Panhandlers/beggars outside church

  • Thread starter Thread starter Secret_Square
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Secret_Square

Guest
Here’s a question for everyone:

What do you do when confronted by a beggar or panhandler as you are leaving church? Do you feel more “obligated” to give something to them because you don’t want to appear to be un-Christian or uncharitable?

I went to confession today – I had really needed to go for some time, and I made sure to confess some acts I felt were uncharitable, dishonest, or both. Just as I left the church to go back to my car, an older-looking guy came up to me begging for money to “buy a sandwich” because he was hungry, etc.

Even though it was against my better judgment – because I know these people will more than likely just spend the money on booze or smokes or whatever – I ended up giving the guy a $10 bill because that was the only bill I happened to have on me, and I felt like it would look really un-Christian of me to blow the guy off right after going to confession! 😦

Of course, if this guy was an experienced panhandler then he probably knows that he’s more likely to “score” when he hits up people on their way out of church.

Sometimes I just use my debit card to buy things and don’t carry cash at all, which gives me a legitimate and truthful way to refuse panhandlers, by telling them I don’t have any cash on me. However I could not use that excuse this time. I should also note that our city has actually banned panhandling in certain areas in and around downtown, so it could be argued that by giving money to panhandlers, one is facilitating or encouraging them to break the law as well… so I can’t decide whether it’s more wrong to give or not give.

I don’t think anyone is morally obligated to give money to panhandlers, given the high probability that they are simply trying to manipulate people and the fact that help is usually available for the truly needy at soup kitchens, homeless shelters, and other agencies. However, I just can’t bring myself to turn down someone begging outside a church. I think of all those old stories about beggars being Christ in disguise, and all that. How do you handle this?
 
I give. Not all the time because I don’t carry cash very much, and I don’t give more than a fiver. I have bought food for people though. I figure that if the worst thing I do is give money to someone who may need it (even if in reality they do not), then I don’t think God is going to come down too hard on me. Next time, if you have time, offer to buy him something to eat. If he says no, then you have done your duty.
 
Give - always give. I enter into conversation with the person who asks. That is the real blessing. They need money, but even more our brothers and sisters need attention. They are stressed out. So the bigger relief for them is not $$, but our attention. I have encountered so much shame in our hungry brothers and sisters for having to beg. Their bigger hunger is for dignity and acknowledgment. In the spirit of “harm reduction” - let’s not require people to be clean sober and functional before we freely give respect, love and support. Let God handle the details. If not for God’s grace many of us would be similarly challenged.
 
I can’t say that I have always done so but I agree, give if you are able.

In this country there sould be no-one that is in dire need of money because of the comprehensive welfare system.

Travelling in Italy and France you nearly always come across people sitting on the church steps soliciting money. It became a real problem in Rome because I made it an aim to visit as many churches per day as I could find - and you have to know there are a lot of churches there. I do confess that I learned how to dodge being asked for money. It’s a real dilemma.
 
Give - always give. I enter into conversation with the person who asks. That is the real blessing. They need money, but even more our brothers and sisters need attention. They are stressed out. So the bigger relief for them is not $$, but our attention. I have encountered so much shame in our hungry brothers and sisters for having to beg. Their bigger hunger is for dignity and acknowledgment. In the spirit of “harm reduction” - let’s not require people to be clean sober and functional before we freely give respect, love and support. Let God handle the details. If not for God’s grace many of us would be similarly challenged.
that is so much like how Mother Teresa thought 🙂

I think it’s a good idea to give if you’re able and especially to be kind to the person.
 
I agree with Lrabbitt. Always give. Many of our lesser fortunate members of society know to go to churches for help. I attend Mass at a parish that is always seeing its share of the poor asking for food, money, etc.

One day, I brought a dessert to confession that wasn’t needed for a event that took place earlier in the day. Hungry people came up to me, asking what I had so I gave each of them parts of it.

In other situations, I’d rather give people the benefit of the doubt and give them what money I can, In another instance, on a hot summer day I witnessed a young boy ask a man in front of a grocery store if he could spare change. The boy was thirsty and standing in front of the vending machines. The guy just blew him off like he was nothing. It is utter selfishness like this that reminds me of Lazarus and the rich man.
 
As much as we should not be happy to see our brothers and sisters in poverty, we should take it as a great compliment that they believe they will find more caring and generous people at church.

