Plane Goes Down in Hudson River

  • Thread starter Thread starter cthulhubryan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Not unless all that ability & other psy/motol function skills were inborn; which they were not.
God, who is goodness itself, works through His creatures, Robert. That’s what we Catholics believe. Of course we’re thankful for the pilot and I’m sure he’s going to get a lot of free beer šŸ™‚ but we’re also thankful for God for working through the pilot to save the passengers on the plane. We give credit where it is due, alright?
 
God, who is goodness itself, works through His creatures, Robert. That’s what we Catholics believe. Of course we’re thankful for the pilot and I’m sure he’s going to get a lot of free beer šŸ™‚ but we’re also thankful for God for working through the pilot to save the passengers on the plane. We give credit where it is due, alright?
After reading your post,I feel embarassed for teasing Robert. Robert, I’m sorry.:o
 
God, who is goodness itself, works through His creatures, Robert. That’s what we Catholics believe. Of course we’re thankful for the pilot and I’m sure he’s going to get a lot of free beer šŸ™‚ but we’re also thankful for God for working through the pilot to save the passengers on the plane. We give credit where it is due, alright?
Yup, & I’m curious whether it is due at all. So I’m asking.

How was God working through him?
 
Wow… you just took away any credit the hardworking guy should have got… & attributed it to God for giving him the ability.

That’s actually fairly insulting, in my opinion.

If God can just do these things, why have people train/practise at all?
How is it God giving him ability, if he TRAINED for it for years?
I find it insulting that you come to a CATHOLIC message board and ridicule people for giving God credit where credit is due.
 
Yup, & I’m curious whether it is due at all. So I’m asking.

How was God working through him?
He gave the pilot the graces necessary to do his job. Now, a grace is a free and undeserving gift given by God for the greater good of souls. Patience, fortitude, strength, love, hope, optimism, joy - these are all graces given to us by God, because, as I said, God is goodness itself, the source and summit of all goodness. Patience, fortitude, love, hope, etc. are all good things, so they come from God, and, because they come from God, they are good things. But not all graces of the Lord are spiritual, that is, immaterial; all corporal or material creations of God are also graces: the universe, planets, stars, night, day, darkness, light, animals, our bodies, minds, hearts, and space and time - in short, everything which God has created is a grace which He has given to all mankind. You are God’s grace to me and I am God’s grace to you, given to each other not only as ā€œbrothersā€ according to the human family but also as instruments of salvation, that is, praying for each other, speaking the truth and correcting lies, being charitable and doing works of mercy. To sum up, God worked through the pilot in three ways: 1) By giving him the training and skills he needed to get the job done, 2) By giving him the courage and mental strength to work in such an emergency situation, and 3) By creating the pilot, giving him a body and soul. Hence, one could say that the pilot is a grace from God, because God gave him to the passengers that they might live.

Now, one could argue that God created the emegercy Himself by having the goose get into the engine, or by having the plane fly off at the time and day it did, or so many other circumstsances which can be attributed to God. However, God gives His creatue the grace of choice and of free-will, so He dose not force them to act like robots, and He permits evil to exist not because He is evil, nor because He is weak, but rather, because He wishes to show man His glory and give him His Mercy and His graces. In a certain sense, God cannot be happy without man, because He is Love. There is no better way I know of to illustrate this than to bring up the image of two lovers, such as the ones in the Song of Songs: the two lovers love each other so much that they cannot be happy without one another. Another image of Divine Love could be that a fool who is so in love with someone that he dose stupid things to prove his love, for example, he knows that someone is going to do something bad, but rather than preventing it he permits it so he can use the oppurtunity to show is love for the person his heart yearns for. But even these examples are a pale shaodw of God’s love for us. And I am not a theologican, so I can’t even begin to correctly speak of God’s Love. However, I do know that God’s ways are inscruitble, for His ways are so far above ours that we could not even begin to understand the reasons for His actions. But we know He is love and mercy, justice, and holiness, and so, we trust in Him, knowing He dose all things for the good of His creatures. Again, I know this is a poor explaination, I am no theologican, so I apology.
 
Wow. Just, Wow!
And praise God!

I live in North Carolina, so naturally this was all over the evening news. Imagine my first thoughts as I turn on FOX News and the first thing I hear is ā€œA miracle on the Hudson Riverā€!

They say it was indeed a ā€œbird strikeā€ that damaged the plane’s engines shortly after take-off.

Allow me to chime in all the whole ā€œmiracleā€ thing. Our news caster described the whole situation with a map of New York to show the plane’s journey from take-off to the crash. He said the plane narrowly missed the George Washington bridge, which would have not only put the passengers in jeopardy but also all the people on that interstate. Then, the plane finally landed right between the ferry docks, the perfect place for rescue workers to work quickly.

I was incredibly touched by the stories of all the people involved, by the skill of the pilot and his crew, the courage of the passengers, the speed and efficiency of the rescue crews, the strength of the loved ones left waiting for several hours, and the assistance offered to those waiting by U.S. Airlines and the Red Cross. And throughout the entire story, prayer kept coming up and how it strengthened everyone involved.

As they wrapped up the story, the only thing my sister and I could say was, ā€œWOW! God’s hand could be seen all over this!ā€

So I’ll say it again.
Praise the Lord! :extrahappy:
 
Wow… you just took away any credit the hardworking guy should have got… & attributed it to God for giving him the ability.

That’s actually fairly insulting, in my opinion.

If God can just do these things, why have people train/practise at all?
How is it God giving him ability, if he TRAINED for it for years?
Insulting? I bet you $100 he’s thanking God.
 
We all know there are no athiests in a foxhole but do you think there were any in this plane landing on the Hudson River? Praise God! Thank God!
 
My question is simple: How will Giuliani take credit in this situation?šŸ˜› :confused:
 
This pilot pulled off the only ditching with no deaths (and no serious injuries!) in the history of commercial aviation. I notice that he is being hailed by the state media as a product of the federal government, since he is an air force vet. Of course, there they train you to machine-gun, rocket, and bomb strangers on orders–not quite the same thing.

And notice how individuals organized immediately to save all the passengers and crew stranded on the sinking plane? No coast guard, no homeland security, no cops. Oh, the NYPD did send three helicopters to circle the wreck and blow more frigid air on the victims. Then pompous government officials told us the geese were probably not members of al-qaeda. But the private pilot went through the entire sinking plane twice, after he thought everybody was out, to make sure no one was trapped.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top