S
Secret_Square
Guest
Here’s a question for everyone:
What do you do when confronted by a beggar or panhandler as you are leaving church? Do you feel more “obligated” to give something to them because you don’t want to appear to be un-Christian or uncharitable?
I went to confession today – I had really needed to go for some time, and I made sure to confess some acts I felt were uncharitable, dishonest, or both. Just as I left the church to go back to my car, an older-looking guy came up to me begging for money to “buy a sandwich” because he was hungry, etc.
Even though it was against my better judgment – because I know these people will more than likely just spend the money on booze or smokes or whatever – I ended up giving the guy a $10 bill because that was the only bill I happened to have on me, and I felt like it would look really un-Christian of me to blow the guy off right after going to confession!
Of course, if this guy was an experienced panhandler then he probably knows that he’s more likely to “score” when he hits up people on their way out of church.
Sometimes I just use my debit card to buy things and don’t carry cash at all, which gives me a legitimate and truthful way to refuse panhandlers, by telling them I don’t have any cash on me. However I could not use that excuse this time. I should also note that our city has actually banned panhandling in certain areas in and around downtown, so it could be argued that by giving money to panhandlers, one is facilitating or encouraging them to break the law as well… so I can’t decide whether it’s more wrong to give or not give.
I don’t think anyone is morally obligated to give money to panhandlers, given the high probability that they are simply trying to manipulate people and the fact that help is usually available for the truly needy at soup kitchens, homeless shelters, and other agencies. However, I just can’t bring myself to turn down someone begging outside a church. I think of all those old stories about beggars being Christ in disguise, and all that. How do you handle this?
What do you do when confronted by a beggar or panhandler as you are leaving church? Do you feel more “obligated” to give something to them because you don’t want to appear to be un-Christian or uncharitable?
I went to confession today – I had really needed to go for some time, and I made sure to confess some acts I felt were uncharitable, dishonest, or both. Just as I left the church to go back to my car, an older-looking guy came up to me begging for money to “buy a sandwich” because he was hungry, etc.
Even though it was against my better judgment – because I know these people will more than likely just spend the money on booze or smokes or whatever – I ended up giving the guy a $10 bill because that was the only bill I happened to have on me, and I felt like it would look really un-Christian of me to blow the guy off right after going to confession!
Of course, if this guy was an experienced panhandler then he probably knows that he’s more likely to “score” when he hits up people on their way out of church.
Sometimes I just use my debit card to buy things and don’t carry cash at all, which gives me a legitimate and truthful way to refuse panhandlers, by telling them I don’t have any cash on me. However I could not use that excuse this time. I should also note that our city has actually banned panhandling in certain areas in and around downtown, so it could be argued that by giving money to panhandlers, one is facilitating or encouraging them to break the law as well… so I can’t decide whether it’s more wrong to give or not give.
I don’t think anyone is morally obligated to give money to panhandlers, given the high probability that they are simply trying to manipulate people and the fact that help is usually available for the truly needy at soup kitchens, homeless shelters, and other agencies. However, I just can’t bring myself to turn down someone begging outside a church. I think of all those old stories about beggars being Christ in disguise, and all that. How do you handle this?