Occasion of Sin and the Internet

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mr.Blank1.5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Mr.Blank1.5

Guest
I regularly go to a website for anime related news. On that site, there is a section shows work from amateur artists. I admit that there have been times where the pictures (on the site or at the artist’s website) have caused me to sin. Despite that, most of the featured artists usually have worksafe art, or I usually avoid explicit materials.

So would going to that section of the website be placing myself in an occasion of sin?
(I need to know if I can recieve communion or not tomorrow)
 
Oh goodness, I have the same exact question…almost…with different circumstances! Rather, does viewing provocative materials (unintentionally or intentionally) constitute a mortal or venial sin in itself?
 
If there is any doubt of mortal sin the go to confession before hand. There is always a Catholic church around that offers confession.

I am thankful that when I struggled I had a church that offered confession an half hour before every mass. Confession restores us in the Grace of God and we need His strength and gifts.

So, go to confession and be at Peace knowing there is no doubt in your mind or heart.
 
I regularly go to a website for anime related news. On that site, there is a section shows work from amateur artists. I admit that there have been times where the pictures (on the site or at the artist’s website) have caused me to sin. Despite that, most of the featured artists usually have worksafe art, or I usually avoid explicit materials.

So would going to that section of the website be placing myself in an occasion of sin?
(I need to know if I can recieve communion or not tomorrow)
Oh goodness, I have the same exact question…almost…with different circumstances! Rather, does viewing provocative materials (unintentionally or intentionally) constitute a mortal or venial sin in itself?
Basically it depends on the intention of viewing the pics and whether or not you react lustfully to them.
 
If going to a website causes you to sin (even if unregularly), than it is an occasion of sin.

Viewing provactive material intentionally, with full knowledge of what the material is, is a mortal sin. Viewing provactive material unintentionally, or without knowing what it is, or under threat, is a venial sin.
 
If going to a website causes you to sin (even if unregularly), than it is an occasion of sin.

Viewing provactive material intentionally, with full knowledge of what the material is, is a mortal sin. Viewing provactive material unintentionally, or without knowing what it is, or under threat, is a venial sin.
Quotes from the Catechism:
1857 For a sin to be mortal, three conditions must together be met: “Mortal sin is sin whose object is grave matter and which is also committed with full knowledge and deliberate consent.”
1858 Grave matter is specified by the Ten Commandments, corresponding to the answer of Jesus to the rich young man: “Do not kill, Do not commit adultery, Do not steal, Do not bear false witness, Do not defraud, Honor your father and your mother.” The gravity of sins is more or less great: murder is graver than theft. One must also take into account who is wronged: violence against parents is in itself graver than violence against a stranger.
2354 Pornography consists in removing real or simulated sexual acts from the intimacy of the partners, in order to display them deliberately to third parties. It offends against chastity because it perverts the conjugal act, the intimate giving of spouses to each other. It does grave injury to the dignity of its participants (actors, vendors, the public), since each one becomes an object of base pleasure and illicit profit for others. It immerses all who are involved in the illusion of a fantasy world. It is a grave offense. Civil authorities should prevent the production and distribution of pornographic materials.
There’s a fine difference between ecchi anime pics and what we enthusiasts call hentai (and I’ll have you know that even the latter is still not as severe as the abomination that is live-action pornography). And while we may consider the fact that intentionally viewing a picture of hand-drawn girl in a bathing suit as adulterous that’s still nowhere as grave as looking lustfully at the picture of someone else’ daughter (or worse, someone in your family… ugh… xp).
 
If going to a website causes you to sin (even if unregularly), than it is an occasion of sin.
If that is the case, I might as well cut myself off from every form of media. Can something ever stop being an occasion of sin?
 
If that is the case, I might as well cut myself off from every form of media. Can something ever stop being an occasion of sin?
If the artist in question stops drawing pictures that are problematic to your call to purity, then yes. This is to say, if the artist reforms themselves and change their art as a result from say hentai or lewd ecchi to something wholesome, then yes. The reason for this is because he has changed his ways and the things he draws are no longer sinful and so are no longer an occasion of sin for himself or any of his/her viewers.

Being an artist myself, I deal with this struggle all the time, having to make sure my art which I share on the internet on art websites isn’t an occasion of sin for others, or I do my best to make it not an occasion of sin with whatever theme I’m working with.

The problem with anime style art, and indeed any art style is that depending on the artist him/herself they may be prone to drawing sensual things, sometimes out of habit or preference. What you, as a viewer, need to look out for is whether the sensual pictures are a regular theme among the artists whose work you follow. If you see that they regularly draw sensual things, like girls with big boobs and skimpy clothes, or there’s excessive fanservice then you know to avoid these artists and you can see they’re occasions of sin for you, them and their work. If you were to check back later and see their art has changed, or that they’re at least drawing something other than the sexy stuff, then I would say the occasion of sin has changed and is now determined by you, because you now have the option of picking and choosing what art from that artist, or any artist, you look at specifically. You don’t have to avoid the artist if you like their style, but you’ll know to avoid their other stuff. Most websites have thumbnails, which show you a small preview of the picture. If you look at the picture (and can see there’s nudity for example) you’ve already been alerted to a potential occasion of sin, and to not click on that thumbnail. To click that thumbnail to see the full-size picture would be to give in to the occasion of sin, and viewing the material may result in sin of some kind. How much of a sin depends on both the material itself (is it fanservice or pornographic, there is a difference) and how did you or did you not entertain the viewing of the picture.

You say you looked at a worksafe site. I’m assuming this means the hentai and nudity pictures have been filtered out. This can reduce the probability of occasions of sin, because the system reduces your risks of exposure to the inappropriate material, but it does not eliminate the possibility of running into something which may tempt you. With anime, even the clean pictures often times have some kind of sensual element, so you have to use your best judgement and senses and be aware of what you’re clicking on and what type of tags or searches you’re running.

Because a priest is not likely to understand all these things, you do not need to go into detail about it. If you know for a fact you’ve sinned, but you’re not sure how or to what extent, tell the priest you viewed the material and briefly explain the content. If they are mostly pictures of hot anime chicks, for example, just mention you viewed pictures of fictional characters, you don’t have to go into detail about it. The key is to make sure to tell him what happened as a result, as that is just as important as viewing the pictures to begin with. If you got turned on, tell him you were arroused. If you entertained the arousal, tell him this also, since he needs to know this to determine culpability factors. Lastly, you also need to tell him how much and how often. Ie- I look at these pictures x amount of hours a week, and I lusted (for example) x amount of times.

Keep it simple like this and you’ll make a good confession, and consequentially, know were you stand morally with your art viewing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top