Obedience to a Priest

  • Thread starter Thread starter Agape_et_Shalom
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I have a deep love for Jesus Christ and want to evangelize His message at every opportunity but our priest doesn’t agree. My son is the youth director at our parish. He’s very well read and his apologetics are excellent. The priest originally approached him to lead because of his understanding of the church. The priest is not involved in any of the ministries and refuses to be involved. Many times they have conflicted over evangelizing issues because the priest seems to view the parish as his personal domain and wants only those students from our own parish to participate. Some of the area parishes don’t have or can’t afford youth groups we happen to be in one of the very wealthy areas of the county. The youth group has grown from a couple of kids to about 40.

Point. The priest decided yesterday that we had to throw out a kid not from our parish, my son refused to. The Catholic Church the child attends does not have a youth group. This issue has come up in the past but this time it is coming to a head. We’ve offered to do fund raisers but he has denied us permission. My son is 31 and volunteers as well as the rest of our family whenever needed. Obviously we need some prayers. Any other (name removed by moderator)ut is welcome. We seem to have crossed the line of obedience.
I’m sorry. Did you state the reason for the kid being thrown
out was because he was from another parish? Is he the
only child in the youth group not from your parish!
Did you directly ask the priest why the kid was thrown out?
 
The kid has not yet been thrown out, the priest is telling my son to do that. He will not. My son is not an employee he’s a volunteer. This has nothing to do with employee/employer even if it did you still have a moral issue. What part of an “awkward child” having a place of acceptance and getting it ripped out from under her is moral or justifiable? I don’t care if she’s atheist…

BTW this is not just a “party” group. These kids are amazing. They do community service, enjoy apologetics and attend conferences.

If you are going to comment please read the posts. I would like to hear from a clergy. Teachccd thanks for reading and understanding.

All Christianity is Catholic we’ve failed at catechizing them and now we turn and walk away? I’m sure glad Peter understood agape and listened to Paul or us gentiles would still be left out.
 
The kid has not yet been thrown out, the priest is telling my son to do that. He will not. My son is not an employee he’s a volunteer. This has nothing to do with employee/employer even if it did you still have a moral issue. What part of an “awkward child” having a place of acceptance and getting it ripped out from under her is moral or justifiable? I don’t care if she’s atheist…

BTW this is not just a “party” group. These kids are amazing. They do community service, enjoy apologetics and attend conferences.

If you are going to comment please read the posts. I would like to hear from a clergy. Teachccd and Blessedwith5 thanks for reading and understanding.

All Christianity is Catholic we’ve failed at catechizing them and now we turn and walk away? I’m sure glad Peter understood agape and listened to Paul or us gentiles would still be left out.
Wait a minute. Are you saying the child in question is a
girl who is atheist? is this a non denominational
group or Catholic? Does it discuss Catholicism
or have it as a basis of mission?
Do you have a permission slip from her parents?
 
You really don’t want me to comment on the bureaucracies it really gets outrageous. I assure you it’s not about the paperwork. Besides the fingerprinting, background checks, lost paperwork etc…

As Jesus said to the blind man, ‘did you get a permission slip before I save your soul? and by the way are you a Jew?’
 
You really don’t want me to comment on the bureaucracies it really gets outrageous. I assure you it’s not about the paperwork. Besides the fingerprinting, background checks, lost paperwork etc…

As Jesus said to the blind man, ‘did you get a permission slip before I save your soul? and by the way are you a Jew?’
Uh I think you might be unfair to the priest.
We cannot catechize minor non Catholics
without parental agreement any more than we can
baptize their infants.
We DO require permission slips
and yes Jesus required a permission slip as well.
He never cured or saved anyone without their YES.
 
Ok and how does this resound to a teenager who is looking for acceptance? I get all the “stuff” but I am referring to where the rubber meets the road. While all are floundering to find out who is funding what and who is “stealing” who’s kids we have our youth going to Protestant churches where they seem to accept everyone with open arms. I get all the particulars and “parish boundaries” scenario but I don’t get how a young person processes this.

