Pick Your Brain?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Heteroclite
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

Heteroclite

Guest
Please educate me: are the following things mandatory beliefs for becoming RC? IOW, do you have to swear to believing these when you go thru the final initiation rite for full RCC membership? (I’m confused b/c (a) someone I know who’s in RCIA does not believe in Original Sin—which even I, a lowly Protestant, believe in [the concept is clearly in the Scriptures!;)]—and (b) at another thread here, someone was commenting on how their RCIA instructor was teaching things that contradicted the RC catechism.). BTW, I’m not posting this [SIGN]in any way [/SIGN]to argue/harrass/harangue: I’m simply after informational clarity. Thanks in advance.

Original Sin

Veneration of Mary

Praying through Mary

Praying through saints

Indulgences

Transubstantiation

Purgatory

(Footnote question: how often are you required to go to confession?)
 
I’m not so sure about indulgences (they were barely mentioned in my RCIA class) but the rest are all absolute yes’s. Although, I believe Purgatory is only for the Roman Catholics (Any EC’s here care to clarify this? Feel free to correct me 😊 )

As for confession, you should go as often as you are aware that you have committed serious, or “mortal” sins. Another note, you MUST be free of serious sins before you partake of the Eucharist; taking Communion while still being under the stain mortal sin is in and of itself a mortal sin.
 
Original Sin - yes

Veneration of Mary - what exactly do you mean? The dogmas about Mary are she was born without original sin and the assumption of Mary. Those two things are required to be believed.

Praying through Mary - no, you don’t have to pray to Mary.

Praying through saints - no, you don’t have to pray to the saints.

Indulgences - not sure.

Transubstantiation - yes

Purgatory = yes

(Footnote question: how often are you required to go to confession?) - I don’t think the Church says you should go to confession X times a year. As the other poster said, if you commit a mortal sin, you should go to confession.

About Mary and the saints, I believe it is fair to say you are required to believe in the communion of saints, ie, they can intercede for us, but you don’t have to personally ask them to…
 
Please educate me: are the following things mandatory beliefs for becoming RC? IOW, do you have to swear to believing these when you go thru the final initiation rite for full RCC membership? (I’m confused b/c (a) someone I know who’s in RCIA does not believe in Original Sin—which even I, a lowly Protestant, believe in [the concept is clearly in the Scriptures!;)]—and (b) at another thread here, someone was commenting on how their RCIA instructor was teaching things that contradicted the RC catechism.). BTW, I’m not posting this [SIGN]in any way [/SIGN]to argue/harrass/harangue: I’m simply after informational clarity. Thanks in advance.

Original Sin

Veneration of Mary

Praying through Mary

Praying through saints

Indulgences

Transubstantiation

Purgatory

(Footnote question: how often are you required to go to confession?)
If you enter into a marriage under false pretense, such as not intending to remain faithful, then those are the grounds for a legitimate annulment of the sacrament. If you enter into the faith on Easter under false pretense, such as not believing in the true presence of Jesus in the Bread and Wine (you don’t have to understand it, but you have to believe it), then your friend needs to know that you cannot make a fool of GOD, HE knows your heart. And “Catholic” is not a club you join it is a life you die to, to become a saint in service to Jesus, whom you consume and place within your body, that you may be more and more like HIM in all things. I pray that your friend will come to believe before they meet Jesus.
As for you, attend the RCIA, and ask these same questions. You do not have to join upon completing the course, and your questions will be of great help to others, such as your friend, when they hear the answers.
 