I’m not naive, I know some people are (as a previous poster said) “professional panhandlers”, but I also do not buy into the absurd idea that I’ve heard proposed many times before that these people are somehow living “the good life”. So whether you’re approached by the “professional” (which only means that they’ve been unfortunate enough to have to beg for so long that they are now very experienced at it) or by someone who appears more pitiable to you, still give.

For the Lord says:

“Give to everyone who begs from you; and if anyone takes away your goods, do not ask for them again.” - Luke 6.30

and

“Then he will say to those at his left hand, “You that are accursed, depart from me into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels; for I was hungry and you gave me no food, I was thirsty and you gave me nothing to drink, I was a stranger and you did not welcome me, naked and you did not give me clothing, sick and in prison and you did not visit me.” Then they also will answer, “Lord, when was it that we saw you hungry or thirsty or a stranger or naked or sick or in prison, and did not take care of you?” Then he will answer them, “Truly I tell you, just as you did not do it to one of the least of these, you did not do it to me.” And these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life.’” - Matthew 25.41-46

That said, I know we’ve all experienced hardness of heart and I admit that I’ve refused to give to beggars many times. Fortunately (and also unfortunately) our Lord gives us many opportunities to make up for our previous lack of charity as the “poor are always with us”.
 
in this specific case of this center-city parish, and in the previous inner-city parish where I worked, the pastor has asked parishioners and staff specifically not to give money to anyone begging on the grounds. The reasons are these: assistance is available daily through St. Vincent at posted hours, and is never in the form of direct gifts of cash, but by meeting the specific need: food, assistance with medical or utility bills through arrangments with those agencies, gasoline vouchers and so forth. Parishioners are told to refer panhandlers to the ushers on the weekends, who give them information on when and how to get assistance, and in cases of immediate need (exceedingly rare) there is a person designated to provide it.

There are emergency meal packages kept on hand with non-perishables that don’t require cooking just for these cases, and the ushers handle that distribution. That way only the designated people get approached and parishioners are not hassled, an experience that can be very frightening for our many elderly and handicapped parishioners, or a family with young children. We don’t serve any food after Masses because of our parking problems, but we did at the former parish, and street people were always welcome to eat what was available.

The gravest reason is security. Several of us including elderly nuns (and I am no youngster, either) work when there is no one else around including in the evening, and the idea that cash can be had for the asking makes everyone vulnerable. The third is child protection laws, as most times when the Church is open for Mass there are also other programs going on, and encouraging street people to loiter puts them at risk as well.
 
I remember when I 1st seen 1 stick his hand out at me in front of church, I almost went to shake it & my family thought it would’ve been cold. Well the guy just sticks his hand out w/o saying anything else. He doesn’t go to church or even take the free food my church gives, so I don’t feel bad as a poor man when he sticks his hand out & I just don’t give anything.
 
Our Pastor has instructed us not to give panhandlers any money, but to direct them to the rectory where they have all the resouces necessary to help them. It is amazing how fast some of them disappear when they find out it is not going to be that easy to pick up some quick cash from people going to church on Sunday!
 
I probably won’t gain many friends by saying this, but I refuse to give cash to any beggar under any circumstances.

My view is that if I do toss him some money, I’m simply giving positive reinforcement to his “chosen profession.” More often than not, any cash I give the beggar will be spent on alcohol or drugs. Maybe it’s something like “tough love” or something.

What I will do, and have frequently done, is to offer to take the beggar to buy him a sandwich, or perhaps a cold drink, if he’s hot and sweaty; but I’ve never been taken up on the offer. That alone ought to speak volumes.
 
Thanks to all for their perspectives.

I like the method puzzleannie’s parish uses – referring panhandlers to the ushers who always know where help can be found. Maybe I should suggest that to the SVDP in my parish. They could be helpful not only to panhandlers and the poor but also to the significant number of out of town visitors and tourists who attend Mass there.

I just thought of another idea as well. Back around Christmas I was approached by a panhandler (not at the church but elsewhere in town) and – not wanting to be too Scroogelike at Christmas – I ended up giving him a fast food restaurant gift card that I had just received in a Christmas gift exchange at work!

I am thinking it might be helpful to keep a couple of the $5 or $10 gift cards from McDonald’s or Subway on me at all times, so the next time someone comes up to me claiming they are hungry, I have something to give them that would help them if they truly are hungry but won’t enable them to feed an addiction if they have one.
 
