Parish bulletin 911 - we will never forget

  • Thread starter Thread starter RayonGama
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

RayonGama

Guest
I have a hard time to understand why on my parish bulletin show that we are going to be in hatred forever toward that event. Aren’t they avenged enough?

I would have preferred, Let’s pray for peace in the world.

Do you have that on your parish bulletin too? Just curious.
 
I have a hard time to understand why on my parish bulletin show that we are going to be in hatred forever toward that event. Aren’t they avenged enough?

I would have preferred, Let’s pray for peace in the world.
Just because they publish “9/11 We will never forget” does not mean that they are ‘hating’ … or that they are going to be in hatred forever toward that event … Now - if they published a diatribe against Islamic terrorists that included the statement “9/11 We will never forget” you might have a case … but I doubt that is the context … Please do not infuse your feelings upon others …

We have not forgotten the attack on Pearl Harbor

Nor the dropping of the atomic bombs that brought about the termination of war in the Pacific.

Jesus died for our sins … we never forget that …

Ever lost a spouse? You will never forget them … even if you fall in love and marry again - you would never forget …

Especially when events happen like the assassination of Kennedy and MLK or the attack on NYC and the Pentagon happen - it affects the entire nation … Hate is not necessarily a component …

And one can argue that it is in the remembering of these horrors that people are moved to find the ability to work towards peace … even of we do so imperfectly [being human beings - after all ;)]
 
Just because they publish “9/11 We will never forget” does not mean that they are ‘hating’ … or that they are going to be in hatred forever toward that event … Now - if they published a diatribe against Islamic terrorists that included the statement “9/11 We will never forget” you might have a case … but I doubt that is the context … Please do not infuse your feelings upon others …

We have not forgotten the attack on Pearl Harbor

Nor the dropping of the atomic bombs that brought about the termination of war in the Pacific.

Jesus died for our sins … we never forget that …

Ever lost a spouse? You will never forget them … even if you fall in love and marry again - you would never forget …

Especially when events happen like the assassination of Kennedy and MLK or the attack on NYC and the Pentagon happen - it affects the entire nation … Hate is not necessarily a component …

And one can argue that it is in the remembering of these horrors that people are moved to find the ability to work towards peace … even of we do so imperfectly [being human beings - after all ;)]
All good points, but the part about , “please do not infuse your feelings on others” struck me as a little unfair if not even lacking in charity. These forums are about exchanges of ideas; stifling them prevent posters from hearing a perspective that might change their minds and their hearts, and in some important matters, turn them to the light of Christ’s truth.
 
All good points, but the part about , “please do not infuse your feelings on others” struck me as a little unfair if not even lacking in charity. These forums are about exchanges of ideas; stifling them prevent posters from hearing a perspective that might change their minds and their hearts, and in some important matters, turn them to the light of Christ’s truth.
hi Neofight - I see your point - to a point …😦 but the OP was the one who took
911 - we will never forget
and interpreted it to mean
why …my parish bulletin show that we are going to be in*** hatred forever*** toward that event.
and referred to remembering as being
Which seems- to me - to be his thoughts infused upon what the parish meant - and appears rather harsh and judgmental in its self such that my observation seem fairly tame as far as unfairness and being less then charitable …IMHO

suffice it to say - I was only attempting to get them to look inside themselves to see where that interpretation came from…obviously - my attempt was clumsy - if not a failure 🤷

mea culpa
 
hi Neofight - I see your point - to a point …😦 but the OP was the one who took

and interpreted it to mean and referred to remembering as being

Which seems- to me - to be his thoughts infused upon what the parish meant - and appears rather harsh and judgmental in its self such that my observation seem fairly tame as far as unfairness and being less then charitable …IMHO

suffice it to say - I was only attempting to get them to look inside themselves to see where that interpretation came from…obviously - my attempt was clumsy - if not a failure 🤷

mea culpa
Ya I was shocked, but I am ok.
My real point is: what political stuff have to do with my parish bulletin.
Had flag last week for labor day, what is the point. With minimum wage so low in the country, thanks to the gouv.
I would like a parish clean of patriotism. It’s a heresy.
 
Ya I was shocked, but I am ok.
My real point is: what political stuff have to do with my parish bulletin.
Had flag last week for labor day, what is the point. With minimum wage so low in the country, thanks to the gouv.
I would like a parish clean of patriotism. It’s a heresy.
All of Church history shows that we are connected to our countries. The Church of Rome who’s patriarch is the Pope was historically very Italian. The Church of Alexandria is very Coptic (Egyptian). Russian Catholics care deeply about Russia. The Church is not of the world but we still live in the world. We can love our countries as long as we put the Kingdom of Heaven first.

1 Timothy 2:1-4 Therefore I exhort first of all that supplications, prayers, intercessions, and giving of thanks be made for all men, for kings and all who are in authority, that we may lead a quiet and peaceable life in all godliness and reverence. For this is good and acceptable in the sight of God our Savior, who desires all men to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth.

Here is are two prayers from the intercessions of the ancient Divine Liturgy (Mass) of St John Chrysostom:

Deacon: For the government and for the armed forces, that they may be upheld in every good deed, let us pray to the Lord.
People: Lord, have mercy.

Deacon: For this city, for every city and country place and the faithful dwelling in them, let us pray to the Lord.
People: Lord, have mercy.

I always got the impression that “we will never forget” refers to those who died. In the Byzantine Rite we emphasize remembering the deceased and say, “May their memory be eternal.” We ask God to save us saying, “May the Lord God remember us in his kingdom.” Remembering is connected to the Old Testament when God “remembers” his people and saves them. The wise thief on the Cross asked Christ to “Remember me when you enter into your kingdom.”

Peace. 🙂
 
I have a hard time to understand why on my parish bulletin show that we are going to be in hatred forever toward that event. Aren’t they avenged enough?

I would have preferred, Let’s pray for peace in the world.

Do you have that on your parish bulletin too? Just curious.
It’s not on my parish bulletin, but if it were I would interpret it to mean we will never forget those who were murdered that day. You say you would prefer “let’s pray peace in the world”. I agree. Maybe we agree on the end result but get lost in communication on how to get there? I will never forget that day on behalf of a coworker who was murdered and another who lived only because she happened to be outside smoking a cigarette. Also, because before 9/11/01 i felt safe going to work at a good job in a high rise building in a big city. It’s nothing to do with hatred or revenge. More of a memorial to those who died. Lets talk more.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top