Obama proposes free community college program

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I can chime in on this one.

My brother has worked as a welder for a metals company for 30 years. He earned a certificate from a trade school, and is very good at his job. In fact, he’s the supervisor on the 2nd shift.

His company won’t hire someone without either a certificate or a Assoc. Degree.

I’m guessing a lot of other companies are the same way.

In other words, you can’t just get hired and be taught by the people who actually do the work. That’s the way it used to be, but not anymore. You have to have that certificate.
Very very true, and excellent example.

Too add to it, one of the things we find about community colleges, as opposed to universities, is that they often feature programs such as this, in addition to other courses of study.
 
What do you suggest for people who are not allowed to serve their country?/QUOTE]

On that, it’s interesting to note that the conditions that existed for the GI Bill make that comparison unworkable now. From 1940 through some point in the 1990s we had a massive military that simply doesn’t exist now. Even though we’re still fighting wars, our military is at its smallest point since 1940, and its hard to get into the service. There’s no comparison that works between today’s military and the conscript one that existed from 1940 to 1973, or the remaining Cold War military whose infrastructure existed into the 1990s. So the “joint the service” argument is unworkable now.

Some will say “do national service”, but the irony there is that when you require servitude of that type, the proposal is not to pay somebody else to do the same work, unless its just work that isn’t going to get done otherwise.
 
It is an interesting point, particularly in that this is estimated to perhaps cost $60B over a decade, but certainly not $200B per year.

Costs are always difficult to control, for sure, but there’s plenty of room to cut costs in all sort of things. Funding education, if well directed, has a proven track record of boosting the economy and incomes, and therefore pays for itself.

Now, of course, a person can find fault with that argument, which perhaps means it needs to be qualified, but doesn’t mean its wholly untrue.
The thing I find amusing about our posters who scream so much about what we can and cannot afford is how quiet they become when you bring up medicare. Somehow, spending $60 billion over ten years is fiscally irresponsible, yet it is just fine to spend $200 billion a year. I think this explains why we will never become fiscally responsible as a country. We flunk the basic math.

To be fair, I am not really that enamored with this proposal because it is too blanket of a proposal. On the other hand, I think it would be an improvement if we spent less on other parts of higher education and more on community colleges.
 
Apologies in advance to all the “good” teachers at community college. I’m sure you’re out there.

But not at the community college in my city. Four different people in our family have taken classes at the community college in our city, and all four of us have found the courses utterly useless and taught at a 6th grade level. Complete waste of time and money.

Three of us took the courses because we needed them to complete our Bachelor’s Degrees, and we couldn’t fit the courses in at our 4-year colleges, and they weren’t offered during the summers. So we used up a summer taking the courses at community college.

At least they were extremely easy “As”.

My husband took a dance course, and I don’t want to go into details because it might be traceable. Briefly, the instructor had no clue. My husband has taken dance from several other studios over the years, and he knows when someone has a clue and someone doesn’t. Waste of time and money.

The community college has a theater program that gets a lot of hype, but when someone in professional theater takes a look at it, they cringe. The professional stage manager in our family attended one show there, and afterwards expressed horror over the extremely expensive lighting system not even being used.

Anyway, I realize that basing opinions on just one college and four people’s bad experiences is unfair and unwise. But frankly, after our collective family experiences, I think it would be a complete throw-away of perfectly good tax money to fund community colleges. In fact, I would be in favor of closing down the community colleges when it comes to the “college” courses, and allowing only the technical training programs that result in earning a trade certificate or license to continue operating. Oh, and it would probably be OK to continue those “Adult Continuing Education” courses in needlework, woodcarving, etc.–but not dance.

Again, apologies to any “good” community college teachers. Tell your peers to get hopping.
 
How about we pay down our debt first?
Goes without saying but do you know how many surpluses we’d have to run before we even make a dent in $18 trillion? Or even in the interest on that $18 trillion?
 
The federal govt is taking in more tax revenue that at any point in history.

It’s not a tax problem, but a spending problem.
Borrowing problem. We depending more and more on the Fed.
 
Goes without saying but do you know how many surpluses we’d have to run before we even make a dent in $18 trillion? Or even in the interest on that $18 trillion?
A lot, but so what? Does that mean we shouldn’t worry about increasing the debt? “Hey, it’s already $18T, what’s a few billion more?”
 
A lot, but so what? Does that mean we shouldn’t worry about increasing the debt? “Hey, it’s already $18T, what’s a few billion more?”
I agree. Actually $4 trillion is borrowed but hasn’t been spent. And the taxpayers are on the hook for all of it. So what we should do first is to force the Fed to sell all of those bonds. It would possibly drive up 5-yr and 10-yr interest rates but some retirees would probably welcome that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top