OK to hate a fictional character?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Maxirad
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Maxirad

Guest
Is it morally acceptable for one to hate a purely fictional character?
 
Um, that’s an odd question. Why would one “hate” a fictional character?

Sounds like some misplaced emotions, emotional immaturity. Let’s not blur reality and fiction.
 
To what end? It seems an incredible waste of time and effort to hate something that doesn’t even exist. :confused:
 
If you’re talking about Gollum, then, no, I don’t think it’s right to hate him.
 
Last edited:
If you have a morally repugnant fictional character, it is absolutely okay to hate them.

Tony Soprano was such a scumbag - by the end of the series, I couldn’t wait to see him get whacked.
 
I remember I watched a series about a guy who slept around with all sorts of women, a real sleaze bag. But I took comfort in knowing that he gets killed at the end. Is that bad?
Maybe, as in harmful to one’s virtue.
But, you can’t exactly trespass against a fictional person.

Of course I wouldn’t want this to happen to a real person.
But fictional characters don’t have a real psychology. They often aren’t even shown to be tempted by devils. They may be written to have certain issues, but in reality they are how they are because the author wrote them like that.

If you hate a character, it is probably because that’s how the author wants you to feel about him.
 
Last edited:
There are plenty of characters written with the intention that you would hate them. That’s the point with a lot of villains. I see no sin in that. But, if you’ve come to hate a character that has done nothing wrong, it probably means that the character is poorly written and should find something else to read/watch.
 
Is it morally acceptable for one to hate a purely fictional character?
I’ve often disliked fictional characters. But hate? That’s too much energy to waste on someone who doesn’t even exist.
 
Not ok.

We shouldn’t “give in” to these tendencies to hate. It will make it easier to hate real people.

Practice generosity even with fictional characters!

The intellect and the will need to be in control over the passions and the appetites, and that includes the case of hating.

A solid priest I know challenged some men as he was giving a meditation.

He was countering the sappy “you don’t have to like everyone, but you do have to love them” saying.

He said…“No, you need to learn to like just about everyone…it takes work and effort, and setting aside the easy excuses for not liking people”.

He nailed it.

We start writing off one person, and soon enough, we find reasons to “not like” more and more people. And before you know it…we’re finding more reasons to hate more people.

Don’t “give in” to the easy tendencies. They weaken us.

Now I can’t wait for someone in this studious group to try undercut my larger point by saying “what about Hitler?”

To them goes the laugh.
 
Last edited:
That goofy purple ess oh bee ought to be hanged, drawn, and quartered. 😃
 
Not ok.

We shouldn’t “give in” to these tendencies to hate. It will make it easier to hate real people.
I thought you devildogs were supposed to be ministers of death praying for war? If you didn’t even hate fictional tv villains, how would you hate your real life enemy enough to be compelled to utterly destroy them?
 
And I think it’s silly to tell someone it’s not okay to hate a fictional character.

If that was the case, the majority of TV shows, movies, and books would be no fun at all.

Hating the evil villains like the Joker or Hans Gruber is half the fun of watching movies like that.
 
All joking aside, do you really mean “hate”, or strong dislike?
 
For horrible villains like Hans Gruber, I hated his guts.

I looked forward gleefully to seeing John McClane throw him out of the window of the skyscraper.
 
A substantial response would consider for a moment what human faculties are marshaled in order to hate someone, and would counsel against it.

The intellect is called upon to generate reasons and a whole rationale for it, the will then cooperates with the intellect and orders up the relevant “responses” by the “sensitive appetites” (irascibilis). So the whole being now gets “more practiced” at hating. Not a good use of God’s gifts or time.

A far better use of time is to practice temperance and charity either with the fictional character or even better with the real persons in the real world, setting aside “entertainment” a bit for a greater good.

So on several levels it’s wrong to put into action these faculties…better to use time to practice making excuses for people, living charity heroically.
 
Last edited:
You’re making way too much out of this Edward - man, you are just SO serious all the time about everything. Lighten up, how can you be joyful if you never allow yourself to relax and loosen up?

You don’t need to philosophize about literally everything. It’s OKAY to relax and get into a good film - and if that includes hating the villain, so be it.
 
Many people don’t understand the dynamics involved in these matters.

It’s a failure of the Church to continue to teach what St Thomas and others so helpfully teased out.

They don’t even really understand the role of the will, the intellect, the passions and appetites.

And this error has grave and serious consequences in how they live.

Case in point

They confuse feelings with love. They don’t understand that love isn’t a feeling, but a decision to pursue a good for someone else, the very sort of “marshaling” that I mentioned above.

So with this error in place…when the eros of love dips, they confuse that loss of feeling with a loss of love!

Not so.

Feelings now drive people…but God designed the will and the intellect to drive us, they are what make us unique and superior to the animals (please…no greeny lectures for me about how animals are people too).

So this is a helpful thead to discuss matters of the will and the intellect and the pasions, and their proper use and ordering.

If these points don’t create or provide entertainment for you, I am sorry, just use temperance and skip over them.

But perhaps there are others here who see value in discussing the separate role of our faculties in very practical matters.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top