And I will say that one should speak to the priest first. In my previous post I mentioned going to the bishop but it is truly better to make sure you understand where the priest is coming from before alerting the bishop.
I understand that the damage has already been done.
This child who has no where to go has ALDREADY found a home at this church.
At this point, one has an obligation to contact his or her parents and explain to them that the kid is attending the Catholic Youth group and see if they are OK with it. This is their parental right.
Kids are not “strays”. When we get our youth groups (yes, more than one) going, there is a registration process. Their parents agree that they desire instruction for their children. Once in a while, a teen will show up with a “guest”. Which is perfectly fine. But we also explain to the “guest” that we are a Catholic Church, and here’s some info, and if your parents are OK with you attending…here’s what the next step is. Welcome.
Beyond that, well meaning people (and I’m sure they are) are asking for a huge amount of trouble. Like it or not, when they are at the Church, on Church property…they are the responsibility of the Pastor.
This is the reason why Youth Ministry is so tricky. Emotions get ahold of people.
This is the reason why the church gets sued. An overwhelming desire to “reach out” overcomes people.
I’m all for loving the children. All the kids in our programs know I’d walk through fire for any of them. But at the end of the day, there is some professional distance that must be maintained. We’re dealing with another’s person’s child. Neglected or not, the parents get to decide. All students should be properly enrolled. Rules for behavior and expectations spelled out.
Wouldn’t we all like to live without these constraints? YES.
But again, teens are not strays. The safety of the other kids has to be taken into account.
We had a teen that burned rubber every time he left the parking lot.
He can’t do that anymore. He’s more than welcome…but mom or dad brings him now.
All the parents are grateful, including his. He’s still a good kid, and we still teach and minister to him. But we got his parents involved for the protection of everyone,
 
First things first, thank you all for your replies and helping see things from different perspectives.

Next, it would be unjust if it wasn’t prefaced that I am the youth director being discussed. Dad undoubtedly started the thread because he wants to ensure as many people don’t leave the Church as he possibly can… He knows the damage leaving the faith can cause, he saw it in all 3 of his children (which is a book in itself).

With that being said and things possibly being taken from a third party incorrectly I would like to clarify a couple things that are pertinent to the conversation:
I volunteer
know the budget
and would not dream of attacking a priest on his shortcomings as a human being

The Rundown:
As an atheist (and an overall egotistical and nasty person) I began to read. That reading led from atheism, to agnosticism, to deism, to pantheism, to dualism, to monotheism and then based on historical fact; quickly from there to Christianity. That is when the quest for who is closest to Christ’s teachings came about, and it became obvious that Catholicism was the answer because of the Early Church. Then naturally (in our day and age) came the question of “is the Church still teaching those things” or was it human hands that had run askew with the Perfect Vessel making Calvin and Luther right. The answer was a resounding “no Calvin and Luther aren’t right” when I had met a certain priest (the priest we’re talking about) gave me an answer that would lead me down the path of the heavenly banquet. I have a very strong affinity to this man from more than just this instance.

The Plan:
Early in our friendship the youth director had a huge falling out with the priest and he had asked me to step in because of the knowledge of the Church, I reluctantly said yes. We went from 40 youth to about 4. Over the past few years we’ve grown it back to about 40 and reduced the budget by nearly $55,000 - $65,000! When he asked what I wanted to do it, the response was, “to help these kids find Christ before they find the pain without Him.” The goal was to keep money free’d up so we could help ANY youth find Christ. Our priest has never had any problem with what I’ve taught them… (Derail: We just had a reconciliation service that had over 30 kids from the ages of 12-17 actively go to adoration and confession:thumbsup:, sorry had to do it, just too proud of them!)

The Problem:
I have always invited any and all children to our youth group. Never was a problem before because the kids got excited to take their so-called “atheist” friends to a place where people were open and welcoming to the challenge (we have some very bright young people). Recently I have been asked several times if a certain individual was coming to Mass anymore at our parish the response was always the same “Don’t know father, with 2 kids under 2 we have a motto of ‘any given sunday’” (meaning we could be there at any one of the three masses on Sunday depending on the kids). Recently, father must have checked the donation cards (its how we check attendance) and found that this individuals family has not been attending. That is when I was told they are not to go to Youth Group anymore.

One further thing on some opinion’s in this thread so far. I own a business and have been blessed with the ability to volunteer Wednesday’s and so understand budget’s along with employer/employee relationships from a different perspective, and if I asked one of my employee’s to do something they thought unethical I would be disappointed if they followed my direction instead of correcting me. Should not one be willing to give up their livelihood to do what is right? Sell their stuff to follow Him? Store up their treasure’s in heaven where moth nor rust destroy?

The Point:
I have to, like Acquinas said, follow my conscience above all things and Paul confirms “Work out your salvation through fear and trembling for it is God who worketh in you.”
 
First things first, thank you all for your replies and helping see things from different perspectives.

