D
Dranu
Guest
I was wondering what some of your all’s opinion might be on giving up something by oath (i.e. you promise to God never to have anything to do with the thing again no matter what) in this particular circumstance or just in general:
As of late there is a hobby I find myself questioning. Initially I would go so far as to say it (and many other things) helped contribute to my conversion and cleanse myself of sin. Unfortunately I have had some recent qualms over the thing, and through these qualms I have spent/wasted a ton of time and energy thinking about the validity of the hobby. Likewise these qualms are not obviously illegitimate and they have made me uncertain of something I before thought was more than just okay but positively/mostly good. I am perhaps a bit over analytical, and so I am really not sure if there is something wrong with the thing itself or if I am just over worrying about the thing, and in honesty I can say that for most people its probably most likely to be good than bad. However, for me I have a qualm with it solve it, find another, solve it, become uncertain of my solution, and the cycle repeats. This, in turn, makes me fear my qualms might be right and the mere fear alone seems to allow the fear to manifest itself (e.g. thinking the thing may hinder my prayer life causing my prayer life to be hindered just by fearing it). With such uncertainty, I have given it up on the condition that it does not appear to be okay, but that very condition allows me to wonder if it is okay and so I am really not totally purged of it (again might be more my scruples than anything). That is, I am still spending too much of my energy being concerned with this silly little thing where I could be spending my time worrying about bigger issues, so one of the qualms that is starting to stick is that I am too attached to this thing simply because I am not swearing to be done with it forever. I wonder if its that or if I realize my qualms about it are silly. To the hobby’s benefit, it is something that allows some secular common interest with others in my increasingly non-secular way of life, and it is one of the few things that I enjoy doing as a primarily leisurely/pleasurable activity. Therefore, I am thinking of swearing to never think about the thing again and never touch it again since I can’t seem to find peace about it. Even if it is just scruples this will assure me I am not overly attached to it and it will not be able to get in my way of living my life for God that way.
My fear with an oath of that gives something up is that I may create additional scruples for myself to where I am afraid to deal with things or think of things that bear a resemblance to what I give up for fear of violating my oath to God. I also fear that it may not be for the best that I give this thing up, either because I am just feeding scruples or, as I have found in the past, such oaths were a little too much like throwing the baby out with the bath water in depriving myself of that which I could legitimately have. Likewise I fear the general finality of it, where as leaving the question open seems a far less serious choice. However, to be rid of any anxiety of improperly being attached to this thing is something I really desire right now and I want to make sure I am right with God. To feel a more certain peace with God’s favor allows me to function far better. I don’t want anything standing in my way to God even if its but a mere shadow. I should also note that none of these things would be concerns for something that is clearly wrong (like things the Church condemns).
Anyhow, what do you think of such oaths and when should they be used?
As of late there is a hobby I find myself questioning. Initially I would go so far as to say it (and many other things) helped contribute to my conversion and cleanse myself of sin. Unfortunately I have had some recent qualms over the thing, and through these qualms I have spent/wasted a ton of time and energy thinking about the validity of the hobby. Likewise these qualms are not obviously illegitimate and they have made me uncertain of something I before thought was more than just okay but positively/mostly good. I am perhaps a bit over analytical, and so I am really not sure if there is something wrong with the thing itself or if I am just over worrying about the thing, and in honesty I can say that for most people its probably most likely to be good than bad. However, for me I have a qualm with it solve it, find another, solve it, become uncertain of my solution, and the cycle repeats. This, in turn, makes me fear my qualms might be right and the mere fear alone seems to allow the fear to manifest itself (e.g. thinking the thing may hinder my prayer life causing my prayer life to be hindered just by fearing it). With such uncertainty, I have given it up on the condition that it does not appear to be okay, but that very condition allows me to wonder if it is okay and so I am really not totally purged of it (again might be more my scruples than anything). That is, I am still spending too much of my energy being concerned with this silly little thing where I could be spending my time worrying about bigger issues, so one of the qualms that is starting to stick is that I am too attached to this thing simply because I am not swearing to be done with it forever. I wonder if its that or if I realize my qualms about it are silly. To the hobby’s benefit, it is something that allows some secular common interest with others in my increasingly non-secular way of life, and it is one of the few things that I enjoy doing as a primarily leisurely/pleasurable activity. Therefore, I am thinking of swearing to never think about the thing again and never touch it again since I can’t seem to find peace about it. Even if it is just scruples this will assure me I am not overly attached to it and it will not be able to get in my way of living my life for God that way.
My fear with an oath of that gives something up is that I may create additional scruples for myself to where I am afraid to deal with things or think of things that bear a resemblance to what I give up for fear of violating my oath to God. I also fear that it may not be for the best that I give this thing up, either because I am just feeding scruples or, as I have found in the past, such oaths were a little too much like throwing the baby out with the bath water in depriving myself of that which I could legitimately have. Likewise I fear the general finality of it, where as leaving the question open seems a far less serious choice. However, to be rid of any anxiety of improperly being attached to this thing is something I really desire right now and I want to make sure I am right with God. To feel a more certain peace with God’s favor allows me to function far better. I don’t want anything standing in my way to God even if its but a mere shadow. I should also note that none of these things would be concerns for something that is clearly wrong (like things the Church condemns).
Anyhow, what do you think of such oaths and when should they be used?