Other gods in Bible

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ion
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I

Ion

Guest
In the Bible there are mentioned false gods. How is false to be understood, like not existing, or existing but not almighty?
Why seems like the jew people didn’t even have the ideea of converting other people to worship true God?
 
In the Bible there are mentioned false gods. How is false to be understood, like not existing, or existing but not almighty?
Why seems like the jew people didn’t even have the ideea of converting other people to worship true God?
There is only one God so by definition all other ‘gods’ are false, i.e. they do not exist.
 
They are interpreted as “Gods who do not exist.”. Like Thistle said, there is only one God. The false gods are demons, who the heathens obey. Though, they might not realise it, but there is only ONE God in three persons, the Blessed Trinity.
 
In the Bible there are mentioned false gods. How is false to be understood, like not existing, or existing but not almighty?
Why seems like the jew people didn’t even have the ideea of converting other people to worship true God?
I don’t understand why you would think that, I mean, it seems to me Elijah and a slew of other profits, in the old testiment, were trying to do exactly that. 🤷
 
They are interpreted as “Gods who do not exist.”. Like Thistle said, there is only one God. The false gods are demons, who the heathens obey. Though, they might not realise it, but there is only ONE God in three persons, the Blessed Trinity.
By saying existing but not almighty, I meant a limited being, only pretending to be god. But a definite being, from this world or another…Are they imaginary demons or real demons?
 
The other “gods” mentioned in the Bible are the same as those mentioned in Homer, or Ovid, the Egyptian Book of the Dead, the Koran, or the Rig Veda - they don’t exist, and are merely figments of the imagination of man, very often merely a personalized or anthropomorphized form of an aspect of nature (I believe Ba’al was a personification of storms). That is, one who worships Ba’al as god of the storm worships nothing at all.

The other interpretation, given credence by The Apostle, is that they are false gods, in that what is worshiped does not exist in any sense that the worshipers imagine - again, figments of the imagination - but that the false gods are in reality demons or fallen angels, and as such do have an independent existence. That is, one who worships Ba’al as god of the storm actually worships Satan as His Infernal Majesty, the Father of Lies.

When Elias (“Jehovah is my God” in Hebrew) called down fire upon the worshipers of Ba’al and was translated to Heaven, it seems most certainly he was trying to convert heathens to the worship of the one true God, as was Daniel trying to convert worshipers of Bel (possibly Ba’al misspelled) in chapter 14 of Daniel, as throughout the books of Judith and Esther, and, in the discourse on Truth in 3 Esdras, as well as myriad examples of the fallen-away (many times, for many generations) heathens being called again to worship the One God, as exemplified by nearly every single one of the Minor Prophets, and Jeremias.
 
No expert on these matters…But I believe that in ancient times the terms god could refer to things other than an “almighty” being…the term might even sometimes be applied to a physical known person - for example, the Roman’s considered their Emperor to be a “god”.

So it can be a bit tricky knowing just what the ancients might have been referring to when they used the term god unless there was further description attached.

At least this has been the impression I have gotten over time…Please correct / clarify if I am off base here.

Peace
James
 
The other “gods” mentioned in the Bible are the same as those mentioned in Homer, or Ovid, the Egyptian Book of the Dead, the Koran, or the Rig Veda - they don’t exist, and are merely figments of the imagination of man, very often merely a personalized or anthropomorphized form of an aspect of nature (I believe Ba’al was a personification of storms).
If they are only imaginary gods, while the jews had the Ark in the temple (solid proof), why did they go to worship other gods? How did they get bribed?
 
Read the book of Hosea! And many others: from cultural degeneration by mingling and marrying with heathen peoples, anger at the true God, edicts of evil rulers (as in the Books of Kings), etc. - but always a remnant remained. Generally three things seemed to be the cause: 1) a top-down change, in which the rulers apostatized and built up shrines to false gods or goddesses and had the people do the same, 2) in which the rulers were seduced by heathen women, which caused (1) to go in to effect, or when the people as a whole were seduced by idolatrous nations and their customs. Some others are also there occasionally, such as short-sightedness, worldliness, feeling abandoned by YH-H because he didn’t give them what they wanted, even when they practiced great immorality (which then caused them to apostatize completely), and so on.

