Nuttiest Things Non-Catholics Have Said or Done Around You Because You're Catholic

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rabbity
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I was joking with a friend the other day, and the subject came up about super villains…she said teasingly “Yeah, you Catholics have the Pope for that, right? He kinda looks like the Emperor from Star Wars!”

I replied, “Yeah, didn’t you know? Our worshiping idols and cannibalistic practices give Catholics the ability to shoot lightning!”

😃
Sorry…that was the first thing in my mind when I saw Benedict for the first time as Pope. He looked identical to Palaptine from a certain angle.
 
Late 1950’s in the South:
I’ve read it was commonly taught in bible study that if Kennedy became President, the Knights of Columbus would rise up and kill protestants in the US. After all, the KoC are the Pope’s militia and they had sworn an oath pledging their lives to the Church.
There was a short article or letter to the editor about the history of the KKK in my small, rural, Midwest hometown. Basically it was the KKK standing on one side of the street and the Catholics (represented by the KoC, I think) on the other side. It blew my mind to read that. I can’t remember how things were sorted out but there isn’t a KKK there anymore.
 
Don’t the Mormons get hold of peoples family history & try to rebaptize people? And this guy has the nerve to put you on the spot about lighting a candle??? Unbelievable:rolleyes:
He put himself on the spot. Everyone was looking at him like he had lost it. His wife unfriended me on Facebook after I became Catholic. For whatever reason, my conversion is threatening to them.
 
I read both of these comments and thought these are paranoid Catholics. I’ve heard time and again about discrimination against Catholics by others but didn’t think it was a big deal.
Late 1950’s in the South:
I’ve read it was commonly taught in bible study that if Kennedy became President, the Knights of Columbus would rise up and kill protestants in the US. After all, the KoC are the Pope’s militia and they had sworn an oath pledging their lives to the Church.
I knew there were protestant ministers that went off the ledge about Catholics but I just thought that was their ignorant misunderstandings. Obviously, those ignorant ministers could convince a lot of people but didn’t think they were of any consequence.

As far as the south is concerned, I grew up in the south and really never heard of such. It’s a credit to my parents that they were the generation that broke with the old and didn’t pass what they had learned onto their children. I knew my parents doctrinally thought their were major differences between Catholics and what they believed and I’m pretty sure that for a time, my father thought Catholics were hell bound. He developed a close friendship with a good Catholic man in the late 1970s and they were friends until my father died. Through this friend, he knew that Catholics could understand the Gospel even if their rituals were different. Before anyone misunderstands that statement “he knew that Catholics could understand the gospel”, let me explain. It was my father’s view and mine, that there were many in this world that professed or had professed faith in Christ, in different faith communities that really weren’t living the life and possibly never believed what they professed.
There was a short article or letter to the editor about the history of the KKK in my small, rural, Midwest hometown. Basically it was the KKK standing on one side of the street and the Catholics (represented by the KoC, I think) on the other side. It blew my mind to read that. I can’t remember how things were sorted out but there isn’t a KKK there anymore.
Anyway, I thought a lot of this rambling was Catholic paranoia. In an effort to prove the quoted posters wrong, I googled a bit and found en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Catholicism_in_the_United_States

I’m nothing short of shocked and amazed that this was something that I had no idea regarding. I had a little bit of knowledge of some of it but had no idea of the institutional and government supported Anti Catholic feelings in our past.
.
As one that didn’t grow up Catholic, I’m more than ashamed that some of these people and I shared a religion. As someone that has been a Catholic for a bit more than 4 months and 1 week, I’m offended that my brothers, my sisters, my Church, my bishop, my Pope, my God and My Savior were treated this way. Everyone thinks that the world in which they are living is as bad as it gets. This is another reminder, that their has always been evil and always will be.

Again, I’m grateful to have had the parents I did that didn’t pass onto me what they probably learned in their childhood.
 
I’m nothing short of shocked and amazed that this was something that I had no idea regarding. I had a little bit of knowledge of some of it but had no idea of the institutional and government supported Anti Catholic feelings in our past.
.
Growing up, the history taught in the public schools I attended was of the Pilgrims fleeing religious persecution to New England where they created a religious tolerant society. It wasn’t until I took a college level American history course that I heard of the bias and bigotry against Catholics and Catholicism.

I was also amazed that I had never heard anything until that point but “God bless the Pilgrims for our foundation of religious freedom”.
 
A co-worker of my father once said he would eat fish any day of the week except Friday because he didn’t want anyone to mistake him for a Catholic. He always insisted on eating red meat every Friday to spite the Catholics in the small city where I grew up.

I always thought that was kind of nutty.
 
A co-worker of my father once said he would eat fish any day of the week except Friday because he didn’t want anyone to mistake him for a Catholic. He always insisted on eating red meat every Friday to spite the Catholics in the small city where I grew up.

I always thought that was kind of nutty.
Yeah, just a bit…
 
One day after our lunchtime assembly at school when we had said the rosary a student (about 12 yrs old, non-catholic) asked me where did the “vanished chilren of Eve” go? Did my best not to laugh while I explained it to her; she was really concerned!
 
When I told a longtime friend heard I was converting to Catholicism, he told me, in front of our young son, that we were going to H—. I said, “Why do you say that?”. He stated firmly that we worship Mary and statues. Our son, at five years old, piped up, “No, we don’t don’t!”. I gently explained a few things about Catholicism to him.

