People with paranormal abilities or experiences

  • Thread starter Thread starter free_thinker
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

free_thinker

Guest
Why is the Catholic Church so quick to judge or dismiss people who have had paranormal experiences or paranormal abilities as a hoax or the work of Satan? There’s all sorts of paranormal things out there that are very insightful. People who have near death experiences are clinically dead yet are out of their body aware of what is going on and some even cross over to the other side. People all over the place have seen/sensed spirits and they can’t all be crazy. And there are those who can communicate with people who have passed. I’m not saying everyone is telling the truth… Because its simple human nature for people to lie or exaggerate… But why don’t some people really listen to what these people have to say? How do we know they aren’t give these abilities so that we can learn and grow from them and gain some insight into the mysteries of God and the nature of the universe?
 
Why is the Catholic Church so quick to judge or dismiss people who have had paranormal experiences or paranormal abilities as a hoax or the work of Satan? There’s all sorts of paranormal things out there that are very insightful. People who have near death experiences are clinically dead yet are out of their body aware of what is going on and some even cross over to the other side. People all over the place have seen/sensed spirits and they can’t all be crazy. And there are those who can communicate with people who have passed. I’m not saying everyone is telling the truth… Because its simple human nature for people to lie or exaggerate… But why don’t some people really listen to what these people have to say? How do we know they aren’t give these abilities so that we can learn and grow from them and gain some insight into the mysteries of God and the nature of the universe?
IMHO, we really have a very limited understanding of the human mind and how it works. Many things we experience, or think we experience, could simply be unconscious workings of our mind. I also believe that our mind may be picking up things in our environment that we are unaware of.
 
How do we know they aren’t give these abilities so that we can learn and grow from them and gain some insight into the mysteries of God and the nature of the universe?
And just how are we supposed discern which “psychic” is telling the truth or not? Which ones are real or not real? Youre so smart, how about you tell us. The Church does acknowledge that people have gifts. Our rules protect us from our own curiosity.
 
Why is the Catholic Church so quick to judge or dismiss people who have had paranormal experiences or paranormal abilities as a hoax or the work of Satan? There’s all sorts of paranormal things out there that are very insightful. People who have near death experiences are clinically dead yet are out of their body aware of what is going on and some even cross over to the other side. People all over the place have seen/sensed spirits and they can’t all be crazy. And there are those who can communicate with people who have passed. I’m not saying everyone is telling the truth… Because its simple human nature for people to lie or exaggerate… But why don’t some people really listen to what these people have to say? How do we know they aren’t give these abilities so that we can learn and grow from them and gain some insight into the mysteries of God and the nature of the universe?
:hmmm: Would you care to define “Paranormal abilities”

If they involve getting in touch with deceased people that is enfaticaly forbidden practice from the Old Testament.

There are guifts of the Holy Spirit that are “paranormal” in nature, The guift of Prophecy for example.

However the Church will evaluate carefully the claim since the enemy uses many times our gullibility to tempt and lead us astray.
 
The majority of people simply do not have the ability to discern if a paranormal event is demonic in origin or not. For many, it doesn’t even cross their minds that it could possibly be something evil these days, especially if the event seems harmless or even, in some way, beneficial. In fact, if you examine all the negative tales of haunting and malicious paranormal activity, you’d find the majority of times, the interactions start out as something fun or even of some perceived benefit which becomes something very negative and even harmful. The infamous ouija boards are a very good case in point of something that is “just a game” that eventually people regret getting involved with due to the results of association with doing that activity.

I believe that this type of experience, with those that are not trained to discern or handle the influence of the demonic, is the main reason why the Church forbids the involvement of its members in the occult activities, even those which appear to be “natural” in origin. God’s own shepherds are zealously watching over His flock with the loving care that is His commandment to all those in apostolic succession. The fact that some of His “lambs” choose to ignore the gentle guidance and concern of the “good shepherds” and run off into the dark where lions await them with hungry jaws to devour and ruin is NOT the Church’s fault.

