Penance

  • Thread starter Thread starter John_of_Woking
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

John_of_Woking

Guest
Hello

What happens if you forget what penance you have been given after confession? Is this sin still forgiven? Should you go back and ask what your penance was? I don’t want to descend into scruples about this.
 
There are two consequences (among others) of committing a sin:
  1. the guilt
  2. the temporal punishment.
By confessing with contrition and the desire not to commit the sin again and have present the will to make satisfaction, by the absolution your sin is forgiven, even if you forget to do the penance. You will have to do it at some point, whether in purgatory or here on earth. But the guilt of the sin is forgiven regardless.

If you forget what the priest has given you, assign yourself one.
 
There are two consequences (among others) of committing a sin:
  1. the guilt
  2. the temporal punishment.
By confessing with contrition and the desire not to commit the sin again and have present the will to make satisfaction, by the absolution your sin is forgiven, even if you forget to do the penance. You will have to do it at some point, whether in purgatory or here on earth. But the guilt of the sin is forgiven regardless.

If you forget what the priest has given you, assign yourself one.
Thanks Stuart. I see you are based in Scotland. Are you going to see Pope B in Glasgow?
 
No problem.

Yes I managed to get a ticket for the Mass through my university.
Good stuff. I am going to Hyde Park with my wife and son. I hear the music won’t be up to much in Hyde Park :rolleyes: but every where else will be in conformity with Pope B’s sensibilities 👍
 
Hello

What happens if you forget what penance you have been given after confession? Is this sin still forgiven? Should you go back and ask what your penance was? I don’t want to descend into scruples about this.
Yes…for it was not intentional…you intended to do the penance when you confessed.

You could ask him what it was next time…or if you could do what you got for similar confessions…
 
As long as you’re clear-headed about why you forgot…you might have been attending/replaying something else he pointed out…and then when you “re-attended” he had already said what the penance was [and you missed it]… I would go and visit the Blessed Sacrament, and have a short talk with God. And say "I am sorry, my Father, I can’t remember how I was supposed to express my love for You…but I offer the following as my penance…[e.g., decade of a very well said, attention-ally-strong Rosary].

Or go back to Confession as soon as you can.
 
As long as you’re clear-headed about why you forgot…you might have been attending/replaying something else he pointed out…and then when you “re-attended” he had already said what the penance was [and you missed it]… I would go and visit the Blessed Sacrament, and have a short talk with God. And say "I am sorry, my Father, I can’t remember how I was supposed to express my love for You…but I offer the following as my penance…[e.g., decade of a very well said, attention-ally-strong Rosary].

Or go back to Confession as soon as you can.
Yes I mean it often happens I am so worked up/stressed out during confession I totally forget the penance. I will try and do what I think it is. The trouble is I suffer from OCD/scruples.
 
well take a long a little notebad and scribble in it quickly…tell Father it happens often…not sure why…and remember Your Father loves you.

Focus on the conversation you’re having with God through the priest. Remind yourself that God is listening, on the other side. Will to be contrite - ignore your feelings.
 
well take a long a little notebad and scribble in it quickly…tell Father it happens often…not sure why…and remember Your Father loves you.

Focus on the conversation you’re having with God through the priest. Remind yourself that God is listening, on the other side. Will to be contrite - ignore your feelings.
It hasn’t happened recently but i am convinced it’s happened once or twice and by then it’s too late to remember which confession/sin it relates to…:sad_yes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top