A few months later, I was working on a project with the same friend and about seven other people, all Baptists like him, and we got into another discussion. He said that Catholics don’t know scripture and that we are just plain wrong when it comes to communion. I asked if anyone had a bible handy. One nice lady did so I asked her to look up John 6 and start at around verse 40 and read to the end. No one had any answer as to why disciples left Jesus and why it was such a hard teaching if Jesus wasn’t talking about His actual Body and Blood. Hehehe!
 
When I told a longtime friend heard I was converting to Catholicism, he told me, in front of our young son, that we were going to H—. I said, “Why do you say that?”. He stated firmly that we worship Mary and statues. Our son, at five years old, piped up, “No, we don’t don’t!”. I gently explained a few things about Catholicism to him.

A few months later, I was working on a project with the same friend and about seven other people, all Baptists like him, and we got into another discussion. He said that Catholics don’t know scripture and that we are just plain wrong when it comes to communion. I asked if anyone had a bible handy. One nice lady did so I asked her to look up John 6 and start at around verse 40 and read to the end. No one had any answer as to why disciples left Jesus and why it was such a hard teaching if Jesus wasn’t talking about His actual Body and Blood. Hehehe!
Right on! 😃
 
One of the weirdest things that happened to me was when I worked as a maintenance man for a Baptist Summer Camp (it was near my house and it was a nice summer job for being 16 years old), there was a Sunday where they had a service at their chapel (typically Sunday was our free day until campers came at 5 or so) and I decided to clean the bathrooms at our visitor center. I took about an hour to clean every toiler and then I got a call on my radio asking where I was as I was driving to our meeting. Unfortunately it started 15 minute earlier. So when I got to our meeting my boss took me aside and said " Now I know you catholic’s have long services but a protestant service lasts 45 minutes typically okay" and I kind of chuckled because typically most masses take about that time. Granted his only experience with Catholicism was having his one daughter marry a member of an SSPX chapel, so was not only surprised we didn’t use latin anymore in most churches and that our services took as long as theirs.
 
the other day at a party, someone said that the catholic church only accepted black people as human beings in 1986! upon correction, they learned I was catholic. then the flood gate opened;

the catholic church is the 2nd richest ngo in the world. I don’t know who number 1 is.
the catholic church has stolen cultural art pieces in a secret vault in the Vatican
the catholic church molests people.
the catholic church has the worst history.

and so on and so forth…
 
I moved to the U.S.A. in the 1960 s as a teenager.
Got a nice job in a big insurance company. It was all very new and exciting , learning
the ropes and operating an accountig machine. Everyone was very friendly and
welcoming . The floor I was on was a large open - plan office.
One day a young lady, who I didn’t know marched up to me and announced
" Your Church is completely wrong about contraceptives ! " When she saw the
blank look on my face she marched off without bothering t explain herself. 🙂
 
I left the Mormon church prior to becoming Catholic. Word eventually got around the office that I was no longer Mormon and drinking coffee and wine (I was asking for advice). One of my colleagues, a faithful Baptist, came up to me and said, “Good for you for leaving Mormonism.” He then asked what church I was going to now. I told him the Catholic Church. His reply was, “Well, at least that is respectable.”
 
I was speaking with a JW about my recent conversion to Catholicism, and I had no idea at the time about the sheer magnitude of anti-catholicism ingrained in the JW; so after a lot of back and fourth, I happened to mention apostolic succession, where upon she immediately called it false and said that there’s no way to prove it as we can’t go back and, I quote, “DNA every pope in history” to determine if there is such a thing. Apparently she had some crazed notion that all the popes are related like some monarchy lol. :confused:

I was floored lol. Literally speechless.

It just brought to light the whole conversation since if she could get something as basic as apostolic succession so terribly wrong, it seems unlikely she could grasp the more subtler nuances of Catholicism.
 
I was speaking with a JW about my recent conversion to Catholicism, and I had no idea at the time about the sheer magnitude of anti-catholicism ingrained in the JW; so after a lot of back and fourth, I happened to mention apostolic succession, where upon she immediately called it false and said that there’s no way to prove it as we can’t go back and, I quote, “DNA every pope in history” to determine if there is such a thing. Apparently she had some crazed notion that all the popes are related like some monarchy lol. :confused:

I was floored lol. Literally speechless.

It just brought to light the whole conversation since if she could get something as basic as apostolic succession so terribly wrong, it seems unlikely she could grasp the more subtler nuances of Catholicism.
Welcome to the Church Jim:thumbsup:
 
I was speaking with a JW about my recent conversion to Catholicism, and I had no idea at the time about the sheer magnitude of anti-catholicism ingrained in the JW; so after a lot of back and fourth, I happened to mention apostolic succession, where upon she immediately called it false and said that there’s no way to prove it as we can’t go back and, I quote, “DNA every pope in history” to determine if there is such a thing. Apparently she had some crazed notion that all the popes are related like some monarchy lol. :confused:

I was floored lol. Literally speechless.

It just brought to light the whole conversation since if she could get something as basic as apostolic succession so terribly wrong, it seems unlikely she could grasp the more subtler nuances of Catholicism.
Welcome Home Jim1905! 😃 👍
 
I saw this in another post and I just found humor in it. The poster is referring to his non-catholic co worker:

“Once or twice over the past couple of months she has invited me to go to the prayer meeting and she mentioned that she’s doing communion now. Yesterday she was quite insistent that I should go because I’m Catholic and they’re having communion.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top