God Bless
 
Why is the Catholic Church so quick to judge or dismiss people who have had paranormal experiences or paranormal abilities as a hoax or the work of Satan?
In truth, I am not sure that the Church does do this. I believe that the Church does look at those things that she is asked to investigate, and also that she will warn the faithful to avoid certain things (as a general matter of teaching).
But if she is NOT asked to investigate a specific event, she generally makes no “judgement” on it.
That at least is my understanding…
There’s all sorts of paranormal things out there that are very insightful. People who have near death experiences are clinically dead yet are out of their body aware of what is going on and some even cross over to the other side. People all over the place have seen/sensed spirits and they can’t all be crazy. And there are those who can communicate with people who have passed. I’m not saying everyone is telling the truth… Because its simple human nature for people to lie or exaggerate… But why don’t some people really listen to what these people have to say? How do we know they aren’t give these abilities so that we can learn and grow from them and gain some insight into the mysteries of God and the nature of the universe?
The Church has a very rigorous process set up for investigating these matters and it generally requires that a request be made for an investigation. How many of these people and or events are “Catholic” so how many would even think to request an investigation?
And without a request…the Church will generally remain silent on the matter…except for her general teachings on these matters.

If I am wrong in my general understanding on this, please correct me.

Peace
James
 
I suppose these sorts of experiences could be summed up as “private revelations”. After all, if someone has some sort of spiritual or paranormal experience, then in a Christian context, it should have some meaning to the person. Otherwise what’s the point?

I for example have often claimed my father appeared to me the night he died. In fact, I’d say it was the very time he died. He materialised near the door, moved towards the foot of the bed, started with an apology, we argued and conversed, and then he disappeared, but not before giving one almighty scream. I still remember much of what we said and the scream even today. That will be 34 years ago next January. And I don’t remember dreams.

I’ve had other experiences eg. “double whammies” (like a breath going through you in waves from head to foot - on 3 occasions); once thought I was going to literally disintegrate when this sense of anger descended on me; and a number of other things.

For me they have meaning, but I hardly regard them as adding to the deposit of faith. My father’s appearance for example indicated to me judgement was real, takes place immediately after death, and the approach of hell is terrifying. I can’t see any difference between church teaching and my experience in that matter.

But I filter that experience through the teaching of the church.

The church’s attitude to “private revelation” is summed up in the Catechism as follows -
67 Throughout the ages, there have been so-called “private” revelations, some of which have been recognized by the authority of the Church. They do not belong, however, to the deposit of faith. It is not their role to improve or complete Christ’s definitive Revelation, but to help live more fully by it in a certain period of history. Guided by the Magisterium of the Church, the sensus fidelium knows how to discern and welcome in these revelations whatever constitutes an authentic call of Christ or his saints to the Church.
Christian faith cannot accept “revelations” that claim to surpass or correct the Revelation of which Christ is the fulfillment, as is the case in certain non-Christian religions and also in certain recent sects which base themselves on such "revelations".
I think it is the last paragraph that provides the clue to the church’s attitude.
 
What about people who have specifically had near death experiences? These people have clinically “died” and have either left their bodies or gone to the other side. A lot of these experiences can be validated, especially if someone leaves their body and has awareness of their surroundings and can accurately recall what people were doing and saying when technically they should be dead and void of any type of humanly consciousness. Many of these people having these experiences are Christian, and many have converted to Christianity after their experience. They have described being in God’s love and many have had such profound experiences that they can’t even put them into words. What does the church feel about people like this? I have read many many accounts of near death experiences and I personally feel that we can all learn and benefit from them. Sure it is a highly subjective and internal occurrence, but I feel like they can spell out some missing pieces of life’s mysterious puzzle. I think the church only tells us a portion of the story and the rest are things we have to discover from other sources or within ourselves.
 
Because they are afraid.

People do not want to deal with it. They see people like that as a problem. 😦
I keep focused on what Our Lord and His shepards have to say. Anything else is just silliness until the Church tells me otherwise. I dig Medjugorie though but that is a whole other conversation 😉
 
I keep focused on what Our Lord and His shepards have to say. Anything else is just silliness until the Church tells me otherwise. I dig Medjugorie though but that is a whole other conversation 😉
I agree. It is hard to know what is of God and what is not, and I stay with what the church says too. I am not a “vision chaser.” 👍

I stay away from Medjugorie, but I have compassion for people who go through things like that. Even if they are crazy or wicked enough to make it up, they suffer a lot because of how others see them and the way they are poked and prodded and scrutinized.
 
These people have clinically “died” and have either left their bodies or gone to the other side. .
FT It is my understanding that “Clinically dead” is not the same as what the Church means by “dead.” In other words, if you “come back again” you were not really dead in the first place. Which therefore means your soul did not leave your body or go to the other side. True death is irreversible.

