Paying for Spiritual Direction?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ElToro
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

ElToro

Guest
For the last several weeks there have been notices in my parishes bulletin for spritual direction. In brief five females from my parish (and serveral others from throughout the diocese) became “certified as spritual directors” per the chancery after completing a fairly trivial certification course measured in weeks and not months or years. Here is what my parish’s website says:

*"Are you seeking a way to affirm and deepen your spiritual life?

Spiritual direction, also called spiritual companioning, is a ministry within the Church where women and men who have been through a formation process walk with another on their faith journey.

The Spiritual directors listed below can help you connect with God in a deeper way, help you discern a new direction in life, and lead you to deepen your prayer life.

(names of five Jane Does from my parish)

The introductory session is always free. During the first session each director will discuss their fee schedule with you. Contact the Diocese of XYZ for more trained spiritual directors. (Click on Diocese upper left corner of this site, click on Ministries then go to Faith Formation where you will find Spiritual Direction)"*

Is this proper? This feels so wrong to me yet I have no idea if it’s allowed? Of the five females listed I know four of them – three of which are problem people in my personal experience in terms of people skills. What gives? This feels almost evil to me yet it might be completely permissable? My bishop certainly approved it. The notices in the bulletin are getting more and more aggressive – as if they are not getting much “business.” Thanks.
 
For enough money, they will reveal the name “Xenu” to you, but I have saved you a bundle. Please send me an appropriate “saved you a bundle” sized payment by way of check, cash, or gold coins.

And then look someplace more sincere and qualified for your spiritual direction.
 
It’s not unheard of for genuine spiritual directors with real credentials to charge for spiritual direction, as it is a lot of individual, one on one work. I noticed that a religious community of Sisters near me is charging $20 per session. Presumably, their formation is a lot more comprehensive than what you describe. I can understand a community of religious charging for this; after all, it is something that they are fairly uniquely prepared to offer.

I’m not being dismissive of lay people offering spiritual direction in the least, and I noticed that when I was searching for a director, there are several in my area. I’m sure that they are very good. However, when I was on my quest, I went where I knew I’d be linked with a director that had real genuine preparation, a specific format, and had been through formal direction themselves–and that turned out to be the Jesuit parish near me. A delightful surprise was that they do not “charge” a plug nickel (but naturally will accept free-will offerings.) You’re free to either pick up the specific reading material and handouts from them for a nominal charge (never cost me more than a few dollars,) or go home and print them out yourself from the website.

I’d be a lot more concerned about what you describe as a trivial and superficial course of weeks in length as their formation for this ministry, and I’d keep looking.
 
Fromt the notice, I agree it sounds improper but I can’t guarentee it from just that.

To me the line about “spiritual companioning” seems off because that is usually used for a non-directive type of SD that tells you about the trees rather than help you reach the mountaintop - although not knowing the people or the course given I can’t guarantee this.

And why do you need to “affirm … your spiritual life”? This also sounds a little off too.

The fee system seems a little weird too. Most good spiritual directors will take donations or ask for a minimal fee (which I can’t guarantee they don’t but why are thety hiding it).

The most important point for Spiritual Directors is their own holiness they can transmit so a course need not be extensive if personal holiness and general knowledge of the Lord’s ways are somehow brought in as pre-requisites (i.e. a holy priest has to recomend them as such beforehand).

I hope that helps.

God bless.

In Christ,
Br Matthew, LC
 
Fromt the notice, I agree it sounds improper but I can’t guarentee it from just that.

To me the line about “spiritual companioning” seems off because that is usually used for a non-directive type of SD that tells you about the trees rather than help you reach the mountaintop - although not knowing the people or the course given I can’t guarantee this.

And why do you need to “affirm … your spiritual life”? This also sounds a little off too.

The fee system seems a little weird too. Most good spiritual directors will take donations or ask for a minimal fee (which I can’t guarantee they don’t but why are thety hiding it).

The most important point for Spiritual Directors is their own holiness they can transmit so a course need not be extensive if personal holiness and general knowledge of the Lord’s ways are somehow brought in as pre-requisites (i.e. a holy priest has to recomend them as such beforehand).

I hope that helps.

God bless.

In Christ,
Br Matthew, LC
I think that’s what scares me the most. Not the fact that they are laity or that their formation seems trivial or that they charge. It’s who they seem to be based on a number of years of interaction with most of them. Those that I know of the group are the type that seem to be looking for something to do – something that will elevate their status a bit in the parish. It sorta makes my skin crawl that they picked SD. It feels evil – and I am not using that word lightly.
 
I had no idea that spiritual directors had a fee schedule.

Tho it does say in the Bible that the laborer is worth his wage.

So, what if you don’t have any money to spare for an SD? Perhaps the extra dollars I have I would rather send to Food for the Poor, CRS, or other charities like those.

In fact the whole idea of SDs bothers me. If they are not a priest and you can’t have what you say sealed by the confessional, then you are perhaps putting a lot of personal info into another’s (who knows how holy?) hands. :eek:
 
Spiritual direction is a highly personal thing.
The one giving and the one receiving must have a level of confidence and comfort with each other. The SD must be able to listen carefully and offer appropriate encouragement, correction and suggestions. Some of this can come from training but only some. SD is a calling, a vocation. It is something that the Spirit inspires.
If a person is not called to this no amount of training will make them effective
If a person IS called to this, training may not even be needed (they’re just “naturals”).

I agree with others in that there are things in the notice that give me concern. On the other hand this appears to be an approved ministry. If you have concerns about it perhaps you could get some more information from the chancery. Just tell them you are interested in the certification (which is true) and could they send you info, course outline etc.
My guess is that this certification is closer to a “spiritual companion” than a “Spiritual director”.
To offer an analogy, it might be like nursing where you have different levels of training from “nurses aide” to LPN through RN and BSN.

Regardless of the validity of the course, it’s length etc, when it comes right down to it, effective Spiritual direction is going to depend on the trust one has with their Spiritual director.

Peace
James
 
If I remember correctly, he said a spiritual director should not charge a fee for spiritual direction.
Generally that is correct but when someone charges $10 or $20 for a 30-60 minute professional consultation, I would see that more as a “stipend” than a “fee.” (Most other professionals would charge 5 times that, minimum.) I would consider this especially in a case of a religious who does this as their primary apostolate as she needs to support her community.

God bless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top