Paying a priest to say prayers for the sick

  • Thread starter Thread starter davidn87
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I believe you are confusing the OP.

No priest in the world can deny a person the sacraments and rites offered by the Church because they cannot pay.

Though it is customary, or the normal procedure, to give the priest a certain wage… but however, if you cannot pay this, the priest cannot deny you the sacrament, blessing, or rite in which you seek if you have the proper prerequisites…

The priest is not here to be served, he is here TO serve.
I’m honestly not sure what you mean in terms of possibly confusing the OP. The fact that a Mass stipend is an optional donation rather than a required fee has been clearly pointed out in this thread by myself (Post #13) and others. But what you’ve stated here needs some further clarification. It is true that all Catholics have a right to the sacraments, and that no one can charge for ministering the sacraments. But the topic of the thread is about arranging to have a Mass offered for a special intention. When asked to specifically do this, a priest is not morally obligated to agree to it. Naturally, it would be rare for a priest to turn down such a request, but a Catholic’s right to receive the sacraments does not extend to a right to have Masses offered for their personal, special intentions. Likewise, the moral obligation of a priest to offer Masses for his community does not extend to a moral obligation to honor every request for a special intention.

For example, let us say that man wants a priest to offer a Mass for the intention that his brother, a violent criminal, gets out of prison. He is certainly free to request a priest to do this. But if the priest thinks that this inmate is a danger to society and should stay behind bars, he can turn down this request in good conscience. If this were to actually happen, I think a priest would discuss altering the Mass intention (i.e., for the inmate’s health, for God’s will to be done in his life, for his rehabilitation, etc.) but the point is that the priest is not morally obligated to offer a Mass specifically for this inmate, or to do it in the manner the inmate’s brother wants. However, once a priest agrees to offer a Mass for a special intention, he is committed to either offering it or seeing that another priest does.
 
Is it required that the priest announce the intention? Because I’ve NEVER heard a priest do this. It’s always printed in the bulletin who the Masses the following week are for (our parish has 2 daily Masses Monday through Friday, and one on Saturday, in addition to a Saturday Vigil and 5 Sunday Masses), but the Priests (we have 3) are either saying it very quietly or to themselves.

In Christ,
Ellen
 
Here in MN, the ‘stipend’ is much steeper; $50.00 - $100.00 is customary and, they are mentioned on Sundays as well.

Interesting.
That sounds more like a wedding stipend. Weddings and funerals involve more than just a Mass for the priest. The larger remuneration is more for recognition of those extra services.
 
Is it required that the priest announce the intention? Because I’ve NEVER heard a priest do this. It’s always printed in the bulletin who the Masses the following week are for (our parish has 2 daily Masses Monday through Friday, and one on Saturday, in addition to a Saturday Vigil and 5 Sunday Masses), but the Priests (we have 3) are either saying it very quietly or to themselves.

In Christ,
Ellen
Priests do not have to verbally announce the intention at Mass. For a further elaboration on this, please see my comments under #2 in Post 13.
 
Here it all is in a nutshell…

There are three different types of intentions that a priest can offer at each Mass:

1) The Mass is offered for the universal Church (i.e., all the living and deceased members). Each and every Mass always includes this intention, and is reflected in the Eucharistic Prayer. Whereas this particular intention is mandatory, the following two are optional.

2) A Mass may also be offered for a “special intention”. Only one special intention may be offered per Mass, per priest (i.e., if additional priests are present concelebrating, each may offer a different special intention). The intention may be for a single individual (such as for the repose of someone’s soul or for the health of someone who is sick), or for two or more people who are grouped together by a common association (for example, for a married couple celebrating their anniversary, for a group of people on a pilgrimage together, for the victims of a natural catastrophe, etc.). A special intention can also be for an event (for example, a good harvest) or for a cause (for example, the Pro-Life Movement).

When someone arranges to “have a Mass said” or “have a Mass offered” for a particular intention, it is along the lines of what I have described here in #2. Many people give a “stipend” (i.e., a donation) for this, usually about five to ten dollars in the U.S. This is entirely optional. A priest cannot charge a fee for this, or for providing any of the sacraments. Once a priest tells someone that he will offer a Mass for a special intention (regardless of whether or not he received a stipend), he is morally obligated to either offer that Mass intention, or pass it along to another priest. If there was a stipend, and if he passes the Mass intention along to another priest, the stipend should likewise be passed along. A priest may agree to offer a special intention on a certain date, but he is not morally obligated to actually do it on that date (but he still has to do it at some point).

The special intention of a Mass may or may not be verbally announced during the Mass. Sometimes it is printed in the church bulletin. All this is up to the pastor. When a special intention of a Mass is announced, it is usually done so at the beginning of Mass and/or during the Prayers of the Faithful. None of this is actually covered by the rubrics of the Missal. Many priests will silently contemplate the special Mass intention at the Opening Prayer (during the pause that follows “Let us pray…”).

