Obligation in taking elderly parent to mass?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ineeda
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I

ineeda

Guest
My mother is 92 and has dementia. She has quite limited mobility. During the winter months and winter, I definitely would not even consider taking her to mass. Recently, I have taken her to mass a few times, since the weather has been nice. She used to pray daily, and attended mass weekly. However, since her cancer treatment, five years ago(cured now), she quit going. She had a deacon that brought communion to her every week. I was always willing to take her, but she did not care to go. Mass was too early for her. Recently, I started going on Saturdays, as I now request not to work on Sat. afternoons. Originally, my request was to make sure I got my ten year-old grandson to mass. (however, I have been unable to get him to go with me - another story) But, since the weather has been nice, my mother was willing to go with me on Saturday evening.

It dawned on me that I should have been encouraging my mother to go more with me. Even if she says that she does not want to go, I should convince her to go with me. It is her dementia that does not want to go. Today, I told her that we need to wash her hair, and she said that she did not want to wash it. I told her that we could do it, later, and go to church in the morning. But, I don’t know if she will be up early enough. It will be difficult to get her to go in the morning.

It occurred to me, today, am I sinning by not making sure that I get her there? I returned to church about five years ago, after being gone for many years. I have been going weekly, and sometimes during the week when I can. It is difficult to take her, and exhausting for me. But, I take her out to other places, such as the park, or out to the store. It is not easy, but I hate to see her sit in the chair all day, just watching tv.

She is quite apathetic. And, I know that she does not even really understand the mass, anymore. She does watch it on EWTN daily. However, strangely, she does not pray anymore. Sometimes, I will hear her praying a bit out loud with the tv. I put her rosary out next to her, but she does not say it along with tv. I even sat down with her, saying it out loud with Mother Angelica on tv. She has fallen asleep. It is so sad to see her like this, as she used to be a prayer warrior. Perhaps, it was her rosary that brought me back to church.

Our deacon has retired, and she does not get weekly communion, anymore. We just started with Eucharistic ministers at our church. I don’t think they have a group organized yet, to go to homebound. But, if I manage to take her anywhere else, then I should be getting her to church. I am the only one in my family that goes to church, so I don’t get much support from others. It would be so much easier, if I had someone to help me with her. I drop her off, and get out walk with her to door.(causing other cars behind me to wait until she gets in. And, she has a slow shuffle) Then, I go park the car. Sometimes, people get irate. Our parking lot is not handicapped friendly.

Sorry, I got so winded, here.
 
Call and make an appointment with your pastor to discuss your mother’s mental health condition; if she no longer understands the Mass, she may be no longer obligated to attend. Your pastor can advise you and might want to think about volunteering to bring communion to your mom yourself.
 
Hi ineeda,

I also recommend talking to your pastor.

I would see if she could receive home visits for communion, but that would be something to discuss with him. 🙂
 
Yes, this is something to discuss with your/her pastor. Ask him about the Sacraments of Confession and Anointing of the Sick as well. At 92 with dementia, she is almost certainly not obligated to attend weekly, and you are thus not obligated to take her. Having said that, it would be very good to take her occasionally, as long as she is able and understands the Mass. Your parish should certainly have someone to take Communion to the homebound. It is good that she watches the Mass on EWTN. The apathy is from the dementia. I have been there. It is sad to watch your relatives decline and pass. Comfort yourself that you are doing The Lord’s work in caring for her.
 
You might want to also include a discussion of confession when you talk with the priest.

If she ever expresses regret over any sins, try and get her to pray an Act of Contrition with you. I know dementia patients go in and out of lucidity, so you might want to be prepared for that.

I am sorry you are going throught this. It is very hard on members of the family.
 
My mom was 89 when she died. She did not have dementia but had a medical condition that I believe was affecting blood flow to the brain and on many days she would be falling asleep a lot and generally not sharp and a bit confused. On other days she was better and more like the smart woman she had been. She also had difficulty walking more than a very short distance and I had to take her many places in a wheelchair.

When she felt up to going I took her to Mass but there were many weeks that she did not feel well enough to go and/or the weather was bad and created a big hazard for her (she lived in an area that gets significant snow and ice in winter). There were also some weeks I was not available to be with her as I had to keep my full time job, partly to help pay for her care as well as cover my own household bills, and her caregivers did not work Saturday or Sunday.

We just did the best we could and got her to Mass as much as we felt we could. For a while she was getting communion at home too, but that stopped because the communion minister was a busy body who took it upon herself to neb into other aspects of Mom’s personal business (such as my relationship with her and how Mom kept house) and make her upset so neither one of us wanted this person coming to the house any more.

I really think when you are caring for a parent who is advanced in age and is having physical and mental difficulties, you need to just do the best you can and not worry about it. It is emotionally and physically exhausting for you as the caregiver also, I know this only too well. If your mom was asking to go to Mass and you were refusing to take her, that would be a different story, but that’s not what’s happening. I am sure if you speak to your priest he will be very understanding. Try not to second guess yourself either. Everything you have said sounds very logical, and very difficult emotionally which is why I suspect the second guessing is happening.
 
Definitely talk with your pastor.

[He may suggest something like you getting a Consecrated Host and using a pyx to bring Holy Communion yourself to the elderly parent.]

[You can also bring a small plastic bottle and bringing home some holy water.]
 
My aunt and uncle were able to take my maternal grandma to Mass on a weekly basis up to the last 2 years or so of her life when she was confined to a wheelchair as her dementia affected her ability to walk, and they had no way to take her to church in their car. She did attend Mass or Catholic services weekly at her facility. I would talk to a priest about making periodic visits in this situation to see if she wants the sacraments. Even our bulletin mentions in it if you or someone you know needs Communion due to being homebound in some way, etc to ask.
 
No you are not sinning in any way when you are unable to take you 92 year old mother with dementia to mass.
 
Thank you for replies. We have had many changes in our parish. We have a new pastor that we share with another parish. And, that parish was merged with a few other one’s.

Extraordinary Eucharistic ministers are quite new to our parish. They are having a meeting to organize to administer to homebound.

As far as confession, I don’t think she can even recall enough to make a confession. I can remember that it was about five years ago, that she called priest to make appointment for confession. I took her for confession. She has never asked to go after that. Her dementia advanced since then.

I really appreciate all of your replies.
 
Keeping you in my prayers. I too am going through the same experience with my Dad who is 90 and lives with us. He is really declining now, has dementia, and sleeps a lot now. We stopped taking him to mass 3 weeks ago. Our parish priest gave him the anointing of the sick last week(but not the final one).

I just wanted to add a belated prayer for your family.
Hail Mary, full of grace
The Lord is with thee.
Blessed art thou amoungst women and blessed is the fruit of thy womb Jesus.
Holy Mary, mother of God, pray for us sinners,
now and at the hour of our death.
Amen
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top