Next, it would be unjust if it wasn’t prefaced that I am the youth director being discussed. Dad undoubtedly started the thread because he wants to ensure as many people don’t leave the Church as he possibly can… He knows the damage leaving the faith can cause, he saw it in all 3 of his children (which is a book in itself).

With that being said and things possibly being taken from a third party incorrectly I would like to clarify a couple things that are pertinent to the conversation:
I volunteer
know the budget
and would not dream of attacking a priest on his shortcomings as a human being

The Rundown:
As an atheist (and an overall egotistical and nasty person) I began to read. That reading led from atheism, to agnosticism, to deism, to pantheism, to dualism, to monotheism and then based on historical fact; quickly from there to Christianity. That is when the quest for who is closest to Christ’s teachings came about, and it became obvious that Catholicism was the answer because of the Early Church. Then naturally (in our day and age) came the question of “is the Church still teaching those things” or was it human hands that had run askew with the Perfect Vessel making Calvin and Luther right. The answer was a resounding “no Calvin and Luther aren’t right” when I had met a certain priest (the priest we’re talking about) gave me an answer that would lead me down the path of the heavenly banquet. I have a very strong affinity to this man from more than just this instance.

The Plan:
Early in our friendship the youth director had a huge falling out with the priest and he had asked me to step in because of the knowledge of the Church, I reluctantly said yes. We went from 40 youth to about 4. Over the past few years we’ve grown it back to about 40 and reduced the budget by nearly $55,000 - $65,000! When he asked what I wanted to do it, the response was, “to help these kids find Christ before they find the pain without Him.” The goal was to keep money free’d up so we could help ANY youth find Christ. Our priest has never had any problem with what I’ve taught them… (Derail: We just had a reconciliation service that had over 30 kids from the ages of 12-17 actively go to adoration and confession:thumbsup:, sorry had to do it, just too proud of them!)

The Problem:
I have always invited any and all children to our youth group. Never was a problem before because the kids got excited to take their so-called “atheist” friends to a place where people were open and welcoming to the challenge (we have some very bright young people). Recently I have been asked several times if a certain individual was coming to Mass anymore at our parish the response was always the same “Don’t know father, with 2 kids under 2 we have a motto of ‘any given sunday’” (meaning we could be there at any one of the three masses on Sunday depending on the kids). Recently, father must have checked the donation cards (its how we check attendance) and found that this individuals family has not been attending. That is when I was told they are not to go to Youth Group anymore.

One further thing on some opinion’s in this thread so far. I own a business and have been blessed with the ability to volunteer Wednesday’s and so understand budget’s along with employer/employee relationships from a different perspective, and if I asked one of my employee’s to do something they thought unethical I would be disappointed if they followed my direction instead of correcting me. Should not one be willing to give up their livelihood to do what is right? Sell their stuff to follow Him? Store up their treasure’s in heaven where moth nor rust destroy?

The Point:
I have to, like Acquinas said, follow my conscience above all things and Paul confirms “Work out your salvation through fear and trembling for it is God who worketIh in you.”
Ok I’m officially confused. Is the child in question
part of a catholic family that stopped attending
or is she a friend of such and an atheist???
In any case it is quite possible the priest
knows more about them than you do.
And have you asked him why the kid was thrown out?
 
Wait a minute. Are you saying the child in question is a
girl who is atheist? No
is this a non denominational
group or Catholic?Catholic
Does it discuss Catholicism
or have it as a basis of mission?Catechize the youth up to the point they are getting rid of CCD for 6-8th grades to put them in youth group

Do you have a permission slip from her parents?Yes
The answers are in bold
 
Ok I’m officially confused. Is the child in question
part of a catholic family that stopped attending
or is she a friend of such and an atheist???
In any case it is quite possible the priest
knows more about them than you do.
And have you asked him why the kid was thrown out?
But why would an atheist child not be welcome to learn about Christ? Because they were brought up in a family of unbelievers means they too should remain ignorant? After all it was Him who said “Go and spread the word to all the nations,” seems to me that’s not left up to interpretation as we see in the Council of Jerusalem with Paul and the Gentile’s.

I ask because I’m curious to your position, it’s interesting to get all viewpoints.

No, I would suspect the priest does not know more about the family than myself.

I tried to answer your questions in my previous post, I apologize if it was not comprehensive enough, I tried to get a couple years worth of information into a small amount of space. I would welcome any suggestions you may have as writing comes as a great pleasure to me and as Mark Twain says “I apologize for not writing a shorter letter but I didn’t have time” or something to that effect.
 
