As described in the full article, the Mass should prove to be an interesting celebration, and I am most curious to see and hear how they plan to interject elements of Eastern Catholic worship into the Latin Rite celebration.
As I read it, this “interjecting” will concern music (emphasis added):
While Pope Benedict will celebrate Mass in the Latin rite, the ceremony will feature “a mosaic of the Eastern rite,” he said, **with music drawn from each of the major Catholic churches in the region. **
which is fine in and of itself. Given that it’s not likely they’d be using full Gregorian Chant, I’d rather have it the “Eastern/Oriental” way than using the usual Novus Ordo-style stuff. (Depending, of course, on precisely what is sung: I have a horrible feeling that the Maronite contributions are going to reflect the neo-Maronite style, rather than anything truly authentic.)
That said, though, I’m not all that thrilled with
One choir will include nearly 300 singers, combining Maronite, Melkite, Armenian Catholic, and Syrian Catholic voices and chants.
which has the potential to be a melting-pot of a mess.
Now, OTOH, if the plan was to include mixing-and-matching of liturgy per-se, I’d have to say the whole idea is bad from the get-go. It’s one thing to mix music, but quite another to play around with rites. Heaven know the Maronites (and to a lesser extent, the SCC) already have more than enough of that sort of thing by way of the ubiquitous Novus Ordo-inspired neo-latinizations.
Personally, I was hoping His Holiness might have considered celebration of a Divine Liturgy.
Not that it matters, but I wasn’t. Which would he choose? Much better this way, although I’d prefer if Benedict XVI were to offer Mass in the Usus Antiquior. Yeah, I know … wishful thinking.
