Planning our wedding!

  • Thread starter Thread starter bdjohnbg
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My mother always said any cake smashers’ marriage wouldn’t last, because they had no respect for each other.
That’s exactly what my mom said. I know others will probably have a much different opinion than mine by the symbolism of feeding each other the first piece of the bridal cake is to represent you will take care of each other. Smashing the cake in your new spouse’s face seems to me say the exact opposite.
 
I’m very excited to be planning mine and my fiance’s wedding, (only 14 months to go!), but I have to say it gets a tad bit overwhelming at times! I guess I didn’t realize how much work goes into it, lol!

At any rate, I’m posting a thread here looking for some suggestions about something specific. My fiance and I find the whole reaching up my dress, pulling off a garter, and tossing it to other men thing kind of vulgar. I’m not necessarily judging people who want to do that, I’m just saying it isn’t for us. The problem is that we cannot decide whether to replace it with something else (and if so, what??), or to just nix it completely and have me just toss the bouquet. Or should we just not do either??

(Side note: I did pose this question to our wedding party, but they all seem to agree that we are silly for letting that bother us, since they view it as a simple wedding reception “tradition.”)

I suppose I would just like to hear what other people think. Are we being silly, or should we do something else? And what suggestions would you have?

Thanks for reading, and responding!
Congratulations! If it bothers you and your fiance, you shouldn’t do it. You can still do the bouquet thing and not the garter thing–it is your wedding! There is no obligation to do both of them together or not at all. Believe it or not, you will talk to some people who will tell you just that. What they really mean is that they like the tradition, your personal tastes are “silly” (sound familiar?), and therefore, you should just do it because that’s the way it is and that is the way everyone else does it. My advice would be to not listen to them and do what you want. This party is for you and your future husband and you don’t have to justify yourselves.

Best of luck with the wedding planning!
 
It’s your reception - do whatever you want!!

I just got married a few weeks ago. (To someone I met here on the CAF! 😃 ) We didn’t do the garter thing, and I didn’t toss a bouquet. (Heck, I decided to carry a fan instead of flowers - I hate the way they smell!!!)

🤷

Do whatever makes you happy!! 👍
 
My best friend and her husband also did not like the garter tradition so replaced it with something of their own. After she tossed the bouquet, he washed her feet out of a large silver bowl and dried them with a white hand towel. The towel was then thrown to the single men.

I really like the idea of giving the bouquet to the longest married couple. As a single woman, I hate having to participate in the bouquet toss.
 
I really disliked that tradition. The bride can pick and choose whichever traditions she wants and can toss out the others. Don’t let other people tell you what to do, go with your conscience.
 
I agree with you that the garter toss is vulgar. We had a rather small party in a restaurant after our wedding. When we decided to leave everyone gathered to say goodbye and I tossed my bouquet. We weren’t really big on the whole MC thing and didn’t have one, so no one made any announcement to gather “all the single ladies” or anything like that. It just sort of happened naturally like I imagine how the tradition might have begun.

I don’t think you need to replace the garter toss if you don’t do it. Nobody ever said, “wow, that was a great wedding, but I wish there had been garter toss.”
 
Yep, We’re definitely skipping the garter toss at our reception. We’ve also decided not to include the “Dollar Dance” because it always made me feel uncomfortable when I saw it at other receptions.

We’re not replacing either with anything, they’re just not happening.

You said you’re getting married in 14 months - September 2013 as well? highfive
 
Yep, We’re definitely skipping the garter toss at our reception. We’ve also decided not to include the “Dollar Dance” because it always made me feel uncomfortable when I saw it at other receptions.

We’re not replacing either with anything, they’re just not happening.

You said you’re getting married in 14 months - September 2013 as well? highfive
I’ve never heard of the “Dollar Dance.” It brings to mind certain adult establishments. I hope it has nothing to do with any of that!! :eek:

Thank you, everyone, for your suggestions. My fiance and I decided we really like the idea of the Anniversary Dance, as the vast majority of our invitees are married anyway. 🙂
 
My mother always said any cake smashers’ marriage wouldn’t last, because they had no respect for each other.
Couldn’t agree more! I find it abusive and embarassing each other in public?! It’s beyond me!!!
Yep, We’re definitely skipping the garter toss at our reception. We’ve also decided not to include the “Dollar Dance” because it always made me feel uncomfortable when I saw it at other receptions.
The first time I saw the dollar dance the bride only did it and the lady sitting next to me said “They’re only just married and he’s already selling her off” :eek: Yes, also dislike the dollar dance.