I have been a Roman Catholic for 50 years. I am happy to tell you what I know, as far as answers to your questions.
To begin, when you are Baptized, the priest will ask you questions like: “Do you reject Satan and all his empty promises”? He will also ask several other questions based on the Nicene Creed. This is called our “Profession of Faith”. You must agree and answer “Yes” to these questions. During your Confirmation, “The Litany of the Saints” is sung. This is beautiful…we ask Our Lady Mary, her husband, Joseph and all the saints (by name) to “Pray for Us”. Before Confirmation you will have to pick out a Saint to be your Patron. This should be a Saint that you share something in common with, or that you want to emulate. For example, I am a music teacher, so I chose the name; Cecilia, who is the Patron Saint of music and musicians. You should also know things about your Patron Saint…about their life and were they a martyr?
  1. Original Sin…With the exception of Our Lady and Our Lord Jesus, we are all born with original sin, due to the failure of Adam and Eve to obey God
  2. Veneration of Mary…We do not worship Mary, but we are to love and honor her. She is afterall, the Mother of Our Lord. Had she not said “Yes”, we would have no way to salvation. There is nothing wrong in praying to Mary…she can intercede for us, as she is the closest to Our Lord. Remember the Wedding in Canaa.
  3. Praying to Saints…Have you never asked someone to pray for you or someone ask you to pray for them? The same reasoning stands. These Holy Men and Women can and do help us when we ask them.
  4. Indulgence…( definition) “The remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins forgiven as far as their guilt is concerned, which the follower of Christ with the proper dispositions and under certain determined conditions acquires through the intervention of the Church, which as a minister of the redemption, authoritatively dispenses and applies the treasury of the satisfaction won by Christ and the Saints.”
An indulgence was a mitigation of the severe canonical penances imposed on the faithful for grave sins. But Pope Paul Vl and Vatican ll Council changed this. From then on the measure of how efficacious an indulgenced work is depends on two things: the supernatural charity with which the indulgenced task is done, and the perfection of the task itself. Partial and plenary indulgences can always be applied to the dead by way of suffrage, asking God to remit their sufferings if they are still in purgatory.
5) Transubstantiation…This is the changing of the Bread and Wine, during the Consecration of the Mass, into the actual Body and Blood of Our Lord, Jesus Christ. You must believe this with your whole heart and soul. This is the most important part of our faith! Without this…we have nothing!
6) Purgatory…When we die if we are not in a State of Grace, we go to Purgatory. This is a place for purification. We must be totally pure to enter Heaven and Purgatory is where we get ready to meet Our Lord. Lets say, you get Baptized and Confirmed at Easter Vigil and the next day you die without having committed any sin…you would go to Heaven in a flash! But, let’s say you committed a venial sin…you would end up in purgatory to be purified.
7) Confession…Go to Confession at least once a month. If your conscience bothers you before then, by all means go when necessary. You don’t have to confess your venial sins in the confessional. Do an examination of conscience each night and say a good Act of Contrition, then when you dip your fingers into the Holy Water and Bless yourself as you enter Church, this washes away your venial sins…so does going to Holy Communion.:thumbsupI hope I have helped you in some small way. By the way, if an RCIA instructor is teaching things against the Catechism, then someone needs to inform the priest or bishop.
God Bless you, on your journey.🙂
 
Re:
Veneration of Mary
Praying through Mary
Praying through saints
As **regression **said, RCs do not have to, but allow me to quote the Eucharist Prayer
From Eucharistic Prayer I:
In communion with those whose memory we venerate,
especially the glorious ever-Virgin Mary,
Mother of our God and Lord, Jesus Christ,
and blessed Joseph, Spouse of the same Virgin,
your blessed Apostles and Martyrs, Peter and Paul, Andrew,
and all your Saints:
through their merits and prayers,
grant that in all things we may be defended
by your protecting help.
**From Eucharistic Prayer III:
**May he make of us an eternal offering to you,
so that we may obtain an inheritance with your elect,
especially with the most blessed Virgin Mary, Mother of God,
with your blessed Apostles and glorious Martyrs
and with all the Saints, on whose constant intercession in your presence
we rely for unfailing help.
Note: other Eucharist Prayers do not have the exact words but to the same effect.
Although privately we do not have to, but publicly we do.
Re: Indulgences
CCC 1471
The doctrine and practice of indulgences in the Church are closely linked to the effects of the sacrament of Penance.
What is an indulgence?
“An indulgence is a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven, which the faithful Christian who is duly disposed gains under certain prescribed conditions through the action of the Church which, as the minister of redemption, dispenses and applies with authority the treasury of the satisfactions of Christ and the saints.”
"An indulgence is partial or plenary according as it removes either part or all of the temporal punishment due to sin."Indulgences may be applied to the living or the dead.
Whether you believe in it or not, RCs in bound by the doctrine indulgence. If you choose you do not believe, you cannot obtain one for yourself although somebody else might obtain it for you (after you have finished your earthly life).
Re: Confession
The Church mandates that all Catholics shall confess their sins at least once a year and recommends more frequent confessions (e.g monthly).

As for the other points, yes we Catholics do believe in them.

Each topic is a rich doctrine that you can explore. Please do not take this forum as your final reference, but study them yourself.

Hope this helps

God Bless
 
You must confess at least once a year to be a Catholic in good standing, I’m pretty sure. Just to clarify.
 
You don’t have to pray to Mary or other saints, though your pastor might use the form of the Penitential Rite during Mass where you ask for their prayers, in which case you ought to participate. I would think that you at least have to believe that you CAN pray to Mary and the other saints. The other beliefs are also important, in fact I would say they are all necessary, to have.

As for confession, I’ve read that you have to go at least once each year, unless you have not committed mortal sin. See here.

As for the stories you’ve told, I find them very disturbing. Do the RCIA instructors know about this?
 
Catholics must believe in the Communion of Saints. It’s in our Creeds. While you don’t need to have any private devotion to saints or Mary, you must believe in their possibility.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top