First things first, thank you all for your replies and helping see things from different perspectives.

Next, it would be unjust if it wasn’t prefaced that I am the youth director being discussed. Dad undoubtedly started the thread because he wants to ensure as many people don’t leave the Church as he possibly can… He knows the damage leaving the faith can cause, he saw it in all 3 of his children (which is a book in itself).

With that being said and things possibly being taken from a third party incorrectly I would like to clarify a couple things that are pertinent to the conversation:
I volunteer
know the budget
and would not dream of attacking a priest on his shortcomings as a human being

The Rundown:
As an atheist (and an overall egotistical and nasty person) I began to read. That reading led from atheism, to agnosticism, to deism, to pantheism, to dualism, to monotheism and then based on historical fact; quickly from there to Christianity. That is when the quest for who is closest to Christ’s teachings came about, and it became obvious that Catholicism was the answer because of the Early Church. Then naturally (in our day and age) came the question of “is the Church still teaching those things” or was it human hands that had run askew with the Perfect Vessel making Calvin and Luther right. The answer was a resounding “no Calvin and Luther aren’t right” when I had met a certain priest (the priest we’re talking about) gave me an answer that would lead me down the path of the heavenly banquet. I have a very strong affinity to this man from more than just this instance.

The Plan:
Early in our friendship the youth director had a huge falling out with the priest and he had asked me to step in because of the knowledge of the Church, I reluctantly said yes. We went from 40 youth to about 4. Over the past few years we’ve grown it back to about 40 and reduced the budget by nearly $55,000 - $65,000! When he asked what I wanted to do it, the response was, “to help these kids find Christ before they find the pain without Him.” The goal was to keep money free’d up so we could help ANY youth find Christ. Our priest has never had any problem with what I’ve taught them… (Derail: We just had a reconciliation service that had over 30 kids from the ages of 12-17 actively go to adoration and confession:thumbsup:, sorry had to do it, just too proud of them!)

The Problem:
I have always invited any and all children to our youth group. Never was a problem before because the kids got excited to take their so-called “atheist” friends to a place where people were open and welcoming to the challenge (we have some very bright young people). Recently I have been asked several times if a certain individual was coming to Mass anymore at our parish the response was always the same “Don’t know father, with 2 kids under 2 we have a motto of ‘any given sunday’” (meaning we could be there at any one of the three masses on Sunday depending on the kids). Recently, father must have checked the donation cards (its how we check attendance) and found that this individuals family has not been attending. That is when I was told they are not to go to Youth Group anymore.

One further thing on some opinion’s in this thread so far. I own a business and have been blessed with the ability to volunteer Wednesday’s and so understand budget’s along with employer/employee relationships from a different perspective, and if I asked one of my employee’s to do something they thought unethical I would be disappointed if they followed my direction instead of correcting me. Should not one be willing to give up their livelihood to do what is right? Sell their stuff to follow Him? Store up their treasure’s in heaven where moth nor rust destroy?

The Point:
I have to, like Acquinas said, follow my conscience above all things and Paul confirms “Work out your salvation through fear and trembling for it is God who worketh in you.”
Sounds like you’re on a personal mission, given your story.
You still have to defer to the priest.
I’m sure you do good work.
Our priests are very often misunderstood and criticized.
St. John Vianney said “never criticize a priest.”
We have no idea what the back-story is.
Peace.
Peace.
 
Sounds like you’re on a personal mission, given your story.
You still have to defer to the priest.
I’m sure you do good work.
Our priests are very often misunderstood and criticized.
St. John Vianney said “never criticize a priest.”
We have no idea what the back-story is.
Peace.
Peace.
Could you please expand on this thought?
 
Could you please expand on this thought?
You have a profound story. You see every struggling teen as yourself before you returned to the faith. I get it.
But as I’ve already said, teens are not strays. It’s wonderful that you feel such compassion, it is. I know you pray for these poor children, surely you have a great desire to help them.
But you have to defer to your priest. It’s his call.
I’m not condemning you…I’m just trying to get you to see beyond your frustration and apparent anger at the priest.
He has his reason, and you don’t agree.
Got it.
 
I don’t want this to come across as abrasive, I really don’t. Are you implying that I have to listen to my priest before my conscience?

And yes I am frustrated and anger isn’t the right word, I would use hurt. I love the guy no differently today as I would have 6 months ago.
 
And for the record, this forum should get a “thanks” button.

Since it doesn’t, Thanks pianist Clare, always good to hear from different positions.
 
