M
Maxirad
Guest
I have often forgotten to say “Amen” at the end of the Our Father. Is this a particularly bad thing?
No, it is just a habit you have developed. It can be unlearned.I have often forgotten to say “Amen” at the end of the Our Father. Is this a particularly bad thing?
I smell heresy. BURN HIM!I have often forgotten to say “Amen” at the end of the Our Father. Is this a particularly bad thing?
I do the same thing occasionally. It’s no big deal - but I often find myself repeating the whole prayer (which is a bit scrupulous of me).I have often forgotten to say “Amen” at the end of the Our Father. Is this a particularly bad thing?
It should be noted that Jews never say “Amen” to their own prayers, only in response to the prayer of others.
The reason is that the word “amen” literally means “so be it,” as in “I agree with what has been said [by another].” It is not clear how “amen” got to be used by Christians after every prayer, including their own, since the “amen” has been adopted from Jewish liturgical use. Theoretically the reason might be found in the fact that Catholics offer many prayers by rote based on memorization of Scripture and are saying “amen” to what has been written by the hand of another in such a case.
Whatever the origin of the Christian practice, in light of this there is never a need to say “amen” to your own prayer if you want to be technical about it. You are stating it, it is coming from you, so of course you agree to it.
