The pope didn’t - none of them did,…nor did the CC,…the bible has it recorded, all about our Heavenly Father bringing the first woman to the first man and joining them and declaring all the points of marriage for them,…what is included and what isn’t and even how long it is supposed to last.

All the popes have done and the other parts of the CC have reprinted this with all that is included into CC writings,…after they have poured over the original to find out all that God meant.

If marriage and its rules including children aren’t liked, don’t blame the pope or the cc because it was never their idea in the first place.

If you leave the cc, where will you go? God is everywhere, and nothing will have changed.
cc rules about marriage don’t come from cc, they come out of the bible,
read it in genesis yourself. Careful study of the whole bible will reveal all the points of marriage and children written down in cc marriage rules. God’s rules. cc only copied them down on cc paperwork. Even if you went to another church shelbysun,…God is there too and He knows what His rules were, not matter what that church’s rules are. God doesn’t change, even though churches do. Usually churches backslide away from what was originally from God. Many are far removed from His ideas, and use their own instead.
 
It has been said many time on this site that a marriage that is not open to children is seen as invalid by the Church. Is the correct or not? If it is then all married couples are suppose to be open to children or they are not to marry. Is that correct or not. There are some people that are not born with the grace to want or raise children, just like most people are not born with the grace to become a priest. Grace comes in many different ways and actions, but I don’t see way if one does not have a calling to have children, they should then not be able to marry, love, care for a spouse.
I understand that you do not understand why a permanent intention against children invalidates an attempt at marriage, however, that has nothing to do with the point I just made.
 
I understand that you do not understand why a permanent intention against children invalidates an attempt at marriage, however, that has nothing to do with the point I just made.
I guess I missed your point.
 
There are millions of Catholics that feel the way I do yet continue to go to the Catholic Church and take communion, which I do not because of my beliefs. I bring up what I do because I question if I should still be in the Catholic church feeling as I do or should I find another Church. If all of us that do not fully agree on a few of the issues with the Catholic Church were to leave the Church would be crippled, at least in the US and from talking to others in Europe also.

There are very few of us willing to say are honest feelings here while not trying to change anyone else opinion. Obviously this site has more devote Catholics posting, I am just here to say there just has many Catholic in the world that feel as I do and maybe we just shouldn’t be in the Church anymore.
Be that as it may, why wouldn’t you want to see the Church’s position on this matter change? Would the Church be better if it adopted your position on some of the issues you’ve raised on this thread and others?
 
I guess I missed your point.
My point was simply that you misunderstood JimG’s post.

JimG said this:
Of course, not everyone is intended to have children. Not everyone is intended to marry. But all are intended to be children of God and transformed by grace.
And you responded this:
So you really think that those who never come around to liking or want children simply don’t have grace?
…
JimG did not in any way say or even imply that people who don’t like children are lacking in Grace.
Like I said earlier:
Shelby that is not at all what he said. He made three distinct points.
  1. Not all people are meant to have children
  2. Not all people are meant to be married.
  3. All people are called to be transformed by Christ’s Grace to become children of God and to work on being better imitating Christ in their lives.
Nowhere did he claim that all people would want or be able to have kids if they just asked for more grace. You are reading too much into other people’s posts.
 
Shelby sun,

Please stop taking things out of context, or leaving things out to change the meaning of what is said, and then presenting it as though it is Church teaching. If you cannot understand the teaching, then perhaps you need to do some more studying (perhaps offline), speak with your priest, and/or see a spiritual director for help in understanding. But to keep implying that “the Church says” these false (or “half-true”) things, especially after the correct teaching has been pointed out to you, is deceitful and manipulative on your part. Please stop it.
In this day an age it seems that it would be more likely a personality issue, a responsibility issue, or a financial reason. There are many people open to having more kids while the ones they have a starving everyday.
These issues could be reasons to avoid pregnancy, which the Church allows in marriage. These reasons would not necessarily mean it’s an invalid marriage.
Nor does the Church say that we should have as many children as physically possible even if we cannot provide for their needs.
can you truly tell me that you believe every person ever born should marry and have children, that would mean murders, rapist, child abusers, sociopaths, etc. Of the parents that abuse their children or murder their families, you would say they still should have had children.
What if deep down a man knows he is like that, but he is Catholic and is taught that he is suppose to get married and have children and then goes on to beat his children.
This is what I’m talking about. You’ve taken what was said out of context and you’ve even changed the meaning of it. The Church does NOT say that “every person ever born should marry and have children.” The Church does NOT say that everyone is supposed to get married and have children. In fact, not even the person to whom you were responding said either of those things.

And in case it comes up (or in case it already has and I missed it), couples who are willing but unable to have children, or who have serious reason to avoid pregnancy for an indefinite amount of time, do NOT necessarily have invalid marriages according to the Church.

As for the couple you know whom you say are not planning to have children… it’s frankly none of your business (or ours) whether they were/are actually open to having children or not–for all you know, it may be a temporary thing or they may have serious reason to avoid pregnancy or they might even be abstaining. Even if they aren’t open to life, how involved they are with their Church and community has nothing to do with the validity of their marriage or whether or not they are sinning. You don’t know enough details (much as you probably think you do) to judge the validity of their marriage, and besides, it doesn’t even MATTER for this discussion. One instance of hearsay does not a valid argument make.

