Perplexed abour Priests Attitude Towards Me.

  • Thread starter Thread starter AussieAnn
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

AussieAnn

Guest
Hi Everyone and God Bless, I am new to this forum. I am a devout married church going Catholic. I am involved in the Liturgy committee of our Church and in many other ways. When I first started at the Parish the Assistant Priest who I’d say is around about my age was happy to answer any emails I had etc and he acted genuinely intersted, welcoming and open etc… I think in total I have sent mabye 4 in total. The last two being in regards to adding my Father to the deceased prayers list and the last to invite him and the senior Parish Priest to our home for coffee. I have had no response to either of these. I also detect a change in his attitude towards me as if he has to avoid me altogethor. At times I did notice him looking at me even when he was sitting up on the altar. I wonder if he has developed some feelings for me and now feels he has to stay away completely. I cannot understand though why it has to be done in such a hurtful way. I did nothing to encourage any feelings from him and have no problems in my marriage etc. I have read some other Priests articles on the web that they are recommended to cut off completely from a woman if they feel that their feelings are out of hand. I just feel that an explanation would help me feel not so hurt and perhaps understand? I guess I have been told I am quite attractive (I am 32 years old) I hate to say it because I feel embarrassed but in the interests of you good people getting a good background on this whole situation I thought I should mention it. I have been racking my brains as to what I did wrong and I can think of nothing. It’s made me feel very awkward and I have avoided going to Church events so much. Can anyone advise me what to do? The only other act of friendship I displayed was sending them both Easter Cards, I did not feel this was inappropriate. I know he is human but so am I and I feel that him cutting me off dead has made the situation actually more awkward. What are some of your thoughts please? Thanks so much for reading.:o
 
Priests are human and have to endure a lot more temptations that we do. If you are good looking, it may well be that he has an attaction for you and is trying to steer clear (which is the smart thing for him to do).

My advise is to try to stay away from him. If the devil knows he has an attaction for you, you can be sure that he is doing his best to tempt him.

I know of at least two Priests who have run off with women. Men like pretty women, so that must be a strong tempation for Priests.

At this point, neither one of you have done anything wrong (from what you have said). The best thing to do is the realize the danger and play it safe. That’s my advise.
 
I’m sorry but I misread your post and I was under the impression that you were male… left me very very confused. Though it seems you have no intentions of wrongdoing as a priest once told me in the confessional, “the devil will always try to tempt us, but lets not help him out.” I don’t think its necessary to completely avoid your priest, but perhaps it’d be best to limit your interaction with him to group settings. Nothing wrong with inviting a priest to your home, but maybe if you invited a few other parishoners or maybe another preist or two he would feel more comfortable.
 
Yes, I understand what you are saying, but “staying away” would involve me not being an active member of my Parish anymore and ignoring my own calling to serve God in the small ways I do. Am I not missing out?. Could he not pray more to just love me as a friend? I have been married for nine years now and there has been alot of prayer to get through the ups and downs. All I’m saying is that is seems to be the woman who misses out when a situation like this arises.I have total respect and admiration for his vocation. Isn’t what he is doing though taking the easy and more hurtful way out? Should he not try to continue being polite at least and pray a whole lot more rather than make me feel like a leper? Thanks for answering though! Oh I did not just invite him I also invited the Senior Parish Priest. I guess I feel a little disapointed because he seemed so devout, dedicated and spiritual, I was surprised to come to the realization that he may indeed have feelings for me. I guess I felt “safe” with him if you know what I mean. I think at first he may have admired my devoutness and then it grew from there. I guess I feel a sense of loss as you would for a good friend? I am now wondering if Priests are able to be friends at all with woman or if the whole things is too hard in the majority of cases?
 
Relax and give them their space.

Priests can be a queer lot to be friends with - lots of issues to balance and demands to accommodate.

A big one is to not be seen as having favorites in a parish.
 
AussieAnn,

Post a pic of yourself and let us decide from there. We need to accurately assess this situation.
 
I have many friends who are Priests. I have maintained a sister relationship with them for more than 20 years. Nothing, but nothing is out of line with them, and they have not been out of line with me.
I tell our Priest all the time I love him, and he does me. We are sister and brother. I am married to my husband of 28 years.
May be it is his temptation or maybe he feels it may be headed a different route. I think it would be best to speak to the other Priest in private and explain your concern, your hurt feelings, etc. He could bridge the gap and bring a resolution.
I believe you should tred lightly because a former pastor of ours left the priesthood to marry. I was devastated. If I thought a pastor was tempted or felt he must put some separation there I would respect it, but let him know you have no ill intent. Prayer to Mary our Mother, and to Christ can help you heal the wounds.
You don’t know what you did, and you probably did nothing. Just dwell on your life, make it happy, and devote your heart and soul to your faith, your church community and focus on Christ alone.
Peace be with you
shelia
 
If as you suspect–the priest has become attracted to you —it may be that your calling now is do what is best for your parish— and distance yourself from a situation --to avoid putting the priest in a situation that can have grave consequences.
 