Our mayor, made a public plea to not give to panhandlers, as it just perpetuates their lifestyles. He then put “change-boxes” on major street corners to donate to the various missions, charities, etc, that cater to the poor and homeless.

Well those change boxes didn’t last long, as they were being sawed off, broken off, etc.

So, the kindest thing you can do for these folks is take them or direct them to the nearest shelter, where they can get the help they need.

Now giving someone food or a cold drink if you have it available, is one thing. But giving money to a pan-handler is doing them no favors.
 
Give money to a wino so that he can drink himself to death? Give to a drug addict so that he can get another fix? Hand a beggar a dollar so that he can gamble in Atlantic City this weekend?

True charity requires doing the hard work to discern who needs charity. Even then we’re just talking money. One could also share the Good News in lieu of cash to anyone one doubts would make good use of charitable money. “What’s your name? I’ll pray for you.” might be a better act of charity than handing out a dollar.

.
 
Here’s a question for everyone:

What do you do when confronted by a beggar or panhandler as you are leaving church? Do you feel more “obligated” to give something to them because you don’t want to appear to be un-Christian or uncharitable?

I went to confession today – I had really needed to go for some time, and I made sure to confess some acts I felt were uncharitable, dishonest, or both. Just as I left the church to go back to my car, an older-looking guy came up to me begging for money to “buy a sandwich” because he was hungry, etc.

Even though it was against my better judgment – because I know these people will more than likely just spend the money on booze or smokes or whatever – I ended up giving the guy a $10 bill because that was the only bill I happened to have on me, and I felt like it would look really un-Christian of me to blow the guy off right after going to confession! 😦

Of course, if this guy was an experienced panhandler then he probably knows that he’s more likely to “score” when he hits up people on their way out of church.

Sometimes I just use my debit card to buy things and don’t carry cash at all, which gives me a legitimate and truthful way to refuse panhandlers, by telling them I don’t have any cash on me. However I could not use that excuse this time. I should also note that our city has actually banned panhandling in certain areas in and around downtown, so it could be argued that by giving money to panhandlers, one is facilitating or encouraging them to break the law as well… so I can’t decide whether it’s more wrong to give or not give.

I don’t think anyone is morally obligated to give money to panhandlers, given the high probability that they are simply trying to manipulate people and the fact that help is usually available for the truly needy at soup kitchens, homeless shelters, and other agencies. However, I just can’t bring myself to turn down someone begging outside a church. I think of all those old stories about beggars being Christ in disguise, and all that. How do you handle this?
if you dont want to hand over cash, how about keeping some none perishable snacks in your car that dont go bad rightaway…like lil bottles of fizzy pop or water, crisps, cookies, crackers, etc, or keep a thermos of hot soup in your car along with some disposable cups and then you can hand out a hot soup…

thats what i would do, though its rare to see beggars around where i live
 
You could say I do a lot of my own personal charity work, a person should give something if he has some loose change in their pockets say .25 or 50 cents here in life in the Philippines its easy to take 1 or 2 pesos from your pocket and give to them but before I retired and lived in NM(I know most of you live in the US)that’s what I would do for them because the vast majority have drug & alcohol reasons whereas here where I am now it’s different many of them have legitimate reasons for begging I have put a lot of rice in households that have none. I employ a widow as a maid and support her and her family which includes an impaired sister as well as two children.

You might concentrate on giving beggars less and look for doing charity for the real poor which is what I do!

When I was young I was on a boat that had been seized unfairly by the mexicans taken to a port Campece where the crew was locked up and the Captain sent back to the US, he returned for the boat but the mexicans wanted too much for our release and he went back to the US with the boat, I was fed one meal a week of beans & tortillas my shipmates weren’t fed because they were disrespectful, they died and they released me after 62 days on the day before the Fiesta of Guadalupe I had to return from there to the US so the whole point of this account is I KNOW WHAT IT FEELS LIKE TO BE A BEGGAR! I know what hunger and starvation feels like I have been there!

So I like to help those that need it!
Dave:)
 
I wonder how many are Holy Angels sent as a test. Not everyone you met is a person. Charity is a virtue. We are supposed to be like Christ. He was totally innocent and he gave everything. I mean they gambled his clothes away.
Code:
   I  help as  I can.   No big deal.   Some of these people have very sad stories. Christ died for every member of the Human Family.  

   That is just my  thoughts.
 
I always felt it was irony that christians could pass up those who appeared in need on their ways to church to give their moneys
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top