C
CaliLobo
Guest
Corki said:1. The way the Church has dealt with the gay community needs improvement. In too many cases, the Church has not been clear that love and acceptance of individuals does not equal tolerance of their behavior.
2. It is not biologically “normal” to be homosexual. Humans are heterosexual by nature as a species. That deviations from the norm exist might be “natural” but that doesn’t make them normal.
3. This is one of my biggest pet peeves. Extending marriage rights to same-sex couples affects many people in many ways. You may think that the negative effect is “worth it” to achieve some perceived equality, but it is intellectually dishonest to say that there is no effect.
4. What does? Legalized same sex “marriage” ensures that more children will grow up in disfunctional homes.
5. Protected from what? The only protection is protection from a portion of estate tax that I know of. Any other protection of the “spouse” needs to be taken care of with a will and/or joint ownership.
6. So? Are you saying that depravity is ok as long as it is “long-lasting”?
7. That is not the nature of law. All laws legislate morality. Laws against rape, child marriage, tax evasion and slandar are all based on moral principles.
8. Non sequitor. Sharia is a body of law. Individual laws bases on moral principles, like most of the laws we have already, do not lend precedent to replacing a body of existing laws with Sharia.
9. Of course not. But it is obligated to set moral boundries and to hold its citizens accountable. Without that, we would be living in chaos.
10. See my response to point #1. Catholics, in many cases, have been confused about how to adhere to Gospel teachings while not compromising on morality. Protestant ministers have been more clear on those points.
11. The Church is always chaning but she won’t abandon core teaching.
- The best way to change people’s behavior is not to legislate against it, but to preach the Gospel. But as far as secular individual rights go, gays deserve equal treatment.
- Yes it is normal. Homosexuality is found in 400 species.
- How does it affect you as a heterosexual? It does not.
- Some gay couples adopt children and have very functional, loving homes.
- You are in denial of reality. Look up how many rights are still being denied unless we extend marriage rights to gays.
- Irrelevant for a secular government.
- It’s not based on morality; it’s based on a desire to provide restitution to victims of crime.
- Legislating based on morality will definitely create precedent that a Muslim can use to justify sharia.
- Once again, secular government should not legislate based on morals.
- Yes, I agree.
- What is the origin of the teaching that we must legislate against gay marriage rights? It’s not found in the Bible. I’ve repeatedly asked CAF where is the Bible verse that teaches we must oppose gay marriage rights politically, and I’ve gotten nothing. Therefore, though we cannot have gay sex personally, our political response to the problem is wide open. So we can tell people to go and sin no more, but it does not follow that we HAVE to oppose their secular, legal, human rights.