You know, it’s obvious this is just going to turn into a fruitless back and forth so I’ll just say this for anyone out there suffering through this kind of struggle or really any struggle:
The Sacrament of Confession is certainly enough for the grace to receive repentance of sins. Addiction, however, is not the same as sin. Sin can lead to addiction, but when a person has a full-blown addiction, an element of their free will is compromised and they need help to “retrain” their bodies and minds that are now captive. Habitual sin, a precursor to addiction, also often needs some outside help. Please do not neglect getting that help. This has nothing to do with questioning how much faith a person has or how powerful God is - this is a matter of dealing practically with the challenges at hand, with brokenness, with habitual problems. It is unfair to reduce all issues down to a “spiritual problem.” We are physical beings and our sin often leads to physical and emotional problems that a priest cannot fully address during the Sacrament of Confession.
Case in point… I had a very devout friend struggle with sexual addiction. He confessed his issues all the time, had a full-time spiritual director, etc and still he was losing the battle. He finally told people - not everyone - but he told some close friends and a counselor (I am the only woman who was told because we were dating and I needed to know as part of discernment). His struggle was infecting our relationship, but being in the dark, I hadn’t know what was going on and didn’t realize that some of the innocent things I wore were a problem for him because it wasn’t a problem for any other man in my life and were modest by general standards. It was infecting everything… his friends could not help him and were in fact, in some ways making it worse because they were unaware that he was weak in areas. So they would communicate over email (when he was trying to avoid the internet), and watch movies with him that wouldn’t tempt them but were in fact, tempting him, etc. It’s the same with alcoholism or drinking problems… when it becomes evident that a friend has an issue, we are more equipped to help, to invite that person to dry events, and to do an intervention if necessary. A priest in the confessional simply cannot have that level of daily influence and accountability over every parishioner nor would I want to place that responsibility solely on the priests. I would imagine that priests rely on all their parishioners to be seeking holiness and helping each other seek holiness. Also, many are not strong enough to seek professional counseling until a friend or family member recognizes the problem and helps them take that step.
Okay, sorry, I hope this hasn’t come off as a rant. It’s just that I’ve seen this above mentality do some real harm to people, and in my opinion is advocating a false kind of holiness. One of the hardest things for a person dealing with habitual sin or addiction, especially sexual, is to admit they have a problem. The last thing that person needs is someone shaming them back into the closet where the sin will just fester. And as Catholics we are called to live in community - no matter how great a book is, it is not the same as a real live friend saying “Look I support you in this struggle, I am praying for you.” Gosh, I know one person who struggles with alcoholism who can barely read. Reading a book would be of not help.