The Old Testament (and the New) doesn’t paint a pretty picture of the early Jews’ religious faithfulness, being prone to idolatry from the time of the theft of Laban’s “gods” (before Moses, so, truly, before “Judaism” itself), down to Aaron’s idolatry while YH-H himself spoke to Moses upon the mountain, to the constant innovations and apostasies and heresies of the kings (think, witchcraft and Samuel, the sins of David, the late sins and apostasy of Solomon, not to mention the truly bad ones, like Manasses), to the rejection of the Messiah.
 
Also, the egyptians, they saw the miracles done for the jews, if their gods were imaginary, why didn’t they convert?
 
I imagine some did, as portrayed in the Book of Jannes and Jambres and the Targum Jonathan Exodus. When the Jews saw the miracles performed by Christ, and even his glorious Resurrection, why didn’t they convert?
 
I imagine some did, as portrayed in the Book of Jannes and Jambres and the Targum Jonathan Exodus. When the Jews saw the miracles performed by Christ, and even his glorious Resurrection, why didn’t they convert?
Now you say it… The jews thought they have God. The egyptian had only stories as you say.
 
If the egyptians had only stories, and they accepted them by ignorance+supperstition+fear , at the sight of the miracles they would have sky jumped at the opportunity starting with the pharaon.
Probably they had lots of lies and stories, but something was there.
 
This is one point atheist make: “start with greek religion, look there such incredible stories, is false, myths for ignorant people so they listen to the rulers… and nowadays look at this christians doing the same, lucky us we have science and darwin…”
We say that greek religion is false, without any clarification, and we strenghten their point…
And as I said before, there must have been something for sure, people were not that stupid…
 
I imagine some did, as portrayed in the Book of Jannes and Jambres and the Targum Jonathan Exodus. When the Jews saw the miracles performed by Christ, and even his glorious Resurrection, why didn’t they convert?
There is an answer to your rhetorical question, too long for this thread. For one thing, the Jews were cautioned by Moses in Deuteronomy not to trust miracles when they are performed by anyone who calls themselves a god. And there are several other reasons as well. Therein lies quite a tale, as you well know.
 
I imagine some did, as portrayed in the Book of Jannes and Jambres and the Targum Jonathan Exodus. When the Jews saw the miracles performed by Christ, and even his glorious Resurrection, why didn’t they convert?
Because for one the idea of only one man being raised from the dead was simply unthinkable. The idea was that resurrection would occur at the end of days and would be a general event involving all those who have died.
 
In the Bible there are mentioned false gods. How is false to be understood, like not existing, or existing but not almighty?
Speaking from a historical context:

There is one opinion that the Israelites were at first, very strict monolatrists: in other words, they considered Yhwh to be their only God and worshipped Him alone, but did not deny that other gods, who in turn must not be worshipped, existed. (Monolatry is the belief that different gods exist but giving worship to only one deity; it’s midway between polytheism and true monotheism. Sometimes confused with henotheism, which also practices worship of one god but acknowledges that others can with equal validity worship other gods, and kathenotheism, which involves worshipping different gods, one at a time.)

Eventually (as per this theory), this idea had upgraded into full-fledged monotheism: the Israelites now understood that there is only one God for all men. Of course this entails realizing that the deities of other cultures are in reality fictional constructs.
Why seems like the jew people didn’t even have the ideea of converting other people to worship true God?
Well, the idea of jumping from one belief system to a totally different one is a relatively recent concept that had its origins in Second Temple Judaism and which was further developed by Christianity.

Religion at that time was very strongly tied with nationality. So for example, if you were Greek, you worshipped Greek gods; if you were Egyptian, you paid homage to any of the gods of Egypt. The same was true of the Israelites. This is why the idea of actively seeking to converting other peoples did not surface: it was essentially tantamount to saying that they must quit their identities. It is only when Jews in the Hellenistic world tried to strip Judaism of its cultural-specific elements and advertised it as an international philosophy, and when Christians (who preached a message that transcended all boundaries of race and creed) began to surface that we begin to see the idea of ‘conversion’ as we know it today form.
 
Also, the egyptians, they saw the miracles done for the jews, if their gods were imaginary, why didn’t they convert?
Why did people who actually saw Jesus perform miracles and listened to him teaching not convert??
 
Why did people who actually saw Jesus perform miracles and listened to him teaching not convert??
I can point the Palm Sunday, when Christ was welcomed in Jerusalem as King.
There should have been the majority of them, including the leaders…
 
When I think of King Solomon times, my opinion is that at the top of wealth and power in the world, he should have thought how to extend it to all the people in the world; instead he wasted his time with hundreds of womens and queen of sheeba etc.
That looks like a turning down point.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top