FT It is my understanding that “Clinically dead” is not the same as what the Church means by “dead.” In other words, if you “come back again” you were not really dead in the first place. Which therefore means your soul did not leave your body or go to the other side. True death is irreversible.
If this is true then we have to give more consideration to other explanations for the phenomena that such persons commonly experience. It appears the collapsing of the brain’s consciousness (due to lack of blood-flow/oxygen in the outer brain structures) back down into the primitive brain-stem is what causes these commonly perceived experiences.
It is said, and is my experience also, that hearing is the last sense to go. We can still hear even when apparantly in a coma - why not when “clincally dead” also?
I’ve related this before, but I’ll tell it again, particularly in view of your comment about hearing being the last sense to go.
I’ve made the claim many times that my father turned up in my room the night he died. The man who turned up four days later to tell me the normal way was my mother’s brother, my maternal uncle. This was in 1979. He also lived in Brighton, a Brisbane bayside suburb.
Anyway a few years ago I was arguing with atheists on a Google Group site, and the topic was “Near Death Experiences”. As usual I was getting nowhere, and copping a lot of abuse in the usual arrogant atheist style.
So I prayed I might meet someone who’d had a near death experience.
Anyway a couple of days later I was driving a Maxi Taxi (van equipped to cary wheelchairs if necessary) and was in a suburb called Boondall, when a Maxi job appeared on the screen for Brighton. I procrastinated for a while as I assumed there’d be plenty of Maxis in Brighton, but when nothing happened I put in for it and got it. It was for a place called Eventide, a state government nursing complex.
When I got there I found a single bloke about my age who didn’t want a Maxi, but just an ordinary cab. He’d been about to give up, but I turned up just in time. He wanted to go to the Royal Brisbane Hospital, which was a good fare, and we had a bit of time to talk.
We hadn’t been going long when he suddenly remarked, “I’m one of those rare people.” I asked him what he was talking about, and he said he’d been technically dead for 10 minutes after an operation. Yet he said he could hear everything eg. “Well, he’s gone. I"d better go and tell the registrar.”
But apparently his finger moved, and then his body shook, and he heard, “Hang on! He just moved! We’d better try again.” And he “came back.” He’d had most of his stomach removed, and this and other reasons were why he was in a nursing, despite being only middle aged.
He remarked, “You should have seen the looks on the doctors’ faces when they came to visit me later!”
However what got me was that he went to the same high school, and was sometimes in the same class, as the oldest son of the same uncle who turned up to tell me my own father had died, four days after the apparition when he appeared in my bedroom. My fare had grown up in the Brighton area also. One of these odd “coincidences” which seem to recur around that apparitional episode from time to time.
He also had the usual “near death” experiences, the white light, a sense of being told to go back etc.
I’m reading a book by Peter Kreeft at the moment on suffering. He made the comment that some eight million Americans are supposed to have had some form of “near death experience.” So from a sheer numerical viewpoint, the church couldn’t possibly pay attention to every story such a person might have to tell.
But anyway, as you stated, his sense of hearing was still there. He said he could hear everything that was being said.