Yes, I understand what you are saying, but “staying away” would involve me not being an active member of my Parish anymore and ignoring my own calling to serve God in the small ways I do. Am I not missing out?
Before I comment, I need to say that I don’t know all the circumstances, and can only go on what has been said here.

Your going to have to decide how to handle it. One thing is for certain, if he is attracted to you, and is being tempted towards you, you are not going to miss out on serving God by staying away for a while. In fact, your staying away for the purpose of not causing him temptations is probably more pleasing to God than any “extras” you do at Church. It would be an act of sacrifical love to give up something you enjoy for the spiritual advantage of the Priest.
Could he not pray more to just love me as a friend?
It would be nice if it worked that way. Unfortunately, our passions are not under the control of our reason, and God rarely performs miracles. He usually leaves us to deal with things the best way we know how… which in this case would be the Priest steering clear of the person he is attracted to.

Your priest should actually be commended. As a guy, I can tell you that avoiding a good looking female is not an easy task. It is much easier to tell oneself “I can handle it. I’ll just be good friends with her”. Unfortunately, the male nature does not work that way with a female he is attracted to. “Those who love danger shall perish in it”, and I think your Priest is smart enough to realize it.
I have been married for nine years now and there has been alot of prayer to get through the ups and downs. All I’m saying is that is seems to be the woman who misses out when a situation like this arises.
Where’s your charity? That sounds like a selfing statement. Shouldn’t we care enough about one another to make sacrifices when necessary? It is the sacrifices, made out of love, that God rewards.
I have total respect and admiration for his vocation. Isn’t what he is doing though taking the easy and more hurtful way out?
Not at all. He is taking the smart way out. He realizes that he is weak, and is doing the right thing.
Should he not try to continue being polite at least and pray a whole lot more rather than make me feel like a leper?
Again, I don’t know the circumstances. It is rare that we handle difficult situations exactly perfect. Assuming he is suffering major temptations towards you, he may be doing the best he can. Cut him a little slack, and don’t take it personally. Keep in mind that women often do react too emotionally and take things too personally. With that in mind, resist the temptation to react in that way, and instead pray for him. Isn’t that what God would want you to do?
Thanks for answering though! Oh I did not just invite him I also invited the Senior Parish Priest. I guess I feel a little disapointed because he seemed so devout, dedicated and spiritual, I was surprised to come to the realization that he may indeed have feelings for me. I guess I felt “safe” with him if you know what I mean. I think at first he may have admired my devoutness and then it grew from there. I guess I feel a sense of loss as you would for a good friend? I am now wondering if Priests are able to be friends at all with woman or if the whole things is too hard in the majority of cases?
It sounds like there was a connection between the two of you - probably too much of one. I remember a Priest telling me that women sometimes get too close which makes it very difficult. Males and females are made different. Males are attracted physically, while females look for the emotional bonding.

I think you may have had more of an emotional attachment to him than you realize, which was also probably more dangerous than you realize. He probably has a physical attraction for you and does realize the danger.

That’s life. We have all kinds of difficulties to deal with. The important thing is that we don’t offend God, and always try to do what God would have us do.

It could be worse. You could be on here admitting that you were having a sinfull relationship with a Priest and asking for advise on what to do. Thanks to the prudent actions of your Priest, that is not the case.
 
Well, it wouldn’t surprise me that anyone sitting behind the altar and looking out might make eye contact with me. Or might look through me. As long as he’s not undeniably making odd faces only in my direction, I would make nothing of that, one way or the other.

I have had priests, not to mention other friends and aquaintances, not answer my e-mails because they got buried and forgot to. Others have missed e-mails because their e-mailbox was full and bounced everything unceremoniously off into cyberspace. Or he accidentally added you to his “blocked” list. Or maybe his reply was bounced and *he’s *wondering what’s up with you. What’s he going to say? “Hey, what happened to the coffee invitation?” He can’t very well do that. So these are possiblities. If someone doesn’t answer an e-mail, ask them if they got it.

Another possiblity is that the younger priest is not avoiding you but is pre-occupied by another matter. Or buried. Or simply overwhelmed. In a parish big enough to have two priests, there are lots of things like that.

As for greeting cards marking Christmas or Easter, I’m not in the habit of going out of my way to acknowledge those, unless I happen to remember when I run into someone soon after the card arrived in the mail. Still, maybe the pastor knows quite well that all this attention started when this young guy showed up, has seen the two of you together, and knows how much these dual invitations have to do with him. He wasn’t born yesterday, and he’s a lot less naive about how these things can go badly than you are.