:gopray2:
 
ok, ladies, you both have valid points and may have misunderstood each other
further up than the CC and the pope, look wayyyy up,…up there, Its our Heavenly Father, and He is the one that MADE marriage and Made all the rules about it. The pope didn’t - none of them did,…nor did the CC,…the bible has it recorded, all about our Heavenly Father bringing the first woman to the first man and joining them and declaring all the points of marriage for them,…what is included and what isn’t and even how long it is supposed to last.

All the popes have done and the other parts of the CC have reprinted this with all that is included into CC writings,…after they have poured over the original to find out all that God meant.

If marriage and its rules including children aren’t liked, don’t blame the pope or the cc because it was never their idea in the first place.

If you leave the cc, where will you go? God is everywhere, and nothing will have changed.
cc rules about marriage don’t come from cc, they come out of the bible,
read it in genesis yourself. Careful study of the whole bible will reveal all the points of marriage and children written down in cc marriage rules. God’s rules. cc only copied them down on cc paperwork. Even if you went to another church shelbysun,…God is there too and He knows what His rules were, not matter what that church’s rules are. God doesn’t change, even though churches do. Usually churches backslide away from what was originally from God. Many are far removed from His ideas, and use their own instead.
Well like the Church backing that the world was flat, science as had us evolve by finding out the world is round. With science we now know that people are very chemically different in many different ways, and whether it is a selfish genes or fear or whatever, not all people are made to have children, which is out biggest responsibility in this world (IMO) to get right by the right people not just any human being alive.
 
Well like the Church backing that the world was flat, science as had us evolve by finding out the world is round. With science we now know that people are very chemically different in many different ways, and whether it is a selfish genes or fear or whatever, not all people are made to have children, which is out biggest responsibility in this world (IMO) to get right by the right people not just any human being alive.
Shelby, I hope you don’t mind answering this question, but is it your belief that the Church teaches that all people are meant to have children/have an obligation to have children, yes or no?
 
Well like the Church backing that the world was flat, science as had us evolve by finding out the world is round. With science we now know that people are very chemically different in many different ways, and whether it is a selfish genes or fear or whatever, not all people are made to have children, which is out biggest responsibility in this world (IMO) to get right by the right people not just any human being alive.
If you are going to attack the Church, it would help your case if you got your facts straight. Please support your claim that the Church supported the idea that the world was flat. This is not an matter of faith, nor morals, so the Church would not have presented any teachings on the matter.
 
Shelby, I hope you don’t mind answering this question, but is it your belief that the Church teaches that all people are meant to have children/have an obligation to have children, yes or no?
It teaches that all those who marry must be open to having children.
 
It teaches that all those who marry must be open to having children.
Yes, that’s essentially right. It holds that intrinsic to the sexual relationship that is marriage is openness to the fruitfulness of that relationship, but within the limits the couple can manage.
 
If you are going to attack the Church, it would help your case if you got your facts straight. Please support your claim that the Church supported the idea that the world was flat. This is not an matter of faith, nor morals, so the Church would not have presented any teachings on the matter.
Yet AGAIN, which you would know if you bother to read the other posts, have I in anyway “attacked” the Church. I have NEVER said the Church was wrong in its teachings, that I think it should change, or that what I feel it right!!!:mad:

If I come across as a bit angry I am. It is completely unfair and ungracious of you to present that I am attacking the Church, when I have simply have never done so! Nor have I ever said anyone here should change their beliefs!

I am not a Catholic theologian, but I have worked with Catholic priests for 230 years and have asked many questions, and none of them presume to know what God wants as much as some people on this site, which I find very ironic.

I have simply present how I and millions of other Catholic feel today, not that we want change or are right! Not once have I said that.

No the church didn’t teach the world was flat, they believed it at one time and through science we all know now that it is not. I have degrees sociology, psychology, and OT and through work in the past I have met people that I would say should not be open to having and raising children, but did find interacting with adult and could easily have a successful marriage.

You really truly think with the way people are today that every married couple should have children? Please don’t say if it is God’s will, because than I would have to say, is it then God’s will for hookers and child abuser to have children while the holiest of couple are unable to have children of there own?
 
The fact that a couple does not have children—even if they never have children—does not allow us to impute to them a permanent intention against children. As others have noted, they may in fact desire children but are never blessed with children. Some couples in such situations do in fact shower a lot of love and attention on other people’s children, nieces, nephews, students, and others.

But in the whole discussion about children we must not forget that all children are individuals, and parents have to get to know them just like they would any new person in their life. Having a truly permanent intention against children would be sort of like saying, “I don’t know who these people will be because I haven’t met them yet, but I’m sure that I won’t like them, no matter what!”

I’m also reminded of the Protestant reformers views on family and children, which in many ways are more strict than the Catholic view. Luther, Calvin and the rest viewed the command to be fruitful and multiply as nearly sacrosanct, as being one of God’s ordinances. While the Catholic Church might have valued celibacy and monastic life, the reformers emphasized their view that most were called to marriage and marriage involved children, a lot of children. A preacher without a large family might be looked on with some reproach. All the Protestant denominations had the same view on contraception as the Catholic Church for some 400 years, up until 1930. Now, in some denominations, that heritage is being reclaimed.
 
You really truly think with the way people are today that every married couple should have children?
I have not read any post here that advocates that. The point in discussion related to the intentions viz a viz children that a couple intending marriage ought to hold. Is an absolute and permanent rejection of fertility an appropriate condition from which to approach marriage?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top