If this is true then we have to give more consideration to other explanations for the phenomena that such persons commonly experience. It appears the collapsing of the brain’s consciousness (due to lack of blood-flow/oxygen in the outer brain structures) back down into the primitive brain-stem is what causes these commonly perceived experiences.

It is said, and is my experience also, that hearing is the last sense to go. We can still hear even when apparantly in a coma - why not when “clincally dead” also?
 
FT It is my understanding that “Clinically dead” is not the same as what the Church means by “dead.” In other words, if you “come back again” you were not really dead in the first place. Which therefore means your soul did not leave your body or go to the other side. True death is irreversible.

If this is true then we have to give more consideration to other explanations for the phenomena that such persons commonly experience. It appears the collapsing of the brain’s consciousness (due to lack of blood-flow/oxygen in the outer brain structures) back down into the primitive brain-stem is what causes these commonly perceived experiences.

It is said, and is my experience also, that hearing is the last sense to go. We can still hear even when apparantly in a coma - why not when “clincally dead” also?
I’ve related this before, but I’ll tell it again, particularly in view of your comment about hearing being the last sense to go.

I’ve made the claim many times that my father turned up in my room the night he died. The man who turned up four days later to tell me the normal way was my mother’s brother, my maternal uncle. This was in 1979. He also lived in Brighton, a Brisbane bayside suburb.

Anyway a few years ago I was arguing with atheists on a Google Group site, and the topic was “Near Death Experiences”. As usual I was getting nowhere, and copping a lot of abuse in the usual arrogant atheist style.

So I prayed I might meet someone who’d had a near death experience.

Anyway a couple of days later I was driving a Maxi Taxi (van equipped to cary wheelchairs if necessary) and was in a suburb called Boondall, when a Maxi job appeared on the screen for Brighton. I procrastinated for a while as I assumed there’d be plenty of Maxis in Brighton, but when nothing happened I put in for it and got it. It was for a place called Eventide, a state government nursing complex.

When I got there I found a single bloke about my age who didn’t want a Maxi, but just an ordinary cab. He’d been about to give up, but I turned up just in time. He wanted to go to the Royal Brisbane Hospital, which was a good fare, and we had a bit of time to talk.

We hadn’t been going long when he suddenly remarked, “I’m one of those rare people.” I asked him what he was talking about, and he said he’d been technically dead for 10 minutes after an operation. Yet he said he could hear everything eg. “Well, he’s gone. I"d better go and tell the registrar.”

But apparently his finger moved, and then his body shook, and he heard, “Hang on! He just moved! We’d better try again.” And he “came back.” He’d had most of his stomach removed, and this and other reasons were why he was in a nursing, despite being only middle aged.

He remarked, “You should have seen the looks on the doctors’ faces when they came to visit me later!”

However what got me was that he went to the same high school, and was sometimes in the same class, as the oldest son of the same uncle who turned up to tell me my own father had died, four days after the apparition when he appeared in my bedroom. My fare had grown up in the Brighton area also. One of these odd “coincidences” which seem to recur around that apparitional episode from time to time.

He also had the usual “near death” experiences, the white light, a sense of being told to go back etc.

I’m reading a book by Peter Kreeft at the moment on suffering. He made the comment that some eight million Americans are supposed to have had some form of “near death experience.” So from a sheer numerical viewpoint, the church couldn’t possibly pay attention to every story such a person might have to tell.

But anyway, as you stated, his sense of hearing was still there. He said he could hear everything that was being said.
 
Why is the Catholic Church so quick to judge or dismiss people who have had paranormal experiences or paranormal abilities as a hoax or the work of Satan? There’s all sorts of paranormal things out there that are very insightful. People who have near death experiences are clinically dead yet are out of their body aware of what is going on and some even cross over to the other side. People all over the place have seen/sensed spirits and they can’t all be crazy. And there are those who can communicate with people who have passed. I’m not saying everyone is telling the truth… Because its simple human nature for people to lie or exaggerate… But why don’t some people really listen to what these people have to say? How do we know they aren’t give these abilities so that we can learn and grow from them and gain some insight into the mysteries of God and the nature of the universe?
Well, because they are incredibly hard things to verify. No one has demonstrated these kinds of abilities on any consistent testable basis. The normal human instinct not to appear gullible. The organizational concern that the reputation of the entire Church will be diminished if they’re mistaken. The huge number of fraudulent psychics, mystics, etc.