Along the lines of what DexUK pointed out, a pastor is obligated to offer (as the special intention) one Mass each Sunday and Holy Day of Obligation for his parishioners. The Latin term for this Mass is pro populo (“for the people”). If for some reason he is unable to (for example, he’s sick in bed) he can do this at a later time (even at a weekday Mass).

As a side note, donations to a priest associated with other events such as baptisms, weddings, funerals, etc. are sometimes called “stole fees” even though, technically speaking, it is not a “fee”. The Church today is trying to get away from terms such as “stipend” and “stole fee”, preferring the term “donation” (to emphasize that this is a voluntary offering).

3) By virtue of his office, a priest can include one or more other personal intentions at a Mass. They can be for himself, for others, for events, or for whatever. They do not have to be grouped together by a common association or such. When a priest tells you, “I’ll remember you (or your sick aunt, or your charity event, etc.) at Mass,” this is probably (but not necessarily) what he means. These sorts of Mass intentions are usually not announced. I know of a priest who keeps a list of personal intentions on a piece of paper in his shirt pocket and touches it while silently praying, “For these intentions” during the Mass. But there is no official way of doing this, and a priest may offer this third type of intention is whatever what he desires.

At this time allow me to offer an elaboration (and clarification) concerning one of my brother’s comments in Post #4. Is there some kind of difference or distinction in terms of the grace associated with each of these three types? To the best of my knowledge, the Church has never officially stated anything along these lines. There may or may not be some sort of distinction, but it has not been revealed to us. Therefore, the answer to this question would be, “God only knows.” Naturally, on our end of things all this should be contemplated recognizing that the spiritual benefit of a single Mass is infinite.
At our parish Church we regularly have a board displayed at Mass with dozens of names for whom Mass intentions are offered. None of these names are connected to each other.
 
At our parish Church we regularly have a board displayed at Mass with dozens of names for whom Mass intentions are offered. None of these names are connected to each other.
Correct me if I’m wrong, but I’m guessing that this board does not tell you the exact manner in which the priest is acknowledging these intentions. Many of them could be according to what I described under #3 in Post 13 (i.e., a priest’s “general intentions”, which do not have to be connected to each other according to a common theme or such). Moreover, a priest is given a lot of leeway in terms of deciding how people can be grouped together for the purpose of a single special Mass intention. For example, a priest may offer as the special intention of a Mass all the people who received a Christmas card from him stating that a Mass will be offered for them.

Some parishes may also have a method in place of people agreeing to combine their intentions together, so they consider their intentions to be in conjunction with one another (to form a single special Mass intention). In light of all this, in terms of the bulletin board in your parish, assuming that these are special intentions (and not the general intentions of the priest) there is a connection there, but one that is simply not readily apparent to the casual observer. The information I provided in Post 13 is of a general nature, so I didn’t go into all these nuances (in order to keep on topic).

For a little more elaboration on this subject, please click on the following link and scroll down to #2 under the heading “Mass Intentions”: Cathedral of St. John Berchmans.
 
We have an excellent arrangement in our parish. There is a desk diary kept in the Sacristy and parishioners wanting Mass offered for intentions (anniversary of death, etc.) consults the Sacristan who enters the intention in the diary. No money is requested or offered at that stage. On the day the Mass is offered, we leave the Mass offering with the Sacristan (before or after Mass) who passes it on to the priest. The intention is announced irrespective of whether an offering has been given. There is no recommended offering. We do have to make our reservation many months in advance if we want a Sunday Mass. Weekday Masses can be hit and miss because funerals and month’s mind take precedence.

One priest in a neighbouring parish announced at Mass that he would no long accept Mass offerings. He said he would include the intentions but would not accept the money.
 
Correct me if I’m wrong, but I’m guessing that this board does not tell you the exact manner in which the priest is acknowledging these intentions. Many of them could be according to what I described under #3 in Post 13 (i.e., a priest’s “general intentions”, which do not have to be connected to each other according to a common theme or such). Moreover, a priest is given a lot of leeway in terms of deciding how people can be grouped together for the purpose of a single special Mass intention. For example, a priest may offer as the special intention of a Mass all the people who received a Christmas card from him stating that a Mass will be offered for them.

Some parishes may also have a method in place of people agreeing to combine their intentions together, so they consider their intentions to be in conjunction with one another (to form a single special Mass intention). In light of all this, in terms of the bulletin board in your parish, assuming that these are special intentions (and not the general intentions of the priest) there is a connection there, but one that is simply not readily apparent to the casual observer. The information I provided in Post 13 is of a general nature, so I didn’t go into all these nuances (in order to keep on topic).

For a little more elaboration on this subject, please click on the following link and scroll down to #2 under the heading “Mass Intentions”: Cathedral of St. John Berchmans.
The board simply has the names of people on it and the priest does not individually go through the intentions of each person named. He states the Mass is for the intentions of those named on the board.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top