I don’t want this to come across as abrasive, I really don’t. Are you implying that I have to listen to my priest before my conscience?

And yes I am frustrated and anger isn’t the right word, I would use hurt. I love the guy no differently today as I would have 6 months ago.
It’s not an either or situation.
Your conscience drives YOU.
He drives the parish.
God bless you…I hope you find much joy and success in your ministry.
But you will do well to try to humbly defer to the priest. Here, or in any parish.
 
But why would an atheist child not be welcome to learn about Christ? Because they were brought up in a family of unbelievers means they too should remain ignorant? After all it was Him who said “Go and spread the word to all the nations,” seems to me that’s not left up to interpretation as we see in the Council of Jerusalem with Paul and the Gentile’s.

I ask because I’m curious to your position, it’s interesting to get all viewpoints.

No, I would suspect the priest does not know more about the family than myself.

I tried to answer your questions in my previous post, I apologize if it was not comprehensive enough, I tried to get a couple years worth of information into a small amount of space. I would welcome any suggestions you may have as writing comes as a great pleasure to me and as Mark Twain says “I apologize for not writing a shorter letter but I didn’t have time” or something to that effect.
Of course not. If she wants to be there and her parents
agree then yes she should be there.
But I don’t understand your donation envelope thing.
Why are they receiving donation envelopes and
attending Mass is they are as you say “unbelievers”?
That is very odd.

In any case why don’t we evangelize every kid?
First we never evangelize without the permission
of both kid AND parents.
If you have both fine and no I don’t understand
why the child was thrown out.
 
I understand that the damage has already been done.
This child who has no where to go has ALDREADY found a home at this church.
At this point, one has an obligation to contact his or her parents and explain to them that the kid is attending the Catholic Youth group and see if they are OK with it. This is their parental right.
Kids are not “strays”. When we get our youth groups (yes, more than one) going, there is a registration process. Their parents agree that they desire instruction for their children. Once in a while, a teen will show up with a “guest”. Which is perfectly fine. But we also explain to the “guest” that we are a Catholic Church, and here’s some info, and if your parents are OK with you attending…here’s what the next step is. Welcome.
Beyond that, well meaning people (and I’m sure they are) are asking for a huge amount of trouble. Like it or not, when they are at the Church, on Church property…they are the responsibility of the Pastor.
This is the reason why Youth Ministry is so tricky. Emotions get ahold of people.
This is the reason why the church gets sued. An overwhelming desire to “reach out” overcomes people.
I’m all for loving the children. All the kids in our programs know I’d walk through fire for any of them. But at the end of the day, there is some professional distance that must be maintained. We’re dealing with another’s person’s child. Neglected or not, the parents get to decide. All students should be properly enrolled. Rules for behavior and expectations spelled out.
Wouldn’t we all like to live without these constraints? YES.
But again, teens are not strays. The safety of the other kids has to be taken into account.
We had a teen that burned rubber every time he left the parking lot.
He can’t do that anymore. He’s more than welcome…but mom or dad brings him now.
All the parents are grateful, including his. He’s still a good kid, and we still teach and minister to him. But we got his parents involved for the protection of everyone,
Just read this, we do the same. It sucks for sure, but I understand the lawsuit side of things (especially being in construction), this isn’t a law issue at all.
 
Of course not. If she wants to be there and her parents
agree then yes she should be there.
But I don’t understand your donation envelope thing.
Why are they receiving donation envelopes and
attending Mass is they are as you say “unbelievers”?
That is very odd.

In any case why don’t we evangelize every kid?
First we never evangelize without the permission
of both kid AND parents.
If you have both fine and no I don’t understand
why the child was thrown out.
I think you might be missing some major points in the conversation thus far. I tried to answer you in bold and then answered again after. I’m new so don’t want to ruffle any feathers but perhaps if you read page two again things will clarify themselves… If not I would be happy to answer, just not sure where you’re coming from right now.
 
I don’t want this to come across as abrasive, I really don’t. Are you implying that I have to listen to my priest before my conscience?

And yes I am frustrated and anger isn’t the right word, I would use hurt. I love the guy no differently today as I would have 6 months ago.
Yes actually you do. Has anything he has done or said
directly contradicted the Catechism?
If you want to go with your conscience and defy
your Pastor unless you can determine what he has
done actually wrong other than not following your
interpretation of Scripture, frankly you don’t
have a case.
Humility comes before all other virtues. If you
can’t humble your conscience to follow a Pastor
you otherwise respect, how could you ever hope
to evangelize well? Your pride would be an obstacle.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top