People perceive things through their beliefs and interpert them that way. A guy moved in next door to me for one night, moved out losing his rent money because he believed there was a demon in it. He’d seen shadows, a light smear in a photograph he took of the house and his fundamentalist church community all posited demons. Prior occupants (house was only 10yrs old and I knew both prior occupants) never mentioned anything. I’ve seen shadows in my house and attributed it to cars moving along a nearby road. I hear creaking noises and think house settling, my kid hears the same noise and says ghost foot-steps. I see a light smear in a photograph and think reflection off some surface.I have a neighbor who investigates paranormal events- he’d love to find any evidence any of them are real, or even find one he can’t prove to be simple physical events. He’s always found a physical normal explanation.

If you’ve ever done any accident/mishap investigation you’ll find that people can’t reliably recall simple physical events. 4 people will describe a car accident completely differently and get basic facts irrefutably wrong, yet insist they are correct. (white car and red car involved, yet someone insists one of the cars was blue. Another witness swears there was a third car involved etc.)

And people’s memories do change over time, their story will change and be completely different, can be manipulated. A lot of interesting research on memory out there if you’ve got the time. (Quite a lot disproving the ‘repressed memory’ concept.). People can recast/reshape events to make them match what they want to believe happened, discard/ignore things that conflict.

I’ve had an out of body experience. Only happened once. I have no idea whether it was paranormal- i.e. my soul/some part of me actually jumping out or simply my mind playing tricks on me. My brain translating things into an external perspective. Since it’s not a repeatable thing, there is no way to test it and figure it out. Under similar circumstances over the many years it never happened again.

So, do you think the Church should investigate every single incident? What does it gain by doing so?
 
Consider near-death experiences.

I have never heard of a near-death experience where the person who suffered near-death had their body pass into rigour mortis.

The Church instructs us to observe natural death. Natural death is when the body passes into rigour mortis. Up until this point the body may still receive the Sacraments. Upon rigour mortis the body may no longer receive the Sacraments. This is simple enough to explain as, once rigour mortis sets in it is no longer a body but remains. We retain our bodies as long as we have proximity to the flesh we were conceived with.

One could argue that once a person who passes into a certain lesser attachment to their body they are gifted with a breadth of vision, a heightening of the intellect. Since intellect (not intelligence) is a neccessary component in the prayerlife a heightening of the intellect will naturally cause the person to be more receptive of and willful to act upon Divine Graces.

Near-death, as it is commonly called, is an example of a super-natural grace. I liken such experiences to the other wordly transports some folks unexplicably enter into when near holy things, such as tabernacles, newly baptised children, suffering people, et cetra. In every case there is a heightening of the intellect making the person more receptive of graces and allowing for greater breadth of vision.

If you would like to open a can of worms, this is one reason why organ removal from non-dead (not yet rigoured) people is morally questionable at best.
 
Consider near-death experiences.

I have never heard of a near-death experience where the person who suffered near-death had their body pass into rigour mortis.

The Church instructs us to observe natural death. Natural death is when the body passes into rigour mortis. Up until this point the body may still receive the Sacraments. Upon rigour mortis the body may no longer receive the Sacraments. This is simple enough to explain as, once rigour mortis sets in it is no longer a body but remains. We retain our bodies as long as we have proximity to the flesh we were conceived with.

One could argue that once a person who passes into a certain lesser attachment to their body they are gifted with a breadth of vision, a heightening of the intellect. Since intellect (not intelligence) is a neccessary component in the prayerlife a heightening of the intellect will naturally cause the person to be more receptive of and willful to act upon Divine Graces.

Death is defined when the soul leaves the body. Even when someone is on loife support if unplugged they die , they have been dead. Brain dead is when soul leaves the body. which defines death

Near-death, as it is commonly called, is an example of a super-natural grace. I liken such experiences to the other wordly transports some folks unexplicably enter into when near holy things, such as tabernacles, newly baptised children, suffering people, et cetra. In every case there is a heightening of the intellect making the person more receptive of graces and allowing for greater breadth of vision.

If you would like to open a can of worms, this is one reason why organ removal from non-dead (not yet rigoured) people is morally questionable at best.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top