You don’t say what the response of your pastor was to your invitation. Was the invitation open-ended, or did you suggest a specific date? Was your husband going to be present, or just you and the priests? Is it possible that your pastor has quietly expressed concern to this younger priest that he might be becoming closer to a young woman his own age than is prudent? Is it possible that he was paying attention to you at the expense of other parishioners? There is a certain distance between you that need not be explained.

Nevertheless, let us say that this priest is struggling with inappropriate feelings about you. That says nothing about you. It should be something he hesitates to share with you. If the feeling were reciprical, that would make his problem worse, not better. If you were shocked…well, you can see about a dozen more bad outcomes that could come out of telling you about that kind of feelings. At the very least, such knowledge would do a disservice to your spiritual life, which must be his primary concern. There is no good way to take that kind of information. Your physician or therapist wouldn’t find it appropriate to share that kind of thing with you, unless he needed to cut off your professional relationship entirely. Neither would a priest who has you in his pastoral care. This is what spiritual directors are for.

It could be any of these, none of these, or a combination of these. At any rate, I would not make more of this than it is. Assume he is still a friend, but a friend with about 300 other equally-close families and friends that also make demands on his attentions.

As for your feelings of hurt, these come from how you have chosen to interpret his actions. If you choose to interpret differently, you might find you’ll come to feel differently, too.

As for avoiding church events, a parish big enough for two priests is hardly going to throw the two of you together. It’s a big place. There is plenty of room for you to volunteer and not have an undue amount of contact with either of the priests. If he has feelings for you, he will be able to endure standing two places behind you in the coffee line or sit at the same table while you make small talk with the president of the altar society. Do not worry about it. Being certain that you are observing prudent boundaries, act as if nothing happened.
 
Dear Pax,
In fact, your staying away for the purpose of not causing him temptations is probably more pleasing to God than any “extras” you do at Church. It would be an act of sacrifical love to give up something you enjoy for the spiritual advantage of the Priest
.

That was the most beautiful suggestion. Thank you. You are right and I shall also pray for this Priest.

But you know what else it is. Here is Australia we have had a severley declining rate in the Priesthood ,in fact, we now “import” Priests from other countries. Father is from Poland. I have had a whole life of much, much older priests which has been great BUT I really jumped at the chance at finding a priest my own age who could relate at a completely different level to what I was used to. So I guess it is selfish of me in a way to not want to give it up but I hope you can see a reason why I felt badly about it.
Your priest should actually be commended. As a guy, I can tell you that avoiding a good looking female is not an easy task
. Do you mind me asking -are you a Priest ? Are you speaking from the experience of Priesthood?

Isn’t it funny the way we can sometimes get so bogged down in the nitty gritty of our own little lives and circle of fanily/friendships that we can become quite “blind” to the big picture. Then when you ask outside parties for advice and then they give it to you, you think" Why did I not see that before". So thanks.
It sounds like there was a connection between the two of you - probably too much of one. I remember a Priest telling me that women sometimes get too close which makes it very difficult. Males and females are made different. Males are attracted physically, while females look for the emotional bonding
. -This makes me feel a little sad. Wouldn’t it help a Priest to grow and mature spiritually to experience an emotional bond? Would it not help him to understand his parishoners lives a little better? Surely not all men just feel or want to satisfy a physical desire?
I think you may have had more of an emotional attachment to him than you realize, which was also probably more dangerous than you realize. He probably has a physical attraction for you and does realize the danger
. I never saw what was wrong with having a healthy feeling of genuine friendship and sisterly love towards him , not to mention my Australian idea of mateship and no worries:)

Anyway, just some thoughts !
 
Before I comment, I need to say that I don’t know all the circumstances, and can only go on what has been said here.

Your going to have to decide how to handle it. One thing is for certain, if he is attracted to you, and is being tempted towards you, you are not going to miss out on serving God by staying away for a while. In fact, your staying away for the purpose of not causing him temptations is probably more pleasing to God than any “extras” you do at Church. It would be an act of sacrifical love to give up something you enjoy for the spiritual advantage of the Priest.

It would be nice if it worked that way. Unfortunately, our passions are not under the control of our reason, and God rarely performs miracles. He usually leaves us to deal with things the best way we know how… which in this case would be the Priest steering clear of the person he is attracted to.

Your priest should actually be commended. As a guy, I can tell you that avoiding a good looking female is not an easy task. It is much easier to tell oneself “I can handle it. I’ll just be good friends with her”. Unfortunately, the male nature does not work that way with a female he is attracted to. “Those who love danger shall perish in it”, and I think your Priest is smart enough to realize it.

