Obligatory weekly Mass contrary to Christ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Holly3278
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

Holly3278

Guest
Hi everyone. I received a Youtube comment on a comment I posted once a while back. The comment is as follows:

19flm12 said:
@Holly3278 Yet Jesus Christ (remember him?) taught:
Code:
		"The Sabbath was made for man; not man for the Sabbath". 
		
		Therefore any construct that Mass attendance is 'mandatory' is  contrary to Christ. You go as you WANT to go; not as you are forced to.  If you cannot find a Catholic Church (or tolerate the local ones), then  you are better off to stay home & pray & read Scripture. 
		
		Non-Catholic services ARE the worship of God, though they are not masses.

How do I rely to his objection to the mandatory mass attendance? 🤷:confused:
 
Hi everyone. I received a Youtube comment on a comment I posted once a while back. The comment is as follows:

How do I rely to his objection to the mandatory mass attendance? 🤷:confused:
Well, the easiest and most obvious way would be to ask the person whether or not he/she recognizes that Christ gave His Church the authority to bind and loose. In other words, if the Church says that Sundays and H.D.O.s require Catholics to attend Mass, then Catholics are supposed to attend mass. If the person does not recognize/accept Church authority (and thereby denies Scripture) tell him/her to stop using it as a source to support his/her erroneous ideas.
 
Hi everyone. I received a Youtube comment on a comment I posted once a while back. The comment is as follows:

How do I rely to his objection to the mandatory mass attendance? 🤷:confused:
Point out that Jesus frequented both the Synagogue and the Temple in Jerusalem. He must certainly have been a regular Sabbath worshipper in the Nazareth synagogue since they allowed Him both to read and preach there, which they wouldn’t have done for someone who wasn’t.

Also point out that Mary and Joseph are recorded as having observed the Passover every year as the law bid - and doubtless taught Christ to do the same. Same with other Mosaic commands, such as Mary’s purification and Jesus’ presentation in the Temple. And other rites and ceremonies like His baptism. So Jesus was the opposite of unobservant or irregular in His habits of worship.

And He wasn’t doing away with Sabbath observance at all with His ‘Lord of the Sabbath’ command (by the way - since when are WE Lords of the Sabbath?) Instead, He was criticising those who took things a step or two beyond what the law required - such as, for example, those who reproached Him for healing on the Sabbath by construing it to be work, which was forbidden.
 
Hi everyone. I received a Youtube comment on a comment I posted once a while back. The comment is as follows:

How do I rely to his objection to the mandatory mass attendance? 🤷:confused:
Holly, you don’t rely on his objection at all. Holy Mother Church mandates that we are bound to go to Mass on all Sundays of the year and holy days of obligation.
 
Holly, you don’t rely on his objection at all. Holy Mother Church mandates that we are bound to go to Mass on all Sundays of the year and holy days of obligation.
Holly’s obviously made a typo and meant to say REPLY to, not ‘rely to’ (she didn’t say ‘rely on’)
 
Here is how I resolved this issue during my journey back into The Church. It deals with undestanding the “Why” of the obligation rather than just looking at it by itself.
  1. The greatest commandment is that We** Love God **with everything we have, body mind spirit and strength.(Mt 22:36)
  2. If we Love God properly then the very first thing we will want to do in our week is to Go to His house and to receive Him worthily in the Eucharist. (or in our day if daily mass is possible for us)
  3. If we Choose not to go to His house first thing (prefering to sleep, or do something else) then we are demonstrating that we do not Love God as commanded in Mt 22:36. We Love something else more than we Love God.
  4. By showing that we Love something else more than God we sin - for in the final analysis, sin is the result of not loving God above all things.
  5. Therefore the Church’s requirement that we attend mass on Sunday, the “first day of the week”, is merely an acknowledgement of the above. It is not a “stand alone rule”, but rather a concise statement that, if you Love God properly you’ll be at Church first thing on Sunday morning. If you don’t Love God properly then you won’t, and by not properly loving God, and Putting Him first, you are disobeying the primary command of Love and to do this is sinning.
Now - having said the above, there are, of course, exceptions. Age, health, emergencies etc. can all mitigate the obligation as we all know. When these things occur, certainly the holy person will seek to praise God in some alternative way - in fact I’d say one would be “driven” to do so out of Love for Him who gives Life and gives it abundantly.

Hope this helps.

Peace
James
 
We are obligated *by justice *to worship and praise God as He requests. Considering all He has done for us, and that we receive the Eucharist 🙂 it seems like a small thing.

In fact, I would say that your friend is infected with the same virus so many of us Americans have… the idea that freedom means freedom from outer constraint.
 
Thanks everyone! And yes, I meant “reply”, not “rely”. Sorry! :o
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top