Once a Catholic, always a Catholic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mgreen77
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

mgreen77

Guest
If someone goes through Baptism, Confirmation, & Holy Communion as a Catholic during childhood, but later in life “converts” to another religion (or even aetheism), are they still considered Catholic (who’s lost their way) by the Church and God in a spiritual, “marked” sense?
 
If someone goes through Baptism, Confirmation, & Holy Communion as a Catholic during childhood, but later in life “converts” to another religion (or even aetheism), are they still considered Catholic (who’s lost their way) by the Church and God in a spiritual, “marked” sense?
Yes
Baptism and Confirmation are indelible marks on the soul that cannot be removed.
 
Yes
Baptism and Confirmation are indelible marks on the soul that cannot be removed.
So during all these last 30 years of wandering and forgetting Him, me being so angry towards God and thinking such horrible things sometimes about Him, the Church, and by association against all of you (who have been so kind)…

He was actually there all along, waiting, even as bitter as I was?

I’m so sorry. I owe you all such an apology. I am truly humbled.
 
So during all these last 30 years of wandering and forgetting Him, me being so angry towards God and thinking such horrible things sometimes about Him, the Church, and by association against all of you (who have been so kind)…

He was actually there all along, waiting, even as bitter as I was?

I’m so sorry. I owe you all such an apology. I am truly humbled.
We go through such trials in our lives. I nearly abandoned the Church once because I felt God wasn’t doing anything for me and all this “knock and the door shall be opened” is just wishful thinking. A bishop recently told me and a group of people a story when he as a young teenager stopped going to church. And he’s a bishop now!

God is merciful to those who seek His mercy. Be glad and rejoice that you are back in His loving arms.
 
If someone goes through Baptism, Confirmation, & Holy Communion as a Catholic during childhood, but later in life “converts” to another religion (or even aetheism), are they still considered Catholic (who’s lost their way) by the Church and God in a spiritual, “marked” sense?
Yes. Baptism imparts an indelible mark upon our souls and incorporates us into the Body of Christ. Even if this person did not complete the sacraments of initiation (Eucharist and Confirmation) they would still be Catholic by virtue of their baptism.
 
So during all these last 30 years of wandering and forgetting Him, me being so angry towards God and thinking such horrible things sometimes about Him, the Church, and by association against all of you (who have been so kind)…

He was actually there all along, waiting, even as bitter as I was?
Certainly. God always waits for us, until our dieing breath. It’s why he went to the Cross for us. He loves us, unconditionally. All we have to do is respond.
I’m so sorry. I owe you all such an apology. I am truly humbled.
You are incorporated into God’s family by virtue of your baptism. That means we are brothers and sisters in Christ. We’re family. I don’t think you owe an apology to us, perhaps going to God with your sorrows in the Sacrament of Reconciliation and then uniting with him once again in the Eucharist would be an appropriate next step.
 
So during all these last 30 years of wandering and forgetting Him, me being so angry towards God and thinking such horrible things sometimes about Him, the Church, and by association against all of you (who have been so kind)… He was actually there all along, waiting, even as bitter as I was?

I’m so sorry. I owe you all such an apology. I am truly humbled.
“You are not far from the kingdom of God.”
 
Welcome home - remember the only sin that we cannot be forgiven for is the one that we do not ask Him to be forgiven for.
 
So during all these last 30 years of wandering and forgetting Him, me being so angry towards God and thinking such horrible things sometimes about Him, the Church, and by association against all of you (who have been so kind)…

He was actually there all along, waiting, even as bitter as I was?

I’m so sorry. I owe you all such an apology. I am truly humbled.
I’m not here often, so I don’t know your backstory, but I just went through a similar situation. My brother, who was actually a Marianhill seminarian, up and left the Church. He attended no church for 40 years. He called me on my birthday to tell me that he went back to church. I asked,“The Catholic Church?” His wife is Lutheran/non-practicing. His reply was “Is there any other?” He found a church he loves, talked to the priest, went to Communion, and had his marriage of 33 years blessed. There’s an entirely different atmosphere to him now.

Nobody comes to Christ by the easy path. As many Catholics and Christians you find here, you will find just as many amazing conversion stories.

Welcome home, and may God continue to bestow His bountiful blessings upon you!
 
My DIL, her mother and 3 sisters - all Baptized, Confirmed and parochial educated are ALL lapsed Catholics who haven’t set foot in a church in years.
But ask one and she will tell you she is a Catholic. 🤷
 
Yes, once a Catholic, always a Catholic. I strayed for a couple years, and through the gift of sacrament of Reconciliation I was once again a full good-standing Catholic, through all my trials and conflicts, God’s forgiveness was always there for me, I have not and will never forget that now, as I believe you have now realized. 🙂
 
I wasn’t even Catholic - had only had baptism in the Protestant Chuch but when I had my first Confession in the dessert in Iraq it didn’t matter how long it took me to get into Church I was Catholic. It is a mark on the soul - not a behavior.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top