Where’s your charity? That sounds like a selfing statement. Shouldn’t we care enough about one another to make sacrifices when necessary? It is the sacrifices, made out of love, that God rewards.

Not at all. He is taking the smart way out. He realizes that he is weak, and is doing the right thing.

Again, I don’t know the circumstances. It is rare that we handle difficult situations exactly perfect. Assuming he is suffering major temptations towards you, he may be doing the best he can. **Cut him a little slack, and don’t take it personally. **Keep in mind that women often do react too emotionally and take things too personally. **With that in mind, resist the temptation to react in that way, and instead pray for him. ** Isn’t that what God would want you to do?

It sounds like there was a connection between the two of you - probably too much of one. I remember a Priest telling me that women sometimes get too close which makes it very difficult. Males and females are made different. Males are attracted physically, while females look for the emotional bonding.

**I think you may have had more of an emotional attachment to him than you realize, which was also probably more dangerous than you realize. ** He probably has a physical attraction for you and does realize the danger.

That’s life. We have all kinds of difficulties to deal with. The important thing is that we don’t offend God, and always try to do what God would have us do.

It could be worse. You could be on here admitting that you were having a sinfull relationship with a Priest and asking for advise on what to do. Thanks to the prudent actions of your Priest, that is not the case.
This is some really great advice. Every word of it, but I’ve bolded a couple of bits that I especially liked.
 
This makes me feel a little sad. Wouldn’t it help a Priest to grow and mature spiritually to experience an emotional bond? Would it not help him to understand his parishoners lives a little better? Surely not all men just feel or want to satisfy a physical desire?
True, but the questions in your post are, in actuality, rationalizations designed to draw him closer to you. That should sound a warning bell. It already has to him.
 
True, but the questions in your post are, in actuality, rationalizations designed to draw him closer to you. That should sound a warning bell. It already has to him.
I see at as a rationalization as to why I wish we could remain solid friends. In all honesty I feel no attraction physically to this man. I felt good old mateship. It seems though, as if this kind of sentiment, must somehow be viewed with a suspision as if there is some kind of ulterior motive. Almost a throwback to Eve, or the succubus. Ive already decided to keep myself to myself if that is what he needs. There is no sense in dragging a dead donkey. The underlying thread of suspision disturbs me though and it makes the whole things seem…unseemly. Your post seems to have confirmed this.

Though I know it is hard, when you don’t know me and the situation well at all. I know you mean no offence, nor does anyone else.
 
I find it very dangerous to analyze another persons thoughts and behaviors. There is absolutely no way to know why the man behaves as he does unless he tells you himself; and it would be in poor taste to ask in this situation.
 
I see at as a rationalization as to why I wish we could remain solid friends. In all honesty I feel no attraction physically to this man. I felt good old mateship. It seems though, as if this kind of sentiment, must somehow be viewed with a suspision as if there is some kind of ulterior motive. Almost a throwback to Eve, or the succubus. Ive already decided to keep myself to myself if that is what he needs. There is no sense in dragging a dead donkey. The underlying thread of suspision disturbs me though and it makes the whole things seem…unseemly. Your post seems to have confirmed this.

Though I know it is hard, when you don’t know me and the situation well at all. I know you mean no offence, nor does anyone else.
This is a debate we could have on just about any message board:

Men don’t generally want to be pals with women. Lots of men will be, but I’ve heard from many men that, deep down, they are sexually attracted. For a lot of men, that’s OK. They’re OK with being attracted because it wouldn’t be the end of their world if he were to get lucky. Or, maybe they just don’t give it a whole lot of thought. But, in general, men and women aren’t going to be close platonic friends.

I would not be OK with my husband being “mates” with a woman. If he were to find himself attracted to her to the point of thinking in ways he shouldn’t, the right thing for him to do would be to steer clear of temptation. To nip it in the bud.

This priest should be seen the same way. He’s not an unusual man in any way, unless you consider that his honor and prudence are unusual.
 
Yes, it is hard not to analyse when you are the brunt of whatever is going on there though. A natural immediate reaction is: What have I done? It would be virtually impossible to be otherwise -male or female.
 
By the way, a great way to support men in the priesthood and men and women in religious life without going it alone in terms of the appropriateness of your relationships with them is to see if there is a chapter of Serra Club in your area:
scanzspac.org/about.htm

Not only do Serrans support and affirm religious vocations, you get to share your faith with other Catholics who have a similar interest.
 
I have had this same problem myself recently. It was very disturbing and sad to me. I wanted a spiritual director. I have to say I was insulted as well because if I were a man this would not be the case. Out of my high respect I have decided to step out of my position. I pray for my Priest and the other Priest in this position.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top