We did do the bouque toss and garter toss, but I had a very big dress and my hubby made sure he didn’t show even a piece of my leg, and the garter was very low. He really wanted to do it, and after some discussing I was fine with it.

I also love the other idea of the bouque, my friend did it so that she had all married couples on the dance floor and the DJ would say “if you’ve been married for less than a year it’s time to leave the dance floor” and so on, ended up with a couple who had been together for over 50 years dancing alone on the dance floor… it was BEAUTIFUL!!!

Congrats to all the Brides 😃
 
You pay to dance with the bride & groom.
Never heard of that either. Sounds unbelievably tacky. Hey, we know you took the time to come here to wish us well, probably got us a gift too, but hey, if you want to dance with one of us, pay up! People actually pay? It would be funny if no one did.
 
I think the dollar dance is more of a Midwestern thing. I don’t see a problem with it because I’ve always seen it done, and all the guests know what it is, expect it, and enjoy it. I think it’s nice if for no other reason than it gives the bride and groom a minute with everyone to say hi, thank them for coming, etc. And the guests get a private moment to wish the couple well.

The bride and groom are then given the money for their honeymoon.
 
I think the dollar dance is more of a Midwestern thing. I don’t see a problem with it because I’ve always seen it done, and all the guests know what it is, expect it, and enjoy it. I think it’s nice if for no other reason than it gives the bride and groom a minute with everyone to say hi, thank them for coming, etc. And the guests get a private moment to wish the couple well.

The bride and groom are then given the money for their honeymoon.
I like the tradition. It’s a good excuse for a shy family member to ask the bride or groom to dance. We had this at our wedding and my youngest brother kept coming up with dollars and came up to dance with me over and over again. It was so cute and sweet! It also gives the photographer the opportunity to photograph the bride or groom with their grandpa, auntie, family friend, etc and I’ve gotten some really great pictures from dollar dances. The only thing I don’t like about it is when the DJ insists that all the guests clear the dance floor. This seems to be the custom where my husband is from in Wisconsin and the end result is only the bride and groom are dancing for twenty minutes while the guests have nothing to do. At most of the weddings I’ve been to, the dance continues for the rest of the guests while the dollar dance goes on, so I insisted on that for our wedding, even though we got married in my husband’s hometown. I think it’s much nicer when everyone is dancing and enjoying themselves. PS- the extra cash came in handy because we forgot to get money to tip the servers and the DJ ahead of time.
 
Never heard of that either. Sounds unbelievably tacky. Hey, we know you took the time to come here to wish us well, probably got us a gift too, but hey, if you want to dance with one of us, pay up! People actually pay? It would be funny if no one did.
How well I remember my parents’ reaction the first time they encountered one of those at a wedding!😃 Suffice it to say that the comments were far from positive. They seem popular in some communities and unheard of in others.
 
How well I remember my parents’ reaction the first time they encountered one of those at a wedding!😃 Suffice it to say that the comments were far from positive. They seem popular in some communities and unheard of in others.
I’m glad it’s unheard of here thus far and hope it stays away.
 
I’m glad it’s unheard of here thus far and hope it stays away.
We didn’t do it at our wedding, but the tradition never bothered me.

We did do the garter thing and dh surprised me by using his teeth! It was all in good fun, though, and I don’t think anyone (including my sweet, conservative mother) was offended or upset or anything. believe me…if she was I would have heard it! LOL

Good memories…
 
Congrats!! I was very much opposed to my husband taking my garter off in front of everyone so he had me sit in a chair and all of his groomsmen and cousins formed a circle around us. They had their backs to us so no one witnessed my husband taking the garter. He then tossed it. I felt like it was much more private but kept the tradition.
 
Honestly, the best advice is simply to do what you feel comfortable with. Don’t get caught up in all the wedding propaganda you will hear about what just “must” be done. If it will be meaningful for you and your guests, by all means incorporate it, but if not, don’t do it just because its the ‘done’ thing. Don’t let the sentiments of a few guests get in the way of what you want to do, or omit, from your wedding, but most of all don’t do anything/wear anything etc that will make you uncomfortable. Its going to be full enough of emotion as it is, you don’t need extra drama or worry. 🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top